Is hunger stalking the suburbs?
Yes, according to Newsweek's February 12 story "Poor Among Plenty -- For the first time, poverty shifts to the U.S. suburbs," by Peg Tyre and Matthew Philips. (How Newsweek managed to obtain a photo of the inside of my freezer is another story entirely.)
"Six years ago, Brian Lavelle moved out of the city of Cleveland to the nearby suburb of Lakewood for what he thought would be a better life. Back then, Lavelle, 38, was a forklift operator in a steel mill making $14 an hour. He had a house, a car and was saving for his retirement. Then, three years ago, the steel mill closed and Lavelle found that the life he dreamed of was just that, a dream. The suburbs, he quickly learned, are a tough place to live if you're poor. For starters, there isn't much of a safety net in his community. Food pantries, job-retraining centers and low-cost health clinics are hard to come by.
Story Continues Below Ad ↓He can't afford either gas or car insurance, and inadequate public transportation hurts him, too. Not long ago, he was offered a job in another suburb, 'but it just wasn't doable.' The commute by public bus would have taken him three hours each way.
"Once prized as leafy haven from the social ills of urban life, suburbs are now grappling with a new outbreak of an old problem: poverty. Currently, 38 million Americans live below the poverty line, which the federal government defines as an annual income of $20,000 or less for a family of four. But for the first time in history, more of America's poor are living in the suburbs than the cities -- 1.2 million more, according to a 2005 survey. 'The suburbs have reached a tipping point,' says Brookings Institution analyst Alan Berube, who compiled the data. For example, five years ago, a Hunger Network food pantry in Bedford Heights, a struggling suburb of Cleveland, served 50 families a month. Now more than 700 families depend on it for food."
That sort of questionable anecdote is reminiscent of the unfortunate misleading trend of media outlets (thankfully on the wane) of uncritically citing U.S. Conference of Mayors annual reports on hunger and homelessness, which, when taken cumulatively, claimed an utterly implausible 1240% increase of hunger in America over the 15-year period from 1987 to 2002.
Tyre and Philips insist:
"Suburban poverty can also be invisible. Poor people who live in the city tend to be concentrated in subsidized housing or in neighborhoods where the rent is low, which in turn attract retail businesses that target customers with low incomes. Poor suburbanites often live in the same ZIP codes as their affluent neighbors, shop at the same stores and send their children to the same public school. And if people don't see themselves as poor, they often don't seek the help they need."
Although the magazine admits many don't seek help, they paint the Democrats as saviors:
"Help appears to be on the way. The new Democratic majority in Congress is trying to make good on its promise to raise the minimum wage for the first time in 10 years. Bills upping the hourly rate from $5.15 to $7.25 by 2009 have passed both the House and the Senate. But analysts at the Economic Policy Institute, a D.C.-based think tank, say that while some 4.5 million suburbanites will benefit from a minimum-wage hike, it's not enough. 'It's not a living wage, it's a minimum wage,' says EPI senior economist Jared Bernstein, who says there's still a yawning gap between what people earn and what it costs to live that must be addressed."
Newsweek fails to mention the pro-labor liberal lean of EPI (no conservative sources are quoted in the article, just two liberal ones, EPI and the Brookings Institution).
Newsweek also ignores the fact that very few family supporters even earn the minimum wage, so raising it would hardly make a real dent anyway, even without the resulting job losses most economists predict. As Eduardo Porter reported in Sunday's New York Times, "The number of workers earning the minimum wage has shriveled in the United States. In 2005, fewer than 2 million people earned no more than the federal minimum wage, down from 4.4 million as recently as 1998."
—Clay Waters is the director of Times Watch, an MRC project tracking the New York Times.















Editor at Large

Comments Policy
I'm not poor and this looks l
February 8, 2007 - 15:37 ET by I am conservativeI'm not poor and this looks like my freezer...
What does being poor mean by having nothing in your ice box? Nothing....
I hate liberals...I really do...
Another thing that seems left
February 8, 2007 - 17:34 ET by Lemurian16Another thing that seems left out in this article is the fact that alot of suburban families are spending nearly 80% of their incomes on mortgages. Otherwise, Mr. Forklift driver would've moved closer to a new job or somewhere that has a lower cost of living. I love the liberal elitist groupthink that socialism will cure all of society's ills which is total hogwash.
And you're point would be?
February 8, 2007 - 17:50 ET by acaiguanaAnd you're point would be?
ACA
...
Hillary Clinton says: "I want to take those profits."
Freewill
February 9, 2007 - 06:03 ET by UnsaneI think he's saying that many people don't know how to budget or live within their means, and that when the chickens come home to roost and they find themselves unable to foot the bills, the first instinct is to whine to the government about how unfair and horrible it all is (when, with a little freewill, they could have avoided it all in the first place!).
And of course, the government is more than happy to oblige, instead of telling them to live within their means.
"HAV3 TH3 BRIDG3S OF INSANITY B33N CROSS3D AND FOR3V3R R3TRACT3D???." - Meshuggah, "3ntrapm3nt", from Catch Thirty Thr33 (2005)
Lemurian, I get your
February 9, 2007 - 12:57 ET by JoeBobLemurian,
I get your point, but your fact about "nearly 80% of their incomes on mortgages" is way off. Most lenders will not grant mortgages with payments greater than 35-40% of income and around 30% is closer to the average.
JoeBob
Without recognizing the ordinances of Heaven, it is impossible to be a superior man. - Confucious
Newsweek, and Mr.Lavelle - si
February 8, 2007 - 15:46 ET by truth_missileNewsweek, and Mr.Lavelle - six years ago I was making less than 14 bucks an hour. I hated it. I took a gamble and went back to school. It was hard to make ends meet, studying by day, working at night, studying some more when I got home. We incurred debt. So much that we had to move a couple of times, ending up in a small one room apartment for a year. When the dust settled, I graduated first in my class with a degree in Computer Science. Today as I write this, my salary is only inches away from six figures and we have a beautiful home with a well stocked fridge. More importantly, I control my future. In a nutshell, don't wait for a gubmint handout. Get off your ass and work to better your own life. This country is the greatest on earth and the true land of opportunity. I have to get back to work now.
Thank you.
He's gotta be poor - freezers
February 8, 2007 - 15:53 ET by FastEdHe's gotta be poor - freezers usually have some frost on the inside, so's I'm thinking there's no electricy in the house either. And, if there isn't enough money in the pay check, maybe the local taxes should go down. But, I've got to wonder, if things are SO bad, why is it that there are so many people breaking the law to work here, and if things are so bad, why don't some of these folks take back the jobs that they don't want. If this soesn't make sense, I'm trying to think like a lib, and now my head hurts.
There is no sense in being stupid, if you can't prove it! - my dad V
There's one upside
February 8, 2007 - 15:56 ET by tumbler_2007Gee, at least the guy isn't being attacked with a chunk of rebar in his slumber.
THAT'S POOR--
Are you referring to Urban Ca
February 8, 2007 - 16:14 ET by FastEdAre you referring to Urban Campers?
There is no sense in being stupid, if you can't prove it! - my dad V
yeah, them
February 8, 2007 - 16:18 ET by tumbler_2007You snooze you lose, Amigo. in San Diego County, anyhow.
newsweek hunger
February 8, 2007 - 15:55 ET by zoro7957Have'nt we been bombarded the last few years with the news that "America is overweight"? I wish these people would make up my mind.............
The MSM doesn't want you to m
February 8, 2007 - 18:17 ET by Scout FinchThe MSM doesn't want you to make up your mind. They want to supply you with conflicting information and keep you deliberately confused and more importantly, feeling guilty.
Interestingly enough, here in the northern Midwest, we've been hit by extremely cold temperatures. Schools were closed on Monday and Tuesday, supposedly so the little ones wouldn't freeze out in the cold waitng for a school bus. Nevermind that most parents have heated vehicles to drive children to school in. But then, word got around, thanks to a NYT article, about poor children attending school with no socks, hats, or gloves. This was the reason some parents thought schools should be closed when it's extremely closed. Really? I'd bet those kids who come to school with no socks, hats, or gloves have plenty of video games and toys at home, along with a mom and/or dad who smoke cigarettes, play the daily lottery, drink alchohol, and go out for fast food. I guess socks are a lower priority with some people.
He He, Clay, He He, $14 an hour and 38 years old.
February 8, 2007 - 15:57 ET by acaiguanaHe He, Clay, He He, $14 an hour and 38 years old.
If there was ever an argument for a 'living wage' I guess this is it, huh?
Let's see. At 38 he would have been out of High School twenty years ago.
That would make him a 1987 graduate. Schools have sure come a long way since then huh? I believe Public Education was crappy back then too.
In twenty years of working age life he makes $14 an hour. Pretty skilled guy, huh?
I on the other hand just bought a William Jefferson Freezer and it was delivered today. I'm having to rent a forklift just to carry the $90K bundles of cash it generates every thirty minutes or so. I'm leasing a new warehouse for the money, but until then I'm having to pay $15 an hour to drop outs with shotguns to protect the pile accumulating on my front lawn.
My wealth isn't invisible at the moment to my neighbors who have started a pretty big crowd and forced me to call the cops.
The governor says he might have to send in the National Guard if I don't find a bank with the staff capable of handling this kind of dough. Most of them are mumbling about vault size and too many $100 bills.
But, I'm sure it'll all work out.
ACA
...
Hillary Clinton says: "I want to take those profits."
Why not use the bales of cash
February 8, 2007 - 16:16 ET by FastEdWhy not use the bales of cash as "sand bags"? Multi-task the cash!
There is no sense in being stupid, if you can't prove it! - my dad V
If things are so bad, how com
February 8, 2007 - 16:02 ET by Clear thinkerIf things are so bad, how come we still have the fattest poor people in the world?
"'It's not a living wage
February 8, 2007 - 16:03 ET by MikeB"'It's not a living wage, it's a minimum wage,' says EPI senior economist Jared Bernstein." Jared, were your Econ professors Marxists? I have a news flash for you: even if you raised the minimum wage to $10,000 an hour, it still wouldn't be enough to live on, because all other wages and prices would rise also. One more time: a minimum wage increase makes unskilled labor too expensive, it devalues the currency, it makes American made products too expensive for foreigners, thereby increasing our trade deficits and eliminating American jobs. American based corporations will send more manufacturing jobs overseas in order to maintain their profitability. Look at the history of previous minimum wage increases.
"A communist is someone who reads Marx. An anti-communist is someone who understands Marx." Ronald Reagan
From the article:The suburb
February 8, 2007 - 16:10 ET by Dave in TexasFrom the article:
Wait a minute? So a family is in the middle of a difficult time financially that's existed for about two months, and Newsweek finds that sufficient to declare that they've "slipped into poverty".
I sympathize with the Pettry's situation, but I also have no doubt that if Newsweek revisited this couple a year from now (which they won't) most likely they would find that they rode it out, found new jobs (possibly after having to move), recovered and are now doing fine.
1240% increase in poverty?
February 8, 2007 - 16:14 ET by Gary Halla "...1240% increase of hunger in America over the 15-year period from 1987 to 2002."
Well, if that were true - it might have been worthwhile to mention that ole Bill Clinton was in charge from 1993 thru 2000 - or most of that period of time.
I wonder how many of the 700
February 8, 2007 - 16:20 ET by I am conservativeI wonder how many of the 700 families Newsweek is referring, are free-loaders??? I used to work for a food bank and so many people would come in with their SUV's to collect food it was ridiculous.
"I wonder how many of
February 8, 2007 - 18:01 ET by ckc1227"I wonder how many of the 700 families Newsweek is referring, are free-loaders??? I used to work for a food bank and so many people would come in with their SUV's to collect food it was ridiculous. "
And that's one economic fact that was conveniently left out of the piece: when folks find out you're giving things away for free, more people will come to get their share, whether they need it or not.
Liberalism is the philosophy of the stupid.
Clay, you and I must have the
February 8, 2007 - 16:23 ET by Dave RClay, you and I must have the same freezer.
We see these stories all the time around where I live. Funny, they never seem to mention one aspect that seems to be consistent in all of these stories:
If Mr. Forklift operator had bothered to avail himself of the educational opportunities that exist in this country, there is a pretty good chance that he would not have found himself in that situation.
I can empathize with the job loss, however, as on the morning of 9/11 I was working as a designer for a multi-national engineering outfit that had an office here in Atlanta. Unfortunately, one of their largest clients, The Port Authority of New York, representing twenty-five percent of their total corporate revenue, was essentially wiped out in the attack. The office closed within 6 months.
It took a month, but I managed to find an equivalent position at another engineering firm doing highway design. Due to the down-turn in the economy and unfortunately for me, our governor killed a huge highway bill that had been passed prior to the attack and I was layed-off yet again. It wasn’t easy, but I kept beating the bushes until I found another job. It got to the point where had I gotten an offer I would have jumped all over it.
The fact that our forklift operater refused a job offer says a great deal about him. You do what you have to do, even if the commute sucks, until you are in a position to do something else.
I hate newspapermen.....I regard them as spies.....If I killed them all there would be news from Hell before breakfast. -William T. Sherman
Yeah, Dave R., that line about 'turned down' a job did it for me
February 8, 2007 - 16:28 ET by acaiguanaYeah, Dave R., that line about 'turned down' a job did it for me.
That's your typical Liberal victim though. Had to turn down a job things were so bad.
ACA
...
Hillary Clinton says: "I want to take those profits."
Couldent take a job. Sounded
February 8, 2007 - 16:55 ET by bassndudeCouldent take a job. Sounded kinda, "I'm not that desperate yet!". In my world, but I live in reality, I have up-rooted my entie family, sold the house, moved to another state, just so I could have a job that paid me to feed my family and provide them a home to live in and schools to go to. Sounds to me like, he aint gonna work unless he has to.
Sell the house and move, you moron.
Save a SeAL, club a liberal!!
Newspeak "magazine"
February 8, 2007 - 16:30 ET by HumanEventsNewspeak "magazine". It's not a magazine, it's a rag. "Help appears to be on the way. The new Democratic majority in Congress.." You would never see them cite Republicans as being help.
And the reason the Demagogues will be the rescuers is because they want to raise the minimum wage? Not only will raising the minimum wage only do more harm than good, but how dare Newsweek "report" as if it's a given that raising the minimum wage is helpful.
Newsweak is the NewYorkTimes of magazines. Bottom of the barrel journalism; 100% biased for the Democrat party. What a disgrace purporting to be an objective news weekly.
Did they find any tv's, stere
February 8, 2007 - 16:36 ET by AntiMediaDid they find any tv's, stereos, or cell phones in the home.
Yeah they were right next to
February 8, 2007 - 16:45 ET by HumanEventsYeah they were right next to the dvd player. I wonder if the car(s) in the garage was as old as 2003?
Goldberg
February 8, 2007 - 17:27 ET by Dave PierreIn Bias, Bernard Goldberg remarked how these kind of stories always seem to creep up more often during Republican administrations.
For over a decade now, my cit
February 8, 2007 - 17:32 ET by mattmFor over a decade now, my city has been moving poor people (i.e. welfare recipients) from the inner city to subsidized housing in the suburbs. I assume that this is a nation-wide practice and is probably the biggest factor in this supposed trend.
I thought the story started g
February 8, 2007 - 17:34 ET by BruzillaI thought the story started going downhill as soon as I read "Lavelle, 38, was a forklift operator in a steel mill making $14 an hour." I think this story stinks worse than the rotting food in Lavelle's unfrosted freezer. I grew up in Pittsburgh so I know a few things about working in steel mills and how the unions and environmentalists had a LOT more to do with running big steel out of the country than any foreign competitor or ruthless corporation.
Lavelle was probably an employee at LTV Steel that closed down in 2001 after years of union issues, and after most investors were scared off by environmental liabilities and didn't want to invest in the plant. I think Lavelle's biggest problem (other than wasting away his life being the Al Bundy of the steel industry) is summed up by a news piece that 90.3FM WCPN did in 2001, which started "The idling of LTV Steel in December put more than 3,000 people in the Cleveland area out of work. That's a major blow to a city like Cleveland, which was already trying to cope with a regional manufacturing recession even before the national economic downturn became official." In short... if you're living in an area where work is becoming more and more scarce... MOVE! I hate hearing people whining about high costs of living, or low wages, in an area, but they refuse to move somewhere that working/living conditions are better.
Indeed, that is exactly why I
February 9, 2007 - 06:10 ET by UnsaneIndeed, that is exactly why I have been recently forced to move to Houston. But then, the great thing about TX is that in all likelihood, you won't have to leave the state to find work.
"HAV3 TH3 BRIDG3S OF INSANITY B33N CROSS3D AND FOR3V3R R3TRACT3D???." - Meshuggah, "3ntrapm3nt", from Catch Thirty Thr33 (2005)
Let's see.Mayor Frank G. Jack
February 8, 2007 - 17:50 ET by Al CzervikLet's see.
Mayor Frank G. Jackson - Democrat
Cuyahoga county - DOMINATED by Democrats
How is it that a Democrat congress is going to solve this? Sounds like more of the same "failed strategy" that got them into this mess in the first place.
I think we need an exit strategy and a date for withdrawal from Cleveland.
They are complaining more poo
February 8, 2007 - 18:06 ET by dscottThey are complaining more poor people live in the suburbs than the cities? Heck, we can solve this problem, round em up and send them by bus back to the city. Here's a novel approach, if you live in a high unemployment area move to where the jobs are. It wouldn't hurt if the politicians took a more business friendly position, so here's a second novel idea, vote out the tax and spenders.
“The object of life is not to be on the side of the majority but to escape finding oneself in the ranks of the insane.” – Marcus Aurelius
OH THAT PICTURE IS AWESOME!
February 9, 2007 - 00:10 ET by Chicago RepublicanOH THAT PICTURE IS AWESOME! Funny story, my wife and I both combined make a very good living, and our refridgerator looks just like that. We usually joke if HHS came to our house and we had kids, we'd be in jail and the kids would be in foster homes. Usually, you open our fridge and there's a case of Miller Lite and a block of chedder cheese. We work and commute into the city and just don't have time to shop/cook. But still, our fridge is pretty pathetic.
Peg Tyre & Matthew Phil
February 9, 2007 - 06:28 ET by sarcasmoPeg Tyre & Matthew Philips need to do some investigative reporting if they wish to use such biased terminology: What "job retraining center" that's funded by my taxe$ works better-than -- or hell, as-well-as -- just "going out and getting your next job"??? Obviously, the steel industry isn't the only one requiring forklift-operators, so that's probably where this guy should start his search IMO, but the idea of employment as a government-must-solve-it problem is distinctly-socialist, and far too often it goes unchallenged in the terminology journalists blithely-use. Like "job retraining center."
JMR