NPR's Narrow Range of Warming Opinion: From Feinstein To Boxer

Photo of Tim Graham.
  • Bookmark and Share

With Democrats returning to power in the House and Senate, political reporters touched on how they felt abused and ignored during their time in the minority. But National Public Radio isn’t treating the Republicans now as a minority. They’re treating them as nonexistent in some stories. On Friday’s Morning Edition broadcast, reporter Elizabeth Shogren assembled an entire story on new Democratic proposals to halt global warming, but there were no Republicans, no energy industry representatives, and no warming skeptics. They only heard new socialist Sen. Bernie Sanders saying "one has got to be a moron" not to be concerned.

No one in the Shogren story was a "liberal" (not to mention a socialist – Sanders was merely described as "independent.") The proposed bills weren’t liberal either, just "aggressive." It was the Bernie Sanders-Barbara Boxer bill versus the Dianne Feinstein bill, which seemed conservative by comparison.

Renee Montagne, host: "Since Democrats took charge in Congress, global warming has become a hot topic. So hot, you might say that the House is creating a special new committee to highlight the problem and senators are introducing one climate change bill after another.NPR's Elizabeth Shogren has more."

Elizabeth Shogren: "For years, climate change has gotten a lukewarm hearing in Congress. But House Speaker Nancy Pelosi says that's changed."

Nancy Pelosi: "We have seen how important energy independence is to the American people, and the great concern that global warming is to them as well."

Shogren: "Yesterday, she took the unusual step of announcing a new select committee to focus on the issues. And she wants the House to vote on legislation by the Fourth of July."

Pelosi: "I'll promise to do everything in my power to achieve energy independence, and to do so within 10 years, and to stop global warming."

Shogren: "The Senate is engaging, too. Already senators have introduced three bills to slow greenhouse gas emissions. More are on the way."

Senator Bernie Sanders: "Well, I think any sane human being has got to be concerned about climate change. One has got to be a moron not to be."

Shogren: "Senator Bernie Sanders is an independent from Vermont. He's introduced the most aggressive new bill. He says there's one big reason climate change is getting so much attention."

Sanders: "You know what? It's increasingly becoming good politics. And a lot of people here in Congress who in the past may not have been so concerned about the issue are catching on that people back home want action, and I think they're going to be prepared to vote for strong legislation."

Shogren: "All three bills introduced so far aim to reduce the greenhouse gases emitted from burning fossil fuels. But they go at different paces and target different industries. Sanders' bill applies across the economy to vehicles, power plants and factories. It would cut emissions to 1990 levels by 2020, and then keep going. It has a powerful co-sponsor, California Senator Barbara Boxer.She chairs the committee that's responsible for drafting a bill. But many Democrats say the Sanders-Boxer approach is too abrupt and would harm the economy. Senator Tom Carper is a Democrat from Delaware."

Senator Tom Carper: "It's a little bit like driving a car down the highway at 55 miles an hour and put in reverse."

Shogren: "Carper is supporting another bill introduced this week. It was written by California's other Democratic senator, Dianne Feinstein. It focuses on the biggest human source of greenhouse gases - emissions of carbon dioxide, or CO2, from power plants."

Carper: "Our approach is to slow the car down, slow the growth of CO2 emissions. Stop the car, stop the growth of CO2 emissions. Then put the car on reverse, reduce CO2 emissions."

Shogren: "The Feinstein bill favors the electricity producers in her state. It would make it more expensive to burn coal, and very little of California's power comes from coal. Feinstein says it's important to reach out to industry."

Senator Dianne Feinstein: "What I've tried to do here is have a certain segment of the electricity sector be in support of it and hopefully be willing to lobby for it."

Shogren: " It's an early sign of the kind of jockeying that's sure to take place as Congress tries to tackle climate change. Elizabeth Shogren, NPR News, Washington."

—Tim Graham is Director of Media Analysis at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Cancel PBS!  These Elitist L

Cancel PBS!  These Elitist Lefties are on welfare! Cut 'em off!  If they can't make it on donations alone, too frickin' bad. 

Now is the time to fight PB

Now is the time to fight PBS and TheWeatherChannel.

We NEED (drum roll) FOX Climate. Tagline.... FAIR NOT CLOUDED !!!

Pelosi: "I'll promise

Pelosi: "I'll promise to do everything in my power to achieve energy
independence, and to do so within 10 years, and to stop global warming."

Gee, it sounds like Queen Nancy and the Democrats have lots of regulations in mind to reduce emissions, but where are their ideas on how to make the country energy-independent?

I'd love to hear them, since they are generally anti-drilling, anti-nuclear energy, anti-wind power etc. The only thing they seem to like is solar power, and I read somewhere that you would have to cover most of Illinois with solar panels just to supply Chicago with electricity....and wouldn't they just love the entire landscape covered in solar panels.....

Interesting too, that one of the first bills addresses coal-burning, which has little effect on California.......funny how that works out.

Hey. They've done a lot for e

Hey. They've done a lot for energy independence. Like drilling for oil in Anwar. Opps. Gotta protect caribo. Drilling in the Eastern gulf. Opps. Gotta peotect blue haired little old ladies. Hydro electricity. Opps. Gotta protect the snail darters and salmon. Wind mills. Opps. Blocks Ted's view, and it can hurt birds.

The very people who scream the loudest for alternative energy have done the most to stand in the way.

"The urge to save humanity is almost always a false front for the urge to rule.”   H.L. Mencken

This is going to cost us bi

This is going to cost us bigtime. If you haven't already, look at some other views of global warming. Here, here and here.

DSG

Want your elected reps to know what you think? Go to http://www.congress.org/congressorg/home/, it's real easy.

NPR liberals

Your TAX dollars hard at work. . .  More of that ‘unbiased’ fair and balanced reporting from NPR.

MSM: Arrogant intellectually dishonest LIBERALS teaching those stupid peasants how to vote by way of selective reporting, misinformation, propaganda, and out right lies.

i remember shogren at the la

i remember shogren at the la times.  i use to read that paper dailey.  i would just fume when i would read her "news" reports.  she is one of the major reasons i have not picked up an la times in almost 10 years.

Senator Tom Carper: "I

Senator Tom Carper: "It's a little bit like driving a car down the highway at 55 miles an hour and put in reverse."

How right you are, Senator. Know what happens when you slam a car into reverse at 55 mph? Well, *if* you don't blow up the engine you'll most certainly destroy the transmission and other parts of the drivetrain, scattering debris and oil all over the place. You're stuck on the side of the highway, hopefully uninjured, with a totalled car and no way to get home, and a big financial bill to pay.

Problem is, Senator, there's no "triple-A for the economy" to tow you to the "economy repair shop" when you play these silly, immature show-off games to impress your friends...

global warming

Maybe these non-scientists, pseudo-scientist and others of the "global warming is a fact and is the fault of humans" cabal...and, all of us should read what the real scientists in Japan, GB and elswhere have to say about global warming: Steve Milloy's web-ste, Junk Science, is a good place to start...Sorry, I forgot that for the idiots in the green/Left/Gore fantasy world, the old saw applies: I have my mind made up, stop confusing me with the facts.

Global warming is a lie and a

Global warming is a lie and a myth.

"Globalwarmingtology" is a pseudo-science of fact-mining and data-sifting to create misinformation and fear about regional, seasonal, and historical temperature variations. It's Bigfoot, Area 51, and the Loch Ness Monster all wrapped up into a nice little doom's day scenario that the MSM can market to the masses. There will be a sighting here and a sighting there, accusations of a government cover-up, and plenty of wackos to say "These things really DO exist!!", but it's still just smoke, mirrors, and theatrics.

For a good laugh on the varying insanities of global warming watch these South Park episodes :

http://www.southparkx.net/episodes/1006-manbearpig

http://www.southparkx.net/episodes/1002-smug-alert

http://www.southparkx.net/episodes/908-two-days-before-the-day-after-tomorrow

And get a bit torrent client here : http://www.bittorrent.com/download.html

And a Real Player here (to play the .ram files) : http://www.real.com/

Be sure to download the (RM) torrent and not the (AVI) ... it can take 30 minutes or more to get the .avi file (even though it will play in Windows Media Player).

Global warming : an oppositio

Global warming : an opposition of science falsely so called [falsely called science].

1 Timothy 6:20-21
(20) O Timothy, keep that which is committed to thy trust, avoiding profane and vain babblings, and oppositions of science falsely so called:
(21) Which some professing have erred concerning the faith. Grace be with thee. Amen.

"Global" warming is a false doctrine used to enact crippling economic legislation against the United States.

Global warmists ignore this key verse :

Psalms 47:9
The princes of the people are gathered together, even the people of the God of Abraham: FOR THE SHIELDS OF THE EARTH BELONG UNTO GOD: he is greatly exalted.

The "global warming" problem has already been taken care of by the 5 trillion trees on earth that remove carbon dioxide from the air, the 7 different 150 m.p.h. jet streams that circle the earth daily (and disperse emissions into space to levels of parts-per-trillion), and the existing FREE-MARKET legislation already in place.

God has already taken care of

God has already taken care of the "global" warming problem ...

He has put more than 5 trillion trees on earth that process and THRIVE on the carbon dioxide that global warmists CLAIM is turning the earth into a greenhouse ...

He has put 7 jetstreams above the earth that can dissipate into space any pollution, "greenhouse gas", or other "harmful" emissions that global warmists, Al Gore, or the U.N. can exaggerate into global catastrophe for Man ...

and He can alter the tilt of the earth or move it a couple of hundred thousand miles further away from the sun if it TRULY were a problem [why are glaciers GROWING in Canada and RECORD LOWS being set each year in Russia, Canada, Argentina, Australia, and Antarctica?].

Aliens, UFO's, the Loch Ness Monster, Bigfoot, and the Yeti just aren't enough ... apocalyptic wackos and conspiracy nuts need "global" warming in their quiver, too.

Remember Al Gore in "Ico

Remember Al Gore in "Iconvenient Truth"  choosing very small print when it came to part about admitting we have the technology to fix this environmental imbalance.

While trumpeting each insta

While trumpeting each instance of a warmer year, or day, or whatever, the global-warming advocates conveniently ignore that Seattle had its coldest January, or Saskatchewan set a record for low temperature, or the ice caps are actually getting thicker in some places, any data that doesn't fit the template.

So, in order to cover all the bases, I have heard the theory that random colder temps can also be part of global warming (pay no attention to that man behind the curtain!!!). And finally, to stop people from bringing up thost pesky facts that don't conform to the warming theory, there is the switch from "global warming" to "climate change"....as if earth's climate has been constant since the creation (or however one thinks the earth came to be), until recently, when we started screwing it up.