Hersh: Bush World's Biggest Worry

Photo of Mark Finkelstein.

If there were any doubt as to the degree to which the MSM loathes and distrusts President Bush, it should be dispelled by the performance of Sy Hersh on today's Hardball and the way he was applauded by Chris Matthews. At the end of Hersh's appearance, Matthews put this question to the investigative reporter:

"What's your biggest worry in the world? Is it Iran? Is it this administration going to war with Iran? Is it a civil war in Iraq? Is it Musharraf's inability to fight the Taliban on his own soil? What's your biggest worry?"

Hersh was nothing if not succinct: "George Bush."

View video here.

Consider that for a moment. Not Iran, with its program to develop nuclear weapons. Not the fact that the resurgence of the Taliban could potentially give Al-Qaeda the platform for another attack on the US. No, the biggest threat to the world in Sy Hersh's mind is the President of the United States.

Did Matthews challenge this slander? To the contrary. Said the MSNBC host: "He's always fascinating because he's always right."

Contact Mark at mark@gunhill.net

Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

And there you have it, a blat

And there you have it, a blatant admission of what it has certainly seemed like for some time now - that the MSM and Democrats consider Bush to be the enemy, not muslim terrorists. Not at all surprising and yet at the same time - WOW!

Clearly the only thing the left cares about is its power. And Bush in the White House means Dems don't have it right now and that burns them up. Iran, AlQaeda, the Taliban, etc. don't occupy the White House or Congress. Therefore, the left hates Bush more than them.

They hate GW because he is no

They hate GW because he is not a Socialist and in fact, the opposite.

I think their hatred is roote

I think their hatred is rooted in their hatred for Christianity.

The liberal MSM has become an enemy of the USA.

You hit the nail on the head.

You hit the nail on the head. We should elect Bin Laden and company then sit back and watch them "protect" the country.

The Only Thing Pres. Bush Did Wrong

HumanEvents...

You're at the cusp of the issue right here. If Al Gore had "won" the election, everything would be right with the world according to liberals. It's sad when one's personal enemy (and this is personal and has gone way beyond political) is the President.

I didn't like Clinton. He got a free pass from the media and the world for most of his presidency. What's sad, is I think Clinton didn't have a clue that most people (including the military and Europe) snickered at him behind his back.

Pres. Bush absolutely gets no credit for anything...Clinton got credit for a booming economy so why can't Pres. Bush get credit for the good that happens? Why is there such a difference?

Just from looking at all the negative posts at Huff n' Puff about the failed assassination attempt on VP Cheney, they went into ecstacy and then horror that he survived. That's extremely sad. This is who the enemy within is...they'd rather support the Taliban killing a sitting VP then extinguishing terrorists.

There will be no peace until these nujobs like Hersh get what they want...a sitting DEMOCRAT as president. If another Republican wins then look out...they may have to commit ritualistic suicide. Or leave the country. Promises, promises.

The difficult we do immediately; the impossible takes a little longer.  Air Force Motto

emjem says: When your brain's stuck on liberalism it self-destructs.

Failure to Concede

The first thing Mr. Bush did wrong was fail to concede the election to Mr. Gore. That is what would have made our liberal friends happy (to the extent they can be made so).

But how would that have panned out, exactly? So Mr. Bush concedes the election. It doesn't automatically make recounts happen in the states and have the results switch over to Mr. Gore. It doesn't change the election certification process in the states. It doesn't give the Electors the freedom to change their votes. How was Mr. Gore supposed to have won the election? The only path I see was to allow Florida to have ex post facto changes in their election laws to create an environment where some method could have been found to manufacture a scenario where more votes could be counted for one candidate over the other, putting that state out of step with the other 49. And if you're going to do that, why not make it a lot simpler and just pass a law requiring that one particular candidate be deemed the winner.

Truly disgusting.Before I fou

Truly disgusting.

Before I found this site, I was merrily living my life...believing most everything I heard on the news.

What an eye opener.

After more than a year here, I'm considering becoming a radical righter (righter of wrongs).

Just because.

Blonde...You go girl!The libe

Blonde...

You go girl!

The liberal MSM has become an enemy of the USA.

Hey Clear,We go on the voyage

Hey Clear,

We go on the voyage together....

Blonde...I'll bring the sunbl

Blonde...

I'll bring the sunblock and beer, ok?

The liberal MSM has become an enemy of the USA.

I gave up on the press in my

I gave up on the press in my late teens to early 20s.  It was around the time cable stations began taking off and we got cable in my neck of the woods.  Historians will note it as the demise of journalism in the US - (let's just hope it isn't also a footnote to the collapse of Western civiliazation - and I'm half serious...).

When the TV in most homes started having more than 3 fuzzy networks, you started having a lot of news shows --

--- which meant you quickly got reporters and anchors and editors and producers --- talking about the news.

The proliferation of outlets led directly to the exposure of these people to the public --- and we began to notice what should have dawned on us long before (at least it should have to me) --- people with this much passion for politics and policy are bound to end up tainting it - especially if the orgs they work for (and the people who manage them) tend to hire people who think like them...

Having these guys on all the time has been both the best and worst thing that has happened to the news media in perhaps forever...

The worst part is he drops th

The worst part is he drops that little nugget and then the interview ends. You can't have a statement like that and just let it lay there. What does that mean? Elaborate. Why is Bush Hersh's biggest concern?

What don't you understand Bal

What don't you understand Bal?  The media and many libs hate George Bush, not disagree with, not prefer somebody else for President, not have respect for an ELECTED president.  They hate him, they hate him because he has beaten those that they supported, they hate him because he ignores them, they hate him because with the surge he may be right once again.  Theres nothing to understand, it's BDS, why can't you see that?  That's what I don't understand.  Hersh would rather defend Iran with the Mullahs than a USA with President Bush.

Sorry, I'm just not going to

Sorry, I'm just not going to assume "BDS." I'd like Hersh to provide some context for his answer.

Balboa, what context would

Balboa, what context would make it OK to call the POTUS the biggest worry? I can't think of one.

Exactly why we need it. H

Exactly why we need it.

He could be talking in terms of foreign policy, he could be talking in terms of how he's handling the Middle East quagmire. Who knows? That's why I'd like context.

look at the question bal

Look at the question bal, the one chrissy blabberews asked, for the context, it's there.

The worst part is he drops

The worst part is he drops that little nugget and then the interview ends. You can't have a statement like that and just let it lay there. - balboa

Of course he can, balboa. That's their tactic. That's why Rush uses the term "drive-by media." Like a drive-by shooter, they cruise up, take the pot shot, and then speed off.

Bal, this is typical Hersh. 

Bal, this is typical Hersh.  Below, find just a taste of some of the heinous crap that has come out of this "reporter's" mouth (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seymour_Hersh):

Speeches

Those who criticize Hersh's credibility especially point to allegations Hersh has made in public speeches and interviews, rather than in print. In an interview with New York Magazine, Hersh made a distinction between the standards of strict factual accuracy for his print reporting and the leeway he allows himself in speeches, in which he may talk informally about stories still being worked on or blur information to protect his sources. "Sometimes I change events, dates, and places in a certain way to protect people... I can’t fudge what I write. But I can certainly fudge what I say." [22]

Some of Hersh's speeches concerning the Iraq War have described violent incidents involving U.S. troops in Iraq. In July 2004, during the height of the Abu Ghraib scandal, he alleged that American troops sexually assaulted young boys:

Basically what happened is that those women who were arrested with young boys, children, in cases that have been recorded, the boys were sodomized, with the cameras rolling, and the worst above all of them is the soundtrack of the boys shrieking. That your government has. They’re in total terror it’s going to come out.[23]

In a subsequent interview with New York magazine, Hersh regretted that "I actually didn’t quite say what I wanted to say correctly...it wasn’t that inaccurate, but it was misstated. The next thing I know, it was all over the blogs. And I just realized then, the power of—and so you have to try and be more careful." [24] In his book, Chain of Command, he wrote that one of the witness statements he had read described the rape of a boy by a foreign contract interpreter at Abu Ghraib, during which a woman took pictures. [25]

At a Columbia University speech given by Hersh in June 2004, author Rick Perlstein reported:

[Hersh] said he had seen all the Abu Ghraib pictures. He said, "You haven't begun to see evil..." then trailed off. He said, "horrible things done to children and women prisoners, as the cameras run." [26]

In an interview with KQED host Michael Krasny on October 8, 2004 [27], Hersh reported speaking with a first lieutenant in charge of a unit stationed halfway between Baghdad and the Syrian border:

His group was bivouacking outside of town in an agricultural area, and had hired 30 or so Iraqis to guard a local granary. A few weeks passed. They got to know the men they hired, and to like them. Then orders came down from Baghdad that the village would be "cleared." Another platoon from the soldier's company came and executed the Iraqi granary guards. All of them.

He said they just shot them one by one. And his people, and he, and the villagers of course, went nuts," Hersh said quietly. "He was hysterical, totally hysterical. He went to the company captain, who said, 'No, you don't understand, that's a kill. We got 36 insurgents. Don't you read those stories when the Americans say we had a combat maneuver and 15 insurgents were killed?'

In a speech at McGill University in October 2006, after describing a video he had seen in which U.S. troops, following an attack on their convoy, had fired upon and killed a group of nearby soccer players, Hersh offered the assessment that "there has never been an [American] army as violent and murderous as our army has been in Iraq.” [28] However, in the same speech Hersh later back-peddled and said that there were other armies that had been worse than the Americans and that he did not believe in moral equivocation, when comparing the atrocities of one army to another.

Hersh needs to justify his la

Hersh needs to justify his last comment listed in your entry. 

If he knows of a US officer who ordered the assasination of civilians, then he needs to put up or shut up!

Of course, as a leftist, he will hide behind the "Need for a Shield Law" argument.

Bal, Hersh's "elaboratio

Bal, Hersh's "elaboration" would sound like this:

" He's shredded the Constitution, allowed 9/11 to happen to start an illegal war for oil on a soverign nation that had nothing to do with 9/11, suspended Habeus Corpus, spying and wiretapping on US citizens, torturing and rendering at CIA black sites, taken our civil rights,  can take anyone away in the night and hold them forever without being charged, stole the elections of 2000 and 2004, restricting freedom of the press, outing covert CIA agent, installing an "activist" Conservative Supreme Court, merging Church & State, while merging Corporate & State/Military, at the same time turning America on a slow slide towards a Fascist Theocracy. Oh and he prays to God."

Do I need to turn my sarc/ switch off?

If the Islamofascists prevail

If the Islamofascists prevail in his lifetime, he will come to regret this attitude.  As an obvious Jew, he is one of the first they will behead.

Who knows, we may soon witness the spectre of Iranian nuclear weapons used to wipe Israel off the map, either through direct application or through indirect blackmail.  I am sure Mr. Hersh will welcome such an event if comes and be justifiably proud, as he is one of those who will have made it possible.

Hersh should move to cuba o

Hersh should move to cuba or china or iran or north korea. Then I think his opinion would be different.

Worst Worry

Funny I have the same feeling about Sy Hersh that he has about President Bush.  People like Hersh and Matthews are trying hard to leave us defenseless before our enemies. Defeat in this conflict comes from within.

Bookends

Bush is the biggest worry?!?!?!?  But I thought the climate change formerly known as global warming was the biggest worry in the world.  Oh, that's right - Dubya has that weather machine in the White House basement......never mind.

Hersh is the perfect bookend for Matthews show - they're both moonbats.

"Sometimes I change events, dates, and places in a certain way to protect people... I can’t fudge what I write. But I can certainly fudge what I say." - Seymour Hersh

Good one, acumen! Here we had

Good one, acumen! Here we had CBS, NBC, ABC, CNN all telling us billions will die, we're all going to die, etc. because of global warming. Yet Bush is the bigger worry of Hersh. Man, how did George top the universal wipe out of global warming? I guess Hersh and Matthews think George would also kill all the life that may be on other planets and galaxies.

Hardball with Chris Matthews? HA! What's hardball about responding to Hersh's psychopathic answer by saying he is always correct?! 

It all gets so confusing HE

It all gets so confusing.......but somehow the blame always starts and stops with Bush.  Amazing.

Here's another doozy by the moonbat Hersh - who Matthews would have us believe is "always right"; "there has never been an [American] army as violent and murderous as our army has been in Iraq.”  But by all means we should not question Matthews or Hersh's patriotism.

Media Bias

Acumen...

Balboa thinks we're all overreacting to "media bias" and that we need to put "context" in what Hersh said. Is Hersh's history, books, and speeches with the one little doozy you enclosed, "there has never been an [American] army as violent and murderous as our army has been in Iraq,” not examples of media hatred, bias, and lies about the military and about Pres. Bush?

Me, pretending to be a liberal (Balboa): Let me stick this finger in the wind and point it in the right direction. If it points left, it's not media bias, and if it points right, it's the right overreacting like they tend to.

Ummmm....(I'm meditating on this right now), thinking deeply...if somebody (insert Chrissy Sissy or any moonbat journalist) says something unequivocally dishonest ("always right") about a guest and let's that guess say something utterly dishonest and untrue without challenging it...would that be a)media bias b)typical "honest" liberal journalism or c) not having enough "context" in an interview. Gosh, Acumen, that makes me deeply pensive. How 'bout you?

The difficult we do immediately; the impossible takes a little longer.  Air Force Motto

emjem says: When your brain's stuck on liberalism it self-destructs.

Well I've had a hard time tak

Well I've had a hard time taking Hersh seriously ever since he claimed he had anonymous sources telling him we were going to attack Iran. I mean hell, he predicited it twice, 2005 and 2006 and I'm just waiting for him to say we're going to attack this summer, his sources promise we really will this time.

Dear Mr. Hersh...Kindly bend

Dear Mr. Hersh...

Kindly bend over and stick your worries up your elitist patoot chute.

The liberal MSM has become an enemy of the USA.

What are people like Sy H goi

What are people like Sy H going to do when GWB is no longer in office?  I'm buying stock in psychiatrists and demolition derbys.

Yes, shame on us, and shame

Yes, shame on us, and shame on George Bush for trying to protect this country from terrorism, and open the world's eyes to islamofascism

I was approached today saying that there aren't any terrorists in Iraq, just militants. To assume that they aren't related is pretty ignorant.

What?!?  They inflict suffer

What?!?  They inflict suffering and death without warning on innocents.  Where ever you stand on our action in Iraq, they are the definition of terrorists!

Dah,You're post makes no sens

Dah,

You're post makes no sense.

Hey  FSU,Can you help?I'm co

Hey  FSU,

Can you help?

I'm confused here.....

Thanks.

Your GATOR pal.

<edit>  Well, I'm obviously way over my bed time...ooops.

Blonde,Good news (I think?)My

Blonde,

Good news (I think?)

My wife is speaking to me again.

Neo,Glad you're out of the do

Neo,

Glad you're out of the dog house.

B - I'm always here to help y

B - I'm always here to help you.  Not sure I understand what I can do???

**************

Support the Spread of Open Society and Capitalism around the World.  Do it for the Children.

FSU,It might help if I posted

FSU,

It might help if I posted correctly.

Now you have some ammo....Gators are silly after ten p.m.

Gators are silly all the time

Gators are silly all the time. 

**************

Support the Spread of Open Society and Capitalism around the World.  Do it for the Children.

Chicago Republican...that &qu

Chicago Republican...that "mean ol Blonde's" gona holler at U    :-^}     (bratt smile)  :-)  ww          v       I    AM PRO  AMERICAN  !  PRO LIFE!   PRO VICTORY!   ww

                               

Whoever made that comment to

Whoever made that comment to wiwf presumably opposes the United States being in Iraq.  That person is attempting to diminish the importance of the US being in Iraq by saying that those Iraqis and imported mercenaries who torture and deliberately kill innocent Iraqis are not terrorists, they are militants.  This is an absurd statement.  One can be opposed to our presence in Iraq while still acknowledging the evil being committed there.

wiwf, can you ask this person what the end game is for these ... um, "militants"?  From what I've seen, they have no desire to govern or even be heard on anything.  All they want to do is kill human beings and pointlessly destroy infrastructure. 

dahlia,I think you and witf a

dahlia,

I think you and witf are at cross purposes here.

I believe his (her?) post was sarcastic in the extreme.....

Just guessing.

Thanks for clarifying.

Thanks for clarifying.

When a Dem is back in the Whi

When a Dem is back in the White House then all their anxieties will be gone like a magic wand.

Like when all the msm reports of the homeless ceased upon Sick Willie's election. The transfer of a Republican to a DemocRAT suddenly transferred the homeless into homes!

Until now, I have never heard

Until now, I have never heard of this guy.  And it's just as well.  He is another non-entity with absolutely nothing to say or offer.

Personally, I am more afraid of that very bad comb-over.

Liberal: a power worshipper without power. George Orwell

Symore's alligator mouth is over loading his cottontail again.

This should in no way be considered a threat or encouragement to commit harm to anyone, but I've got to wonder what kind of security pissants like Seymour and blockheads like Matthews feel comfortable with.  The animus they deliberately generate does not serve any meaningful discourse.  Makes one wonder why they feel safe in doing it.

confronting the Islamist th

confronting the Islamist threat in the end destroys the leftist worldview, its no wonder these nutjobs are going to these type of extremes.

I was just getting ready to g

I was just getting ready to go to bed when I read this boogereater's comments.

So, lets recap, folks.

GWB, elected twice in the US, a nation with a media hostile to Republicans, bound by the restrictions of the US Constitution - he is a greater threat to the World than fascists nations around the world.

GWB doesn't even muzzle the NY Times when it leaks information detrimental to National Security; he operates within the bounds of the Constitution (please, civil liberties kooks, challenge that statement) and does NOTHING to silence his critics; he is a threat.

Meanwhile, lesser threats are totalitarian regimes around the world with UNLIMITED power, closed societies and sock puppet medias.  Some of them have nuclear weapons and other WMD.  Yet, this guy here with the bad combover thinks BUSH is the threat to world peace.

Things like this really make me suspicious of the claims of Natural Selection.

**************

Support the Spread of Open Society and Capitalism around the World.  Do it for the Children.

chris know's all

this only tyical of this elitist group of insiders ,discount any one who would stand for this country!! "crap'thews" an his ,"corn'ies" in the front offices with a lil help from the blue dog "bozo's keep the common folk disimformed so much,an divided,

 that the "masses" cannot find commom ground to start honest dialogue.

Bless and support All the troops--Liberalism is a mental disorder,

Wow, not even hiding it anymore

Just comes out and says the biggest problem in the world is the President. Here I'd been making excuses and seeking sanity in those who oppose the war in Iraq, who dismiss the Iranian threat, who blame hurricanes on the President, and argue that his daughters should go to war. Turns out all their opposition and nuttiness really is campaign 2004 oriented.

Check the calender moonbats. It's time to wake up and smell the jihad. There IS a world beyond the mastermind of George Bush's conspiratorial control.

my biggest worry?obamaedwards

my biggest worry?

obama

edwards

clinton

gore

they make bush look like alexander the great.

Matthews

Matthews' last comment proves what an ignoramus he is. How old are you, Chris? News Flash---no one is "always right". Time to grow up.

NEVER,NEVER trust a liberal

Chris Matthews - Bush Biggest Threat

So, I guess with the exchange at the end, Chris Matthews also believes that President Bush is the biggest threat to the world. Maybe someone should ask him about that.

Nothing sarcastic in that p

Nothing sarcastic in that post. The guy honestly implied that we shouldn't care about fighting the militants, even though the US considers them terrorists. Needless to say, I was dumbfounded that he'd say something like that. But being the good friend I am, I promptly changed the subject as to why he was gay. :P

If said fellow gets back online, I'll see what he has to say

Oh, and I'm a he by the way, thanks ;)

I'd like to issue a challen

I'd like to issue a challenge to these people: Travel around the world, go to various countries on each continent- making sure to cover at least one democracy/republic and one communist nation for each continent- stand out on a street corner and publicly denounce the government, the national religion, its foreign policy, etc. Which countries are you more likely (or even guaranteed) to be arrested, tortured or even killed, for saying such things?

Remember Stalin's Great Purge during the late 1930s.  Among those arrested were people who told jokes about Stalin, heard jokes about Stalin, or even wrapped a fish in a newspaper that had a picture of Stalin were sent to the Gulag and tortured until they "confessed to their crime." North Korea, Cuba, China, and soon-to-be Venezuela aren't much better.

"I don't know the key to success, but the key to failure is to try to please everyone." - Bill Cosby

Those poor fish

...or even wrapped a fish in a newspaper that had a picture of Stalin...

Those poor fish- good thing they were already dead for the most part before they were wrapped.

Carp