Matthews the Non-Liberal Says Surge Goal Is 'Ethnic Cleansing' [Video]

Photo of Mark Finkelstein.
  • Bookmark and Share

As everyone knows and Andrea Mitchell has confirmed, Chris Matthews is no liberal. Don't let the fact that he describes the goal of the impending Iraq surge as "ethnic cleansing" fool you.

Matthews discussed the impending surge into Baghdad on this evening's Hardball with David Ignatius of the Washington Post and Gary Berntsen, the former CIA field commander for the agency's Jawbreaker team at Tora Bora.

Said Matthews, speaking of the role of US troops:

"If they are forced to do patrol duty in the streets of the Sunni areas where they are expected to basically be part of the ethnic cleansing because they will be shooting at Sunnis, they are going to get shot back at."

See video here.

Ethnic cleansing of Sunnis? The essence of the surge strategy is that the joint US/Iraqi force will be going into all neighborhoods, specifically including Shia neighborhoods such as Sadr City controlled by the eponymous Moktada.

But "ethnic cleansing" has such a nice ring to it. For non-liberals like Chris, that is.

Mark was in Iraq in November. Contact him at mark@gunhill.net


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

All you guys are watching '

All you guys are watching '24' rather than reading this, aren't you? That's OK. Guess what? Based on all your recommendations I'm watching '24' for the first time ever tonight! Don't really know what's going on but finding it entertaining.

Bishop's wife from "Mil

Bishop's wife from "Millennium", the kid from "Sky High", Kumar, and the doctor from "Deep Space Nine" are no replacement for the ultra-hot Elisha Cuthbert...

This season has been a little disappointing so far.... Bummer.

Holy crap. I take that back.

Holy crap. I take that back.  Holy crap.

Incredible.

YOWZA!!

Daaaaaaamnnn She is Ssssmokin hot.. Whew! DAMN! I definitely need to start watching that show. Killing extremists AND t*tties? Hot damn!

Not all Muslims are Terrorists.  However, all the Terrorists have been Muslim. 

You forgot the number crumche

You forgot the number cruncher from Numb3rs....

Please make sure your train of thought carries freight.

Pustule

That screen shot kept shouting something at me but I couldn't exactly place it.  Then eureka!  His head reminds me of a swollen boil that needs to be lanced.

Is Chris trying to marginalize himself to below Olbermann?

Is Chris trying to marginalize himself to below Olbermann?

That's how he does it huh?  Just throws out these little gems with enough context that the guy answering never gets around to addressing the silly 'ethnic cleansing' comment?

Thank goodness no one watches this stuff.

...

Acaiguana says:  "I love blind Monkeys and any inference that I am making fun of blind Monkeys would be wrong.

"Just throws out these

"Just throws out these little gems with enough context that the guy
answering never gets around to addressing the silly 'ethnic cleansing'
comment?"

I think you nailed it. It was, as you say, just thrown out there, not really inviting a comment on the substance, just a little nasty dig. Still, if I had been there I would have immediately called him on it.

Chrissy Sissy Unbelievable

You know, Chrissy Sissy, your grasp of military strategy is amazing. If we shoot at the Sunnis then we're ethnic cleansing. How are we supposed to react when the Sunni militants, terrorists, and militias are shooting at us? What's to be done when they're shooting and killing Shia? Just let it be? Yet another liberal presuming to know the situation on the ground when in fact he's an empty suit full of empty ideas. What next? Will he become a talent judge on American Idol? I'm waiting.......

The difficult we do immediately; the impossible takes a little longer.  Air Force Motto

emjem says: When your brain's stuck on liberalism it self-destructs.

by emjem 24: "You kno

by emjem 24: "You know, Chrissy Sissy..."

LMAO! There's another blogger at Anklebiting Pundits (I think) that calls the oh-so-sensitive commentator "Chrissy (I squat to pee) Matthews"

I'm not watching '24' tonight

I'm not watching '24' tonight, and probably never will.  But I've stopped watching Matthews' show long ago because of absurd statements like his 'ethnic cleansing' label. 

I just finished reading Gary'

I just finished reading Gary's book titled "Jawbreaker" and I recomend it.

Mark, does this strike you as odd? :

they are expected to basically be part of the ethnic cleansing because they will be shooting at Sunnis, they are going to get shot back at."

American troops will be shooting at Sunnis, not American troops will be shooting back at Sunnis. We are the ones starting all the conflicts over there! Those poor Sunnis, such victims.

Chris

This guy looks and sounds like he is about to have an on air meltdown. He doesn't look very well.

So, Mark.... where's the libe

So, Mark.... where's the liberial bias?

:p

Gee, Rog.(1) You never paid m

Gee, Rog.

(1) You never paid me for correctly identifying hayes in your last quiz (Yellow flower power guy).

and....

(2)  Your SEC post today was stupid beyond belief!  Not your fault, I know....but it was still in the category of UNFORGIVEABLE!

Hey, I can't help it if you G

Hey, I can't help it if you Gator Girlz have issues... I have been to the University of Ga, and the women were mighty fine indeed....

I tried to find Katie in her Bratz® outfit tonight, but couldn't.... I thought for sure I was going get your $10...

as it is, I am still owing a woman... Story of my life...

Yeah, well, Rog...If you coul

Yeah, well, Rog...

If you could find a pic of Katie on the newscast tonite...I'd forgive you your debts.

She looked like a sorry girl scout cookie pusher.

I am SERIOUS....she was wearing a blouse and a "jumper".  You wouldn't put such an ugly outfit on your fourth grader!  I know this for a fact, because my mom never made me wear one!

You're Lucky Blonde

You're lucky, Blonde. My mom had no fashion sense (hey it was the 80's sorry Mom). I actually have a school picture with frizzed out, permed hair and blouse and jumper. Ewww....thank god I now make my own fashion decisions. Moms mean well but sometimes they don't know better and the kids become the fashion victims. Now, who can explain the whole baggy pants hardly being held up by a belt thing? 

The difficult we do immediately; the impossible takes a little longer.  Air Force Motto

emjem says: When your brain's stuck on liberalism it self-destructs.

em...We all have our mom's fa

em...

We all have our mom's fashion things to, um, talk about.

However.....you obviously didn't see Ms. $15 million a year....in a really, really, really UGLY junior high school style "jumper" outfit tonite.

I am well and truly sorry.  I work very hard, as a professional woman.  I wear slacks, I wear skirts, I wear suits, I wear leather pants, I wear short skirts, I wear a lot of things......

But I have NEVER EVER EVER worn a high school jumper like Katie Couric did on the evening news this evening!!!!!!

She looked dumber than a cheerleader!  (And a seventh grade one at that...possibly it was her daughter's outfit).

I am beyond offended.

Remember 'tight' skirts?

Remember 'tight' skirts?

ACA

...

Acaiguana says:  "I love blind Monkeys and any inference that I am making fun of blind Monkeys would be wrong.

Remembering...

I do, and thoroughly approve.  Especially if as short as legally possible.

:-)

"HAV3 TH3 BRIDG3S OF INSANITY B33N CROSS3D AND FOR3V3R R3TRACT3D???."  - Meshuggah, "3ntrapm3nt", from Catch Thirty Thr33 (2005)

BTW, Rog.No absolution for TH

BTW, Rog.

No absolution for THAT lame excuse!

Correct

American troops will be shooting at Sunnis, not American troops will be shooting back

at Sunnis. We are the ones starting all the conflicts over there! Those poor Sunnis, such victims.

Ding ding ding!!! We have a winner!!!

That is the line for me that put this comment into a special place reserved for the highest scorn. When your natural mind-set is to portray the Sunnis as the victims simply trying to protect themselves from Americans who are helping Shiites ethnically cleanse your neighborhood - you have reached depths that require a swift punch in the face.

Chris Matthews accusing our t

Chris Matthews accusing our troops of taking part in ethnic cleansing is below even John Kerry's standards of describing them.  You know another term for "ethnic cleansing?"  Extermination

I don't know about you guys, but this isn't just bias, it is OUTRAGEOUS.  I am absolutely appalled and infuriated.

Chris Matthews should be exposed on Hannity as an Enemy of the State. 

What a Sick SOB

In his desperation to face reality, Chris chooses to point accusing fingers at American soldiers for crimes they haven't even committed in a place that they (the troops of the surge) haven't even fully arrived in yet, for missions that don't even exist.

Hmmmm, let's try and define what speculation really means:

If "X" goes to "Y" and does "Z" then since Z is a crime against humanity, and Y should never have happened in the court of MSNBC National Security decision-making, then X are what? They are criminals.

Let's just ignore the fact that just about every Dem in Congress has said the US needs to send in enough resources (read troops) to do the job once set upon into war, that most of the leadership demanded a surge, that most of the leadership has said they'll support it before they were against it...nah, let's just ignore all checking of that power and the lies they told so....what? So MSNBC can blame American troops for crimes against humanity?

Ya know, the "I was following orders" gig doesn't work for such things.

Either Droolboy Matthews thinks the American soldiers are committing crimes against humanity

(not in country yet)

(not ordered to do so)

(hasn't occurred)

(is an execusable crime to do so)

Or Droolboy Matthews owes a serious apology to men and women of the armed forces who are committed to success in Iraq, who have not accepted defeat, and who are not committing crimes as Matthews says they will.

Easier to speculate on the criminality of American forces than it is to accept that he was lied to and played as the political pawn (doesn't even rate TOOL level) that he is.

Man, even other Dems are realizing now that they never had a plan, that the "New Direction In Iraq" pledge was a fullout lie-one that Matthews in particular bought hook, line, and sinker.

Chris Matthews, Moonbattus Denialus Supremisimo

I Agree With Black

Hey Black, I agree with you. It's all well and good to trot out our troops when it suits the MSM (we were for the troops before we were against them). Matthews is at a new low but then the only people who will challenge his drivel are at Fox News and heaven forbid anyone challenge this horse's ass. Where did Chrissy Sissy get his military strategy expertise? The Jimmy Carter School of Foreign Enemy Butt Kissing? Yet another proud moment for MSNBC.

The difficult we do immediately; the impossible takes a little longer.  Air Force Motto

emjem says: When your brain's stuck on liberalism it self-destructs.

The fact that the left feels

The fact that the left feels it must make this insane charge of ethnic cleansing means they are fairly sure Bush's change of tactics is going to work.  Why else make the charge? 

We know that the reason why the terrorists haven't been fully rooted out was due to the PC crap of the Iraqi government factions preventing the US from going in there to clean them out of the neighborhoods.  We had a good example of this in Sadr City and being forced to let go of one of the chief bomb makers for the Mahdi Army under orders from Maliki himself. The liberals knew this as well and counted on the safehavens to be a continual source of bomb making thus fuel their campaign for ousting Repubs at home.  Now the PC crap is over, the liberals know there is no safe place in Iraq from which to launch attacks.  This is the beginning of the end of the insurgency, they (liberals) know it and they must forstall it by any means possible.

“The object of life is not to be on the side of the majority but to escape finding oneself in the ranks of the insane.” – Marcus Aurelius