It's very natural for journalists, just like anyone else, to dismiss scandals when your friends or heroes are involved. As CBS anchor Katie Couric is embarrassed by having a ghost writer make up her childhood memories -- and plagiarize someone else's work -- CNN anchor Soledad O'Brien insists it will pass, and insists that poor Katie is often personally attacked because she dared to be a pioneering woman anchor. The New York Observer reported:
The Transom asked for Ms. O’Brien’s take on the recent scandal over at CBS, which fired producer Melissa McNamara after she plagiarized a Wall Street Journal column for one of Katie Couric’s first-person commentaries. “Well, you know, she’s a mentor of mine, so I talk to her all the time,” Ms. O’Brien said of Ms. Couric. “When I was at NBC and I didn’t have an agent, she called up her agent, and the next thing I knew, I was represented by CAA. I mean, people don’t do that. So I’ve always been incredibly grateful to her.
“I think she’s a great role model for women, because she’s made a very brave choice,” Ms. O’Brien continued. “She’s gone out and tackled something, and nobody before her—no woman—has done the evening news, and I think she has gotten a lot of barbs because of that. Some of the attacks are very personal, and because she is a woman. I’m sorry to have to admit that, but it’s true. I think she’s handled it with grace. This too shall pass, because one thing Katie Couric is, is a terrific journalist. Everybody knows that. And Brian Williams too!”
Forgive me if I just roll my eyes at the "no woman has done the evening news" line spilling out again. Barbara Walters and Connie Chung were national co-anchors at ABC and CBS. Women were solo anchors of the evening news on the weekends for years in the 1980s and 1990s, and even Elizabeth Vargas was a solo anchor at ABC months before Couric (due to co-anchor Bob Woodruff's wounds in Iraq.) Couric's historic landmark is that she is the first female solo weeknight news anchor officially announced by a network in a press release. (Since ABC carried the pretense that Bob Woodruff was still a co-anchor as he recovered for many months.)
Also in the CNN world, Larry King never wants to retire, but he has been honoring younger men with the idea they could replace him whenever he goes. In a USA Today interview, King recently anointed new CNN anchor John Roberts:
Q: Go ahead, anoint your successor.
A: (CNN's) John Roberts. He was a great White House correspondent, and he's a natural interviewer.
That might seem like an honor. But before Roberts, King had anointed a different successor -- American Idol host Ryan Seacrest. He called him a "classic generalist," but didn't know if he had any game in the political arena. The comparison of Roberts and Seacrest isn't completely off-base, since Roberts used to be a video jockey in Canada (he went by the name "J.D. Roberts.") One of his old CBS colleagues told me they used to needle him by calling him "J.D." in the hallways.
PS: When asked who his top five interviews were, Larry King cited Frank Sinatra, two 1960s black leaders (Malcolm X and Martlin Luther King), and two annoying leftists (Mario Cuomo and Jane Fonda).
—Tim Graham is Director of Media Analysis at the Media Research Center
















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Katie
April 21, 2007 - 07:43 ET by allanfSomehow it is not suprising that the saccharin sweet Katie would have an aide make up childhood history. Wow that's just like Hillary!!!!
Just why they would fire Ms. McNamara is puzzling. Do these guys at CBS still purport to be a non-fiction shop?
As for Soledad, I can understand her gratitude towards Katie. Just know Soledad that if you had expressed any conservative leanings, Katie would not have been as nice.
Katie Couric a journalist?
April 21, 2007 - 07:44 ET by NoMoreClintonsKatie Couric a journalist? When did that happen?
I can understand this as I ha
April 21, 2007 - 08:49 ET by americaneagleI can understand this as I have been the victim of this type of scandalmogering as well! It all started when my ancestor Kunta Kinte was captured and brought here on a slave ship, piloted by a conscience striken captain....oh wait, that's not me that's Alex Hailey! Excuse me while I fire my assistant for this grievous error.
Katie Couric+CBS+falling ratings=journalistic fraud
AE -- it's funny and kinda
April 21, 2007 - 09:00 ET by Jack BauerAE -- it's funny and kinda weird that you should mention that tall tale in relation to Couric.
It has long since been proved that Alex Hailey was himself a plagiarist and fantasist. The supposedly real Roots is a work of fiction stolen from another author.
Hey thanks Jack, I was thinki
April 21, 2007 - 16:03 ET by bigtimerHey thanks Jack,
I was thinking along those same lines when I read ae's post...just didn't quite know how to do it...
So I left it to you!
Great job.
The corruption of the langu
April 21, 2007 - 08:57 ET by Jack BauerThe corruption of the language continues...
The lib***l definition of bravery?
Sure. That's amazing. Give that woman a medal.
Right, Jack. It's not like
April 21, 2007 - 15:31 ET by motherbeltRight, Jack. She's been angling to get that job for years. And now we're supposed to think she's a hero because she got it? Give me a break. And I'm going to say this.... I really think if the network wasn't so dead set on having the first woman solo anchor, she would not have gotten the job.
There! I said it!
I think I am feeling sick...
April 21, 2007 - 09:22 ET by goldenthroatThis left-coast, bleeding-heart, 'do-as-I-say-not-as-I-do' liberal mutual admiration society makes me want to get out the barf bag and the pepto-bismol.
Never dance on an empty stomach unless it's a liberal.
Pelosi and Katie are suppos
April 21, 2007 - 13:56 ET by Right2thePointPelosi and Katie are supposed prime examples of breaking the glass ceiling, but most of the highly competent women I know are doing a polish salute single hand smack to the forehead and searching frantically for the self destruct button on these misguided missles with the other.
All of these people really tr
April 21, 2007 - 15:48 ET by bigtimerAll of these people really truly live in an elitist leftist bubble.
No reality. None.
Twilight Zone.
“She’s gone out and tackl
April 22, 2007 - 00:55 ET by MidAmerica“She’s gone out and tackled something, and nobody before her—no woman—has done the evening news,......
The evening news? What the heck is that? Is it different from morning news? Is it more real?
Or is it just a holdover from another time.
It's like when neanderthal man and modern man briefly existed together.
After reading this piece, m
April 22, 2007 - 05:13 ET by jmad627After reading this piece, my conclusion is that Soledad supports plagiarism.
The comment about Alex Haley was brilliant. I'd forgotten about that, and was shocked when I learned about it. However, in my recollection I don't think much was made of it then. The story came and went real quick--although I could be wrong.