
The Media Research Center's Gala has only recently concluded. It will be almost a full year until the DisHonors Awards are again distributed. Even so, Scott Pelley's query to John McCain, aired on this evening's 60 Minutes, has to be considered a strong, early contender for Most Inane Question in next year's running.
View video here.
Let's set the stage. 60 Minutes had devoted extensive time to McCain's recent trip to Iraq. Particular attention was paid to his visit to a Baghdad market, which, as it turned out, was carried out with very considerable security surrounding him. Even so, McCain acknowledged during the course of the interview that he was in large measure staking his candidacy on the success of the surge.Immediately preceding his question, Pelley had noted that five generations of McCain's family had attended West Point or Annapolis. McCain was shown in his Senate office pointing out a picture of his father in Vietnam when he was commander of US forces in the Pacific.
Observed Pelley: "Now McCain's family is serving again. He has a son in the Naval Academy and another son 18 years old, headed toward Iraq."
There then ensued this exchange:
SCOTT PELLEY: Your son Jimmy volunteered to serve. Why?MCCAIN: Cause he's a fine, he's a patriotic American.
PELLEY: Did you try to talk him out of it?
MCCAIN: No. But I really don't talk about him or my other son very much. I think my son is no different than the thousands and thousands of other sons and daughters who decide they want to serve their country. And I'm not sure it's much more complicated than that.
Let's review. Pelley knew that McCain was a war hero who had spent five years as a POW in Vietnam. That he came from a long, proud line of military men. That he fervently believes we need to try to win in Iraq, and that he is staking his candidacy on it.
Under the circumstances, were there any circumstances -- any -- under which Pelley could have conceived that McCain would have attempted to persuade his son not to serve, much less tell Pelley that he had?
If an MSMer is going to ask a more inane question in the coming year, he's going to have to work very hard. Then again, when it comes to this kind of thing, the MSM are a very hard-working bunch. But, on this final day of the Masters, let's say Pelley has the early clubhouse lead.
Mark was in Iraq in November. Contact him at mark@gunhill.net
—Mark Finkelstein is a NewsBusters contributing editor and host of Right Angle. Contact him at mark@gunhill.net.















Editor at Large

Comments Policy
How disappointing for Pelle
April 8, 2007 - 20:03 ET by motherbeltHow disappointing for Pelley. You know he had to be hoping that McCain would say yes, although you have to wonder why he would think he might. He was plainly fishing. He should have followed the trial lawyers' advice: never ask a question that you don't know the answer to. I just wish that McCain, instead of elaborating, had simply said "No." It would have been interesting to see what Pelley's follow-up question would have been.
It's obvious what he meant
April 8, 2007 - 22:21 ET by SportPoliticsIt's obvious what he meant. He meant " Why the hell didn't you talk your son out of it ? "
Of course, that's exactly why he had to ask it. What lunatic would not try to talk their son out of a failed war that was started on lies to steal oil and enslave other nations and control the middle east and give favors to Halliburton ?
It was his personal way of INSULTING McCain.
Fake war on terror
April 9, 2007 - 19:06 ET by 01-20-09I didn't have to give my kid the pep talk, he knew on his own not to
join the military -- just like my dad didn't have to talk me out of
joining for Nam.
Him and all his friends all went to good NE colleges and are making
good bucks, not one of them joined to serve Bush and Halliburton in the
fake war on terror. They are all smart, big, 24 year old, athletic kids
-- we all got together at the corner bar over Easter, most flew in.
90210...ain't America great?
April 9, 2007 - 19:27 ET by RJAin't America great?
Even small-minded, self-congratulatory, self-centered families like yours can participate. Not only that, but no one is saying you're required to help others protect your freedoms. What a great country!
Once again, someone I am obli
April 11, 2007 - 10:34 ET by BDOnce again, someone I am obliged to feel superior to....
Just so you know, BD
April 11, 2007 - 10:53 ET by RJJust so you know if you run into this 90210 leech again, BD: last night, he was in full throated rage against our military and GWB. (it's gone now because of Matthew's system correctons) He peppered his posts with all the standard moonbat words: "nazi, lie-brary, illegal war, Nixon, cronies, and so on. Of course, the soldiers who told Diane Sawyer that they wanted to complete the mission were "instructed in what to say."
Seems to me he protests too much. I'm betting he knows he's a leech. I'm betting he's embarrassed that honest, proud people are protecting his lifestyle.
I wished 60 Minutes would be
April 8, 2007 - 20:12 ET by bigtimerI wished 60 Minutes would be reduced to 60 seconds.
Pelley was totally insane to ask such a question...but insanity runs in the media markets of all venues.
I know what I would of said to Pelley....
Go ahead, tell us! [PG-13
April 8, 2007 - 20:23 ET by Mark FinkelsteinGo ahead, tell us! [PG-13 version, of course]
Well see Mark, thats where I
April 8, 2007 - 20:38 ET by bigtimerWell see Mark, thats where I have a problem...the PG-13 version....
Hmmmm...still thinking how to revise my thoughts...still thinking...nope can't be done!
LOL!
Seriosly...I would of asked Pelley if he was mentally challenged to ask such an asinine question with a sweet well-moderated voice...McCain knows how to do that well for the media...if he kept it up, I would have to use my best stick it where the sun doesn't shine ...and then pull a Lynne Cheney and ask if he is one of those that want us to lose the war...that I am damned proud of my sons, they are protecting your arse type of retort....
See, thats why I would never make a good politician!
Mark and bt
April 8, 2007 - 22:27 ET by Gary HallI think this is something one could have fun with - but as you noted Mark, it's a bit tough to keep it PG-13.
How about fair and balanced questions Pelley could ask of, say Hillary Clinton.
The correct response would be
April 8, 2007 - 22:30 ET by RJThe correct response would be: "I don't understand why you ask that. Would you please elaborate?"
I have to agree: would have
April 8, 2007 - 22:36 ET by Mark FinkelsteinI have to agree: would have really enjoyed that.
RJ and Gary...Yeah well I'm j
April 8, 2007 - 22:39 ET by bigtimerRJ and Gary...
Yeah well I'm just not correct or PC enough....lol!
In my opinion Pelley would of just tried to spin it another way...but thats just me.
Gary that was rich....I would give anything if just once someone, anyone would ask questions like you posed...never gonna happen I know....still I wished!
Hypocrites all...obvious hypocrites at that.
oh, it'll happen
April 8, 2007 - 22:58 ET by Gary Halloh, it'll happen -- just about the time that the earth warms up 7 degrees - or, just as our sun is aging into a red giant.
Okay Gary...Gotcha!When pigs
April 8, 2007 - 23:13 ET by bigtimerOkay Gary...
Gotcha!
When pigs fly!
Laughing out loud now from your post...my dog is worried!
John McCain's son was sent t
April 8, 2007 - 20:30 ET by ZoneDaiatlasJohn McCain's son was sent to Camp Pendleton in September last year when my baby brother graduated there from the Marine Corp...
Here I thought that none of
April 8, 2007 - 21:06 ET by John in CAHere I thought that none of our politician's children were fighting this war.
What the MSM can't understand is the desire of many to serve. They can't understand why in some families, generation after generation choose to serve. Somehow the MSM sees that as a flaw. They don't understand that those previous generations were proud of their service and passed that pride on to their children. They don't see that some Americans think this country is worth fighting, and even dying, for. The MSM sees that as a defect.
Duncan Hunter is a veteran, Army Airborne, IIRC. His son was (is?) a Marine with two deployments to Iraq. Why, oh why, the MSM would ask.
Would the MSM ask someone why generation after generation in some families become cops? Or firemen? I doubt it.
My Dad was a career Navy man. He never tried to talk me out of serving - never. All he ever told me was that I could do anything I wanted to do, and made sure (kicked my butt even) I did well in school.
Give a Democrat Party free America a chance!
The question to McCain raises
April 8, 2007 - 21:25 ET by GalvanicThe question to McCain raises the issue about elites, their progeny, and the all-volunteer military. Certainly, Pelley thoughtthe qeustion relevent because McCain comes from a family with a long line of distinguished, career service.
But with all the huffing and puffing by the anti-war crowd, and in particular, Congressman Charles Rangel (D-NY), about restoring the draft in order to, ostensibly, curtail the President's and Congress's use of military force, perhaps the MSM should ask these questions of all politicians:
1. For those with children 16 years of age and older: Have you ever discussed military service with your son/daughter, and if so, what did you recommend?
2. For those with children under 20 years of age: If the Selected Service was restored, and your son/daughter were drafted to serve and dodged the draft instead, do you think you son/daughter should be arrested and prosecuted?
congress has a higher percentage in military
April 8, 2007 - 21:35 ET by Pragmatic-ManJust as a note: congress has a higher percentage of proginy serving in the armed services than the general population.
Not detracting from your point, though. The questions are still valid, if worded correctly. I would rephrase to take out the personal nature, and instead generalize as to what they think a parent should advise, or how a parent should act once their child makes a decision to enlist or dodge. It's the personal trap that politicians get caught in. Cheney's stand on gay marriage versus his relationship with his daughter, for example. A fine line surely, but always important in my mind to try and separate the family man from the political man. But even I have difficulty with this at times. I like Newt, for instance, but hey, how can we take him seriously when he was cheating during the impeachment?
"Just as a note: congr
April 8, 2007 - 22:14 ET by John in CA"Just as a note: congress has a higher percentage of proginy serving in the armed services than the general population."
Pragman, that's what I was trying to say - obviously not very clearly. Shoulda used the standby /sarc off tag. Dang internet communications, sometimes the intent gets lost in the bits and bytes.
How many Americans, thanks to Michael Moore believe that politician's kids don't serve? Too many would be my guess.
Give a Democrat Party free America a chance!
Dang! Sorry John...
April 8, 2007 - 22:39 ET by Pragmatic-ManDang! My sarcasm detector is not functioning well. Sorry, John!
And look at the curious place
April 8, 2007 - 21:35 ET by winston smithAnd look at the curious placement of Pelly's middle finger against his temple. You think he's trying to send a subtle message to McCain? Would be a great Captionfest pic.
Pelley is a very seasoned TV
April 8, 2007 - 21:38 ET by Gat New YorkPelley is a very seasoned TV person - I would have a hard time believing that it is an accident.
pelley
April 8, 2007 - 22:14 ET by Emma GrumpPelley is just another plastic talking head, spouting off the official MSM agenda. Anyone who volunteers to serve this country is an ignorant boob in their eyes. Patriotism, duty, honor, and courage are qualities they do not possess, nor does anyone else in their limited circle of like-minded friends. In olden days, people like him were known as cowards, but I guess that is politically incorrect in today's self-absorbed society.
"The use of the word 'coward' has been deemed judgmental, and is hereby banned from use. The new term 'vertebraically challenged' shall be used in its stead".
Once again we have a Republic
April 8, 2007 - 23:00 ET by jdhawkOnce again we have a Republican, one that I don't think deserves the nomination by the way, that is underserved by his supporters. That McCain and his supporters didn't realize that the drive-by media is there to ensure that whoever emerges as the Republican candidate fails to get elected is just stupid. What does it take for McCain, et al, to stand up to this type of questioning and throw it back in their faces?
jd,I think ALL of the Republi
April 8, 2007 - 23:09 ET by Blondejd,
I think ALL of the Republican candidates need to continually throw everything back in the faces of these liberal tools who work for the mainstream media.
It's the only way.
They can play, or they will pay. I won't vote for anyone who goes along to get along....particularly not anyone who plays paddycake with the mainstream media.
Remember, they have to impress us, before they get to run in the general election.
blonde--- pelley
April 8, 2007 - 23:16 ET by misterbillI would like about 5 minutes in a dark alley with Pelley. About two weeks ago he had the Lieutenant that is up on charges of murder in Iraq as a guest. He asked him questions like; "How could you do such a horrible thing?" etc. He was convicting him in the court of public opinion before he even went to trial. The lt. was afool to go on the show. He was no match for "when did you stop beating your wife" questions. He may indeed, be guilty, and get convicted, but it is not up to scumbag Pelley to do it on public TV. I detest the man.
Huckster journalism, to be su
April 8, 2007 - 23:25 ET by BlondeHuckster journalism, to be sure.
These predators (no other word for them) "interview" regular people, then try to frame it as though they interview professional politicians, or somesuch.
It's disgusting.
The entire journalism profession is beyond repair, IMO.
I'd much rather get my news on a forum like this....we have great bloggers who pick up the basic stories....but I always find the links from the commentators to shed so much light on a subject.....and a much more well-rounded way of gathering information, too.
<edit> mrbill.......great to have you back here, kind sir. Leave tumbler alone...he's not worth raising your blood pressure.
blonde
April 8, 2007 - 23:31 ET by misterbillI was in Tampa last week with old friends. I suggested to wayne that he tune in to NB. He asked me some questions about the types of people esp. the opposition. I told him about tumbler, blarsen and others. He said he would not join in because he gets so angry with fools that he may have a heart attack. (He is 72.) He detests the MSM, he watches Fox and Cspan. He onlines (as I do) with National Review). BUT--he said he just does not want the aggravation of listening to Liberal fools. (I will not use the language he used when discussing the St Petersburg Times.)
PS
April 8, 2007 - 23:32 ET by misterbillPS-- He is not thrilled with the Real estate tax in FL either.
Well, mrbill....I'm glad you
April 8, 2007 - 23:39 ET by BlondeWell, mrbill....
I'm glad you were in my lovely state last weekend.
Sorry your friend doesn't care to join...but if you can do as I do, and only engage the trolls when you feel like it, it's just fine.
Liberal fools are a fact of life. I can't even get into the conversation with two libs I had a few weeks ago....I'm still shaking my head.
I asked one why she was supporting Hillary....the response was "because she's so pretty and smart".
D'oh!!!!!......And you wonder why I'm still shaking my head!!!!!!!!
Good to see you though, mrbill. Keep walking on the bright and right side, enjoy, and don't ever let tumbler bother you again....he's just a troll.
blonde - off thread
April 8, 2007 - 23:44 ET by misterbillCame back to Atlanta--freezing my buns off (about 40 out there now). All last week in Tampa I was sitting on the veranda in T shirt and shorts. Come on summer!!!!!!!
I have detesed Pelley so long
April 8, 2007 - 23:32 ET by bigtimerI have detesed Pelley so long now misterb I have forgotten...he makes my hair fry without Global Warming...
That is why I originally said my reply would not be allowed on this site!
BT- I am sometimes oblivious
April 8, 2007 - 23:36 ET by misterbillBT- I am sometimes oblivious when I listen to theses talking heads---but--I really got so mad at Pelley that I was shouting at the television.
"For everything there is a time and a season for everything desirable under the heavens."
I believe that those of us who stray will answer one day!
Job Security
April 8, 2007 - 23:37 ET by acumenPELLEY: Did you try to talk him out of it?
McCain: No, that's your job.
acumen...Now that would of be
April 8, 2007 - 23:45 ET by bigtimeracumen...
Now that would of been perfect!
... They (the leftist msm) have worked hard at, year after year, to do just that.
In a somewhat related story,
April 8, 2007 - 23:47 ET by jdhawkIn a somewhat related story, I was flipping the channels this evening and came upon this gem, "Live from Bagdhad" circa 2002 HBO made for TV movie. It supposedly tells of the brave courageous CNN folks that arrive in Iraq just after Hussein had invaded Kuwait. What we know is that happenstance is a bold face lie as is the rest of the movie. CNN was there and had been there for years prior to Hussein's invasion of Kuwait. In fact they admitted that they had on the editorial pages of the NYT and had done Hussein's bidding. The movie moves from one castrophe to another with the CNN reporters screwing up American's lives in Iraq while sending back to the American people a pack of BS.
If there ever was a white wash of the truth this movie has got to be it. To recap, CNN hides how for years they got the stories they did while in Iraq . They screwed up American's live while in country. They legitimized Hussein. Then, they have a movie made to make themselves out has heroes and cover up their complicitnous of a heinous murdering henchman.
CNN has yet to make apologies to the Iraqi people let alone to the American public.
An interesting aside, if you read the reviews on the IMDB web site of the movie ( http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0319758/usercomments?start=0), the majority of the reviewers lambast HBO's efforts for portraying CNN for being like Fox News (conservative) and doing the "bidding" of President Bush. It is truly incredible.
Note to Clueless Pelley: Mc
April 9, 2007 - 00:27 ET by TENote to Clueless Pelley: McCain's son is not "in" the Naval Academy. McCain's son is "at" the Naval Academy.
While searching his bio at 60
April 9, 2007 - 05:53 ET by old croWhile searching Scott Pelly's bio at 60 Minutes, I can find nothing on his age but he graduated college and got his first job in 1975. He has a son, age not given, who I wonder has ever been in the military or even thought of being in the military. Odds against anyone? His bio reads like a Forrest Gump "been at all these defining moments" type of thing. To bad he hasn't learned anything from them.
Truth fears no trial.
- Proverb
Does Pelley have his middle f
April 9, 2007 - 07:39 ET by Chubby57Does Pelley have his middle finger raised in the picture?! Must work for CBS (Crescent Broadcasting System).
Excellent spot chubby. Yes,
April 9, 2007 - 07:59 ET by Jack BauerExcellent spot chubby. Yes, he appears to be giving McCain the middle finger.
How times change.
It used to be conservatives who gave RINO McCain the MF, when he was the media darling and favorite Republican for the MSM.
I didn't had the opportunity
April 9, 2007 - 08:28 ET by Senior ChiefI didn't had the opportunity to watch the show, but why Pelley didn't scrutinize Sen. McCain instead about his military service, his POW experience, his political views, his candidacy. Leftoids has to find faults from folks serving in military. My 3 children, at 12 (twins) and another 6YO has determined to serve in the military. Did I talked to them to join or not to join? NO, they just love their country, and military service I believe is a way to prove their patriotism. Maybe they'll change their views in later years, but as parents, we will support their endeavors what might that be. For now, their favorite books are from Limbaugh, O'Reilly and Savage.
Senior Chief:I have been tryi
April 9, 2007 - 12:16 ET by BDSenior Chief:
I have been trying to tell people for years that it is not the downtrodden in our society that serve in the military at demographically out of whack numbers, but rather the children of military members like yourself.
I am one of a very few members currently serving who did not have any family history of service. I am a rarity when I compare my family history to my friends surrounding me at the barbecue yesterday here on post.
When you compare the kids of military members who enlist, you would hardly consider them poor, rather mostly middle class who have excellent educations courtesy of DOD schools who get into the best schools at a slightly higher percentage rate as compared to the general population of middle class as a whole.
Will my kids join? I cannot say, but if the current demographics hold true, I would say that barring physical disqualification - it is highly likely.
How long before the NYT posts
April 9, 2007 - 10:30 ET by nicksmith112How long before the NYT posts McCains son's picture and unit number.
Wouldn't the enemy (terrorists..not the MSM...lol.)love to get that info.
60 Minutes
April 9, 2007 - 11:16 ET by connmanHaving just watched the final round of the masters, I was too lazy to change the channel from 60 minutes and watched for the first time in a long time. I agree that Pelley asked one imbecilic question after another. I liked how he tied Bush into costing McCain the nomination in 2000. Did anyone see the Andy Rooney piece at the end of the show where I think he was trying to compare the President to the Queen of England? Or how when the opposition Parliment there that comes into power can vote out the Prime minister, wishful thing on old Rooney's part. The best part he saved for last, that most of "us" think that the President should go home to Crawford and stay there. How pathetic is that? Andy's 60 minutes were up a long time agao.
Rooney became looney a long t
April 9, 2007 - 11:43 ET by ThisnThatRooney became looney a long time ago. Too bad -- he was ok, and actually funny, in his early years. I liked it when he would question products or the small things that people do that everyone could relate to. He certainly is targeting a more liberal and rancid audience now. Wonder why he had to change the template? His idea? The boss? The environment he works in?
Rooney became looney a long t
April 9, 2007 - 11:43 ET by ThisnThatDouble post. What's wrong with this site? And why is it so sloooowwwwwww?