A Real Outing of CIA Operatives Fighting Terrorists: 'Where's the Outrage?'

Photo of Brent Baker.

So asked James Taranto in his Wednesday “Best of the Web Today” column for OpinionJournal.com. Taranto highlighted a Sunday Los Angeles Times story, “Pilots traced to CIA renditions: The Times identifies three fliers facing kidnapping charges in Germany related to a 2003 counter-terrorism mission,” which though it did not list their real names, identified the aliases and enough information about each to help anyone trying to find them, including how they all live within 30 miles of a certain rural airport. One “drives a Toyota Previa minivan and keeps a collection of model trains in a glass display case near a large bubbling aquarium in his living room,” another “is a bearded man of 35 who lives with his father and two dogs in a separate subdivision” and a third “is 46, drives a Ford Explorer and has a 17-foot aluminum fishing boat” where he lives “in a house that backs onto a private golf course here." (Taranto explained: “In a town of 13,000 the Times identifies in its dateline.”)

Taranto ruminated: “Remember all the outrage when Robert Novak 'outed' Valerie Plame, who apparently worked a desk job at CIA headquarters in Langley, Va.? Here the L.A. Times is publishing extensive personal details on three men who have actually done dangerous work defending the country. Where's the outrage?” Good question.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

An excerpt from the February 18 Los Angeles Times story by Bob Drogin and John Goetz:

....The names they used were all aliases, but The Times confirmed their real identities from government databases and visited their homes this month after a German court in January ordered the arrest of the three "ghost pilots" and 10 other alleged members of the CIA's special renditions unit on charges of kidnapping and causing serious bodily harm to Khaled Masri, a German citizen of Lebanese descent, three years ago.

None of the pilots responded to repeated requests for comment left with family members and on their home telephones. The Times is not publishing their real names because they have been charged only under their aliases....

According to Masri's account, he was detained by local authorities while crossing from Serbia into Macedonia on Dec. 31, 2003. Three weeks later, seven or eight men in masks stripped him naked, put him in a diaper and jumpsuit, drugged him and then chained him, spread-eagle and blindfolded, to the floor of a Boeing 737 that flew to Afghanistan on Jan. 24, 2004. German prosecutors say the men in masks were with the CIA rendition team.

At the time, U.S. intelligence authorities believed Masri was involved with radical Islamic groups in Ulm, a city in southern Germany. Masri was released five months later after undergoing what he described as repeated beatings and other physical abuse in a now-closed CIA-run prison called the Salt Pit in Kabul, the Afghan capital. U.S. officials have told German authorities that Masri was seized and imprisoned in error because his name is similar to that of a suspected terrorist linked to Al Qaeda.

Flight records show that Aero Contractors, based in Smithfield, N.C., operated the plane that carried Masri from Macedonia to Afghanistan. The charter aircraft company has flown scores of sensitive missions for the CIA and has played a key support role in counter-terrorism operations since the Sept. 11 attacks, according to former agency officials.

The three pilots in the Masri rendition case live within a 30-minute drive of the guarded Aero hangar and offices at the rural Johnston County airport. Reached by telephone Saturday, Aero official Freddy Pearce declined to discuss any aspect of the company's business.

The chief pilot in the Masri case, who used the alias Fairing, called Pearce at his Clayton home during his layover in Spain.

In real life, the chief pilot is 52, drives a Toyota Previa minivan and keeps a collection of model trains in a glass display case near a large bubbling aquarium in his living room. Federal aviation records show he is rated to fly seven kinds of aircraft as long as he wears his glasses.

His wife, reached by phone at her office, said her husband had done no wrong. "He's just a pilot," she said.

His copilot, who used the alias Fain, is a bearded man of 35 who lives with his father and two dogs in a separate subdivision. He called home during a subsequent mission from the Royal Plaza Hotel on the Spanish resort island of Ibiza, according to records collected by Spanish investigators from the Guardia Civil.

The third pilot, who used the alias Bird, is 46, drives a Ford Explorer and has a 17-foot aluminum fishing boat. Certified as a flight instructor, he keeps plastic models of his favorite planes mounted by the fireplace in his living room in a house that backs onto a private golf course here. His wife declined to comment....

—Brent Baker is Vice President for Research and Publications at the Media Research Center


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Nothing like the Times to sho

Nothing like the Times to shorten the life expectancy of our folks fighting the war on terror, right?

How about if we start publishing the addresses of Times employees, expected routes to and from work as well as anticipated times, and favorite hangouts of said employees on  government webpages?  I bet they would SCREAM!!!!

I think the Half Hour Comedy Hour on Fox News could get some mileage out of this or terrorists being released in the boardroom of the Times or the ACLU HQ post release from Gitmo following prodding by both entities.  Comedic footage of journo's and ACLU lawyers being thrown from windows ala Monty Python could be most hilarious.

The left will be applauding t

The left will be applauding the "patriotism" of the Times.

Of course, harming your natio

Of course, harming your nations defense capability is ALWAYS good for it....

Fitzgerald has a real case to run now.

Fitzgerald has a real case to run now. Where's the prosecution ?

I guess this nation is totally toasted.

BD, I love the idea of doing

BD, I love the idea of doing a piece on these reporters and giving away some of those personal details so that it may be easy top track them down.  Fight Fire with Fire, do unto others as,,,,,,

Okay, so if the guys used fak

Okay, so if the guys used fake ID's, aviation records, credit cards etc, then all is fair?

This reminds me of the news-crews who used to park outside of Whiteman AFB and watch the take offs and landings of the B-2 Stealth Bombers so they could go live with the "Hey, Surprise blown, we are about to Bomb them" stories...

What if the newspaper were to bribe someone to obtain ACTUAL identities of the persons involved, should the publish them so the Germans can actually locate and prosecute?  If so, should the newspaper then hold out on the information on who it bribed to gain said information?

They have their real names

They have their real names. Phonebook,  addresses, home telephone, wives' workplace numbers.

They basicilly gave everyone else their real identity. To the tiny city of 13,000 and to the golf course abutted homes. To the condo with Daddy, son and 2 dogs. A day or two to find them, if that, in a car. See the boat. Located address, check the local phonebook or better yet realtors directory for everything.

 They're identified, no doubt about it.

What?  The gist of the post

What? 

The gist of the post is that the LA Times is outing these guys - which is laughable unless you think the Greman's are not able to trace phone calls (hotel records).  On one layover, two of the 3 guys called home.  The German's can and will identify them without the LA Times printing anyting. 

The LA Times is a red herring.  A better question is why has the Bush adminsitration allowed the German's to even prosecute the pilots.  Why didn't the Bush admin get flight  permission before these flights were initiated?

The herring up dingdong777's amnesiac brain

The herring up dingdong777's amnesiac brain:

The NYT and the LATimes exposed the rendition program to the world, initiating the global scandal in the several governments, and the demise of the program.

 Anything but a red herring, except in the conveniently amnesiac mind of a liberal fool.

There are a handful of peopl

There are a handful of people who were subjected to rendition and are being represented pro bono by human-rights lawyers

They did not need the NY or LA Times to tell them what happened to them. 

ding7777 the dong

ding7777 the dong in your head is the fact that now you know, thanks to NYT and LAT,and so do all the raging shrieking threatening gagglebot libs storming the parlaiments. 

 A few lawyers arguing like they always do never make the rendition flights exposed or the "case" explode.

SportPolitics - Various gover

SportPolitics - Various governments,  international lawyers,  UN Human Rights Watch, Canadian and European media, etc, etc all had exposes re the CIA rendition flights prior to the NYTimes article. 

The people in Sweden did not need the NYTimes to tell them what their government was doing (it was documented on Swedish TV a full year before the NYTimes article)  

Keep believing it was the big bad NYTimes who bursted the bubble, Sport

Ding7777:You miss the point,

Ding7777:

You miss the point, it is the DISSEMINATION of this information that is the issue.  The real nightmare scenario is that the families of these individuals are now at risk.

Now all any terrorist, or terrorist wanna-be like the guy up in Salt Lake City can easily access this information by reading the Times and go on a spree amongst the families of the agents/aviation personnel.

We are not particularly worried about a euro court asking for extradition for a task that serves the interest of the US government as the current US government has too much moral courage to turn them over.  Only a money grubbing trial lawyer would worry about that aspect......

That is why I say we should allow the news paper personnel to accept the same risks as the families of our folks...

Hey Sparky, it's the CIA.I th

Hey Sparky, it's the CIA.

I think they have a little experience in covering their trail.

Unless, of course, these supposed pilots were prancing around their town telling everybody they were agents, of course.

Shrub - No reason for them to

Shrub - No reason for them to "prance around their town telling everybody they were agents" since they are not  CIA agents; they work for a small airline service who does contract work for the CIA. 

Policy of Rendition

Always worth mentioning - for the beneift of those who will curse at the current President for such a needed program - that it was set up at the request of one, Bill Clinton, back it the mid 1990's.

Yep. And some of us also bi

Yep. And some of us also bitched about it back then when Slick did it, too...Well, at least one of us.
JMR

Just a wild thought, but coul

Just a wild thought, but couldn't it be that these kinds of stories are merely a government smokescreen for the real covert operations that nobody ever hears about?                   

Oops...maybe I shouldn't have said that.....

(Just kidding, there is no such thing.  Really...) 

You would hope mattm

You would hope mattm, but this one was obviously reported since Bush hate reigns supreme along with 30 year old CIA hatred, and for the fact that it got "shutdown". So now, it's "compromised", and the NYT gets to gloat in it's accomplishment in that area.  They obviously set off scandals in several foreign governments as well. Lotsa' power exposing those secrets... really sent the "man running" this time.

 They must be very proud and thrilled.

yes ...

I saw this article, too. Thank you, Brent (and James), for reporting this!

Taranto

James Taranto is right on the money here, as he so often is. I enjoy his column. The more desperate the LA Times gets the more nuttier they get. I wonder who is still subscribing to this crap?

Taranto: wish he was on 24/7.

Taranto: wish he was on 24/7.  His columns and words are great, love him!

"He who has a thousand friends has not a friend to spare, and he who has one enemy will meet him everywhere"          -Ali ibn-Abi-Talib, 4th Islamic Caliph

This is just too surreal, lik

This is just too surreal, like when one cannot wake up from a BAD nightmare. I would volunteer to be on this firing squad (with the live round) if someone brought them up on treason charges...HELLO, USAG...make my day.

"To bad Ignorance isn't painful..."

Disgusting Double Standards

The media is all about disgusting double standards. It's okay to out a CIA Operative who was no longer undercover but to out current, active, and undercover CIA operatives is just beyond the pale. I say, more rendition. Let's get information from these suckas any way, any fashion possible. Why do we care (or the Europeans and their precious EU for that matter) what happens to these terrorist thugs? But to out these guys on purpose just is CRIMINAL. No one will investigate this incident until something serious happens to these great Americans. We need more of them and screw Germany and Italy. If you protest now when we've been doing all your dirty work you're not allies because you've betrayed that relationship.

The difficult we do immediately; the impossible takes a little longer.  Air Force Motto

emjem says: When your brain's stuck on liberalism it self-destructs.

"But to out these guys

"But to out these guys on purpose just is CRIMINAL."

Not if they were involved in criminal activity themselves. The german and italian government knew about it and didn't say anything. If you want to blame something, blame the independence of the judiciary.

"Hegel says somewhere all great events and personalities in world history reappear in one fashion or another. He forgot to add: the first time as tragedy, the second as farce."
The Eighteeenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte (1852) sect. 1, Cf.

Please tell me which US law t

Please tell me which US law they violated?

BD

It's a little bit ignorant to think that they had to violate U.S. laws in order to be prosecuted. They have broken german and italian laws (or, giving them the benefit of doubt: they allegedly broke german and italian laws). That is enough.

"Hegel says somewhere all great events and personalities in world history reappear in one fashion or another. He forgot to add: the first time as tragedy, the second as farce."
The Eighteeenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte (1852) sect. 1, Cf.

So, you are willing to surren

So, you are willing to surrender them to the Euro judicial process for fighting the GWOT?

What if the Belgians come back up with their demand to have access to our soldiers for actions in Iraq?  Wanna send them over to stand trial?

Scary, very scary!With the in

Scary, very scary!

With the info printed in the Times a bounty hunter or a repo man could find these guys in less than 8 hours. When is our government going to prosecute these SOB's?

You mean the german prosecuto

You mean the german prosecutor and the italian judge?

"Hegel says somewhere all great events and personalities in world history reappear in one fashion or another. He forgot to add: the first time as tragedy, the second as farce."
The Eighteeenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte (1852) sect. 1, Cf.

The  prosecuter and Judge di

The  prosecuter and Judge did not disseminate the information in a form usable by our enemies....  The paper did.

BD

You have no idea what was going on in europe, have you? The italian judge issued arrest warrants with the real names of the agents (not their undercover names). A german television crew was even trying to get an interview at the doors of some CIA agents. This information is out for at least 6 months if not more.

"Hegel says somewhere all great events and personalities in world history reappear in one fashion or another. He forgot to add: the first time as tragedy, the second as farce."
The Eighteeenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte (1852) sect. 1, Cf.

While I think it is heinous t

While I think it is heinous that the LA Times made an attempt at "outing" these heroes, if there is a bright spot concerning this it is that it is fair warning to terrorists that where ever they are we will find you, find what we need to know from you and/or kill you. 

Since the New Year, the Tribune's (TRB), the parent of the LA Times, stock price has fallen another 10%.  Meanwhile, the current management has seen the light and is trying to dump this turkey to whomever will buy it.  So, far a lot of kicking of tires, but no takers.  Keep up the great "reporting" LA Times.

jdhawk -  if there is a bri

jdhawk -  if there is a bright spot concerning this it is that it is fair warning to terrorists that where ever they are we will find you, find what we need to know from you and/or kill you. 

If the terrorists give money to the NRCC, the NRCC invites them to be on its Business Advisory board.  According to the NRCC,  these terrrorists (Abdul Tawala Ibn Ali Alishtari and Yasith Chhun for example) need due process (no renditions for them,  nosiree!) And of course the NRCC will keep the money they gave.

 Terrorists Fundraiser of the Year

Yeah, ding7777 - and when you give money to the Democrats....

Yeah, ding7777 - and when you give money to the Democrats, you aid the terrorists too.

And the Democrats, in lockstep with the Al Qaeda strategy do everything in their power to destroy troop morale; destory America's will to fight; and to give hope to the enemy that if they just 'hang in there' they will win because we will quit.

Good work.  Keep on thinking ding7777; that's what is happening with an entire political party, not just some slimeball hack who was using politicans as cover for his sedition.

ACA

...

Quoted from:  'Acaiguana Notes from the Bomb Shelter' (soon to be a movie at theaters near you)