GMA Uses Interview with Gay Basketball Player to Discuss America’s ‘Secret Prejudice’

Photo of Scott Whitlock.

As already reported on NewsBusters, Friday’s "Good Morning America" used the pretext of the 2008 presidential election to wonder just how bigoted America is. In a segment that aired in the 7:30 hour, Diane Sawyer talked to former NBA star John Amaechi about his new book, the revelation that he’s a homosexual, and an anti-gay diatribe delivered by ex-Miami Heat star Tim Hardaway.

This is the second time in five days that the ABC program has promoted Amaechi’s book. And just as with the piece on Senator Obama and his candidacy, Sawyer used isolated incidents to draw conclusions about all of America:

Diane Sawyer: "All right, as we said now, we're going to give you a story that wades right into this country's secret prejudice against gays in America. The former pro basketball player who revealed he is gay is with us. His name is John Amaechi. He has been the target of an anti- gay tirade by a former NBA all-star, Tim Hardaway."

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

In an apparent conflict of interest, Sawyer failed to mention that Amaechi’s autobiography is being released by ESPN Books, a division of ABC’s parent company. Oddly, on February 11, when GMA ran virtually the same piece on Amaechi, they offer the full disclosure information about the connection.

In the segment, which aired at 7:32am on February 16, Sawyer introduced a report by correspondent John Berman:

ABC Graphic: "NBA Star's Anti-Gay Rant: Does Hardaway Apology Mean Anything?"

Diane Sawyer: "All right, as we said now, we're going to give you a story that wades right into this country's secret prejudice against gays in America. The former pro basketball player who revealed he is gay is with us. His name is John Amaechi. He has been the target of an anti gay tirade by a former NBA all-star, Tim Hardaway. ABC's John Berman launches this tale."

John Berman: "Banished from this weekend's NBA all-star festivities, a chastened Tim Hardaway returned home to Florida last night."

Tim Hardaway: "I've very sorry. That's- That's no doubt about it. I'm very, very sorry about it. But, you know, a lot of people don't think so, but I am."

Berman: "But the former all-star's comments about gays are still sending shock waves through the sports world."

Hardaway: "You know, I hate gay people. I let it be known, I don't like gay people. I don't like to be around gay people. I'm homophobic."

Berman: "The comments were prompted by the release of the new book from former player, John Amaechi, in which he comes out of the closet. Only a small handful of gay athletes in major men's team sports have ever come out of the closet. And then, only after they retired."

Billy Bean: "My dream is to be a major league baseball player. Everything, that I hoped and dreamed that my life would become, none of it had to do with the reality that I’m a gay man."

Berman: "The machismo of male sports might make it hard to come out, but for women, it seems to be different. Athletes like Billie Jean King, Martina Navratilova, and Cheryl Swoops are all openly gay."

Christine Brennan (USA Today Sports columnist): "If you want to play sports, if you wanted to play on the basketball team, or the volleyball team, the softball team, you weren't maybe going to be maybe the most popular girl but you would be accepted. There was a place for you there."

Berman: But Tim Hardaway's initial rant shows that the sports world for men today might not be nearly so accepting. For Good Morning America, John Berman, ABC News."

Sawyer followed that segment with a full interview and the tone of her questions clearly indicated her full support for Amaechi:

Sawyer: "And joining us now is former NBA player John Amaechi who did publicly reveal in his book, 'Man in the Middle,' that he is gay. He is also, by the way, the only British player?"

John Amaechi: "That's correct."

Sawyer: "-Person growing up in England to play for the NBA."

Amaechi: "Indeed, yes."

Sawyer: "It's great to have you here. It's good to see you. All right, Tim Hardaway, you heard his comments. What do you want to say to him this morning?"

Amaechi: "I really want to impress on him, and to people in general that people whose voices can ricochet around the world need to be careful how they wield their words. It's important that they realize that right now there are hundreds of thousands of people who feel less safe, less secure, more anxious, not just gay and lesbian people, but people who are perceived to be gay and lesbian. It pollutes the atmosphere when you hear these words of hate. And not only that, he's emboldened the bigots. He's made people who, perhaps, would keep their hatred, their bigotry inside, perhaps pushed them to a point where they are now feel they are free to say things and do things that will impact other people."

Sawyer: "You have written that you're particularly concerned about kids because it's sports. And when bigotry is incited against kids who have yet to tell people, it's a different kind of thing."

Amaechi: "It is, really. It's so damaging. I mean, everybody knows that the formative years, your teenage years, when you're just kind of understanding, coming to understand yourself, it's so difficult. You add onto that issues with your sexuality and the confusion and then comments like this, it makes life ever more difficult."

A few minutes later, Sawyer seemed to make it clear where she stood on what should happen to Tim Hardaway:

Sawyer: "Let me go back to Tim Hardaway for a moment, because, as you know, he was asked to leave the all-star game in Las Vegas this weekend. Do you think that was appropriate?"

Amaechi: "I think David Stern has made a very clear message. He wants to the NBA to be a meritocracy. I think we should want society to be a meritocracy, not based on these other prejudices and stereotypes. So I'm very pleased that he's-- that David Stern and the league have put their money where their mouth is."

Sawyer: "Another question about Tim Hardaway's apology. He said 'As an African American I know all too well the negative thoughts and feelings hatred and bigotry cause.' So that was his apology."

Amaechi: "Yeah, it seems a little trite, doesn't it? As a black person myself, I know some of those very same issues. But it has changed the way I think. It makes me more open. Where as with him, it seems to have made him less so."

Sawyer: "I want to ask you about something, somebody else said. Shaquille O’Neal. He came out and basically said, 'Anybody who would try to get to a gay player on my team would have to go through me first. And he said, 'If he was on my team, I guess I would have to protect him.' And he said, 'I'm just not the type of person who judges people.'

Amaechi: "You know what, it's enlightening, it's heart-warming. It- Those are the words that inoculate against some of the hatreds that we've heard. You know, I heard that first this morning and it's just been, it's put a smile on my face."

Sawyer: "Well, I know people have been overwhelming you with e-mails, and we wish you the best."

Amaechi: "Thank you very much."

Sawyer: "Thank you so much for coming in. Again, it is 'Man in the Middle,' and it is bringing out into the public a debate, that as David Stern said, maybe sports needs to lead the way sometimes."

Amaechi: "I hope so."

So, Tim Hardaway goes on a rant and is banned from appearing at the NBA all star game? Sawyer’s approving comment about David Stern and sports leading the way appeared to indicate she agrees with the commissioner’s action. However, when the Dixie Chicks faced boycotts and fans burning their albums after they attacked President Bush, the GMA anchor was on the other side. On May 23, 2006, she touted how the group had come "roaring back." Sawyer also asked sympathetic questions, including whether the group felt they had "been vindicated and that the American public moved to your position?"

As noted earlier, "Good Morning America covered this exact same topic only five days ago on the Sunday edition of the ABC program. That segment, unlike the Friday interview of Amaechi, did point out that the ex-NBA player’s book is being released by a parent company of the network. It also featured remarkably similar comments by the morning anchors. For a transcript, head over to the posting by the MRC’s Tim Graham.

—Scott Whitlock is a news analyst for the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Fags...

Ya wanna be a fag...be a fag, just know it is perverted and disgusting so quit whining when you parade your immorality and people find it just what it is...disgusting.

But this is the way it has become. What is right is wrong, what is wrong is right. Perversions are good and morality is shameful. But HEY...maybe someone should go ask TONY DUNGY the Born Again Christian COACH what he thinks about homosexuality and what HOW QUICKLY he runs from his Christian identity and biblical morality.

There is nothing SECRET about many Americans rejecting homosexuality.  This pathetic shame tactic won't work on people with a backbone.  In fact people should come right out and say, "Yes, I believe homosexuality is immoral and if your bigotted rejection of my religious orientation isn't going to shame me into abandoning it so now quit being a bigot against me and questioning my religious morality you bigot".  That might help.

If you claim to be a conservative, please don't disgrace yourself and conservatism by thinking and arguing like a liberal. Go Rudy!

DAMN RIGHT!!! The best way t

DAMN RIGHT!!! The best way to help rectosexuals is to keep reminding them of their moral depravity and to QUIT BEING A FAG.

My liberal friends will hate

My liberal friends will hate what I'm about to write, cool huh?

Anyway.... our liberal friends always scream freedom of speech when anyone says anything controversial concerning any of the usual liberal causes, but when someone says something against gays... holy crap the worlds gonna end!

Tim Hardaway has the right to say what he said, period! Was it a smart move, maybe not, but he still has the right to say it. I'm betting that he hates what gays do, but does not actually hate the person. If this is what he means then I am in the same camp as he is. I know gay people and get along with them just fine, but if any of them ever asked me if I liked what they did (living in sin) I would have to tell them the truth... I hate what they do. Does this make me homophobic? Maybe, but thruth be told, I could care less.

Homophobia...

Homophobia is a made up word used as a weapon to attempt to characterize anyone who rejects homosexuality as irrational. Hardaway is so stupid he doesn't even know the correct meaning of the word and called himself homophobic...but that isn't surprising. He doesn't have any irrational fear which is the meaning of the word, he simply doesn't like fags and in fact hates them. We all have our prejudices but it doesn't mean it is a phobia...sheesh.

If you claim to be a conservative, please don't disgrace yourself and conservatism by thinking and arguing like a liberal. Go Rudy!

I can't believe Tim Hardaway

I can't believe Tim Hardaway would say such a thing.  He seemed so articulate and clean.

Thank you. Those are my fee

Thank you. Those are my feelings exactly on the word "homophobia." Simply an attempt to make something sound scientific. Reminds me of Roger's 2nd Rule of Liberalism - "if you say something enough times then it must be true."

"Homophobia is a ... wor

"Homophobia is a ... word used as a weapon."

Homosexuals and homosexual consenters are HETEROPHOBIC, THEOPHOBIC, and SCRIPTURAPHOBIC.

Freedom of speech means we can use any words at our disposal to confront homosexuals, homosexuality, and the venomous words they use against Christians, conservatives, and anyone who dares to tell them that their lifestyle is immoral, depraved, and barbaric.

A little English lesson

Phobia: a persistent, irrational fear of a specific object, activity, or situation that leads to a compelling desire to avoid it.

Now what is it there that you disagree with as a definition?

My point is ... WTF do you care what people do in the privacy of their own home or non-public place? I don't care what they do - or what YOU do as long as it doesn't concern me.

Yeah yeah ... you hate them, want to kill them all, maybe, wipe them off the face of your Godfearing Earth.

Flash - not all people believe in your version of religion.

No - I'm not gay (happily married 36 years, 1 son), but I do have a few gay friends/aquaintances, and they respect my feelings as I do theirs. They have at times been better friends than my straight friends when the caca hit the revolving airfoil. I had a gay friend on the PD who had more balls than most of the "real men" I worked with.

Get a little education before you go around talking like an ass.

Saurus, Whoa Boy....He never

Saurus, Whoa Boy....

He never said that he hated gay people or wanted to kill them. Relax.

Yes, you're right, nobody should care about what anybody does in their private life. But when you come forward, when you publicly state your sexuality, you are not ammune to judgement.

We're not there yet.....

poke him with a stick

Dear saurus,

I see you're an emotional dude. Especially about "education". Why is it you talk like an ass, being putatively better educated than "real men"--? Education never made gays less reprehensible. A gay Oxford don is no more worthy than gay male prostitutes. They're the same peas in the gay pod.

Things being relative, I would poke you with a stick first; then the gay Oxford don. Because he has the decency to remain discreet. You blow your mind because you're so "educated".

All our sins are equally offensive. Here you sin all the more cursing religion. Of course it's on account of your lovely education. --SNOB.

Tumbler,Most of you're post w

Tumbler,

Most of you're post was nonsense. Quit ruining the good name of conservatives with you're blabber. Don't get me started on you're favorite topic.

NeoContorted

My, NeoCon-- I thought my post made sense. I'm ordinarily OK with others needling me; just have your fun. How are you enhancing the good name of conservatives? Your wedgie? Not much a NeoCon should be proud of.

Just give us a jump-start on "my favorite topic," I'll have you creeping on your neo's in short order.

saurus, you are wrong!

You stated that, "WTF do you care what people do in the privacy of their own home or non-public place? I don't care what they do - or what YOU do as long as it doesn't concern me.

 I don’t believe you.  Police all around the country arrest people everyday who”do in the privacy of their own home or non-public place" things that are against the law! What about tobacco smokers in California and other places that are not allowed to smoke even in "the privacy of their own home or non-public place (car)"?  The fact is that people who do not believe in homosexuality on MORAL grounds are demonized, but all laws are based on MORAL grounds!  Why is it illegal for consensual sex between a grown man and an adolescent above the age of consent?  Some believe it is IMMORAL, others think it is "JUST A LIFESTYLE CHOICE". How was it that 12 and 13 year olds were getting married to GROWN MEN in the UNITED STATES in the 17 &1800's, but now the same person would be a pedophile! The MORALS changed, thats all. It is a moral matter and no matter how long and loud homosexual activists yell that their lifestyle is just as MORAL as heterosexual activities, there will be some who disagree on religious reasons (Christian, Jewish, Muslim). 

Flash: Just because one is against homosexuality, it does not mean one "hate(s) them,(wants to) kill them all, or wipe them off the face of" G*D's Green/Blue Earth! 

I laughed when I heard what T

I laughed when I heard what Tim Hardaway said.  Why?  Because he was being honest and if more people had the balls to actually say what they felt, then we might be in a better place.

I don't particularly care for gays either.  Why?  Because they constantly say I should care for them!  They dont care for me!  Why the heck should I care for them?

This was my first thought whe

This was my first thought when I heard about the uproar.  Maybe we should give Hardaway an award so he can say how a lot of people used their free speech, ala Natalie Brainless.

"People everywhere confuse what they read in newspapers with news."  - A.J. Liebling

What a pity Sawyer didn't t

What a pity Sawyer didn't take the opportunity to ask her new best pal President Amadinajhad about Iran's public prejudice?

That's the one where he okayed the public hangings of two youths for alleged homosexual activity. From a crane. Two years ago. In Tehran.

Her being all that concerned about some retired player's "words."

"Our readers don't give a rat's ass about what you think. They want facts."

Elmore Leonard, 'The Hot Kid'.

 CHICAGO, February 19th, 200

 CHICAGO, February 19th, 2007 (AP) -- Senator Barack Obama announced this morning that, along with being black, Liberal, AND Muslim, he is now also homosexual, and that he is leaving his wife to move in with his partner, a Hispanic gardner named Raoul Jesus Garcia. The Senator was quoted to say "in 2008, the American people now have the opportunity to vote for a gay black Hispanic-loving ex-smoking former drug-using Muslim to be the next president of the United States". The Council for Asian  Relations could not be reached for comment, but the Native American Brotherhood did state they they hope Senator Obama discovers his American Indian roots real soon.

rog, idiot white supremacist

Why are you picking on Raul (the proper hispanic name) Jesus Garcia?

Why make it an hispanic? I always figured you for an habitual masturbator. You never let up. (You never grow up.)

As for Obama Shama, his closest kin is a Yellow Macaca. Make of that what you will, Roger Up A Rope.

Hey tumbly,Unlike you (on ILL

Hey tumbly,

Unlike you (on ILLEGAL immagration) Roger actually has a sense of humor.

Roll the burrito, crisp the taco, salsa the chips, and go to bed!

my feelings exactly

It's because I know Rog can take it with a grin, I'm posting this.

Hope you don't object?

Tirade?! He said he didn't li

Tirade?! He said he didn't like fags.

Proverbs 28:4

They that forsake the law praise the wicked: but such as keep the law contend with them.

They that adhere to the truth contend with the wicked.

They that toss it out the window praise them for their "courage" in flaunting their sin before the world and leading others into the depths of sexual deviance and depravity.

Again?

Geez, are you at it again with the proseletizing? Enough already, eh?

What really disgusts me is

What really disgusts me is that a no-talent like John Amaechi even made it to the league. That coulda been me, if only I were a foot taller. And gay.

I have a problem with peopl

I have a problem with people that call me homophobic for not voting for gay marriage or "basic legal rights" (Colorado's Ref. I). When I was in high school, people would say that they were agorophobic, arachnophobic, aquaphobic, and claustraphobic. These people had the living hell scared out of them if they came in contact with spiders, pools, confined spaces. They would scream and GET OUT OF THE WAY if that fear appeared.

Not once have I screamed, had the living hell scared out of me, or gotten out of the way of a gay person. I am in no way afraid of them, but that doesn't mean I approve of their way of life.

Since -phobic seems to be the new, hip suffix to call someone names, I've just decided to do the same thing: I call people smoke-ophobic that support tobacco taxes and smoking bans. Victory-ophobic if they oppose the Iraq war. Basically, if they disagree with YOUR viewpoint, tell them that they're (your viewpoint)-ophobic

Instead, let's let -phobic be used where it is meant to be used. People that are deathly afraid of something: like spiders, high places, and nancy pelosi.

News Alert

NEWS ALERT:  Natalie Maines has come out in defense of Tim Hardaway's freedom of speech.  SHe said, "I can understand how it must feel to just express your opinion and have the whole world be down on you." 

Sony Music Corporation said that, although they don't agree with what Mr. Hardaway said, they still believe in his right to say it.  In support of freedom of speech, they have asked the NBA to stop playing "We Will Rock You." which Sony owns the rights to.

Also, the Democrats proposed a "non-binding resolution" which would say they deplore the media asking questions, such as this, of any sports personality.  They also insisted that they support Mr. Hardaway's freedom of speech.

Finally, Presidential Aspirant Hillary Clinton said that she had heard of the incident and was looking into it.  She would have something to say on it next week.  Sources close to Mrs. Clinton say she probably didn't agree with Mr. Hardaway but needed to think about how she felt about Freedom of Speech, in this particular instance. 

NOT!

Pretty soon, nobody will be a

Pretty soon, nobody will be able to say anything derogatory about anyone, BY LAW. Certain groups are already in the works of calling this kind of language a "hate crime". Look into it if you havn't already. 1st Amendment has always been in danger. Kinda makes me depressed...

Agreed, MM. Once a group g

Agreed, MM. Once a group gains a certain amount of "acceptance", then anyone criticizing them is out on "the fringe." If gay "marriage" becomes legal, it will be considered bigoted, and possibly a "hate crime" to speak against it.

Hey, get a clue...

Man - some of you folks need to sit back and take a breath.

Newsflash - not all gay people are the "in your face, I demand" kind you see on TV. The majority want to be left alone to live their lives in peace like the rest of us. They are not out to "convert" straight men, abscond with our kids (the VAST majority of pedophiles are straight men), or otherwise interfere with your life or rights. I know a gay couple who have a better relationship than the majority of straight married couples I know. They aren't out screaming about being allowed to get married (as if that means anything). They both work hard, are great neighbors to everyone and anyone, and don't push their lifestyle on anyone.

The pushy, demanding ones you see and no doubt are afraid of are no different than the dimocrats of moveon.org and their ilk, the Earth Liberation Front wackos, and any other group of nutjobs who think their way should be your way.

Get over it, for crying out loud!

Saurus,There's no doubt that

Saurus,

There's no doubt that you're friends have spurred you're compassion for the topic. I'm confident that they are the norm not the exception. I too have friends that are gay. They are quality people. But doesn't tolerance work both ways? Are you positive that a certain percentage of the gay community doesn't share the bigotry of herosexuals in a mirror? Just because your buddy is gay, doesn't it ever cross your mind that what he stands for (in the way of a relationship) makes you feel uneasy? Remember, having ill feelings toward something doesn't mean that you're automatically wrong.

I couldn't agree more!! Libe

I couldn't agree more!! Liberal's automatically label us as "bigots" "homophobes" "gaybashers" etc. However, most of us are just stating our religious beliefs or moral standards. Do we not have a right to explain our position using our 1st Amendment right?

It all comes down to one thing: the left can SHOVEL IT but they can't TAKE it.

It seems to me there are seve

It seems to me there are several aspects to this story that have less to do with Amaechi’s admission, yet the MSM chose to typically ignore them:

1.  Amaechi was quoted in a newsprint article earlier in the week about how people use this issue for "political gain".  Yet clearly the timing of his own admission is for his financial gain, to promote the release of his new book.  Had Amaechi not been gay, it is unlikely that his new book would have generated any kind of interest, sales-wise, as reflections by a run-of-the-mill sports player rarely do.  Hence, Amaechi was hoping for exactly the kind of reaction supplied by Hardaway, in order to assist his own financial gain.  It is sad that no one in the MSM is willing to focus on this issue, exactly because of the nature of the issue itself.  When Pete Rose "confessed" to gambling at the same time of the publication of his 2005 book, many reviewers or media-types jumped on the issue of timing; in conclusion, there's less risk of prosecution by the MSM to cover issues associated with gambling than with homosexuality – perhaps their own bias got in the way.

2.  Hardaway represents one former NBA player out of thousands; the fact that his name is more recognizable than many is only a bonus.  When I read the above narrative of the ABC reporter (Berman), I was hoping for some attempt to find a greater reflection of opinion from a sports' population base than just one person.  However, for most in the media, it isn't really about creating a true reflection of opinion, when one will do just fine to create the controversy desired.  Hardaway's opinion could be a reflection of less than 1% or 10% or 50% of all athletes.  There may have been other athletes (such as the token second-hand quote from Shaquille O'Neal) who would or may have expressed contrarian opinions; however, the sound bite from those athletes clearly wouldn't generate the controversy desired, so the MSM continued to search until it got the one athlete's opinion it needed.

3.  Finally, it's hard to see what side the MSM was looking for in this story, as there was really nothing new, other than the "harshness" with which Hardaway spoke - even the choice of the word "secret" to describe the "prejudice" is an attempt to draw attention to a non-issue (because clearly if it was an issue, wouldn't there be an attempt at a solution?).  However, notwithstanding any feeling pro-or-con towards Amaechi for his personal life election, this story is simply one man selling himself for personal gain, and using a pre-determined high-anxiety issue to do so.  Perhaps next week Araechi can send Hardway a nice, thankful parting gift.  As said before by others, there's really nothing here - just move on (no pun intended).