I'm feeling a lot of love out there. Directed by the MSM toward Joe Biden, that is, for having called Barack Obama the first "clean" and "articulate" black presidential candidate. Earlier this evening, as noted here, Chris Matthews, joined by MSMers Jay Carney and Anne Kornblut, cut Biden mucho slack.The forgive-a-thon continued on Countdown. First, Keith Olbermann declared Biden's comments "a slip." Washington Poster Dana Milbank then got into the evening's understanding zeitgeist, assuring us that "nobody sees Joe Biden as a racist."
Olbermann spun a theory that "the conservative media establishment" including "bloggers" who are "doing a lot of Biden bashing today" are motivated not by outrage over Biden's comments but by "a desire to inflict damage on a Democratic chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee."
View video here.
Please. How can Milbank possibly be so sure that Olbermann is "exactly" right? Has Dana interviewed a single member of that "conservative media establishment"? Speaking as one humble blogger, I can assure Keith and Dana that the notion of discrediting Biden as a Bush administration critic never crossed my mind. The thrust of my outrage is the hypocrisy of the MSM. What incites me is the MSM's willingness to so readily excuse Biden, whereas Olbermann and company would surely have had a field day excoriating the hapless Republican who made similar remarks.
And while I'm not calling Biden a racist, before totally letting him off the hook I'd be curious to know what he meant in calling Obama the first "clean" black presidential candidate.
UPDATE -- Kudos to ABC for its fair coverage of the flap on this evening's "World News". Charlie Gibson introduced the segment: "Delaware senator Joe Biden is the ninth Democrat to jump into the candidate pool. But tonight, he might be wishing for a do-over, after being accused of making a racially insensitive remark about a rival in his first day as an official candidate."
Senior national correspondent Jake Tapper took it from there, noting "Joe Biden hoped that launching his presidential campaign would bring headlines about his experience and gravitas. But he spent much of the day explaining comments he made to a news reporter about Senator Barack Obama, a rival for the nomination"
Tapper, focusing on what I consider the most controversial aspect of Biden's statement, said: "observers from both parties questioned what Biden meant, especially by the word 'clean.'"
Tapper then played a clip of Jesse Jackson saying Biden "should interpret what he meant by those loaded words," and even one of Rush Limbaugh observing "folks, this is the problem for the libs. Once they get off script, they expose their idiocy. They expose their prejudice."
Contact Mark at mark@gunhill.net
—Mark Finkelstein is a NewsBusters contributing editor and host of Right Angle. Contact him at mark@gunhill.net.




















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Mark, I see you caught a scre
January 31, 2007 - 20:59 ET by Roger the ShrubberMark, I see you caught a screen capture of Keefy with his "serious face". You know that face, right? Just pretend you are passing a kidney stone.
I've had enough of this one.
January 31, 2007 - 21:06 ET by tracheostomyI've had enough of this one. Who cherry picked Biden's statement anyway? You could tell someone was looking for some Macaca-payback here. This is just a retaliatory accusation. See prev. statement in prev. blog. I'm pretty hot about this.
-PJ
Draft Condi for '08!
This site is for the exposure
January 31, 2007 - 21:14 ET by saw the lightThis site is for the exposure of a liberal bias in the news media, not just a lively debating forum (which it often is). When this statement became known, most of us on the site were wondering how it would be spun, knowing the LSM would undoubtedly circle the wagons to protect Biden. The same LSM that did crucify Allen for the "macaca" comment or Trent Lott pandering to a retiring, elderly statesman.
I bet if this protection from the LSM doesn't work, they will say that he plagiarized the words from a Republican, most likely President Bush.
"People everywhere confuse what they read in newspapers with news." - A.J. Liebling
NO! This is manufactured bias
January 31, 2007 - 21:19 ET by tracheostomyNO! This is manufactured bias. Plain & simple.
1. Who was the first to "discover" the racism inherent in the Biden statement?
2. Where's the full text of the interview? All I heard on the radio today was the statement itself. I want the context.
3. Is this a slow bias day or something? Isn't there something better to go after? This is in no way equiv. to macaca. Someone is just hot for revenge and a WIARHSI rush to judgement.
Straighten up you guys!
-PJ
Draft Condi for '08!
I agree that it is manufactur
January 31, 2007 - 21:23 ET by saw the lightI agree that it is manufactured bias, but the manufacturers are Olbernutt, Chrissy Matthews, and their ilk who are excusing the comment by saying that they "know" that he is not a racist. How do they know that, and is that their job to divine what Biden meant to say? How about just telling us what was said and let us decide?
"People everywhere confuse what they read in newspapers with news." - A.J. Liebling
I want past quotes by Biden s
January 31, 2007 - 21:34 ET by tracheostomyI want past quotes by Biden stating evidence of clear racism. The statement in question is not clearly a racist statement and conservatives are clearly overreacting.
Which is of course, typical liberal behavior. We made the mistake of reading the tea-leaves too closely on this one. The best we could do with the quote is what Rush did with it. Absurd? Yes. Spun in favor of Obama? Yes. Racist? Geez, you wish; you guys are showing your cards.
Defame the liberal at all costs? Not at the cost of rationality.
Gah, I can't believe I'm defending Biden anyway, but I'm not doing it for him. Hope someone out there understands.
-PJ
Draft Condi for '08!
Maybe I misspoke. I am not
January 31, 2007 - 21:36 ET by saw the lightMaybe I misspoke. I am not saying the comment is racist. The reaction to a controversial comment is why I am objecting.
"People everywhere confuse what they read in newspapers with news." - A.J. Liebling
Naw, you are totally right 'cut throat'.
January 31, 2007 - 21:51 ET by acaiguanaNaw, you are totally right 'cut throat'.
I can't see the problem. Biden only said:
“I mean, you got the first mainstream African-American who is articulate and bright and clean and a nice-looking guy,” he said. “I mean, that’s a storybook, man.”
So, Obama is the...
first mainstream African-American who is articulate.
first mainstream African-American who is bright.
first mainstream African-American who is clean.
and...
first mainstream African-American who is a nice looking guy.
What's the big deal?
ACA
...
Acaiguana says: "I love blind Monkeys and any inference that I am making fun of blind Monkeys would be wrong.
It's the angle you took it fr
January 31, 2007 - 22:31 ET by tracheostomyIt's the angle you took it from. Read my other comments praising Rush to that effect. He didn't fall for the same trap as Hannity did.
And I don't mock allies ACA. You're better than that.
-PJ
Draft Condi for '08!
I couldn't resist. :-) ACA
January 31, 2007 - 22:34 ET by acaiguanaI couldn't resist. :-) ACA
I'm in that kind of mood today.
Had some real duds posting today and got my Irish going.
<edit> and I detest Joe Biden. <edit>
ACA
...
Acaiguana says: "I love blind Monkeys and any inference that I am making fun of blind Monkeys would be wrong.
lest we forget...
January 31, 2007 - 21:11 ET by DeepSouthFarRightJoe Biden's other "slips". Such as his "Delaware was a slave state" remark. Or his crack about Indian-Americans flowing into Delaware in such great numbers that you "can't go to a 7-11 or Dunkin Donuts without seeing one." Does plagiarism count as a "slip", too?
Links, please?-PJDraft Condi
January 31, 2007 - 21:36 ET by tracheostomyLinks, please?
-PJ
Draft Condi for '08!
Read Brent Baker's latest pos
January 31, 2007 - 21:37 ET by saw the lightRead Brent Baker's latest posting on NB's main page.
"People everywhere confuse what they read in newspapers with news." - A.J. Liebling
Rush had the better approach.
January 31, 2007 - 21:16 ET by tracheostomyRush had the better approach. Instead of zeroing in on the word "clean", he went after the word "first" in the statement to show the absurdity of Biden's quote.
But when it comes down to the level of parsing a singular word molehill in order to build up some kind of full blown scandal. . .I don't apprecate that from fellow conservatives. We're held to a higher standard and more dignified behavior than a bunch of waffling cut-n'-run hippies. So let's act like it.
-PJ
Draft Condi for '08!
which half is racist?
January 31, 2007 - 21:17 ET by James AnthonyOf course biden is a racist. He is calling ohamma an African American because of half his race. It's only HALF correct. olamma's moma was a white girl from Kansas and his daddy was a black man from Kenya. The man is half black AND half white, so isn't not recognizing both racist?
But biten is an idiot like everyone else on the hypenated American train!
Continents do not denote race, only country of origin.
biden went on to say that jesse jackson and al sharpton know what he means. So does that mean that two black men know what's it's like to be half white in bidens little world?
Does biden say that two white people he knows know what it's like to be half black?
See what happens when you're a coward and can't speak the TRUTH? Why do people keep electing these chicken sh*ts? It doesn't work, look at france!
If this was said by a Republi
January 31, 2007 - 21:24 ET by ZoneDaiatlasIf this was said by a Republican then Keith Olbermann would accuse the person as a Racist and name him "Worst Person of the Day"....
Oh, I agree. But that's becau
January 31, 2007 - 21:26 ET by tracheostomyOh, I agree. But that's because libs play dirty and try to "read between the lines", what. . .have we now sunk to their level?
Let's look for some macaca-payback somewhere else. M-kay?
-PJ
Draft Condi for '08!
naked racist
January 31, 2007 - 21:35 ET by James AnthonyThe man laid it out and now you want no one to pick it up? It's not degrading to use the same weapon against someone who uses it routinely against you. It's stupid not to. It sounds more like you're worried about something else.
Oh, please-please name that o
January 31, 2007 - 21:38 ET by tracheostomyOh, please-please name that one thing I'm worried about. See, you're speculating motive here. Not a good idear.
And no, as conservatives we don't have to sink to their level. Using their tactics makes us no better than they are.
-PJ
Draft Condi for '08!
closet door starts to open
January 31, 2007 - 21:46 ET by James AnthonyYou're worried that this will stick and hurt your hero. It's not making anything up. He said what he said and he meant what he meant. He's a racist and you're probably a liberal. The whole premise that owamma is a black is BS he's 1/2 & 1/2. By ignoring the non black half, bittin is racist. Same crap with harold the freak show ford. Or is that one of your latent causes too?
"Hurt my hero". . .
January 31, 2007 - 21:55 ET by tracheostomy"Hurt my hero". . .? Excuse me? Who?
Oh you just put really your foot in it without any help at all. My paper trail on this board speaks for itself.
-PJ
Draft Condi for '08!
you're excused...not
January 31, 2007 - 22:08 ET by James AnthonyIf it reads the way this page has so far with you not wanting anyone to put the screws to a traitor like biden, then what ever I stepped on was your tail.
There can be no effort that does not constitute utilization in turning this country away from the destruction that is on the horizon. If it takes nailing everyone of these sobs everysingle time on every single thing then that's what it takes. And if you have the illusion that playing fair or being nice is going to confront the level of what's going wrong with the people who are coming into power on the blood of our soldiers, then you are part of the problem.
Is it me or do these 2 guys l
January 31, 2007 - 21:39 ET by FishFace222Is it me or do these 2 guys look like they have feelings for each other?
no, it's you
January 31, 2007 - 21:55 ET by James AnthonyYeah, there's feelings. But probably not the kind you're hoping for.
The whole premis of what racism is and isn't is at the very heart of what I'm trying to get across. That's probably going to be more than you're comfortable thinking about since it involves some thought beyond being on one side or the other. Maybe after bin ladin is a firm power in the US via destroyed race relations it will freaking dawn on you that we are Americans first. Little late by then fishface.
I'm not sure what the hell yo
February 1, 2007 - 20:10 ET by FishFace222I'm not sure what the hell you are talking about. My comment was directed at Milbank and Olberman.
I wasn't going to comment --
January 31, 2007 - 22:25 ET by ucI wasn't going to comment -- by time I got to end of thread and remembered his Democratic role on Foreign Relations and remembered my support of President Bush limiting much of oratory and print to frequent use of "stay the course" I couldn't rightly not comment. This Biden sentence is just a "mess." Though the worst word in such combination of thought with "clean" (though maybe meant to be "clean-cut") is the use of "Mainstream." Does Biden mean the mainstream of African Americanism or does he harken to a more historic american mainstream that once excluded some? I hope he can claim he didn't write this comment and that it wasn't a natural off the cuff comment. Glad he isn't in charge of Domestic Relations, and, that President Bush only used "stay the course" for reasons Biden's word choice and order luminates.