Thomas Sowell, are you reading? I've got a new chapter for your book "The Vision of the Anointed: Self Congratulation As a Basis for Social Policy."
Washington Post columnist Courtland Milloy condescended to the great unwashed of the District of Columbia in his March 14 column as he dismissed the desire to exercise one's 2nd Amendment rights as lethal childishness. Milloy was reacting to a federal court ruling that invalidated D.C.'s gun ban on Friday.:
Perhaps it's my inner child, but a part of me secretly cheers the libertarian. Especially those wild and crazy guys at the Cato Institute. The Washington think tank thinks government ought not try to stop people from using whatever drugs they want -- cocaine, heroin, alcohol, cigarettes, you name it -- or from gambling or watching porn online.
And now it's won its argument to let you keep a handgun in your home in the District, one of the most violent cities in the nation.It's as if Cato took its motto from the Isley Brothers' 1969 hit "It's Your Thing (Do What You Wanna Do)."Story Continues Below Ad ↓
Right on, says my inner child; you can't tell me who to sock it to.
In shooting down the city's strict gun control law last week, a three-judge panel agreed with arguments by Cato that the Second Amendment gives us the right to own handguns and that we are not too clumsy and ill-tempered to handle them safely. The libertarian view is: Trust the people more than the government.
Thomas Jefferson once said: "Men by their constitutions are naturally divided into two parties: 1) Those who fear and distrust the people. . . . 2) Those who identify themselves with the people, have confidence in them, cherish and consider them as the most honest and safe . . . depository of the public interest."
Catoites, and my inner child, fall into the latter category. But the adult knows better. Several studies have shown that a gun in the home is up to 22 times more likely to be used for suicide or to kill a family member than to fend off a burglar. Surely the Founding Fathers would not have given the right to bear arms to a homegrown militia that was more likely to shoot itself in the foot than stop a British invasion.
I might update this post a bit later with links to more information discrediting the studies Milloy cites. Feel free to recommend good pro-gun rights bloggers who have addressed the point and look for updates accordingly.
—Ken Shepherd is Managing Editor of NewsBusters




















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Several studies have shown
March 14, 2007 - 12:52 ET by Dave in TexasSeveral studies have shown
that a gun in the home is up to 22 times more likely to be used for
suicide or to kill a family member than to fend off a burglar.
Ah yes, the liberal MSM's love of manipulating statistics. I wonder why Mr. Milloy didn't just give us the following statistics and let us draw our own conclusions?
Percentage of guns in homes:
- That are never used to kill anyone.
- That are used in a suicide attempt.
- That are used to kill a family member.
- That are used to fend off a burglar.
Oh wait, that's right. We're all too stupid to draw our own conclusions.
Dave,By their logic, 99.999
March 14, 2007 - 13:37 ET by Dave RDave,
By their logic, 99.999999 percent of homes in which someone was shot contained a refrigerator.
Does that mean I should get rid of mine?
Ditto!
March 14, 2007 - 14:23 ET by TheBigMackDaddyLOL, great point Dave; how about-
The number of burglers who chose not to break into a house because they knew the owner had the right to protect himself with a gun?
"Why don't we just ask Osama bin -- Osama Obama... Obama what -- since he won by such a big amount." -- Ted Kennedy
Doesn't this idiot realize th
March 14, 2007 - 12:55 ET by InfomanOhioDoesn't this idiot realize that the reason Washington, DC is so violent is that the citizens are NOT armed? I think burglars, muggers and rapists would think twice about committing a violent act if they thought their victim might be armed.
Besides, any fool realizes that strict gun control laws do not stop criminals from getting their hands on guns - it only prevents law-abiding citizens from being able to defend themselves.
As Bugs Bunny would say, "What a maroon!"
The truth may be ugly, but it is still the truth.
That darn Constitution!
March 14, 2007 - 13:01 ET by TheBigMackDaddyThis article clearly demonstrates the difference between Liberals and real people. Liberals have little faith in people and therefore feel we need to rely solely on Big Government to protect us. If Milloy does not like the U.S. Constitution then he should call to have it amended or, better yet, just tear it up and Have a Socialist call the shots - that worked great for the Germans in the 1930's!
"Why don't we just ask Osama bin -- Osama Obama... Obama what -- since he won by such a big amount." -- Ted Kennedy
John K
March 14, 2007 - 13:11 ET by CarpareusMy favorite cartoon is John K.'s "Powdered Toastman" where PT becomes president and uses THE constitution as a firelighter. THAT tendancy is not limited to "Liberals".
Dr. Carpareus, ASS.SK.
Too bad his inner child didn'
March 14, 2007 - 13:01 ET by BruzillaToo bad his inner child didn't pay more attention in school. Many of the Founding Fathers had been part of a homegrown militia, one that in addition to many failures managed to keep the British Army tied up long enough for Washington and the Continental Army to get its act together. He would also know that the British owned the turf at the time, and hadn't invaded anything.
As for guns, yes they do account for a large number of suicides, over 50% in most cases. But very close on the heels of guns are hangings and poisonings (the much preferred method for women), so since there's no shortages of ropes to hang yourself with, or bottles of Windex to drink, does this guy really think that the abscence of firearms would make a dent in the suicide rates?
A gun in the house does not result in a suicide or shooting of a family member. It is the actions of a suicidal, homicidal, or careless resident that results in these situations. A gun in the house does not result in a criminal attempting to gain entry, but it does provide an option for responding to that situation.
Let us not forget the old Ove
March 14, 2007 - 13:12 ET by Airforce_5_OLet us not forget the old Over Dose or is that included in Poisioning?
I would think so, but how do
March 14, 2007 - 14:14 ET by BruzillaI would think so, but how do you know when an overdose is accidental or a suicide? Also, a co-worker of my daughter killed herself last week. She took several Xanax pills, pulled a plastic bag over her head, then pulled a blanket over the bag. When she fell asleep the blanket weighed down on the bag enough to suffocate her, so I guess that counts as a poisoning and an asphyxiation.
If only they would get smart and ban trash bags and blankets from our fair city, this never would have happened to this seriously disturbed woman who had tried to kill herself with drugs three times before. I curse thee Glad Bags and Cannon Fabrics... yee are the bringers of death!
Pills and alcohol seem to be
March 14, 2007 - 14:54 ET by Airforce_5_OPills and alcohol seem to be the preferred choice for the attempts we see on the base. Those that succeed are those using the rope and gun. Sad suicide is a permeate solution to a short term problem.
My Guns
March 14, 2007 - 13:03 ET by lkoturMy Firearms have killed fewer people than Ted Kennedy's Oldsmobile.
LMAO......Now that is funny.
March 14, 2007 - 13:08 ET by Airforce_5_OLMAO......Now that is funny.
not practicle
March 14, 2007 - 13:15 ET by CarpareusStop trashing and start stopping dude- laughs are easy.
Dr. Carpareus, ASS.SK.
In 1994 -1995 Oklahoma was co
March 14, 2007 - 13:07 ET by Airforce_5_OIn 1994 -1995 Oklahoma was considering a concealed carry law. The Libs were up in arms but it passed. Oklahoma City was notorious for car jacking. Two weeks into the new law five car jackers met their maker and all of a sudden the number of car jacking fell like a rock. I think it is time for a change in DC. Let’s watch and see if the violence falls off.
5 0The real question is once
March 14, 2007 - 13:10 ET by florida_chad5 0
The real question is once the violence drops will the MSM cover it.
ChadThey will find away to pu
March 14, 2007 - 13:17 ET by Airforce_5_OChad
They will find away to put a negative to it.
Something like: Livelihood of
March 14, 2007 - 17:03 ET by Mean Gene Dr. LoveSomething like: Livelihood of Criminals Threatened by Armed Citizens.
...starving crack addict eating out of dumpsters and going through withdrawls because he can no longer safely "score" cash and merchandise.... --more at 11.
A vote is like a rifle: its usefulness depends upon the character of the user. Theodore Roosevelt, 26th president of US (1858 - 1919)
Wasn't the Muslim fanatic tha
March 14, 2007 - 13:13 ET by BeanManWasn't the Muslim fanatic that shot up the mall in Salt Lake City taken out by a guy with a concealed carry permit?
YEP - same thing happened in
March 14, 2007 - 13:16 ET by florida_chadYEP - same thing happened in Va a couple of years ago. The national media reported the shooter was stopped by fellow citizens. The local papers reported that a guy with a concealed gun brought the shooter down.
Got a concealed carry myself.
March 14, 2007 - 13:23 ET by Airforce_5_OGot a concealed carry myself. Can't bring it here on base but were ever I go, so does the 40.
Yes and it was no coincidence
March 14, 2007 - 13:25 ET by Subsailor599Yes and it was no coincidence that the Muslim fanatic chose a mall that did NOT allow concealed guns.
Subsailor,Did the Hero get
March 14, 2007 - 13:43 ET by MightyMouthSubsailor,
Did the Hero get prosecuted for carrying where it was not allowed?
"There are two types of people in this country; those who provide freedom and those who enjoy it." MM says...
MM, the "Hero" was
March 14, 2007 - 14:01 ET by JABMM, the "Hero" was an off-duty police officer shopping with his wife and yes, I believe the Mayor or Governer awarded him a medal and the justified recognition of his selfless acts.
"To bad Ignorance isn't painful..."
Good, justice still prevail
March 14, 2007 - 14:08 ET by MightyMouthGood, justice still prevails in a few areas of the United States.
"There are two types of people in this country; those who provide freedom and those who enjoy it." MM says...
Turns out the signs at Trolle
March 14, 2007 - 15:15 ET by Carbon SasquatchTurns out the signs at Trolley Square were just corporate window dressing. Utah law exempts permit holders from arbitrary 'victim disarmament zones.'
The Hero is a police officer
March 15, 2007 - 06:54 ET by Subsailor599The Hero is a police officer that was off duty at the time. As far as I can tell he isn't being charged for carrying a concealed weapon on the mall property.
See, this is where we need
March 15, 2007 - 16:53 ET by Ken ShepherdSee, this is where we need to sharpen our coverage a bit. I'm sure this stuff was probably reported locally but didn't make it through the filter of the national media.
You can read this blog that i
March 14, 2007 - 17:11 ET by Mean Gene Dr. LoveYou can read this blog that is updated daily on stories like that.
A vote is like a rifle: its usefulness depends upon the character of the user. Theodore Roosevelt, 26th president of US (1858 - 1919)
I'm actually a DC resident.
March 14, 2007 - 20:51 ET by KpajI'm actually a DC resident. Right now things are in limbo. The Mayor got onto local TV and told the residents that the police will still enforce our current laws. So currently there's no real mass purchasing of firearms.
We're all just in a wait and see mode.
And we all know that unruly a
March 14, 2007 - 13:14 ET by Chris NormanAnd we all know that unruly and immature "children" need direction and control from a strong parent - Big Mommy and Daddy Government.
The dogs bark, but the caravan moves on.
- Arabian Proverb
If the story was about handgu
March 14, 2007 - 13:30 ET by InsufficientContextIf the story was about handguns, why did the reporter feel the need to inflate the numbers by giving statistics for all firearms? No bias here....
A Few Fun Facts
-Of the 2.5 million times citizens use their guns to defend themselves every year, the overwhelming majority merely brandish their gun or fire a warning shot to scare off their attackers. Less than 8% of the time, a citizen will kill or wound his/her attacker.
- A Justice Department survey of felons showed that 93% of handgun predators had obtained their most recent guns "off-the-record."
- A study claiming "guns more likely to kill you than help you" is a total fraud. Not surprisingly, the figure claiming one is three times more likely to be killed by one’s own gun is a total lie. The author of this study, Dr. Arthur Kellerman, refused to release the data behind his conclusions for years.
-Mafia turncoat, Sammy "the Bull" Gravano, expressed his love for gun control in an interview with Vanity Fair: "Gun control? It’s the best thing you can do for crooks and gangsters. I want you to have nothing. If I’m a bad guy, I’m always gonna have a gun. Safety locks? You pull the trigger with a lock on, and I’ll pull the trigger. We’ll see who wins."
Okay, I'll stop with the cut and paste. All of this and much much more can be found here. http://www.gunowners.org/fs0404.htm
intruders
March 14, 2007 - 13:32 ET by Carpareushow do you stop intruders from entering your domicile?
let it get ripe.
Dr. Carpareus, ASS.SK.
What so few liberals seem t
March 14, 2007 - 13:43 ET by Challenger GrimWhat so few liberals seem to realize is that armed citizens is exactly how democracy WORKS. Even if we never apply force, the very threat of that force is what keeps the system going. Think a moment that your most fevered anti-Bush delusions are real and he actually dissolved Congress (or replaced EVERY representative with a puppet), how exactly would you get him to heed your vote? Protest outside the white house? The idea behind the 2nd amendment is that if the government suddenly stops listening to "the people" we can rally together and MAKE it listen.
And I know some will show up and say "you think you can take on the police/military with your puny handgun"? To which I always reply with: Well then what's your bright idea? I may not be able to make a dent against the oppression but I'll be damned if I roll over without taking a few with me. (Look at it another way: hitler killed what, 6 million jews? now imagine those 6 million all armed) A weak option is always preferred over no option.
rally
March 14, 2007 - 13:47 ET by Carpareusrally- humour 8P.
long as i have sufficient ammo to rally.
Dr. Carpareus, ASS.SK.
If I become the victim of a
March 14, 2007 - 14:54 ET by Fred911If I become the victim of a home invasion or other violent crime, I have absolutely no problem relying on the benevolence of the thug who is in charge of the crime. Many of these criminals are professional, they have been involved in this activity on numerous occasions and really know what they are doing. If I am to believe the news accounts of the abuses these thugs face at the hands of police, many of them are "honor students".
I probably have at least a 50-50 chance of coming out of the incident with litte or no injury. Who knows what might happen to an idiot like me if I tried to actually defend myself with a gun......I read the papers you know!
I hope you are being sarcasti
March 14, 2007 - 15:04 ET by Airforce_5_OI hope you are being sarcastic there Fred cause that is pretty whacked if you ask me.
For home protection all you need is a pump action shot gun. No aim needed and if you pump that sucker it is the universal sound of fear. SHUCK-SHUCK and the invader is gone (one way or the other).
Amen. And always think-safe
March 14, 2007 - 15:12 ET by sarcasmoAmen. And always think-safety & think-jury. (Translation: "Load birdshot & if you have to shoot, plan ahead on enough rounds for only one surviving witness!").
JMR
SarcBetter to be tried by 12
March 14, 2007 - 15:18 ET by Airforce_5_OSarc
Better to be tried by 12 then carried by 6 I always say.
Actually, I am a firm belie
March 14, 2007 - 15:40 ET by ScottyDogActually, I am a firm believer in #2 buck shot leaving the shooter and family members as the only witnesses protecting his home from the armed invader.
We have several pumps ready to go in our home for just such an ocassion.
Kudos to the DC Jurists that finally can read plain English.
Is this Mexico or the USA
Wait, 50-50 chance with lit
March 14, 2007 - 15:26 ET by Challenger GrimWait, 50-50 chance with little or no injury? So does that mean that there's a 50% chance you'll be severly injured/killed?
AND YOU'RE OK WITH THAT?
Tell me, would you go bungie jumping, flying, driving, parchuting or doing any activity if you knew you had a 50% chance of dying in it? (i mean, i would, but I'm insane) And what about your loved ones? Is say... a 50% chance your wife will be raped acceptable? (the chance going up or down depending on her attractiveness) No offense, but you sir, but I do hope you were being sarcastic. If I'm in my home (which is my castle), my chances of coming away with little or no injury better be damn well below 50%. And the crooks better hope I'm not in a REALLY sour mood less I forgo the gun and get out some of my medieval weapons for the really intense pain.
Actually, for those who think
March 14, 2007 - 21:15 ET by UnsaneActually, for those who think the police/military can just mow down everyone they see, you have to remember, there are only so many bullets, and so many people you can kill. That, I suspect, is one reason of many why the fall of the Eastern European communist governments in 1989 happened as bloodlessly as they did (with the exception of Romania).
"HAV3 TH3 BRIDG3S OF INSANITY B33N CROSS3D AND FOR3V3R R3TRACT3D???." - Meshuggah, "3ntrapm3nt", from Catch Thirty Thr33 (2005)
The uprising in the Warsaw
March 15, 2007 - 06:54 ET by jmtThe uprising in the Warsaw Ghetto started once the Jews got their hands on some firearms. Before that, there wasn't much they could do.
jmt
http://www.jmichaelt.org
Sage Advice
March 14, 2007 - 13:48 ET by TeamcheeserSeek the advice of the Sage from South Central, Larry Elder. "Michael and Me" and "Ten Things You Can't Say In America"
Rudy
March 14, 2007 - 13:54 ET by Carpareuswatched a b-ball game in that vicinity seein' as how i was with my bro Rudy.
Rudy- where yah bean
Dr. Carpareus, ASS.SK.