In his culture column this week, Brent Bozell talks about the rare hawkish corner of entertainment, and finds it a bit troubling that while "24" sends a gung-ho message in the War on Terror, it's starting to look a bit like an FX show. (Remember that episode of "The Shield" with the face-melting-on-the-burner scene?) He starts by noting his mother was always a big John Wayne fan, that standard-bearer of red-blooded patriotism, and salutes that neglected genre of entertainment. But:
The sixth season of “24" premiered on January 14, but this time even otherwise supportive critics are worried that Fox has gone over the top, with plot twists so extreme and brutal that one concludes the network is irresponsibly falling back on the old formula: shock for the sake of shock.
In the season premiere – which began in the family hour at 8 PM Eastern, not its usual 9 PM start – a terrorist spreads his tools out on a table and selects a specific knife to stab into Jack Bauer’s shoulder. The hero tries to stay calm, but screams in agony when the terrorist pours alcohol over the stab wound. Moments later, Bauer is able to escape when he pulls out the heart monitor with his teeth. He takes out his captor by biting his neck so viciously that he rips a chunk of the neck off. Bauer then spits out the flesh and frees himself. Some of the show’s fans might have been thrilled – but did it need to be so vividly gruesome, especially when youngsters are in the audience?
In the February 12 episode, there was another over the top scene, this time with a drill. When a terrorist learns that the Americans are hot on his trail and that his time is running out, he holds a hostage held against a wall, then plunges a power drill into his back. The whirling drill bit is shown digging into the man’s skin and then the camera hones in on the screaming face of the victim, who then falls to the floor in a pool of blood.
These kinds of intensely graphic scenes are growing more common. The Parents Television Council found that Fox’s “24" showed 67 scenes of torture in the first five seasons. To put that in its proper perspective, there were 110 torture scenes in all of prime time television between 1995 and 2001. From 2002 to 2005, the number soared to 624 torture scenes.
The controversy over the show’s graphic scenes pits the hardcore action fans against the child protectors. There is a happy medium. Take the really grisly stuff out, and put it in the theaters. If it’s a quality show – like “24” – it is unnecessary, as witnessed by its spectacular success before this year. Who knows? Maybe my mother will fall in love with Kiefer Sutherland, too.
—Tim Graham is Director of Media Analysis at the Media Research Center



















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Dear Brent-Just like we remin
March 3, 2007 - 13:18 ET by CaringwhiteguyDear Brent-Just like we reminded Arab-Americans and Mexican-Americans when they over-reacted to certain portrayals on 24, it is now necessary to remind red-headed, bearded white Americans. IT'S FICTION! IT'S A SCREENPLAY! Remember Tipper Gore's campaign over music lyrics?
Maybe I'm in the minority...
March 3, 2007 - 13:28 ET by JRMaybe I'm in the minority, but I wouldn't consider 24 family viewing. My son is grown now, but he wasn't allowed to watch violent movies or television programs when he was younger. For parents who monitor their children's television viewing habits this is a non-issue.
JR,I absolutely love the show
March 3, 2007 - 14:00 ET by jcrapes4JR,
I absolutely love the show but I am with you I don't let my 13 year old and 8 year old daughters watch the show. My kids have their tv monitored and their internet usage is monitored. The rule about internet is simple no internet unless mom or dad is in the room.
For parents who monitor the
March 3, 2007 - 15:28 ET by DontFeedTheTrollsFor parents who monitor their children's television viewing habits this is a non-issue.
That's the key, if you have kids, it is YOUR responsibility to monitor their activities, 24 (no pun intended) hours a day.
D
Native Americans didn't believe in secure borders. Look what happened to them.
I understand how people would
March 3, 2007 - 13:56 ET by amberI understand how people would think the show is too graphic, but to me, it is a little more real than just a show. Nothing they have shown is too far out there that it couldn't happen (except perhaps the timeframe it occurs in). What worries me, as an American, is more people care about showing pretty pictures on TV than they care about protecting this country. Frankly, I could care less if the government listened to ever phone call and read all of my email, just so long as they do not put any recording equipment in my house. If it means that we are safer, then fine, privacy is not a real expectation anymore, not because of the government, but because people can take photos of you in your living room, in a rest room, write comentary about you and post it on the WWW. If you have not learned discression yet, then you're screwed, I want my family protected. Who cares if 24 shows a man eating the testicles of a terrorist, don't watch it. Isn't that what people tell me about all of the nudity I have to endure? Do they show commercials of Jack eating someone's ear? No. But they show victoria secret whores pretending to fondle themselves while I am trying to watch the 5 o'clock news. Get over it and toss out your TV if it bugs you.
Jack returned from China co
March 3, 2007 - 13:58 ET by JDWJack returned from China completely shaken, the psychical pain being the minor factor. He was later forced to torture his treasonous brother, his blood and family, the aftereffects which brought him to the ground weeping. It wasn't until the nuke that he was able to regain his posture and realize his mission.
We see Bauer himself tortured throughout the existence of '24' yet all of this complaing fails to focus on that. Everyone whines about the poor terrorists.
We have had 67 torture scenes during the 5 year course of the program, how many times a day is America updated on terrorism? Decapitation numbers, lost limbs, blown-up, shot... no complaints about the fact that terrorist fatalities numbers are not revealed.
News media is reality and it not only sides with terrorism, it explicitly defines it's position in everyday forum. The program '24' is fiction which sides with America revealing truths about war and terrorism. Those who oppose the show are free to not watch yet consider the perspective of our news media, dems, and Jane Mayers.
JDW
Wounded skier, beware of mistakes.
News media: Scoreboard for terrorists
While I agree that parents
March 3, 2007 - 16:53 ET by motherbeltWhile I agree that parents should be monitoring their kids' TV viewing, "24" IS on at 8 pm, which kind of puts it in the "family" viewing hour. But there is lots of stuff on at 8 that kids shouldn't be watching, so "caveat emptor." That being said, I am an adult, and find that some scenes, like the one where Jack bit the guy's shoulder, just make me cringe. I think they could probably do away with the more egregious stuff and still have a great show....after all, it's the story that makes the thrill, not the gore. As for the news, I don't give them a pass because it's "news"; some of that makes me angry when it's just for sensationalism. One of my biggest pet peeves is when, after a bombing, or an accident, they shoot video of the blood stains on the ground. Gross, and gratuitous.
There is a disclaimer at the
March 3, 2007 - 18:23 ET by Right Wing Attack DogThere is a disclaimer at the beginning of the show that should tip anyone that can read off that your not about to watch Captain Kangaroo or Mister Rogers. Turn the channel.
"Good Morning, Captain!.
March 4, 2007 - 05:59 ET by Chicago Republican"Good Morning, Captain!...." memories. Mr Green Jeans was the man.
**************
Support the Spread of Open Society and Capitalism around the World. Do it for the Children.
Quote: "Some of the sh
March 4, 2007 - 04:42 ET by Squalls BladeQuote: "Some of the show’s fans might have been thrilled – but did it need to
be so vividly gruesome, especially when youngsters are in the audience?"
What a dumb statement. 24 or any other show shouldn't be worried about "youngsters" in the audience, it's not their job. Their job is to make the best show possible for Adults. 24 isn't a kid show and I like it that way. I like Jack Bauer ripping out someone's neck with his teeth. I liked that scene in The Shield where Vic burned that guy's face on the stove. There's plenty of crap for kids to watch, whole channels dedicated to kids, pre-teen, and teens. They have their stuff, let the adults have ours. If you can't take it don't watch, nobody is making you. The Shield and 24 are my two favorites shows and I'm glad they don't make 'em kid friendly.
Democracy is not enough. If the culture dies, the country dies. - Pat Buchanan
squalls, what does your Buchanan quote mean?
March 4, 2007 - 04:44 ET by acaiguanasqualls, what does your Buchanan quote mean?
ACA
...
Quoted from: 'Acaiguana Notes from the Bomb Shelter' (soon to be a movie at theaters near you)
Squalls Blade, as previous po
March 4, 2007 - 11:17 ET by UnsaneSqualls Blade, as previous posts have indicated from him, has bought into Pat Buchanan's populism hook, line, and sinker.
"HAV3 TH3 BRIDG3S OF INSANITY B33N CROSS3D AND FOR3V3R R3TRACT3D???." - Meshuggah, "3ntrapm3nt", from Catch Thirty Thr33 (2005)
unsane -- someone may also
March 4, 2007 - 11:27 ET by Jack Bauerunsane -- someone may also care to point out that the United States is not a "democracy."
It's a constitutional Republic.
In other words, and trying not to be recondite, a "democracy" is governance by the majority.
A constitutional republic is governance by the rule of law.
John Adams defined a constitutional republic as "a government of laws, and not of men."
Yes, the U.S. is not a demo
March 4, 2007 - 14:47 ET by Squalls BladeYes, the U.S. is not a democracy, but that doesn' t stop about 95% of the public from thinking it is. I believe Pat was just trying to put things where most could understand it in that quote.
So you like Meshuggah eh, Unsane? I'm a metal head myself and own a couple of their CD's. I've been jamming out to the latest from All Shall Perish myself.Democracy is not enough. If the culture dies, the country dies. - Pat Buchanan
What on television today isn'
March 4, 2007 - 12:05 ET by JDWWhat on television today isn't leftist? The incessant attempts to void our ability to not only watch whatever the dems spin as too dangerous for our younger viewers, realize just like real life once accomplish, all of the other areas they will attack. How long thereafter will the greens be pushing to prohibit car, jet, sub... scenes? Imagine all of the vocabulary which would be prohibited, nukes, terrorists, illegals, radiation... No, we will be watching shows about single mothers getting knocked-up and the escapades of their new family lives or students in daily class listening to teachers blister our president...
JDW
Wounded skier, beware of mistakes.
News media: Scoreboard for terrorists
Is '24' Going A Little Over the Top For Prime Time TV?
March 5, 2007 - 00:12 ET by CarpareusIs '24' Going A Little Over the Top For Prime Time TV?
No.