NY Times Columnist Selena Roberts' Huge Hypocrisy on Rutgers-Imus Flap


After sliming the Duke lacrosse players falsely accused of raping a stripper, Times sports columnist Selena Roberts returned to school on Wednesday with "A First Class Response to a Second-Class Putdown," about the Don Imus-Rutgers University women's basketball team controversy, in which the talk radio host denigrated the team by referring to them as "nappy-headed ho's." Roberts gushed about the Rutgers' players speaking truth to power:

"Of grace and dignity, without a single boob joke for ratings or a raunchy sidekick for on-air laughs, the women wearing Rutgers scarlet managed to capsize society’s power differential yesterday….But possessing the power differential means bullying someone your own size. With the ear of a national audience, Imus denigrated women who have revealed the courage to play a sport in its pure, fundamental form even though it is often branded inferior to the dunk style of men. The gals absorb enough put-downs as it is."

This marks huge hypocrisy on the part of Roberts, given that in the Duke lacrosse case, she eagerly sided with two separate bases of "power "-- an out-of-control local prosecutor, Michael Nifong, who now faces an ethics complaint from the North Carolina state bar*, as well as a politically correct college faculty and administration eager to side with what they considered an oppressed minority victim.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Not to mention Roberts herself, a prominent sports columnist in the nation's most influential newspaper, with the eyes if not the ear of a national audience that's comparable to that of Imus (as the MRC's Brent Baker demonstrated, Imus's TV and radio ratings are quite low).

For more New York Times bias, visit Times Watch.

*Editor's Note (Ken Shepherd | April 12, 11:34 EDT): We originally noted that the complaint was leveled by the North Carolina Bar Association. However, NCBA's Russell Rawlings informs us that it is not his organization that is pursuing ethics charges against Nifong, but rather the "mandatory N.C. State Bar which regulates the practice of law in North Carolina."

—Clay Waters is the director of Times Watch, an MRC project tracking the New York Times.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

I was sickened

I was sickened my ESPNs "group think" mentality yesterday.

I didn't hear ONE person on any of the shows I saw (granted it was only the daytime stuff) do anything but say Imus should never work another day.

It's amazing to me that the lesson that is being taught these girls, as if they are elementary school kids, is if you are insulted, revel in it and see how far you can milk the victim status.

It's ridiculous.

I just listened again to the coach's diatribe.

We can't forgive and forget. Another great lesson.

The comment that caused my mo

The comment that caused my mouth to drop was from one of the players when she said, "I am scarred for life."  FOR LIFE? How thin skinned can a person get? Of course, another player admitted that they hear this talk all the time in rap music.....(wonder why the first player isn't scarred for life from listening to rap music?)

Don't settle for a RINO. Let's find and support a TRUE conservative.

If you're going to let Don

If you're going to let Don Imus scar you for life, you've got problems. You probably shouldn't go outside, let alone compete in D1 college athletics.

the girls have obviously been manipulated

Odds are she was just repeating something she heard from the Coach or one of the University officials.  It's clear that these girls have been manipulated.

Remember, most of them are teenagers, and quite a few are freshmen.  These young girls have seen coaches as "gods" most of their lives.  From a young age, they have been taught to follow.   It's doubtful that any young woman of similar experience would be able to go her own way at this stage of her life. 

Right RJ

Especially when you are forced to have either practices or games Sunday Morning.

Many kids that are part of our church really go through allot trying to put God first and be at Church and then be part of Athletics which demand it be the #1 thing in your life.

young girls exploited by power figures is a well known phenom

What many don't seem to grasp in their rush to condemn everyone involved in this overblown wailing party is that young girls are especially prone to manipulation by power figures in their lives.  Why do you think we have a need to go out of our way to try to protect them from being sexually exploited by older power figures?  Because it's well known that they are vulnerable to manipulation by those power figures.

Edit:  Your example seems to prove my point more than refute it.  The girls you mention are following the wishes of their leaders, not going against them.

scarred for life

If I didn't know what they were talking about I would have thought that Imus had brutally raped and beaten them and left them for dead or something.

I am sure there are women who have gone through the above and walked away with more dignity then some of those at Rutgers.

Uh, oh!Imus better have a go

Uh, oh!

Imus better have a good attorney. "Scarred for life" is the code phrase for "We're gonna sue his ass!".

I haven't listened to any of it

I haven't listened to any of it, and probably won't.

I do not believe a single player nor the coach nor any of these goofy reporters are actually offended.

It's all about me face time, and seeing not only how much TV talk you can acquire and milk from it, but how you can "get back" with it and look all goody two shoes. If you call for firing, that means you are so good those few words are something so bad you've never done it in your life, and never would by golly you're a saint. LOL ( Not a single person babbling is above those words ).

There's one "bad person" here, IMUS, all the other players get their "I feel good not being a racist bigot insensitive lout, like that IMUS was, and I'm so good, I'm gonna help all the rest of us goodies to publicly punish and humiliate that bigot. This is a lynching, now pull up a chair for the show trial. By the time we're done he won't ever be able to even think what he said again and admit it. We'll instill the required fear, and watch him grovel before all of us. No circus ticket purchase required. "

Yes, they're all such wonderful people, so kind to make 3 words on a radio their life mission, and they smell like daisies, the more punishment they call for, the more they smell like roses, pile on for goody two shoes points.

 That's pretty much it. They know they can do it, and they know they've destroyed others for the same or less. It's a big power trip as well, no doubt about it.

...these "offended"

...these "offended" people really do seem to be enjoying the opportunities arising out of this incident now don't they...?

Is this really hypocrisy, or

Is this really hypocrisy, or could it be unmitigated stupidity? 

i think this lady places the

i think this lady places the importance of being a liberal over that of being  female ... nice

OK, pile on. I don't see the

OK, pile on. I don't see the hypocrisy. These are two totally different situations. What am I missing?

(see above)

(see above)

There have been 2 standards

There have been 2 standards and people like Salena Roberts and many others in the news media feel they have the right to slander and defame people they do not like or agree with based on zero evidence and then give a pass to others who they do agree with. Sharpton called jews every derogatory name in the book and you still see him acting as some sort of moral authority. The man is gutter trash and should never be given a microphone. to spew hishate.

What was fascinating was watching Spike Lee the film maker who Imus and his producer were quoting sitting in the Today Show continuously stating that Imus should not be given another chance. And he wrote and produced this stuff.

Affair

This entire affair exposes liberalism for what it is. Moral relativism-- only right or wrong depending on who you are and what other "conditions" exist. Total hypocrisy-- P.C. at its worst. The predominance of ignorance--any nation who would take Al Sharpton ( or Rosie,or most other "mush for brains" commentators) as the arbiters of "racism" is in deep soup. This is what liberalism has wrought. Sad.

NEVER,NEVER trust a liberal

Balboa

The similarity,or rather the difference balboa is, in the first case she sided with big powerful authority - when it was wrong , and in this case - she sides with "the little people" claiming it was a huge victory putting power and authority in it's place.

 So, she should have put power and authority in it's place in the Duke case, instead of doing the opposite there even as the power and authority was as wrong, and 1,000,000 times more wrong than in this case. 

The New York Times is the nat

The New York Times is the nation's most influential newspaper?

Is life so dear, or peace so sweet, as to be purchased at the price of chains and slavery? Forbid it, Almighty God! I know not what course others may take; but as for me, give me liberty or give me death!´´
--Patrick Henry

Patrick Henry

People just won't go out on a limb anymore, will they?

This is how Selena Roberts th

This is how Selena Roberts thinks: Female black players are innocent. Male white players are presumed guilty.

I am sick and tired of the hy

I am sick and tired of the hypocrisy in the msm...sick and tired of it all.

The media needs to make a huge apology, quit being so quick to judge people instantly for months and months, plus a couple of people Nifong and the accuser need to go to jail/prison.

By the way here is a picture and info on this wonderful gal who has made these mens life hell and hurt women that have been raped in real life that will be afraid to report a real rape.

http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,265374,00.html

Where is the outrage of the reverse racism and sexism...where?!