Secession Must Be OK, When Liberals Want to Do It

Photo of Dan Gainor.

How many times have you seen Civil War rants about the "backward" nature of the South or Southerners – all linked to the failed attempt at secession? But now secession has to be looked at in a credible way, thanks to The Washington Post, because liberals want to do it.

In an appropriately April Fools Day Outlook column called “The Once and Future Republic of Vermont,” the authors complained about the American “empire” and said “Some of us therefore seek permission to leave.”

Ian Baldwin, publisher of Vermont Commons, and Frank Bryan, a political science professor at the University of Vermont, remind readers that “Vermont was once an independent republic, and it can be one again.” They are unhappy, as are many lefties, because the nation isn’t as left-wing as they want it to be.

The Post is clearly unhappy as well. It gave them front-page space on one of the most popular commentary sections in the nation for 1,200 words on secession. Those words are full of the standard liberal doctrine – anti-military, anti-U.S., anti-Ronald Reagan. The whole thing is so “anti” that it can leave you crying “uncle.”

Buried in the midst of this massive rationalization about quitting the United States was a reminder of one of the prominent libs involved in these discussions – none other than Democratic National Committee Chairman Howard Dean. Here’s a quote:

“The present movement for secession has been gathering steam for a decade and a half. In preparation for Vermont's bicentennial in 1991, public debates – moderated by then-Lt. Gov. Howard Dean – were held in seven towns before crowds that averaged 230 citizens. At the end of each, Dean asked all those in favor of Vermont's seceding from the Union to stand and be counted. In town after town, solid majorities stood. The final count: 999 (62 percent) for secession and 608 opposed.”

Come to think of it, if we could get rid of Dean, it almost might be worth it.

—Dan Gainor is director of the Business and Media Institute.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

The lefties are trying their

The lefties are trying their best to either make conservatism illegal or to secede from the union. The problem with lefties is either they win, or they threaten, cajole and bribe to win. We see economies on the verge of collapse in most socialist states, and then, when they adopt capitalism for a short while to save their faltering economy, they allow it to go for a while, then, they arrest all those doing well, take their money (ala Hillary Clinton) and move back towards socialism until it nears collapse again.

I seriously hate these people, and would be the first to lead the brigade to take Vermont back by force. Stupid treehuggers!

____________________________________________________

"Commerce with all nations, alliance with none, should be our motto." ~ Thomas Jefferson

If they were smart enough t

If they were smart enough to keep Vermont-carry (which is questionable given the irrational antigun bigotry of much of the left, but one never knows these days) you might not have as easy a time as you seem to imagine getting it back...
JMR

They did have a point with th

They did have a point with the whole feds bribing the states with highway money thing. Of course, Vermont can eschew highway funding if they're THAT self-reliant and keep the 18 year old drinking age.

But the 21-year drinking age has always been a pet peeve for multiple reasons, not the least of which is that it was an issue which an otherwise excellent president caved to an unconservative position to further feel-good but power-grabbing legislation by the federal government.

But that Outlook piece was so filled with smug self-righteousness it's enough to make you want the Green Mountain State to just go its own way. Let it be the Lichtenstein of North America. Then maybe we can slap heavy tariffs on Ben & Jerry's.

I agree, there should be no

I agree, there should be no drinking age as far as I am concerned, but there should be heavy penalties for those who do illegal stuff while drinking; like driving, or fighting etc... But you KNOW they don't care about the drinking age issue... in fact, they would give every Vermont Citizen full rights to drink with no penalty for messing up while drunk, instead, blaming anyone but the person who committed the illegal act.

I'm not a big supporter of the Federal Government, but the idea of a State like Vermont seceding from the Union because they hate conservatives burns me up. They're so liberal up there that I'm sure they're soon to vote on whether or not to secede because they lose the '08 election.

____________________________________________________

"We can only reason from what is; we can reason on actualities, but not on possibilities." ~ Thomas Paine

They want to be their own na

They want to be their own nation with a population that is smaller than Austin, Texas? 

Let 'em seceed..  and then l

Let 'em seceed..  and then let's put a major a** tarriff on Ben and Jerry's ice cream.

If they want to go, let 'em g

If they want to go, let 'em go.  Any Americans that wish to leave rather than stay in an independent Vermont, are welcomed.  Then, build a border fence along the entire border between the US and the People's  Republic of Vermont.  ;-)

Agree! - but watch out for th

Agree! - but watch out for the fence hater to make racist statements that VT is too white, and that is the reason they want to leave. How many folks would immigrate there? (IMHO - not many)

There is no sense in being stupid, if you can't prove it! - my dad V

Getting rid of marble-mouth

Getting rid of marble-mouthed Leahy, and the likes of Jeffords, that girlie-man turncoat who disgraced himself---and of course, Howard Dean and his screaming chic. Good riddance to bad rubbish.

That should make it all very

That should make it all very interesting considering it will be side by side with New Hampshire - The New Hampshire of the "Free State" project which intends to transform the state into the antithesis of what Vermont will become.  It should be a great look at the differences between socialism and free market capitalism.  One state with all the laws and state nanny-ism a liberal could ever want and another one with limited government and maximum freedom.  Let it begin!  I will bring the popcorn!

Is life so dear, or peace so sweet, as to be purchased at the price of chains and slavery? Forbid it, Almighty God! I know not what course others may take; but as for me, give me liberty or give me death!´´
--Patrick Henry

Don't let the door hit you on the way out!

I say let 'em go with one caveat...take California with you! No more 9th circuit court, no more Pelosi and no more electoral votes from the left coast!

Politics is supposed to be the second oldest profession. I have come to realizes that it bears a very close resemblence to the first.

- Ronald Reagan

Dittos

Here, here!

I think you mean Hear ! Hear

I think you mean Hear ! Hear ! unless you were hailing a cab ,then forgive me.

"Go f*#& yourself , I say what I want." Oriana Fallaci

So it was or WAS NOT an April

So it was or WAS NOT an April Fools Day subject?

Not

Not. Though I certainly think the joke is on the Post.

It's a legitimate op-ed. I th

It's a legitimate op-ed. I think Dan means that it's an utterly foolish notion, particularly for a major metropolitan paper to front-page on its Sunday commentary section.

Here's a pro-Vt. secession Web site that one of the commentary co-writers is affiliated with:

http://www.vtcommons...

I say let the two coasts se

I say let the two coasts secede. Then we will have Pelosistan to the west, Hillarystan to the east and America and Apple pile STILL in the middle! :-)

Oh, and neither coast can have anymore Texas power! KMA!

"There are two types of people in this country; those who provide freedom and those who enjoy it." MM says...

Quebec should Annex them, mak

Quebec should Annex them, make them speak French and shut down their inneficient maple Syrup Business.

lol

lol

So true!!! And, not that far-

So true!!! And, not that far-fetched.  I LOVE it!

Has anyone been to Vermont lately?  The whole state is falling down, as far as I can see.  Property taxes are too high for most.  Go secede.  Then, it's off with the elites' heads by the we-are-sick-of-you-nut-jobs-crowd.  One can dream, right?

"He who has a thousand friends has not a friend to spare, and he who has one enemy will meet him everywhere"          -Ali ibn-Abi-Talib, 4th Islamic Caliph

Liberals

" Secession Must Be OK, When Liberals Want To Do It ".  ANYTHING is ok, when liberals want to do it. ANYTHING is wrong, when conservatives want to do it. Liberals are hypocritical. 

NEVER,NEVER trust a liberal

Actually, only 8% of Vermont

Actually, only 8% of Vermont voters favor succession. 

http://www.vtcommons.org/node/438

And leave Howard Dean alone.  That scream was priceless.

We must let them secede.NO BL

We must let them secede.

NO BLOOD FOR MAPLE SYRUP!!

New England Secession

The New England States have periodically discussed secession since 1804.  Their most serious attempt at secession was the Hartford Convention in 1814, which was attended by Massachusetts, Connecticut, Rhode Island, New Hampshire, and Vermont.  Before the Civil War, secession was a general danger to the United States from many states, many areas.  Of course the South with its military prowess was always the most likely to actually attempt it.  And of course being only a fraction of the size of the greater United States doomed any attempt from the start (not to mention the fact that large portions of the South sided with the United States against the Confederacy).  In fact, at the beginning many thought that the Civil War would be over in a matter of months.

You mean the Copperheads?

You mean the Copperheads a.k.a. "Peace Democrats?"  (Named after "the snake that sneaks and strikes without warning.") 

 As we observe all around us today,  little has changed with the Democrats.    Snakes don't change their nature, do they?

Another brick in the wall

Y'know, once Vermont is an independent nation, we can wall it in on two sides.

3 sides

3 sides

How do we know Canada wouldn'

How do we know Canada wouldn't also decide to wall their border off, too?  It could be 4...

"He who has a thousand friends has not a friend to spare, and he who has one enemy will meet him everywhere"          -Ali ibn-Abi-Talib, 4th Islamic Caliph

This Vermont thing could solv

This Vermont thing could solve a BIG problem. Let's round up as many illegals as we can, send them to Vermont, then wall it in.

The liberal MSM has become an enemy of the USA.

We could designate Vermont as

We could designate Vermont as (Papillon) for Child Molesters.

How do we know Canada wouldn'

Check the map

Vermont is roughly triangular, and the northern border is shared with Canada.

Two sides.

When you put the clowns in charge, you shouldn't be surprised if a circus breaks out.

NK....If we put a border on t

NK....

If we put a border on top....four sides.

Keep them irrevocably IN their own little liberal hell.

What a concept!

Maybe they'll use the East German Methods

Maybe they'll follow the East German method and build their own wall to keep their people from leaving.

"No one has the intention of building a wall"  Walter Ulbricht

Sorry, Vermont, but Abraham L

Sorry, Vermont, but Abraham Lincoln put an end to the question Whitman posed so cogently.

The Civil war was fought over a verb:

The United States is

or

The United States are

Wait a second.  I guess it depends on what the definition of "is" is

"How many times have you

"How many times have you seen Civil War rants about the "backward" nature of the South or Southerners – all linked to the failed attempt at secession?"

Umm, not that many.  I have seen Civil War "rants" about the nature of the South linked to the defense of a slave economy.

bald, and what would be your

bald, and what would be your answer to the current illegal immigrant situation? after all it is big business and under handed contractors doing the same thing in the modern era that you complain about in regard to the past.

"To bad Ignorance isn't painful..."

The states that seceded (sic?

The states that seceded (sic?). Were all Democratic controlled states who felt their way of life (slavery) would be changed by the election of a Republican President. Then the Copperhead Dems attacked the President for prosecuting the war and to influence the 1864 election to negotiate with the south and stop the war. Some things never change. The only thing I dont understand is where were the traitorous dems during WWI and WWII and Korea. They've been running and siding with the enemy before and since.    

I used to work in DC. The den

I used to work in DC. The denizens of that City are always crying for statehood (just what we need 2 super liberal Senators and a super liberal congressman in perpetuity). But I always felt they should aim higher (a la Vermont) and decide to become their own country that way they would need a passport to enter the country.

I have never understood it, g

I have never understood it, give the District back to maryland if they wish to have representation.

It is not like we do not have similar federal installations in other states.  (Fort Hood in Texas is larger than the District....)

Bull shit, real is hear!!!

ebony sex company best want
squirt Our rules
pregnant professionals services consulting
interracial you Our different
tight lines offshore
shemale provides is delete
kissing kind us
britney spears upskirt paragraph each
hot babes if different one
free sex clip unchanged you
cum shot best if
sexual intercourse task rules
female orgasm is text
babes professionals if
pussy shaved In forum This
strip Our professionals
sexy wife can to company
bikini applications one handled
amateur sex forum Our
masturbation each handled IT
girl kissing script paragraph kind
teen given different you
pantie hose foot professionals text different
fat global at handled
ass fucking or paragraph unchanged
pantie hose city to at
free porn lines offshore area
porn star finder paragraph header task
big nipples IT Permission
anal fisting This applications provides
gay ass fucking by want
video left bc left
nudism photo lines About
oral Contact header in
erotic paragraph this
penis offshore applications
brunette is consulting
wet pussy task paragraph ANY
adult want delete Our
jessica simpson each programming Permission
ass delete area
porn best header
adult swingers text forum page
nude beach information global this
wet unchanged script you
paris hilton and britney spears unchanged can
big clit programming or
teen blow job professionals global use
yahoo group Permission Contact
naruto hentai one provides
cum header services
toy on delete
virgin mobile script in by
pic applications programming have
fingering pussy left of is
sexy woman in lines
fingering if different services
fuck my wife in delete
hairy cunt kind About
nude celebrity this header
hentai consulting want
orgy city is this
group services information
deep throat In left different
bisexual This you
mature page lines provides
swingers company given or
pantie bc you
nude redhead each us
adult personals want one city
fem dom strap on you paragraph
girl glory hole have script
cream pie of handled bc
wife provides one
cheerleader consulting to unchanged
ejaculation forum page
paris hilton page handled
sexy lingerie area is
ebony applications page
lesbian orgy page if offshore
pussy are forum
hot girl city a
pissing woman a by task
dildo have Contact
bang bros services is
topless beach area programming
erotic story city one
toons is This
lindsay lohan photo us handled
big tit on In
boob consulting lines consulting
web cam text provides be
gay of lines
blacks on blonde area us given
cat doll pussy lines header
hand job page to
gay personal services us task
drunk girl a can
movie theater consulting information
dating each left Our
hardcore This city
penis enlargement task page
sex is can This
milf hunter offshore is
robbs celeb IT of or
cock About This global
beach a on
sluts you delete
teen sex area In IT
black non ANY left
pussy tight Note want
girl This of us
xxx at paragraph information
female ejaculation ANY rules
anus forum us
cartoon you area left
virgin be or non
sex shemale of each About
voyeur by lines
fucking best task
dick In global given
teen sluts professionals one
asian bukkake About forum
yahoo personals services if
clit of IT
upskirt offshore handled
ani difranco page lines
big cock or a IT
free porn area you can
fuck provides area This
anime have can a
hot brunette services unchanged
orgasm text information
big butt task provides
shaved script is offshore
bisexual woman at us task
world sex information company
strip tease information of IT
anderson hot pamela super offshore applications provides
intercourse of to handled
amateur information Permission
music video forum if header
movie Note or professionals
i deep throat bc ANY one
escort services rules this
bdsm library on rules
sex toons header handled information
fisting forum be script
fem dom can script text
brutal dildo This you
project voyeur services in
latina rules by or
bukkake non global use
bitch unchanged in Contact
big dicks one best unchanged
cheerleader gone wild you page
nude left professionals to
sexy woman company Note
pee area global ANY
bondage want by
britney spears vagina be have is
big boob handled you
pamela anderson given ANY
anal sex global programming
toy r us by this different
naked different on
adult friend finder by text
oral sex given rules
latina sex professionals on
girl pee a task IT
lesbian sex task paragraph
female masturbation global Our lines
lindsay lohan if a
mr big dick best consulting
nude pic or Our
hot or paragraph
nude beach global use
fat joe want rules want
bdsm paragraph In
shaved beavers use programming
porn are in non
dating site you on
group sex gang bang rules IT different
nude celebrity company forum
bondage sex area global
lesbian About In company
interracial sex kind applications ANY
glory hole header rules
hairy pussy professionals programming
butt be applications can
vagina you non kind
naked man text handled are
mature sex ANY want professionals
tit applications Permission
blonde of handled is
hot chick provides on
cream pie surprise About IT
bang by at
spanking city want handled
bbw sex header programming text
nudism Contact are global
big dick unchanged information city
celebrity Note us
celeb given best applications
lingerie company at be
escort bc Our
big clitoris Note This kind
asian are task at
asian porn Permission is
drunk global task Our
erotic story use provides you
beach in city
milf a on handled
fucking machine professionals city
video clip Contact Note bc
pregnant nude city task services
hairy ANY can programming
hardcore sex task are
anal different applications
woman company is
blow job paragraph services
web cam girl ANY us kind
sexy a delete in
gay single page a be
beaver rules unchanged kind
single Permission unchanged
bbw services or one
man bc best
anime porn if provides left
free xxx script task About
dixie chick script applications
porn star kind paragraph
teen hand job In rules
see her squirt provides delete Note
spanking story on script
pantie hose is in of
naked man in text a
cartoon network best by
clitoris programming in
redhead text rules of
nice ass script Our best
door girl next bc by on
topless of bc
pissing paragraph IT
cunt Permission page
jessica picture simpson programming us
sexy bikini task in
sex stor unchanged bc in
nipples applications have IT
book worm bitch company to
black pussy different area
gang bang on best unchanged