Boston Globe: Iraq Insurgents Just Like Our Founding Fathers


I wonder if the MSM ever gets tired of trying to make evil look good? And if they aren't trying to make evil look like good, they are trying to soft peddle evil with a they-are-really-just-like-us analysis of evil’s actions. Such is the case today in the Boston Globe wherein writer H.D.S. Greenway equates Iraqi insurgents to being just like America's founding revolutionary generation.

In 'Surge' doomed to final failure, a badly garbled reading of history is foisted upon an unsuspecting reading public that culminates with H.D.S. Greenway boiling down the entire American Revolution to the claim that British soldiers were a "conquering force" in the Colonies and the Colonists were mad at them for it.

And so conquering foreign soldiers will be resisted in Iraq, as they have always been everywhere down the centuries. In early April 1775, the British governor of Boston sent John Howe out to gather intelligence in that hotbed of insurgency now called the western suburbs, but then the Anbar province of its time. Howe met an old man cleaning his rifle who looked too old to hunt game.

The old man said he expected foreign soldiers -- "a flock of redcoats" -- would be arriving soon, and he thought they would make good targets. Arrive they did, and with them the American revolution that in many states degenerated into civil war. The British soldiers were mostly of the same race and religion as the people they fought, but they were by then foreigners, and eight years later they were gone.

This simpleminded "gotcha" point that H.D.S.Greenway seems to imagine he has stumbled upon makes a mush of what really happened in 1776 and before to cause the American Revolution. Apparently H.D.S. Greenway is unaware that the British didn't "conquer" the Colonists because the colonies were part of the territorial possessions of Great Britain in the fist place. Putting down an insurrection is quite different than conquering and the British were not truly "foreigners" – Revolutionary rhetoric aside-- even to most American citizens. Unwanted, yes, but “foreign”? Not really. In truth, many U.S. citizens felt they were being truer Englishmen than the Brits were being.

He also seems unaware of the many decades of deteriorating political ties and governmental debacles that preceded the Revolution, causing it to erupt.

In the final analysis British troops in early America and the Revolutionary era hardly lends an apt comparison to U.S. troops in Iraq today.

And did you notice the they-are-just-like-us touch there when he said that the “western suburbs” were the “Anbar province of its time”? Nice touch, don’t you think? Utterly false, but nice touch just the same.

I also found it interesting that the “r” in Revolution was not capitalized in the on-line version. It should have been, but was not. Is this just editorial ignorance, or did they mean to demean the American Revolution?

But, in any case, we shant let facts and grammar get in the way of Greenway's gymnastic back bending to twist the American Revolution into an example that would be "just like" Iraq, shall we? Nor will we allow reality to get in the way of his desire to advocate for a precipitate pull out of American troops from Iraq.

Nor should we allow truth to get in the way of Greenway saying that it is US troops, not the insurgents, that is the cause of the unrest in Iraq.

When the president and surge proponents talk about restoring law and order to Baghdad, they underestimate the fact that it is the very presence of American soldiers themselves who are sparking the resistance...

Spurring his bout with runawayitis, Greenway was quite taken with the picture from Iraq he saw a while back.

The photograph shows four American soldiers, dressed in full, intimidating battle gear, around the periphery of a Baghdad living room. In the center, on the carpeted floor, lies a collapsed woman in a traditional black dress... A man, identified as her son, is holding her in his arms. His feet are bare, as if he were caught by surprise..."

While Greenway's "His feet are bare, as if he were caught by surprise" was a nice novelistic flourish, it is nonsense, of course. Muslims take their shoes off when entering their homes, so bare feet would not be uncommon indoors in an Iraqi household!

But, leave it to a denizen of the MSM to make a complex situation simplistic and to mislead readers with a picture to buttress his agenda.

In any case, H.D.S. Greeway's is just another example of an MSM that isn't capable of either telling a balanced and truthful story, or of any historical analysis.

I wonder if the H.D.S. of Mr. Greenway's name stands for "He Doesn't See"?


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

I read this yesterday and imm

I read this yesterday and immediately thought that Mr Greenway obvously had no grasp on history. 

I do not recall the population supporting the revolution filling wagons full of gunpowder and pulling in to Boston Common in order to maximize the devastation to their fellow citizens.

One of the important pre-requ

One of the important pre-requisites to being a liberal and/or Democrat these days is that you have no clue about history. It is pointless to explain how wrong this analysis is (e.g. we were for freedom of religion, did not detnate bombs in crowds of our own children, our founding fathers were from here, we did not behead captured English soldiers, etc) but that is a waste of time.

It is just funny and sad how the Globe will hire anyone and print anything.

"Why don't we just ask Osama bin -- Osama Obama... Obama what -- since he won by such a big amount." -- Ted Kennedy

Will or Krauthammer had a gre

Will or Krauthammer had a great column a few years in ago in which he pointed out that when you don't know history everything is unprecedented and hence is to be treated as a crisis.  This can also be tied in to the fact that for the Left everyone to the right of them is a fascist or a Nazi, therefore showing either a) a complete lack of understanding of what the Nazis were about or b)  they are so full of hate they are delusional.

...and a little side-note

I copied this from another post, a good point to note:

The Nazi's were hard-core Left-Wingers. I know the modern-day Left has been successful at re-writing that trivial piece of History. Sure it is easy to confuse the National SOCIALIST Party as a Right-Wing Movement (The Official Name was actually the National Socialist German Workers' Party) The Nazi's were like any other left-wing movement: they believe so much in their mis-guided cause that they attempt to impose it on everyone via force.

I seem to recall being taug

I seem to recall being taught that our founding fathers fought in the Revolution for political and religious freedom. The terrorists only want political and religious oppression. Don't believe me? Stand in the middle of a Middle Eastern city and publicly denounce Islam. You won't live long enough to count how many times you're shot.

Show me the law, and only then will I pay income taxes.
“Our Constitution was made only for a moral and religious people. It is wholly inadequate to the government of any other.” - John Adams

Also, our Founding Fathers

Also, our Founding Fathers were highly educated, cultured gentlemen. Let's see Islam produce anything like our Declaration of Independence, our Constitution, or the Federalist Papers. To compare a band of murderous, barabaric slugs to some of the greatest political geniuses that ever lived is... someone help me out here with a suitable strong adjective!

Patently evil and subversive.

Patently evil and subversive.

Is this Greenway guy an idiot

Is this Greenway guy an idiot or just ignorant?

Save a SeAL, club a liberal!!

I canceled the Globe several

I canceled the Globe several months ago. It started with my revulsion of the Op-ed pages, and Greenway was a major factor. He and the other Globe communists are so predictable -- pick a topic, any topic, and you already know what they are going to say. The drumbeat became too loud.

The final straw was the ever-increasing bias in the regular sections. I thought I could hold out for a while because I liked the sports, but soon that even became too political.

I keep getting phone calls from them, though, inviting me back. I'll tell ya -- I love taking those calls. I have a great time -- till they hang up.

Judith

Tidbit from Little Green Footballs:
Curriculum for 4 Year Degree in Journalism:

Year One:
Womens Studies-4 credits
The History of Mean White Europeans Who Stole America from the Indians-4 credits
Math for Journalists (mastery of adding and subtracting two digits plus memorization of multiplication tables is not mandatory)-4 credits
The Science of Global Warming-4 credits

Year Two:
English for Journalists (student may get credit if passed 8th grade English course)-4 credits
Glorious History of Weather Underground-4 credits
Chemistry of Global Warming-4 credits
American Music (from CSNY to Puff Daddy)-4 credits

Year Three:
Journalism 101(how to write good)-4 credits
The Science of Hyperbole (mandatory)-4 credits
Economics (covers European Socialist models)-4 credits
Sex and Health (may receive partial credit if you had an affair with one or more of your junior high school teachers)-4 credits

Year Four:
Journalism 102 (learning the NYT model of reporting)-4 credits
Advancse Science of Global Warming (memorizing key words is prerequisite)-4 credits
Islam, Religion of Peace-4 credits
Creativse Writing and Editorials-4 credits

The remaining 64 credits can be earned in the following programs:

*3 month internship with LA Times or NT Times-64 credits
*Write two articles for Mother Jones-64 credits
*Assist in writing for MoveOn.org website-64 credits
*Write a 1000 word essay on why Noam Chomsky is correct about America-64 credits
*Go to bed with Michael Moore-64 credits (85 credits if Michael is on top
*Go to bed with Bill Haher-15 credits
*Go to bed with Journalism 101 instructor-64 credits
*Send two jokes to Jon Stewart-64 credits
*Send two working ideas to Doonesbury-64 credits
*Write 1000 word essay on why Global Warming will kill us all by 2020.

I hope this answers the question of "Why are these news people such dopes?" (Please excuse any typos, long dissertation)

As a former journalism studen

As a former journalism student, you are not far off...

In my case I got credit for listening to NPR badmouth Ronald Reagan for a semester while working at a campus radio station.

I also had to sit through diatribes from NPR on "THe good Sandinista's versus the bad Contra's" for the same period.

practacing physician

"I'll have you know I'm a practacing physician."
"Well when you're through practacing I gotta couple of slugs in the back garden that need to be removed." The Tale of the Giant Rat of Sumatra

Our founding fathers advocate

Our founding fathers advocated a separation of church and state.  The Jihadist wants the Church to run the state.  Big difference.

As a moderate that puts our f

As a moderate that puts our founding fathers on a pedestal of the HIGHEST respect, I find this article offensive. H.D.S. Greenway needs to think before writing.

Liberals, Democrats, and the

Liberals, Democrats, and the MSM in a nutshell ...

Isaiah 5:20

Woe unto them that call evil good, and good evil; that put darkness for light, and light for darkness; that put bitter for sweet, and sweet for bitter!

This Comparison Is Just Wrong!

As a a former teacher/historian myself, I just find this comparison between our Founding Fathers and terrorists not only wrong but disingenuous. This comparison reflects the utter lack of American history knowledge that prevails not only in our public schools but in our colleges and media. Where our young people measured or even scored higher than their contemporaries around the world for primary school subjects, our students slump and underperform both in middle and high school as well as college.

This is the most stupid article I've ever read! I never read how our revolutionary army and those who fought for freedom from British tyranny ever bombed whole comunities or neighborhoods like terrorists resoundly do in Iraq and Afghanistan (along with other choice places around the world). I wish other media would condemn this as the fake historical tripe analysis that it is. However, America will tolerate it because as a whole, it has trouble identifying what holds this country together historically and contemporaneously.

The difficult we do immediately; the impossible takes a little longer.  Air Force Motto

emjem says: When your brain's stuck on liberalism it self-destructs.

More Like the War of Northern Aggression

The Iraqi insurgency is more akin to the War of Northern Aggression, aka The Late Unpleasantness, aka American Civil War then the American Revolution. MSM are not historians. The British have it right when they call them "newsreaders."

Our real problem, then, is not our strength today; it is rather the vital necessity of action today to ensure our strength tomorrow. Dwight Eisenhower

Liberals are stupid beyond belief

This comparison of the Islamic Terrorists to our Founding Fathers has been seeping around the sewer brains of the far left for several years.  That it is actually published in a major newspaper reveals the intellectual bankruptcy of the liberal elite media.  

It's also more evidence that liberals, as a class, are stupid beyond belief.

Emjem, I completely agre

Emjem, I
completely agree with you on the point that we will accept this article with only passing (if any at all) resistance to the inaccuracies and libelous correlations between Islamic murderers and our Founding Fathers. As was pointed out in the article and various
posts, the American colonies were just that;colonies. This implies being an extension or a part of something. Iraq has no such prerequisite with us. The Founding Fathers were inspired by the writings of great men such as John Locke and Trenchard, the Magna Carta, and other sources that aspired to a constitutional contract
between governments and the governed. The terrorists only desire control and domination, not freedom and individual rights. Our founding documents speak of protecting rights given to us by God, our creator, while their founding document speaks of killing and death to infidels and heretics. Boston was not a town under siege because it desired violence and chaos but because it wanted just the opposite!Rather than striking across the world to bring about a world-wide caliphate, the Founding Fathers struck against tyranny. We are offering freedom and choice, not forcing it. This is the choice that those in the Middle East must make; that of joining the civilized world or reverting back to 8th century barbarism.