Economist Counters Al Gore: Cars Are Saving the Planet

Photo of Noel Sheppard.
  • Bookmark and Share

Dr. Global Warming, aka Al Gore, in his 1992 book “Earth in the Balance,” proclaimed that the internal combustion engine was “a mortal threat . . . more deadly than that of any military enemy.”

An op-ed written by an economics professor at the University of Georgia counters Gore’s dire assertions, and fervently stated that this invention is actually saving the planet.

In his piece published Tuesday in the Atlanta Journal-Constitution, Dwight R. Lee wrote (h/t JunkScience.com, emphasis mine throughout): "The motto of all environmentalists should be 'Thank goodness for the internal combustion engine.'"

Got your attention? Good, for Lee was armed for Gore, err, I mean bear:

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

The abuse heaped on the internal combustion engine by environmentalists was never justified. But a recent story on cow flatulence in the British newspaper, The Independent, makes the environmental benefits from gasoline-powered engines even more obvious. Based on a recent study by the Food and Agricultural Organization, The Independent reports that "livestock are responsible for 18 percent of the greenhouse gases that cause global warming, more than cars, planes and all other forms of transport put together."

Long before global warming became an environmental concern, however, the move from the power provided by animals to that provided by gasoline had greatly improved the environment. The emissions that came out of the tailpipes of horses were much more lethal pollutants that those now coming out of the tailpipes of cars. Horse emissions did more than make our town and cities stink; they spread fly-borne diseases and polluted water supplies that killed people at a far greater rate than the pollution from cars and trucks ever have.

Lee deliciously continued:

Photochemical smog is clearly a health risk, but not nearly the health risk of cholera, diphtheria and tetanus that have been largely eliminated with the help of gasoline powered transportation.

Before the internal combustion engine it wasn't just cows, sheep and pigs emitting pollution down on the farm. Tractors and other types of gas-powered farm machinery eliminated the horses, mules and oxen that had provided most of the power necessary to grow and harvest our food and fiber. This not only reduced the problem that still exists from animal waste that environmentalists, with justification, still complain about. The internal combustion engine also eliminated the need to produce food to fuel millions upon millions of agricultural beasts of burden. It has been estimated that in 1900 it took about 93 million acres of land to grow the food for the farm animals that were replaced by current farm machinery. Most of that land has now gone back to woodlands, greatly increasing the number of trees that are reducing the problem of global warming by absorbing carbon dioxide.

That’s not something you’ll hear from Dr. Gore or any of his global warming sycophants in the media, is it? Lee continued:

The above consideration should have been enough to warrant an environmental shrine to the internal combustion engine. And now we find that by eliminating all those farm-yard animals, the internal combustion engine also eliminated vast amounts of methane-producing flatulence, which is a much more powerful greenhouse gas than the carbon dioxide produce by burning gasoline.

Even though the internal combustion engine is less polluting than what it replaced, it is obviously not pollution-free. Efforts should, and will be made to make it even less polluting than it is, and some day internal combustion will be replaced by an even less polluting technology. But history will look kindly on the internal combustion engine as a major contributor to the steady progress toward a healthier environment that has been made over the centuries.

Sounds good to me. I’m off for an unnecessary drive to nowhere in particular to do my part in cleaning the environment.

—Noel Sheppard is the Associate Editor of NewsBusters. Follow him at Facebook and Twitter.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

"The emissions that ca

"The emissions that came out of the tailpipes of horses were much
more lethal pollutants that those now coming out of the tailpipes of
cars
."

As proved by a classic (and IMO hilarious!) Budweiser commercial, which put the censor-lobby into a minor tither the year we saw a major tither from 'em over Janet Jackson's briefly-exposed saggy tit.
JMR

I wonder how many Global Wa

I wonder how many Global Warming models included this impact in their calculations?

makes sense

All of the components of oil that's used to make gasoline are carcinogens, and most of the components in gasoline are broken down from complex hydrocarbons to various forms of carbon, hydrogen, and oxygen. Better to have those in the air, than the hydrocarbons in the ground

Tractors and other types of g

Tractors and other types of gas-powered farm machinery eliminated the horses, mules and oxen that had provided most of the power necessary to grow and harvest our food and fiber. - Can we at least come up with something that would eliminate demolibs and algore? Maybe an interal cumbustion engine powered positronic brain? and maybe it'll only run on Alaskan oil? or the hair gel algore uses?

There is no sense in being stupid, if you can't prove it! - my dad V

al gore responds, with a heat

al gore responds, with a heated reply!

Well I would say that it make

Well I would say that it makes perfect sense to me. Becouse we all know 99% of what they speak is just another SHITTY MYTH.  ;-)P

                             

One of the reasons alGore and

One of the reasons alGore and his flock can get away with their nonsense is because too many people are ignorant about basic science. I learned in grade school that people inhale oxygen and exhale carbon dioxide. Plants absorb carbon dioxide. Therefore, it seems less costly and troublesome to simply plant more trees. Or get rid of some people. I'll refrain from suggesting where we could start.

Queen...I must disagree with

Queen...

I must disagree with a portion of what you said.

Sure, a lot of us learned these things in our basic science classes, buuuut....

Most people get their news from the liberal MSM and have let themselves become slaves to the info that the liberal MSM spews. This has left people not bothering to think for themselves (and remember what they were taught) and letting the media do the thinking for them.

Sad, but true!

The liberal MSM has become an enemy of the USA.

It's so much easier that way,

It's so much easier that way, Clear.

"One of the reasons al

"One of the reasons alGore and his flock can get away with their nonsense is because too many people are ignorant about basic science. I learned in grade school that people inhale oxygen and exhale carbon dioxide. Plants absorb carbon dioxide. Therefore, it seems less costly and troublesome to simply plant more trees. Or get rid of some people."

Hi Queen,

Actually, that's not a good solution *if* you believe CO2 is responsible for global warming. Trees respiring(breathing) are responsible for 10 times the CO2 output that man is. Therefore, planting more trees would INCREASE CO2. But you'll never hear that from Gore and his minions.

As for getting rid of people, that is the ultimate goal of many of the enviro-nuts. They want to get rid of as many people as possible to ensure the survival of the earth. Their ideal scenario would be to get rid of everyone. Otherwise, we'll all suffer from the coming disaster, lol.


Reminder: Don't forget to pay your taxes. 12 million illegal immigrants are counting on you.

ckc: I must admit that I'm a

ckc: I must admit that I'm a bit skeptical re: your assertion that planting more trees would increase CO2. Can you please provide documentation? Thanks.

P.S. This is what I learned in school about trees and CO2. I did find an article however that stated that trees produce methane. Trees fart?

Also: "Trees remove (sequester) CO2 from the atmosphere during photosynthesis to form carbohydrates that are used in plant structure/function and return oxygen back to the atmosphere as a byproduct. About half of the greenhouse effect is caused by CO2. Trees therefore act as a carbon sink by removing the carbon and storing it as cellulose in their trunk, branches, leaves and roots while releasing oxygen back into the air."

This site would be nothing wi

This site would be nothing without Al Gore. NewsBusters has become a one-trick-pony. The majority of stories here all revolve around Al Gore, Al Gore Al Gore!!! Their trying to kill Darth Cheney and all you people can talk about it Al Gore and GLOBAL WARMING!

My GOD...WHERE'S THE HUMANITY?!

Actually, it's not Newsbuster

Actually, it's not Newsbusters that is infatuated with Al Gore, it's the mainstream media. And since Newsbusters is supposed to be a place to talk about what the news media is talking about, the Gore material here is perfectly legitimate. You just want us to change the subject, right?

If you do a Google News search, in the day and a half since Gore won the Oscar, some 2400 stories have been published about it. And yet in about the same time period, less than a hundred stories have been published about how much energy he uses at his empty-nest mansion.

So. So Wrong. You democrats h

So. So Wrong. You democrats have a whole lot more fools to skewer. They never cease to amaze me. He's just the dems and medias flavor of the month.

"The urge to save humanity is almost always a false front for the urge to rule.”   H.L. Mencken

You're right. We do have a l

You're right. We do have a lot of fools to skewer. Let's see, there's Bush, Rove, McCain, Lieberman, Jeff Sessions, Don Young...and just about everyone at Faux News!

blarsen,Coffee break is over

blarsen,

Coffee break is over - get back to work doing whatever you hate America first types do over at MoveOn.org.

Let's not forget Pelosi, Reid

Let's not forget Pelosi, Reid, Boxer, Dean, Schumer, Kennedy, Clinton, Kerry,  Obermann, C Matthews. This list could go on and on. 

"The urge to save humanity is almost always a false front for the urge to rule.”   H.L. Mencken

Where can I nominate this guy

Where can I nominate this guy for a Nobel Peace Prize?   Unfortunately his clear, precise, reasoned thinking will not surface through the flatulence of the main stream media and its group think.

I've heard responses to the

I've heard responses to the cow farts argument to the fact that cows actually don't fart (when they started to explain, I stopped paying attention). This article still holds true, whether cows release farts or another form of methane expulsion.

One of the kids fed baloney t

One of the kids fed baloney to the dog on a car trip once...  whatever they call animal emissions, I can attest they are noxious and deadly.

Oh, how I love this!  And I

Oh, how I love this!  And I can attest to some of this first hand.  I attended a small college in Nebraska and I would commute some 20 miles each day to the campus, and in so doing it was necessary to pass by a huge feed lot.  OMG!!!  You almost couldn't breathe!  And on hot summer days..  forget about it!!!  If there had been ANYway to contain that gas in an enclosure and then light a match, it would have been nuclear! 

Al-jazeera Journal/Constitution

Noel,

What I find really amazing about this is that the Al-Jazeera Urinal/Constipation (my hometown "newspaper") actually printed that op-ed.

Maybe Cynthia Tucker was away for the day or something.

I hate newspapermen.....I regard them as spies.....If I killed them all there would be news from Hell before breakfast. -Gen. William T. Sherman

On behalf of your neighbors a

On behalf of your neighbors and the planet, Noel, thank you for leaving the horse drawn carriage home.

Finally the truth is coming

Finally the truth is coming out about this socialist plan to tax everyone based of a bogus pyramid scheme called Global Warming.

Now we need some brave soul to point out there is no energy shortage but a Government that has caused domestic energy sources of energy not to be developed.

We have more oil locked up in Alaska than in all of Saudi Arabia but congress keeps it all capped in places like Gull Island and ANWAR.

We have a bunch of con artists and criminals that inhabit Congress.

Is this Mexico or the USA

I couldn't help myself

Good, for Lee was armed for Gore, err, I mean bear:

Don't you mean, "Lee was armed for for Gore, I mean manbearpig." ???