Rosie on Attorney Firings: False Facts, Bizarre Comparisons, and Impeachment Call

Photo of Justin McCarthy.
By Justin McCarthy | March 28, 2007 - 15:47 ET

The ladies of "The View" tackled the U.S. attorney firing controversy with more false information, comparisons to the mob, and once again Rosie O’Donnell called for impeachment. Rosie reported her take of how the attorney firings went down.

O’DONNELL: Okay, Republican officials who supposedly called these judges that were fired and said, are you going to prosecute this Democratic, and they said, I can't talk about that because I'm actually a judge, and it's illegal. And they said "click," and they got fired.

HASSELBECK: Yes.

O’DONNELL: Now what is really scary, are the ones who they called and said yeah, sure I will. And they're still on the bench. That’s even more frightening.

First, these were attorneys, not judges, the president fired. Judges are appointed for life and the president has no authority to fire them. As previously noted, there were plausible and very defensible reasons for the firings of at least three U.S. attorneys. One reason for Carol Lam’s dismissal was her failure to prosecute gun crimes. Rosie O’Donnell, a famous gun control advocate, did not note that. Token non-liberal Elisabeth Hasselbeck did not challenge Rosie on that claim.

Rosie brought up her favorite subject again, calling to impeach the president. Hasselbeck felt that would be "a bit extreme right now."

O’DONNELL: I think if there’s not enough reason to call for the impeachment of the president, I don't know what it takes. Somebody needs to stand up and do it.

[applause]

HASSELBECK: I think it's a bit extreme right now. I think it’s a bit extreme right now.

This led Rosie to speak of her other obsession: The administration is allegedly "torturing" terrorists.

 O’DONNELL: You have to have seen that documentary. Did you see his handwriting on the torture memos?

HASSELBECK: It standing on a box for eight hours was not that bad. That's what [Donald Rumsfeld’s] hand writing said.

O’DONNELL: And the people who were on the box, Elisabeth, were hooded, they had electrodes to them.

HASSELBECK: Right, he did not, he did not authorize that

O’DONNELL: He just wanted to stand on the box like you did on "Survivor."

HASSELBECK: I’m saying if you’re going by what he authorized.

O’DONNELL: It was a torture memo.

Joy Behar exclaimed this is another Watergate. Rosie did not buy that, this is much bigger in Rosie’s World.

BEHAR: It's Watergate again.

REID: It is. That’s what they’re saying.

BEHAR: There’s a lot of that going on. It’s deja vu all over again.

O’DONNELL: It's Watergate exponentially increased, because Watergate was Nixon and a bunch of guys who broke into his competitors building to see what their plans were.

BEHAR: There was abuse of power in those days and all of that.

O’DONNELL: Not to the extent of this administration. I mean, come on.

Finally, Rosie, in a really bizarre statement, compared firing only a certain number of prosecutors, as opposed to all of them, to "mob tactics"

O’DONNELL: But wait, but wait, if he wiped out 95 judges the first day, and you don't cherry pick the ones who are going to hurt your administration. That’s very different. That's mob tactics. That's Tony Soprano. We’re going to lean on people. That's what the president’s doing. That’s scary.

—Justin McCarthy is a news analyst at Media Research Center.

Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

I pity whoever Rosie decides

I pity whoever Rosie decides to lean on.

Sorry. That was too easy to pass up...

A good one, nonetheless.  :-

A good one, nonetheless.  :-)

A good one, nonetheless.  :-

(dupe entry)

El Shrubborino.Congratulati

El Shrubborino.

Congratulations on working the words 'Rosie' and 'lean' into the same sentence.

That has to be a first!

The answer is socialism. But only if the question is:

"What's the fastest way to impoverish, enslave and destroy people?"

It is no surprise that Rosi

It is no surprise that Rosie the O is mouthing off about something that she has no idea about. It's not even surprising that none of the other women know enough to be able to correct her. Attorneys, judges, what's the difference? Who cares?

Which part of "at the pleasure of the President" do they not understand????

Elisabeth Hasselbeck is the one that really makes me want to scream. Why does she kowtow to Rosie????? Impeaching the President is "a bit extreme right now"???? That's the best she could come up with?

Whoever dubbed this show "Rosie's Pig Pen" hit the nail on the head. She tramples everyone and everything in her insistence on running the show.

PS: that picture of Rosie is typical; mouth wide open and waving her arms. Same drivel, different day.

I agree with your assessment

I agree with your assessment of Hasselbeck.  She occasionally has the facts in order and fights back well, but generally, she gets brow-beaten by O'Donnell and her basket of myths.  Behar is even dumber than O'Donnell, so she just cheerleads.  And Walters --- once considered a serious journalist --- rarey corrects "The Mouth" when she should know better.

I'd pay to be in the studio audience the day "The View" has someone like Peggy Noonan, Laura Ingraham, or Kate O'Beirne to call O'Donnell on her 'facts.  I list those ladies, because the producers would never let Ann Coulter or Michelle Malkin on the show to make them all look stupid.

Galvanic...Coulter would be t

Galvanic...

Coulter would be the perfect replacement for Elizabeth!

I would pay to see a catfight between Rosie and Ann.

The liberal MSM has become an enemy of the USA.

motherbelt

"Impeaching the President is "a bit extreme right now"???? That's the best she could come up with?"   

Translation--"you fat ignorant loudmouth. pull your head out of your rear end and stop talking stupid." I wish Hasselbeck had the courage to say that then tell Baba Wawa,"You, Madam are a complete farce. You and your lardass queen over here should both br drummed off the air. As for me, I quit and you can kiss my foot."

Where ’s the coward that would not dare to fight for such a land?

Sir Walter Scott

Rosie's Pig Pen

Rosie's Pig Pen ( a.ka. The View ). She's so lucky to have what she has, yet she constantly bites the hand that feeds her. If she lived in Iraq, she'd be forced to wear two burkas ( one wouldn't fit ) and have her mouth sewn shut. She's a disgusting disgrace to womanhood.

NEVER,NEVER trust a liberal

Can we start a petition or

Can we start a petition or something to get "The Spew" cancelled? I am ready to do something. This is so past being a worthless show...it shouldn't be allowed on our public airwaves.

There are too many mindless T

There are too many mindless TV zombies that watch it for it to be cancelled. What really frightens me is they believe what they hear.

If only EH could/would stand up to her......

I honestly don't know how BabaWawa can slepp at night, seeing how her 'news' reputation gets drug further and further into the mud daily. Why doesn't SHE shut Rosie's big mouth?

Be thankful we're not getting all the government we're paying for. - Will Rogers

The vast majoirty of those &q

The vast majoirty of those "mindless tv zombies" are young single women. Who will all vote for Mrs. Bill Clinton in 2008. Be VERY afraid.

As for Baba Wawa, she knows this too. And since it would be a big part of her "legacy" to help elect the first woman President of the US, "journalistic integrity" be damned!

Oh yeah! More Rosie consterna

Oh yeah! More Rosie consternation. Let's start a petition!

Check this out, if you daaaare!

Reality has a well known liberal bias.

Ahhh! Now I understand. You

Ahhh! Now I understand. You hang out with lunatics! oooooh... I daaaare, I daaaare!

LMAO..... creep!

"There are two types of people in this country; those who provide freedom and those who enjoy it." MM says...

That's interesting, but she

That's interesting, but she's a piker when compared to Hillary Clinton, who, during Special Prosecutor and Congressional investigations used variations of "I don't recall" over 200 times. (Stats from Progressive Review website)

Clinton Legacy

I know you will say it's from a Clinton-bashing website, but that won't change the numbers.

Hey wiki wiki! Tell us about

Hey wiki wiki! Tell us about that other scandal, you know the one with Fannie Mae's former Clinton "Assistant Attorney General" Jaime Gorelick?

Ok, I just had to point thi

Ok, I just had to point this out - your tagline bugs me to no end because it is so incredibly stupid.

Reality by it's very nature cannot be biased. Bias by it's definition is how we deal with/interpret reality. Why don't you claim that chocolate has a liberal bias or that hurricanes have a conservative bias?

Good one Grim!  This just pr

Good one Grim!  This just proves that to a liberal, reality is relative. They have a "living, breating" reality that morphs into whatever they want it to be.  

This comment form Wacky Wacky's web link tells you everything you need to know about those nut jobs...   

"I guess the only place to really get the honest news IS from Jon Stewart"  

LOL!

When asked if he went to war with Iraq  to derail the impeachment vote:  “I don’t think any serious person would believe that any President would do such a thing." - President Clinton (Dec 1998).

It has always seemed to me

It has always seemed to me that liberals have a much stronger need to be vindicated and to 'belong' to a group - that they have a much greater problem with individuality than a lot of conservatives. It doesn't take long for a surfer of a liberal site to find a commentator or two claiming (perhaps, reassuring) how reality and the vast majority agree with him/her and the like minded echo of the site. (my favorite quote from that link: what do they have? culturally?? other than Toby
Keith? I wonder what music these people listen to or what films they
watch? For instance, do they EVER see stand-up comedy?? They have
nowhere to turn because EVERYONE disagrees with them and they hate it.
)
I've yet to see a sign that they can really exist outside a herd mentality. So many conservatives I've met wouldn't be depressed/angry/etc if they were the only one in a 100% liberal world. I guess it comes from having a backbone.

When ever Rosie speaks, one p

When ever Rosie speaks, one phrase comes to mind, "Diarrhea of the mouth." Come to think of it, that pretty well sums up the view.

Save a SeAL, club a liberal!!

This has got to be the dumbes

This has got to be the dumbest batch of bitches ever assembled for viewing pleasure.......or a close second!

for viewing pleasure---dugu

for viewing pleasure---dugun

Are you serious??????

Gag.


Hi, Everyone ... Newbie here.

There was an episode of "All In The Family" where Archie compares Edith to a gumball machine.  She just drops an idea down from her head and lets it roll out of her mouth like a gumball ... Yeah, sounds about right ... Come to think of it, looking at the Rosie picture above she closely resembles a gumball machine.  Sorry if I'm ruining gumballs for everyone ...

I think an apology to gumball

I think an apology to gumball machines is in order.  :-)

Not only that, but what then

Not only that, but what then would be coming out of her mouth. I will leave that to everyones personal brain nightmare - I take no responsibility for your horrid thoughts.

There is no sense in being stupid, if you can't prove it! - my dad V

JawBreakers!

JawBreakers!

er.. in Rosies case, JawlBreakers!

"There are two types of people in this country; those who provide freedom and those who enjoy it." MM says...

Obviously Rosie the whale nev

Obviously Rosie the whale never read Mark Twain.  He made one of my favorite quotes "It is better to keep your mouth shut and be thought a fool than to open it and remove all doubt"

What I find incredible is t

What I find incredible is that Rosie can actually hang upside down. One would think that, given her tiny, empty head that tends to float up like a balloon and her large, massive ass that tends to sucumb to the forces of gravity, this would be an impossible act for her.

She is truly a moron for all seasons.

Justin,You are one lucky dude

Justin,

You are one lucky dude. Your prize for being well educated and having exceptional writing skills is that you have to listen to Rosie O’Donnell who is a 2 college drop-out yet is the king intellect on this women’s television show.

Of course you could also be assigned to Sean Penn ( . . .  your smarmy pundits . . “) who dropped out of Santa Monica College after not being able to pass auto mechanics.

Or the great Tim Robbins (“There’s a cold wind a blowin’ . . “) who couldn’t make it after 2 years in SUNY Plattsburgh and had to escape to film school in L.A.

The great left wing intellect.

Let us not forget that algore

Let us not forget that algore dropped out of divinity school - and they only have one book, even if it is a Good Book.

There is no sense in being stupid, if you can't prove it! - my dad V

And John Kerry had lower coll

And John Kerry had lower college grades than Dubyah! By the way, did you know that Kerry served in the quagmire that was called Vietnam?

He did?  Oh, right, now I re

He did? 

Oh, right, now I remember.

Can you tell me again, how he didn't get "Stuk in Irak" all by himself in the lunchroom?  LOL.

Funny how this b**** can be s

Funny how this b**** can be so scared about judges being fired (which is completly the perrogative of the president), yet she'd almost be willing to go hetero for her hero Bill Clinton who's had more people connected with him end up in jail or in the morgue than any other politician in American History - and only escaped jail himself because so many gutless people cared more about the image of the presidency than they did about putting Billy behind bars where he belongs.

You don't hear a peep from th

You don't hear a peep from the corrupt MSM about this lunatic.
The left will take all the votes Rosie can get for them from the daytime television viewers even if she rarely uses any factual information.
Did any news outlets write about her 9/11 conspiracy nonsense??? I didn't see a word written condemning her.

I'm sure the prime viewer dem

I'm sure the prime viewer demographic for "The View" is young single females who aren't terribly bright.

Which is exactly the voter demographic that will give Mrs. Bill Clinton the Presidency in November 2008. 

Funny how this b**** can be s

Funny how this b**** can be so scared about judges being fired (which is completly the perrogative of the president), yet she'd almost be willing to go hetero for her hero Bill Clinton who's had more people connected with him end up in jail or in the morgue than any other politician in American History - and only escaped jail himself because so many gutless people cared more about the image of the presidency than they did about putting Billy behind bars where he belongs.

Like I said before; these libs are simply out for revenge over Bill Criminal's impeachment.  (Even though they should be thankful the RINOs in the senate were too gutless to convict him) - A lot of good being nice did for you, eh RINO's?

Actually, if Clinton HAD been

Actually, if Clinton HAD been convicted during impeachment, Al Gore would have become President, and as the incumbent would have easily won election in 2000, and re-election in 2004. All of which is scary to imagine.

But think of all those great

But think of all those great new inventions he would have created like the he did the Internet, not to mention saving the world from the imminent global climate catastrophe.

Dammit, Del, didja have to br

Dammit, Del, didja have to bring that up???  Talk about ruining a good thought ...

How sad

That poor woman is so ignorant, she doesn't know the difference between a "judge" and a US Attorney. Here's a freebie Rosie, US Attorneys are not sitting judges. And I rather doubt you would want them to be. If that were the case, they could argue their case to THEMSELVES while prosecuting. Talk about being judge, jury and executioner! They would be both prosecutor and judge. That would definitely help their percentage of successful convictions though. ;)

What is really sad is that most of her audience probably doesn't understand the distinction either.

Intellectually speaking, we have truly fallen a long way, haven't we? Should I laugh or cry?

I suggested before that the

I suggested before that the "Powers That Be" who run this blog call a moratorium on "Rosie the O" stories, because there's pretty much nothing left to say about her. But she's kind of like a car wreck....you don't want to look, because you know it will be ugly, but you can't help yourself.

I don't normally read any o

I don't normally read any of the Rosie posts. I see her picture next to the post on the front page of newsbusters, and I know without reading a single word that Rosie has said something completely insane and devoid of all logic and rational thought. It is really a case of same song, different day.

I forced myself to read this particular newsbusters post because I realize that (as scary and unfathomable as it may seem) Rosie provides an accurate portrayal of a not so insignificant portion of the American populace. As much as I would prefer to turn my head, or should I say bury my head in the sand, I force myself to stay semi-abreast of her lunatic ravings, just to be informed. But truthfully, I would prefer to bury my head in the sand. I love this country dearly. I would give my dying breath in defense of this country. And it pains me to see just how devoid of rational thought some of its citizens are. Some of those people are voting!

I worry for our country.

reply to Apache

I thought maybe I was the only one who thinks our country is not only half red/half blue but half smart/half dumb. Rosie Blubber proves I am right. Wonder where she went to school, probably with Ellen Degenerate. These people actually vote and we are right to worry. Government schools busy teaching multicultureism and computers but nothing else. Diversity crammed down our throats daily. Hoping for a backlash. Go Rudy!

Here Rosie...try to open you

Here Rosie..try to open you fat eye-lids enough to read...digest...comprehend some facts...you whale of a scum boat...you too Elizabeth, the poor pretty gal with no back-bone...

I am so tired of these people....just am.

Try to have to reconnect to the link later...sorry about that.

Huge problems with my local ISP today....messed up some things I am just finding out about...local Co. against Verizon...long story. 

This woman is unbelievable, b

This woman is unbelievable, but more unbelievable is that Barbara Walters has put up with it.  From what you all say, she never corrects the idiotic comments out of Rosie's mouth.  And so, what must be true is..... that Barbara is as stupid as Rosie, but has normally had people around her, telling her what to say and not say.  Now, she is letting it be said - all the things she evidently believes herself. 

In other words - "what tree would you be?" really was the level of her intelligence.

A street corner and a soap box

A street corner and a soap box.  Any idiot could speak.  We've always had them but now their soap box is taller and it's harder to avoid them.   It's National Enquirer on the Boob Tube.

The O'Donnells, the Cafferties, the Olbermanns, the Roonys....they're hired BECAUSE they say stupid and outrageous things.  And, God help us, it makes good ratings, which tells us scary things about the kind of people out there walking the streets and voting.

Amen RJ.... to all of that!Sc

Amen RJ.... to all of that!

Scary, spooky and pathetic! 

yeah...How many times have yo

yeah...How many times have you seen Jay Leno and others do their "man in the street" interviews? Of course they deliberately pick the stupidest responses to broadcast, but I doubt they have any difficulty getting enough stupidity to fill the allotted time.

Lee T.

U.S. Navy (ret.) / Hillsboro, Oregon

I have enough money to last me the rest of my life. Unless I buy something.

I have to say this and I hope

I have to say this and I hope I’m not too far over the line but I’m sick and tired of this Lib***l B***h.  She is unhinged, misinformed, and nucking futs.

Baba, wake up and scrap what ever dignity you had and fire this winch. 

AF,Did you see...of course yo

AF,

Did you see...of course you did...the reference I put up to Blackfive?

I am so supremely sick of the unhinged liberals.

I function, mostly day to day, in a "real" job.  But I have a hard time not taking heads of idiot libs.....you know, the "anti-war" dips.....can you help me out?

I'd appreciate something that would put them down (no, I don't mean a la a dead dog) that would make the libtards realize what our military is doing for us?

I am frustrated beyond belief! 

What I'm looking for is one cogent sentence, that would drive the liberal line of blather right into the ground.  And make the idiots stand up and say...wow!  I need to get on board.

Okay, AF...I know I'm asking for alot...but I am frustrated!

Thoughts...anyone?

It depends, blonde

It depends on your goal, blonde...do they have to remain friends or continue doing business with you?

Actually, I'm kidding.  I don't think they can learn to begin thinking for themselves with just a line or two.

RJ,It has nothing to do with

RJ,

It has nothing to do with my friends...

I am just so totally upset by the nastiness that passes for day to day discourse.

I call it the death of common

I call it the death of common sense and responsibility.  The liberal mind set is say anything, do anything to bring discredit upon the conservative movement in this country.

If it is religious (Christian mostly) it is bad.

If it is moral, it is bad.

If it is in any way American, it is evil. 

They are engaged in a war against the basic of the Constitution while hiding behind it.  Example: Rosie can spout any amount of drivel she wants yet cuts off the speech and belittles the token conservative on the show.  Then she will complain about the vast right wing and how it is trying to silence her.

Sorry Rose Bud (dude) you can’t have it both ways.  If you want to engage in a dialogue then shrill down the rhetoric and use your common sense. (I’m being optimistic there.)   

AF,That's close, but not exac

AF,

That's close, but not exactly what I was after.

I wanted a super put down....for the libs.

I suppose I, as well as all of the rest of us, are just tired of fighting this fight.

Sorry...I am just weary.

So, let the jihadis chop off the heads of our enemies.

What is so difficult about "Islam"?

Okay, I'm done for tonite.

Blonde,How about:  Heteropho

Blonde,

How about:  Heterophobic, conspiracy weaving, tree hugging, loud mouth college dropout with a passion for useless information and to wear a burka.

reply to air force

When did this evil begin? We weren't like that when Kennedy stole the election from Nixon? Bush needs to grow some and start using TV to address the people consistently and steadfastly about all this sh**.

I believe it started with Car

I believe it started with Carter and his getting in bed with Arafat.  Through the Regan years the counter culture off spring (Kerry, Clinton, ect...) really started their quest for power and a general hatred for the Conservative movement.  You can see the shift of the left in the schools and colleges of America. 

With Clinton coming into power we saw a crippling of the structure of the military and the intelligence departments. 

As partisan politics began to take hold in America it became the us against them attitude.  You saw on the left that any action we took to secure the well being of this country the Democrats hated and voted against it.  This is where the attitude of America is evil has came from.

Without flexing our muscle and putting down Bin Laden early we have enabled our enemies.  When people like Rosie spout her bile across the air ways and our present Congress does not support our President they empower them.

My opinion only.

reply to air force

Nucking futs....good one. You cannot reason with anyone like that; there is no other view point. They know it all...which is to say in Bubble Butt's case, nada.

"But wait, but wait, i

"But wait, but wait, if he wiped out 95 judges the first day, and you
don't cherry pick the ones who are going to hurt your administration"

Didn't Clinton fire 93 attorneys (which is what I assume Rosie meant by saying "judges", since she clearly doesn't know the difference)? Or is there something special about these 8 attorneys compared to those 93?

"something special"? yes -- t

"something special"? yes -- these 8 give the libs another outlet to express their BDS.

Lee T.

U.S. Navy (ret.) / Hillsboro, Oregon

I have enough money to last me the rest of my life. Unless I buy something.

Don't forget the all import

Don't forget the all important letters: Clinton (D) and Bush (R). I figure if you want to get away with anything in public office, just run as a Democrat. But you need to be a really liberal Democrat to get away with the worst behavior.


Remember; always obey High Lord God-King Al Gore. For His Word is law and must never be questioned.

"It's a freak show ... b

"It's a freak show ... baby on the dance floor ...

It's a freak show ... baby baby tonight"

(er ... this morning)

rosie's ignorance is more evi

rosie's ignorance is more evident every day she opens her yap ...

i work for the fed gov't ... our state director is APPOINTED in the same manner... the President appoints people at his leisure ... they are NOT contracted employees ... they can be let go for whatever reason at any time.  this whole argument is based solely on partisan politics not on the fact that those let go are POLITICAL APPOINTEES, not contracted federal employees.

following the 08 election, we'll get a new director ... simple as that.  these appointees do not have the same rights as a regular employee.

hey rosie ... tom cruise, star magazine and danny devito are not reliable news sources ... wake up

"At some point, the 'public' has to contribute more to society than just exercising its rights" - [PMOH]Buck

Okay. Here's my take on O'Don

Okay. Here's my take on O'Donnell and "The View":

I would guess that the audience is composed of young, ignorant, single females who have no jobs and may be at home with young children which they prefer to ignore. While other stay-at-home moms are too busy raising their children to have the time to sit down for coffee and chatter with the likes of O'Donnell and Behar. I believe that "The View" is nothing but a left wing tool being used to indoctrinate a whole class of people who will believe anything that someone who may be richer and more successful has to say. These viewers have neither the intelligence nor any interest in learning about the facts on their own.  Such programs are mere distractions for such viewers. And their influence is subtle but effective. And Walters knows exactly what she's doing. She's on the set in order to give the whole enterprise the appearance of respectability and credibility.