GMA Provides Hyperbolic Report on ‘Moderate’ Global Warming Estimate

Photo of Scott Whitlock.

On Saturday’s "Good Morning America," correspondent Christianne Klein hyped this past weekend’s global warming rallies by reporting hyperbolic and misleading information on the subject of rising sea levels. Reporting from lower Manhattan before a gaggle of environmental activists, she said of the protesters, "Now, where they will stand represents where the Manhattan coastline could be if the sea level rises just 10 feet, actually, a moderate estimate for global warming standards."

A 10 feet increase is a moderate estimate? Not quite. As the CATO Institute's Patrick Michaels noted, the much hyped U.N. report released by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) suggested a rise of inches, not feet, is likely:

Under the U.N. Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change's medium-range emission scenario for greenhouse gases, a rise in sea level of between 8 and 17 inches is predicted by 2100....Even 17 inches is likely to be high, because it assumes that the concentration of methane, an important greenhouse gas, is growing rapidly.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

On the subject of global warming, "Good Morning America" has quickly morphed into the most activist network morning show. On Friday, April 20, GMA will take part in an all day event that a recent ABC advertisement described as "a call to action." Additionally, it asserted that "mother nature is sending us a message." The ABC program has also hyped a global warming college tour and the phenomenon of "green weddings."

So, perhaps it’s not surprising that "Good Morning America" has a somewhat skewed impression of what a "moderate estimate" is.

A transcript of the brief segment, which aired at 7:32am on April 14, follows:

RON CLAIBORNE: "And across the country today, hundreds of rallies are planned to try to spark action on the problem of global warming. ABC's Christianne Klein joins us now from downtown New York with more. Christianne?"

CHRISTIANNE KLEIN: "Well, Ron, in just a few hours, this place will be packed with people all wearing blue. Now, where they will stand represents where the Manhattan coastline could be if the sea level rises just 10 feet, actually, a moderate estimate for global warming standards. This is just one of 1300 events happening across the country today. The campaign is actually called Step It Up. It was kicked off last night in New Orleans. And the goal is to push Congress to cut global warming pollution by 80 percent by 2050. And just last week, an international group of scientists warned that the Earth is heating up, mostly due to greenhouse gases. They warn 30 percent of species could face extinction. There could be more heat waves, wildfire danger and more intense storms. Now, as individuals, there are many ways to cut down on carbon emissions. By reducing your garbage by just 10 percent, you can actually save more than 1,000 pounds of carbon dioxide a year. Ron?"

—Scott Whitlock is a news analyst for the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

a rise in sea level of betwee

a rise in sea level of between 8 and 17 inches is predicted by 2100

You mean back to where the sea level was during the Medieval Warming period when the Vikings settled Greenland?  And this is a disaster how?

“The object of life is not to be on the side of the majority but to escape finding oneself in the ranks of the insane.” – Marcus Aurelius

Klein probably found the find

Klein probably found the findings of the latest IPCC report too "inconvenient" for her story.  However, if she takes ridiculous Gore's forecast of 20 ft, then 10 ft is moderate.  It's still alarmist.   

Right-O. This issue abando

Right-O. This issue abandoned science -- even leftward science like the UN's -- a long time ago. Thus Algore IS the "global warming standard."

Once again Newsbuster outdoes

Once again Newsbuster outdoes themselves with the apt use of caption photos accompanying their stories. Bravo! It is good to see the mentally-handicapped finding opportunities as tv news reporters.

The picture is hilarious. Lo

The picture is hilarious. Looks like the St. Patrick's day parade in blue instead of green.

and the "sea" of pe

and the "sea" of people absolutely multudinous

All I need for this one is

All I need for this one is the tagline below.

Lee T.

U.S. Navy (ret.) / Hillsboro, Oregon

The history of the race, and each individual's experience, are thick with evidence that a truth is not hard to kill and that a lie told well is immortal.-- Mark Twain

Beside the obvious and typica

Beside the obvious and typical pro-APGW misinformation, I'd like to know how many protesters were there.  Only 8 show up in the photo. 

I was at an anti-tax rally on Saturday where several thousand people attended, but the local media either didn't cover it, or underrepresented the numbers.

Actual numbers or Good Mornin

Actual numbers or Good Morning America/Nation of islam math? Kind of like the modest 10 foot sea level rise. Inflated by quite a factor.

"The urge to save humanity is almost always a false front for the urge to rule.”   H.L. Mencken

While even the IPCC with its

While even the IPCC with its flawed models forecasts a sea rise of 8-17 inces by 2100, folks like ABC (Klein) apparently prefer to use estimates pulled out of thin air with the caveat " . . . could happen."

Of course, anything could happen over the next century, but we can't get anywhere with exaggerated claims like those.

For instance, we could be struck by a meteor, much like the catastrophic event believed to have triggered the Ice Age.  Should we invest trillions of dollar in meteor defense?

The only reason the network

The only reason the networks are peddling this tripe is because it makes money for them. If it didn't make money, they wouldn't be so enthusiastic about reporting this crap.

You watch. As soon as the monetary potential has been exhausted... they'll move on to something else.

You know that brings up a goo

You know that brings up a good point.  We know that the environmentalists special interest groups and certain politicians are behind this; one pushing for it's living in the 19th centruy type agenda and the other for more tax monies and for their true socialistic utopia.  Knowing that this (GW) is now big business, who else is behind this (besides the idiots in the MSM who will feed any info the said proponents above tell them too).  Everybody says AGW deniers are oil industry sympathizers----but has anybody looked into those that may be AGW sympathizers and disciples of this "religion"????  I.E. those that own Ethanol refineries and distribution hubs?  What about wind energy companies?  Even nuclear.

It would be well worth looking to see who needs to be exposed.... 

Hey, help a non-math-major

Hey, help a non-math-major out here. The planet is 75% ocean. Land based ice covers what...1% of the remaining 25%? That's 0.25% of the planet covered with ice and snow. In order to raise the ocean 10 feet, the water volume of the ice would be an average of 3000 feet deep...and it would all have to melt...and all the melted ice would have to stay in the ocean and not enter the evaporation-precipitation cycle.

Quit with your logic and nu

Quit with your logic and numbers. Countin and stuff, Al Gore can count too! one two- for- five! big deal! Let me ax ya dis... let me ax ya dis... can ya kick AL's ass?

end of gag.

"There are two types of people in this country; those who provide freedom and those who enjoy it." MM says...

According to this, a total

According to this, a total melting of Antarctic, Greenland, and mountain ice-cap and glacier ice would raise the sea level approximately 68 meters. They don't say what the percentage of land--bound ice is as it relates to water. Their estimate for surface area of the ocean is 362 million square kilometers.

I should probably point out that the link is to a report written by the IPCC in 2001. And we here at Newsbusters generally have a great deal of contempt for the IPCC. I wish I could have found a more trustworthy source.

Lee T.

U.S. Navy (ret.) / Hillsboro, Oregon

The history of the race, and each individual's experience, are thick with evidence that a truth is not hard to kill and that a lie told well is immortal.-- Mark Twain

abc removed

Already Been Canceled

This channel was removed from my list after I read the 10th Rosie story. These people don't like America and will do whatever is necessary to forward their agenda.

Send them some email, especially to their advertisers, and let them know you don't watch ABC anymore. With enough support we can get these liars off the air.

m1xram

And now Al Gore can't help sa

And now Al Gore can't help save the planet.

Sure he can -- he can get r

Sure he can -- he can get rid of the mega-mansion and live like a REAL American. But that would mean admitting he really isn't better than everyone else in the world.

Lee T.

U.S. Navy (ret.) / Hillsboro, Oregon

The history of the race, and each individual's experience, are thick with evidence that a truth is not hard to kill and that a lie told well is immortal.-- Mark Twain

Whataya got to say about this

Whataya got to say about this, swabby?

LeBron James hasn't tried t

LeBron James hasn't tried to tell me (yet, anyway) that I'm the cause of GLOBAL WARMING.  He can spend his money any way he likes, as long as he doesn't try to tell me how to spend mine.

Lee T.

U.S. Navy (ret.) / Hillsboro, Oregon

The history of the race, and each individual's experience, are thick with evidence that a truth is not hard to kill and that a lie told well is immortal.-- Mark Twain

"Whataya got to say ab

"Whataya got to say about this, swabby?"

Nice to see logic and the liberal mind are still far, far apart.

I could be wrong but it loo

I could be wrong but it looks like those folks holding the sign up are freezing their butts off in mid-April. How many more theatre of the obsurd tales do we get to see? Now that's comedy.