CBS Blogger Highlights Blogs Agreeing with Iran's Government About '300'

Photo of Ken Shepherd.

In time for the Persian New Year, CBS's Melissa McNamara trawled the blogosphere (including MySpace blog entries) and found bloggers who think Iran's Islamic extremist government has a point about "300" being "anti-Persian." In doing she, she produced a handful of blogs that appear to generate light traffic and in at least one case is just a rambling screed.

McNamara told readers that the "Islamic Republic News Agency" (IRNA) finds fault with the film's version of historical events. She left out that IRNA is Iran's official state-controlled news/propaganda service. CBSNews.com's resident "Blogophile" also noted objections from an Iranian newspaper, Hamshahri, which she described simply as "Iran's biggest circulation newspaper."

That's akin to a journalist during the Cold War describing Pravda as simply the Soviet Union's best-selling newspaper. Hamshahri co-sponsored a political cartoon contest that the Iranian government held last year that generated hundreds of entries that were anti-Jewish or anti-Israeli. Portions in bold are my emphasis:

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

TEHRAN, Iran — Iran awarded a Moroccan artist Wednesday the top prize in an exhibition of cartoons on the Holocaust that has received international condemnation, including from U.N. chief Kofi Annan.

Meant to be a response to the Danish cartoons of Islam's Prophet Mohammed that sparked rage among Muslims around the world, the exhibit appears inspired by Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad's tirades calling for Israel to be destroyed.

Tehran has several times announced plans to host a conference to examine the scientific evidence supporting the Holocaust, dismissing it as exaggerated. Its most recent announcement came in September during Annan's visit to the Iranian capital, where he said he discussed the cartoon show with officials.

"The Holocaust is a myth and this issue has finally made waves thanks to the action of President Ahmadinejad in daring to express himself on the subject and break the Holocaust taboo," Iranian Culture Minister Mohammad Hossein Saffar-Harandi said as he announced the cartoon winners.

Abdollah Derkaoui received $12,000 for his work depicting an Israeli crane piling large cement blocks on Israel's security wall and gradually obscuring Al-Aqsa Mosque in Jerusalem. A picture of Nazi Germany's Auschwitz concentration camp appears on the wall.

The mosque is Islam's third holiest site.

Tehran Museum of Contemporary Arts, next to the Palestinian Embassy, which was the Israeli diplomatic mission before the 1979 Islamic Revolution.

The exhibit curator, Masoud Shojai, said the contest will be an annual event.

"Actually, we will continue until the destruction of Israel," he said.

The display, comprising 204 entries from Iran and abroad, opened in August.

Carlos Latuff from Brazil and A. Chard from France jointly won the second prize of $8,000 and Iran's Shahram Rezai received $5,000 for third place.

None of the foreign winners were present at the award ceremony. Shojai blamed "political pressure" for their absence.

Many Muslims considered the cartoons published by the Danish newspaper Jyllands-Posten a violation of traditions prohibiting images of their prophet.

The Tehran daily Hamshahri, a co-sponsor of the exhibition, said it wanted to test the West's tolerance for drawings about the Nazi killing of 6 million Jews in World War II. The entries on display came from nations including United States, Indonesia and Turkey.

—Ken Shepherd is Managing Editor of NewsBusters


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

You're spot on in your compar

You're spot on in your comparison, Ken. Once again, we have the government-owned mouthpiece of a Muslim country hypocritically objecting to some cartoon or film portrayal, while that government itself is guilty of far graver distortions of history and truth.

There's nothing for either the film's producers or the US government to apologize for.

Here I though it was just a m

Here I though it was just a movie based on a comic-book. Sheesh, I have a lot to learn.

Seems that most people have

Seems that most people have lost sight of this. I read some criticism about how far-fetched it was and historically inaccurate. Well, most comic books are that way.

No shit Sherlock. You're a f'

Wrong again. Read the history of the battle of Thermopylae. The movie is correct even if over-dramatized.

Thanks for completely misun

Thanks for completely misunderstanding what I wrote just so you could say "Wrong again."

The only thing correct about

The only thing correct about the movie is the basics, there were 300 Spartans, but there were also 6,000 other Greek allies, and during the final stand there were 700 Thesbians as well as the Spartans. There were 100,000 to 500,000 Persians, depending on who you believe. The names of the major players are correct. The final outcome is correct, except for no mention of the Thesbians. The locale is correct. The movie is far from the truth and even farther from being accurate. It is fiction, based on a comic book that used an historic event for it's outline.

The Battle of Thermopylae took place 1,100 years before the founding of Islam. The idea that it is an insult to Iranians or Islam is laughable. Even more so when you consider that most people don't even know that present day Iran was once ancient Persia.

Quite simply, there is nothing more to this film than escapism. An excuse to buy some popcorn and enjoy some fantasy.

I am allergic to piety, it makes me break out in rash judgements. - Penn Jillette

How dare you imply Mr. Kafi

How dare you imply Mr. Kafir is wrong!!!

What was I thinking?Did I men

What was I thinking?

Did I mention the complete omission of the sea battle? Persia lost that as well. Again out numbering the Greeks.

I am allergic to piety, it makes me break out in rash judgements. - Penn Jillette

omg! haha bal, another &quo

omg! haha bal, another "buddy" for ya!

<edit>I liked your first version better Kafir :-)

"There are two types of people in this country; those who provide freedom and those who enjoy it." MM says...

Get a life

Newsflash... This is a MOVIE not a DOCUMENTARY!

IRNA >>>>>>> get over it.

The liberal MSM has become an enemy of the USA.

Was going to say the same thi

Was going to say the same thing! Can it be more obvious?

There is no sense in being stupid, if you can't prove it! - my dad V

Why isn't she questioning the

Why isn't she questioning the accuracy of "An Inconvenient Lie"? Don't answer that....I know the answer..

I'm surprised sub-basement

I'm surprised sub-basement ratings dweller Couric hasn't brought up a sympathetic take on Iranian objections to the slam-dunk thriller movie. She combines the right ingredients of ignorance, dishonesty, and treacherous inclinations to include it on her unwatched evening news disaster.