John Gibson and Danny Bonaduce Slam Alec Baldwin and Robert Redford

Photo of Noel Sheppard.

NewsBusters fans are certainly aware that former Partridge Family member Danny Bonaduce is a highly outspoken conservative that doesn’t mince words as reported here and here. On Friday, Bonaduce was John Gibson’s guest on Fox News’s “The Big Story,” and the pair took issue with the following statements recently made by Robert Redford (video available here courtesy of our friend at Ms Underestimated):

ROBERT REDFORD, ACTOR/DIRECTOR: In light of what's happened in the last six years, political diversity has been attempted to be thwarted, and we have kept it alive here. We have nodded here to any of the snuffing attempts that have come from the administration.

I think anybody with a rational mind, with a sense of decency, is being positioned as a lefty by the behavior of the extreme right.

Gibson was first up to take swings at this piñata:

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

As I see it, open and shut case, case closed, Hollywood is far left. People have been saying all along that Hollywood is one big left-wing propaganda machine, using their movies to tout their politics. Now Redford is actually admitting it. What took him so long?

[…]

Now, Danny, the deal about this that I think is interesting, is that we have all known that Barbra Streisand and a whole bunch of other Hollywood people are left-wingers, but this guy controls the gate, the door into the movie business for a lot of young people. Didn't he just give them their marching orders? You want to be in Sundance, make sure you do this kind of film?

Bonaduce took the bat, and predictably swung even harder:

Yes, he did. That's a very good point. That's exactly what he did. But what he also did was just so self- serving, when he said these movies are made like -- to make you make this kind of a decision, but we don't do that here.

You know what? At my house, I'm going to go lower my American flag and put up a statue of Robert Redford for reminding me I'm an American. I will tell you what, Robert, you can make any kind of movie you want. And if you have got the nine bucks, you can go see it and make a decision for yourself.

And as much as I admire Robert Redford -- because I love him -- I can make up my own mind.

Gibson then made a salient point that seemed lost in Redford’s remarks: “The thing that's curious to me, Danny, is he says that somebody was trying to squelch political speaking out. I haven't noticed any shortage of it among the liberals who make entertainment.”

Bonaduce agreed:

I have noticed -- I have noticed actually more of it. And first of all, if somebody owes America an apology, it is Robert Redford for "Legal Eagles" with Demi Moore. But let me just tell you right now, these people, the actors drive me insane. Alec Baldwin, who I used to worry about because I think he was a brilliant actor and he was so handsome, I didn't think he would get the credit he deserved. And then he blew up like Brando, and I had to stop worrying.

But didn't he promise to leave this country if President Bush was elected? Well, I have got a Ryder truck outside, and I will pack you myself. I am so sick of everybody making these giant political statements, but nobody does anything. President Bush may not be popular for sending young men off to war, but things need to be done, and movie stars just talk about it.

Gibson then asked a Hollywoodan what causes this delirium in most Hollywoodans:

Well, what is it about the -- about the culture that you live in out there, the air that you breathe out there, that you have got to be left? That being a -- somebody who might support the war, might support the president or might have thought it was a good idea is just a doofus or worse?

Bonaduce responded:

Or worse. You could really, really injure yourself, because especially in a time of war, which is, by the way, the reason I voted for Bush twice, because I didn't think we should unseat a president during a time of war.

If I worried about my business life, you know, I have never been real rich, but I have been real poor, which makes me OK for the rest of my life now and I'm not afraid of these guys. And the fact that if Barbra Streisand thinks she can keep me out of work or Steven Spielberg thinks he can keep me out of work because I believe in America, I would rather be out of work.

Gibson asked another marvelous question: “Is that the punishment for expressing a view that's out of step?”

Bonaduce answered:

Now, that, to be honest with you, I don't know, because I feel very privileged and I feel very lucky, and I say what's on my mind all the time. I never pull punches. When I see these actors go on and say things -- and not just actors. Singers like -- I think like the Dixie Chicks, for example. If they want to say they are embarrassed that Bush comes from Texas in Texas, OK, because that's covered by the First Amendment. But you don't do it on foreign soil. That's this close to treason, as far as I'm concerned.

Though clearly infrequent, isn't it refreshing to hear sanity emanating from this bastion of lunacy?

—Noel Sheppard is the Associate Editor of NewsBusters.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

But didn't he promise to le

But didn't he promise to leave this country if President Bush was elected? Well, I have got a Ryder truck outside, and I will pack you myself. I am so sick of everybody making these giant political statements, but nobody does anything. President Bush may not be popular for sending young men off to war, but things need to be done,
and movie stars just talk about it.

I like this guy. Bush has a plan, the dems do not, and he realizes it.

JDW

Kerry: "You know, education, if you make the most of it ... you can do well. If you don't, you get stuck in Iraq."

Where are the follow-up quest

Where are the follow-up questions for Mr. Rednyet?

1) How has political diversity been thwarted?

2) Name the 'snuffing attempts' from the administration!

Never happen. Just like that old CNN Live show with Judy Woodruff years ago.

In 1996, when it was popular for the MSM to hate Gingrich, she asked a young female audience member who did she dislike the most in politics? The answer was, predictably, "GINGRICH!"

Then Judy did something she probably was repremanded for later. She actually asked this lib a follow-up question: "Why do you dislike Gingrich so much?"

The answer?

"Daaaaaaaaaa. Ahhhhhhh . . .I just hate him!"

I gave a hungry man a fish. I did not encourage him to catch his own fish, for then, he would not need me! - Old liberal proclamation

The elephant man is in NY,

You're dreaming.

JDW

Kerry: "You know, education, if you make the most of it ... you can do well. If you don't, you get stuck in Iraq."

Nothing like good Hollywood w

Nothing like good Hollywood writing.  Oh, the days I have heard talked about of Reagan films.  Oh, no wait, what is going on here >> I thought Democrats disdained actors as qualified to be President - even if they had led a union and been a Governor???  Have you heard that Obama has option from Hollywood to save alot of money with their efforts by cutting down on speaking rolls and grouping him with Hillary >> If they get to cast one as Sodom and the other as Gomora then speaking rolls can be avoided and imagery can directly get to message.  One "Ill-o-knows" (Illlonois) and our "empire state" (New York) candidates literary/historical/biblical lesson we shouldn't forget.  They bring it to mind for some reason - not, for the record, my regular concerns about most of America.

Bonaduce

What sets Bonaduce apart is that he is intelligent, logical, thoughtful, and patriotic. I love his remark about once being poor and therefore appreciating what you have. How different from so many spoiled ignoramuses in Hollywood. I never liked this guy--boy was I wrong. 

NEVER,NEVER trust a liberal

Hollywood "culture"

I saw, what's that guys name, oh yea, Glenn Beck interview Bonaduce and the subject of Hollywood "culture" came up.  Bonaduce said, 'My graduating class was me, Christian Brando, and Micheal Jackson.  I'm the most well adjusted one, just think about that for a minute'.   And Bonaduce with all of his alcholism and addiction is still one of the sanest people in Hollywood, just to put all of Hollywood in perspective.  And there is absolutely, positively no doubt that he is one of the most intelligent personalities in Hollywood.  Having said that, he knows he has problems.  I guess just admitting that you have problems in Hollywood puts you in a very elite group in terms of self-awareness.

The Hollyweed folks say they

The Hollyweed folks say they have the right to say stupid things, as did the Dixie Chick. Which they do. They can be as stupid or as mean as they wish.

Then whine when we tell them what we think of them. Or decide not to support them.

They feel we have an obligation to listen to them and keep them rich.

Arrogant a----.

"The urge to save humanity is almost always a false front for the urge to rule.”   H.L. Mencken

Another conservative in holly

Another conservative in hollywood? How many is that now five?

Thank you Gibby and Danny.

Thank you Gibby and Danny. What is Danny Bonaduce up to now? Is he getting another radio show?

(I wish Mark Steyn would get a show on Fox, replace Greta with Steyn with maybe Victor Davis Hanson or something.

Maybe it is just me.)
WhatAMaroon

Go Danny, I thought he was nu

Go Danny, I thought he was nuts but maybe we're all just asleep at the wheel.

So Danny Bonaduce is the new

So Danny Bonaduce is the new champion of the conservative movement? Solid choice.

Liberals

Those who preach tolerance and diversity cannot tolerate diversity thaat does not fit their narrow definition. Eveything else is labled hate.

Remember, Mulligan  - Divers

Remember, Mulligan  - Diversity to the Left is a room full of various racial and sexual minorities all pontificating on the virtues of Marxism.

Balboa

B,

Good morning. I think you need some coffee. :-)

C'mon, B, that's pretty facile, dontcha think? Do you believe that conservatives recognizing these statements of Danny's makes him our champion? With significantly more high-profile conservatives like Rush, Sean, Ann, Michelle, Mark, Mark, Hugh, Neal, etc., etc. out there?

C'monnnnnn.  ns

I just think it's funny that

I just think it's funny that you are willing to post an article about statements from Bonaduce, as if he's any king of expert on anything other than career nose dives, while you're willing to bash Clooney, Damon, etc., for the exact same thing.

Balboa

B,

First, I am here specifically to make you laugh. As such, I'm thrilled to be succeeding.

That said, I find it funny that you don't see a difference between an actor commenting about foreign policy and an actor commenting about statements made by another actor. After all, it seems to be more likely that an actor will have a more valid opinion concerning others in his industry than about geopolitics.

With all due respect given your high position as one of the resident sane liberals at NB, why does this seemingly obvious distinction elude you?  ns

That said, I find it funny th

That said, I find it funny that you don't see a difference between an actor commenting about foreign policy and an actor commenting about statements made by another actor. After all, it seems to be more likely that an actor will have a more valid opinion concerning others in his industry than about geopolitics

Good point. But I wouldn't put a lot of stock into what The Duce has to say. That's just me.

John Gibson and Danny

That's all right, speaking for myself, I don't put any stock into anything a liberal (communist, marxist, socialist ) say either.

What's good for the goose is just as good for the swan too.

Public image trumps substance

 Balboa wrote:

"But I wouldn't put a lot of stock into what the Duce has to say.  That's just me."

It's good of you to admit that.  So you are saying that if a person makes a logical and well-reasoned argument, you are happy to disregard it on the basis of that person's public image.  You're brave to admit it. 

If Cindy Sheehan were ever to speak truth or display insight in one of her arguments, my belief that she is a hopeless mess would not make it any less true or insightful.  But that's just me.

I agree with Bal on this one.

I agree with Bal on this one. I hold Bonaduce in the same regard as I do Matt Damon, Alec Baldwin, Sean Penn, Flava-Flav, or the guy who played Nick Tortelli on "Cheers". They all amount to nothing. Alot of my Conservative friends on this board cheer on D-level "celebrities" like Bonaduce only because their opinions agree. They are no different than the Libs who cheer on Ben Affleck, even though Affleck makes little sense.

That being said, Conservative Hollywood-types are a rarity (at least the ones 'out of the closet'), so I can see why people would be interested in seeing such an oddity, regardless of celebrity status.

Rog

People should be warned: A conservative is about to publicly disagree with a fellow conservative. Despite suggestions by folks on the left, this will not result in an epic calamity. So, everyone relax.

Rog,

I don't agree. Something that you're missing is that many baby boomers that grew up with the Partridge Family LOVED this character. If you recall, this was the brains of the outfit. As such, for conservatives my age, his current political gravitas if you will is just an extension of the cocky, red-headed and freckled kid we loved thirty years ago. This makes it extra special when he goes off on liberal Hollywoodans.

Furthermore, as you said, an outspoken conservative Hollywoodan is almost as rare as an honest Democrat. So, how can we NOT be fascinated by it?   ns

I'd say any "LOVED&quo

I'd say any "LOVED" was reserved for Danny's uber-hot fake sisters, in my case...
JMR

Noel,I am a child of the 70's

Noel,

I am a child of the 70's. I remember both, er, all the good times. I also remember Bonaduce beating up transvestite hookers and being a total loser. I do not really consider him to be someone to prop up as a spokesperson for American Conservatives, just like I laugh at the thought of Ben Affleck representing the Left.

Warning "token Neo-con ad-hominem attack" alert: 

Noel, me say to you that you must like sheep, since your last name is Sheppard. :P

*cue rimshot, bow and exit stage left*

j/k. I agree with your points too. I guess I am pretty 50/50 on this topic. Sorry about the "sheep" comment. My rabid Noe-conservatism must have taken control of my typing hands.

Rog

Rog,

Can you imagine the chiding I took as a kid with the name "Noel Sheppard?" In particular, one very large neighbor who had been left back once and, as a result, was bigger than everyone else always called me simply "Sheep-herder." BTW: I always thought he was a liberal!  :-)

I actually didn't follow any of the tawdry events in Danny's life. I'm one of those rare Americans that isn't at all interested in reading about the seedy side of Hollywoodans.   ns 

Noel, how dare you not be interested in an 'actor's life'

Noel, how dare you not be interested in an 'actor's life'.

As you can imagine, I'm exposed to these idiots more than I can say.

Hilaire Bellock

ACA

...

Acaiguana says:  "I love blind Monkeys and any inference that I am making fun of blind Monkeys would be wrong.

ACA

ACA,

You are correct. I'll do better in the future.

That said, why Hilaire Belloc? Are you referring to his debate with H.G. Wells?  ns

Naw, Noel, I was thinking of this poem.

Naw, Noel, I was thinking of this poem.

Young Algernon, the doctor's son,

was playing with a loaded gun.

He pointed it toward his sister,

aimed very carefully,

but Missed Her!

His father, who was standing near,

The loud explosion chanced to hear,

And reprimanded Alegernon,

For playing with a Loaded Gun.

HB

ACA

...

Acaiguana says:  "I love blind Monkeys and any inference that I am making fun of blind Monkeys would be wrong.

Actually, Bal

Actually, Bal--I had hoped that you would have an Epiphany and become our Conservative champion. Alas, in spite of your courteous discourses, I fear you are doomed to eternal liberalism.

Liberal

MB:

Bal's a liberal. Look at the illogical conclusion he just reached. 

NEVER,NEVER trust a liberal

You can trust a liberal, you

You can trust a liberal, you just can't trust them to do the right thing.

Come on, Bal - you guys have

Come on, Bal - you guys have people like Cher and Matt Damon as your celebrity mouthpieces, so there isn't a lot of room for criticism.  Oh, and Christy Brinkley and her brilliant suggestion to Laurie David that I should paint the roof of my house white to combat Global Warming.  The roofer's coming to my house later this week, I'll talk to him about that, see what my options are......

Oh, and Christy Brinkley an

Oh, and Christy Brinkley and her brilliant suggestion to Laurie David that I should paint the roof of my house

I'd like to paint giant bullseye on Laurie David's roof, and invite the USAF in for target practice.

Proud member of the all-powerful and vast militarist/industrialist/capitalist/zionist-bagelist complex

Now, Jack, I expect people li

Now, Jack, I expect people like you to rise above advocating violence against other Americans, even if they are blithering dumkopfs.

Chicago -- dummy bombs only

Chicago -- dummy bombs only, for dummies, of course.

Proud member of the all-powerful and vast militarist/industrialist/capitalist/zionist-bagelist complex

Now, Jack, I expect people li

*For all your energy needs, shop Exxon Mobil.  Exxon Mobil - providing fuel and tax revenue for the hardworking American and the spend happy Democrat, respectively.  

(apologies - computer error - duplicate entry - computer froze). 

Anything pertinent to say abo

Anything pertinent to say about what he's saying? 

It's not about who is or who is not a "champion" of the conservative "movement", it's merely a discussion about the Hollywood culture and its narrow-minded anti-anything-not-ultra-liberal bigotry. 

Talk about a "solid choice" as a "champion" for a movement: how about Michael Moore, Barbara Streisand, Alce Baldwin...are they your "champions"?  Solid choices....

I was being ironic. Moore et

I was being ironic. Moore et al aren't the left's champions anymore than Bonaduce's is the right's.

Balboa

B,

Really? Then why was he prominently seated in the VIP box at the 2004 Democratic presidential convention right next to Jimmy Carter? Do you envision Bonaduce being so honored at the 2008 Republican convention?  ns

In addition to Moore getting

In addition to Moore's being treated as a "Guest of Honor" at the Dem Convention, he also received a standing ovation when he won the prestigious Palme D'Or award at the Cannes Film Festival-the first "documentary" to win that award in nearly 50 years. And later in 2004 when he screened F-911 at the American Rennaisance Film Fest in Dallas, he received a 10 minute standing ovation there.

All of those people clapping were right wingers, I'm sure!

John Gibson and Danny

You think Danny saying all this just so he could get a VIP seat at the Republican Convention? I think he's going to be disappointed if it's another blue-blood country club Republican.

God bless the Peacemakers.

OK, bad example. Damn you, S

OK, bad example.

Damn you, Sheppard. You and your damn, dirty valid points.

Gibsons point about the Enter

Gibsons point about the Entertainment Industry never being silenced despite its incessant claim of this kind of political censorship is a very good one.  Look at some of the movies Hollywood has cranked out in the last five years (Fehrenheit 911), the comments made by musicians (Kanye West's idiotic dig about "Bush not caring about black people) and books published (about how one could assassinate Bush).  Try to show me one instance where Bush tried to use the power of his office to silence these people?  He just doesn't do it.  Those of us Right-of-Center just engage them in the arena of ideas or laugh at them.  The Left, not just in Hollywood, but especially in Academia, tries to silence its critics with the very censorship of which it accuses us of.  I remember Dinesh D'Souza talking about being at a major University to give an address.  A woman came running up screaming "get this man of the stage!"  As security drug her away she screamed "I'm being censored!" 

A lot of folks say the administration should press charges of treason against the New York Times for its various leaks of classified information.  While there is certainly legal standing for such a move, I have to say I like the fact that Bush does NOTHING to use force of law to silence his critics.  That way, he makes people like Redford and Sean Penn look like idiots for making this charge.

Wow! this is great, Hillary's

Wow! this is great, Hillary's announcement for candidacy "honeymoon" is already over.  I do hope the womans movement doesn't take the blow that not having other women get into this race would cause.  There must be atleast one other woman that wants to be first female president?  American history and hollywood writers could do much better than "Hill of Rodsham," like, "Bill the Rich." of New Mexico >> much more straight to the point and politically open.  "Laurals of Bush" against "Hill of Rodsham" except for natural objections to "W" not having to move out of White House for one of them my raise - would make much more interesting scripting.  Hillary why did you flee the south, why did you flee the often self-described bible belt?  Did you after being first lady of the ark use the north star to get you out of the south?  Barrack feel free to repeat this question >> all american deserve and answer/explanation for her carpetbagging.  Anyone remember Steve Martin's movie "All of Me"? 

go to sundance utah.  see wh

go to sundance utah.  see what a wonderful thing robert (i have mine but you can't have yours) redford has created in the mountains.  ask him about the ecological damage done by his festival and development.  asked about the drugs and prostitution he brings to the mountains.  ask about the damage to the wildlife and forest.  ask about the 6 lane freeway cut though beautiful forests and along a beautiful natural river to get to his sundance.

he is the scum of the earth.  he is a liar, a cheat, a man with dilusions of granduer, a serial adulterer, a drug user and a fake.  he is a high school drop out.  he is on the take from george soros.

few lumber companies have done more damage to the forest than redford has done.

Ask him about the $35.00 park

Ask him about the $35.00 parking while your askin'

Ask him about the $35.00 park

Ask him about the $35.00 parking while your askin'

First, where did you get thes

First, where did you get these facts?

Who cares?Redford is a horses

Who cares?

Redford is a horses rear end period, I do not care one way or the other, he is and always has been for years an over-blown, self-absorbed pretty boy. May have gone down in history with some admiration from the masses, but he had to open his yap and prove what a socialistic idiot he is.

"If we ever forget that we are a Nation Under God....then we will be a Nation Gone Under."  Ronald Reagan

Well, that's just a lot to bl

Well, that's just a lot to blame Redford for, and I'm just wondering where buddy's getting his info, how accurate it is, etc.

Bt, as rarely as I agree with

Bt, as rarely as I agree with balboa about anything, he asks a reasonable question.  This site is about media bias, and we give the LibMedia all sorts of hell when we catch them lying or being inaccurate then stonewalling about a correction.  What was said about Redford is completely plausible, but these accusations should be backed up with citations or links.

Bal, at least, has never accused someone of "hate speech" when citing true and valid statistics, nor has he referred to someone as a "dufus" when making true statements that are verifiable about a country.  Your "who cares?" was a bit cavalier.

"A communist is someone who reads Marx.  An anti-communist is someone who understands Marx."  Ronald Reagan

Excuse me for being cavalier.

Excuse me for being cavalier.

Some days are like that...some aren't.

Glad you brought that to my attention MikeB.

Redford is still a horses arse.

"If we ever forget that we are a Nation Under God....then we will be a Nation Gone Under."  Ronald Reagan

Excuse me for being cavalie

Excuse me for being cavalier.

That's okay BT, I'm a Roundhead!

For those not familiar with the opposing sides in the English Civil War, the Cavaliers were the Royalists supporters of Charles the first; while the Roundheads had Parliamentary and Republican tendencies!

Proud member of the all-powerful and vast militarist/industrialist/capitalist/zionist-bagelist complex

Huh...I... did not know that.

Huh...I... did not know that.

Is that where UVA and the Cleveland NBA team got it?

Well, many of the Puritans

Well, many of the Puritans who sailed across the pond were from the same stock as the Roundheads.

The term derived from their closely cropped hair, unlike the ringlets and tights favored by the cavaliers!

Proud member of the all-powerful and vast militarist/industrialist/capitalist/zionist-bagelist complex

Me either boa...I learn somet

Me either boa...

I learn something from ya every time ya post Jack!

Thanks!

Btw...does that make me bad? Referring to being Cavalier that is....

LOL!

"If we ever forget that we are a Nation Under God....then we will be a Nation Gone Under."  Ronald Reagan

BT --As I mentioned , the C

BT --

As I mentioned , the Cavs favored makeup, ringleted hair, and tights.

And that was just the men.

Politically, unless you yearn for a restoration of the British monarchy, you would definitely be a Roundhead!

Proud member of the all-powerful and vast militarist/industrialist/capitalist/zionist-bagelist complex

Whew!I'm safe! Had me worried

Whew!

I'm safe! Had me worried there for a sec Jack!

Glad you know me so well!

Roundhead I'm proud to be!

"If we ever forget that we are a Nation Under God....then we will be a Nation Gone Under."  Ronald Reagan

John Gibson and Danny

Hey now it's kind of too much to include being a high school drop out as one of his vices. There's a lot of fine people who dropped out of high school and made something of their lives.

There's more to illegal immigration than the guy mowing the grass for five dollars.

ROBERT REDFORD, ACTOR/DIRECTO

ROBERT REDFORD, ACTOR/DIRECTOR: In light of what's happened in the last six years, political diversity has been attempted to be thwarted,

THWARTED!

THWARTED!?

Surely you jest!

He and all his ilk just prove the left are insane.

What world do they live in...it certainly isn't the real one.

Earth to Redford...Earth to Redford!

"If we ever forget that we are a Nation Under God....then we will be a Nation Gone Under."  Ronald Reagan

No Balboa- he isn't an expert

No Balboa- he isn't an expert- he just shows common sense core American values (Talking about his political views, not his own life's choices) which the folks you mentioned do not (the one core value exception perhaps being the right for them to freely act like idiots in public saying the most assinine things - levelling the most rediculous accusations toward the administration of course) 

http://sacredscoop.com

I've always loved the word &q

I've always loved the word "thwart"; it makes me chuckle when people try and over-annunciate it.  That's another childish issue though...

I categorize Redford's comments no different than those of recent academia wingnuts (Duke's Group of 88) or MSM elitists (pick one).  All groups are simply not used to being called-out or forced to backup their statements.  They have grown accustomed to the furious sounds of pencils scratching on paper as we commoners try and record their every word as gospel.  Who are we to question their sovereignty?

In the eyes of the political diverse, I'm sure they feel as if their voices are being thwarted.  However, whereas historically they have shouted their diatribes and dribble into a canyon with no echo, now their words are coming back to them.  Apparently they don't like the sounds of their own voices when it returns.

Simply put, Redford has mischaracterized opposition as suppression.