On Four Year Anniversary, 'Early Show' Accentuates Negative on Iraq

Photo of Justin McCarthy.

CBS took the occasion of the four year anniversary for Operation Iraqi Freedom to report on nearly everything negative related to the war's outcome and reconstruction.

Despite word from the troops that the media do not report the whole picture, reporter Allen Pizzey accentuated the negatives.

On the March 19 edition of "The Early Show," Pizzey insisted that "Iraqis have little to be thankful for." He  briefly mentioned that an Iraqi general is declaring some success, but quickly countered with reports of recent attacks. With all of the negative coverage, Allen Pizzey did not bother to mention reports that insurgent attacks dropped 80 percent since President Bush announced the surge. The transcript is below.

HANNAH STORM: Four years ago today President Bush announced the start of the war in Iraq. CBS News correspondent Allen Pizzey is live in Baghdad with more on that. Good morning, Allen.

ALLEN PIZZEY: Good morning, Hannah. Well, you know, as big a day as this is in the United States, here in Baghdad it frankly is just another day. There will be no celebrations partly because gathering in groups just makes another target for insurgents. And in fact, there have been six bombs that we know of this morning, one about two miles off here to my left, five simultaneous ones in Kirkuk, which served to underscore the way Iraqis have very little to be thankful for. Nothing represented the hopes and dreams of the invasion better than this moment. The past was wreckage and out of it would be built not just a new Iraq but a new Middle East.

UNIDENTIFIED SOLDIER: One, two, three.

PIZZEY: Four years on, American soldiers used the last monument as a backdrop for souvenir photos of a place they had hoped to be gone from by now.

UNIDENTIFIED SOLDIER #2: Being a super power means you have to make a solid commitment with the nation and plan to stay for the long haul. And, and I don't know if the American people are ready to pay that price here.

PIZZEY: Life for Iraqis has been turned upside down, too, but the side they have now is not the opposite of Saddam's time, it's another version of tyranny. Fear of Saddam has been replaced by fear of even less identifiable terror. Every car with no passengers could be a suicide bomber. Every checkpoint, and there are hundreds, is a target. Fear that your neighbor might be a spy for Saddam's secret police has been replaced by fear that the police may actually be death squads loyal toward different brand of Islam. Whole neighborhoods have been ethnically cleansed and militiamen are seen as the only protection. Children have to learn what they call a safe name, a false identity that does not reveal whether they are Sunni or Shia. The surge plan puts American troops living alongside Iraqi Army and police units to neighborhoods like violence riden Sadr city, 24/7. A couple of dozen stations are up and running, as many as 100 are planned. American commanders are cautiously optimistic.

MAJOR GENERAL WILLIAM CALDWELL, USA: We know that there has been a decrease in violence, but things still need to get better. We still need to be patient.

PIZZEY: The general's Iraqi equivalent, Brigadier General Kaseem al Mousawi on the other hand, is already crowing success. The insurgents responded with spectacular attacks. A car bomb that tore apart Mutanobi street, the book seller's market, considered to be the capital's historical and cultural heart, turned fear and fatigue into despair. "We're poor and tired people," Taha the book seller says. "For three years now, no services, no water, no electricity. What," he asks, "have they done to us?" Fixing the people's problems has become as a much a priority as killing the enemy. Power plants are high on the list.

COLONEL JOHN CHRISTIANSEN, USA, CORPS OF ENGINEERS: My ideal would be 24 hours a day of power unfortunately that's probably not going to take place for quite a while.

PIZZEY: Neither is saying good-bye to Iraq. Many of the soldiers here are on second and even third deployments, and there are no doubt the job will take longer than people counting on the surge think it will, because they see the problem up close and personal.

PRIVATE FIRST CLASS CHRIS GATES, USA: I think that the Iraqi people need to take a little more pride in their country as far as taking it over. So it's going to be a while before they develop that pride that we're trying to instill in them.

PIZZEY: The Iraqis would counter that by noting that pride in their country is not something they were ever short of even under Saddam, but a combination of the insurgency, foreign jihadists, and an occupying force has left them with little sense that they even have a country to call their own.

—Justin McCarthy is a news analyst at Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

pride

PRIVATE FIRST CLASS CHRIS GATES, USA: I think that the Iraqi people
need to take a little more pride in their country as far as taking it
over. So it's going to be a while before they develop that pride that
we're trying to instill in them.

You can't instill pride in the people of a country. This is such a problem... how do the people of a counry become proud? Living in fear, being occupied, becoming refugees?

We broke that country... now we have to fix it. Maybe if we double the number of troups and more heavily occupy each city we can bring control. Maybe triple the number. That might not even be enough.

When do you feel proud? When someone does something for you? Or when you accomplish something on your own?

Pride back at ya...

Pride back at ya...

"We broke that country..."

Ha Ha HA HA HHAAAA....

You sir are a talking point icon.

ACA

...

Quoted from:  'Acaiguana Notes from the Bomb Shelter' (soon to be a movie at theaters near you)

pride

So, try discussing the pride comments and questions constructively.

Nonsense Blamer

 We broke the country, Blamer?  Iraqis were living such an idyllic life under Saddam?   How can anyone repy "constructively" when you begin with such a deep pile of smelly nonsense?

Actually, that was in the 4

Actually, that was in the 4th paragraph, I began with the quote about "instilling" pride in people.

Trying to discuss that. But, focus on what you will.

You're still not making any s

You're still not making any sense, and I'm sorry I became involved.  ACA's reaction was the appropriate one....

RJ, what exactly is confusi

RJ, what exactly is confusing you? I'd love to clarify my initial thoughts for you.

nice editing RJ"smelly

nice editing RJ

"smelly" adds such class

Interesting article. Thanks

Interesting article. Thanks for sharing.

Are ya from DC?

Wasn't sure if you could read it since got the impression you were from DC or worked for the DIMS!

nope. 2 strikes.

nope. 2 strikes.

Still swinging

Must be a REPORTER!

Still swinging

Must be a REPORTER or NEWS READER!

RUUUNNNNNNSomeone who rea

RUUUNNNNNN

Someone who reads!!!!

AAAHHHHHHH

Definition of NEWS READER

That was meant to be the likes of the 16 million dollar reader!!  Can read but doesn't understand, just like you didn't!

Well, it seemed the more appr

Well, it seemed the more appropriate response to what you're dumping on the thread, Blamer.

I understand. When you can

I understand. When you can't discuss something...

avoid!

Good job. Or you could try to talk about pride.

Whole Unit

Why not talk to whole unit when ask this?  Just as our wives say we have selective hearing, the MSM has selective interviewing-if it fits our headline to bring down USA & BUSH, then we'll air, if you're for USA & BUSH & FREEDOM, then we don't have enough time to air that!!  That's where the BLAME is!!

"We broke that Country&q

"We broke that Country"

This implies you think that Stalinist dictatorships are not broken forms of government, because that was what Iraq's government was before "we broke it".

How do you break something th

How do you break something that allows hundreds of thousands of its citizens (poss Millions) to be wiretied, led to a ditch, and executed with a single shot to the base of the neck before being unceremoniously dumped in the ditch and buried using a Bulldozer?

Or, having a monority slaughtered using chemical weapons?

Or a majority being slaughtered village by village?

How did we BREAK THIS?

So sorry, Squiggy, but we can

So sorry, Squiggy, but we can't send any more "troups" over there. Bobby Troup, who wrote "Route 66" and later played Joe Early on "Emergency!", died many years ago. His daughter Ronne, who was on "My 3 Sons", might be available, but she's above military service age. 

See a tongue-in-cheek visual

See a satirical tongue-in-cheek visual "celebrating" the fourth anniversary of the Iraq War...here:

 

http://www.thoughttheater.com/2007/03/iraq_war_happy_fourth_anniversary.php