Matthews' America the Bigoted

Photo of Mark Finkelstein.
  • Bookmark and Share


For Chris Matthews, there is one constant to be considered in analyzing the prospects of the presidential contenders on both the GOP and Dem sides: the presumed bigotry of his fellow Americans.

Kibitzing about '08 on this afternoon's Hardball with a conservative-free panel composed of Chris Cizzilla of the Washington Post, Mike Allen of Time and Howard Fineman of time immemorial, Matthews first handicapped the Dem field in these terms:

"Is the low estimate of [Democrats'] belief in [Hillary's] electability low enough that they think that an African-American guy has a better shot than she does? I mean that's a statement, I think, of pessimism about her shot if you shift to him for electability reasons."

View video of Matthews on Hillary/Obama here.

Bigotry again raised its ugly head for Chris when it came to analyzing the Republican field:

"Every time there's a national opinion poll, Rudy Giuliani wins it. And the people have cognitive dissonance. They don't see that because they don't want to see it. But he does keep winning the polls among people who say they're Republicans, who are identified as Republicans. Why does he keep winning every poll? Despite all the smell that keeps coming out about Bernie Kerik, the usual prejudices against New York and ethnics up in the big cities, he keeps winning every poll!"

I don't know, Chris; could it be because your notion of America the Bigoted is wrong?

View video of Matthews on Giuliani here.

Bonus Coverage: At one point, Allen, perhaps moonlighting for NOW, upbraided Matthews for not speaking of the junior senator from New York in sufficiently respectful terms.

Matthews: "The Democrats go with their heart, they go with either Obama or Hillary. Does everyone accept that?"

A dead serious Allen: "Why do you call her Hillary? She's Senator Clinton."

Matthews did not seem amused: "What are you, being politically correct? I call her Hillary because there's only one Hillary in the country, that's why."

Video of the sharp exchange here.

Contact Mark at mark@gunhill.net

—Mark Finkelstein is a NewsBusters contributing editor and host of Right Angle. Contact him at mark@gunhill.net.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

I am forever amazed all of th

I am forever amazed all of these whiz-bangs actually draw a salary.

"If we ever forget that we are a Nation Under God....then we will be a Nation Gone Under."  Ronald Reagan

Guess this is what my mom mea

Guess this is what my mom meant by the saying , pot calling the kettle black. Jezz and this freck wants to call me a bigot. This guy is way past his usefullness. HEY chrissy go back to work for the great tip oneil will ya.

A dead serious Allen: &quot

A dead serious Allen: "Why do you call her Hillary? She's Senator Clinton."

Matthews did not seem amused: "What are you, being politically correct? I call
her Hillary because there's only one Hillary in the country, that's
why."

Oh please. The only celebrity on a first name basis with the world was Elvis.

One Hillary? I have known a few and worked with a few. She DREAMS of the kind of personality and fame and adoration he had. Guess what sHrillary? You are no Elvis. And less well liked. Much less.

C-fisted...Elvis was not the

C-fisted...

Elvis was not the only one. There's Pluto, Dumbo, Donner, Blitzen, etc. You know... more in the Hillary family!

You know... more in the Hilla

You know... more in the Hillary family!

I thought she claimed the Sir Hillary family... 

"If we ever forget that we are a Nation Under God....then we will be a Nation Gone Under."  Ronald Reagan

Puhleeeeease... you can call

Puhleeeeease... you can call her manly all you want, but royalty...eeeek!

It was her story...and she di

It was her story...and she didn't stick to it!

LMAO!

"If we ever forget that we are a Nation Under God....then we will be a Nation Gone Under."  Ronald Reagan

Right you are, bigtimer.  Sh

Right you are, bigtimer.  She claimed her mother named her after Sir Edmund Hillary because of his fame in being the first to climb Mt. Everest.  The trouble was, when the Hildebeest was born, Edmund Hillary had not yet climbed Everest, he was a beekeeper in New Zealand.  He didn't make his famous climb until Ms. Rodham was seven years old.  I guess for the first seven years of her life, Hillary's mother just called her "Hey, you!"

"A communist is someone who reads Marx.  An anti-communist is someone who understands Marx."  Ronald Reagan

This is the subtext of what M

This is the subtext of what Matthews was really saying.

"Why does Giuliani keep winning every poll? No one I hang out with would be seen dead voting for that little i-ti shitzu"

That's right Chris, everyone knows the dead all vote Democrat.

Proud member of the all-powerful and vast militarist/industrialist/capitalist/zionist-bagelist complex

Yes, I'm a bigot

I'm a bigot. I want someone in leadership who can lead. If that makes me a bigot I'll wear the tag.

I'm a bigot. I want someone in leadership who will tell me what they are going to do, do it and never tell me one thing and do another. If that makes me a bigot I'll wear the tag.

I'm a bigot. I read the Second Amendment and see an individual right to keep and bear arms. A politician who doesn't read the same words with the same meaning isn't going to get my vote. If that makes me a bigot I'll wear the tag.

Now that we've established what sort of bigot I am, where does that leave Chris Matthews?

If you don't stand for something you'll fall for anything.

Rudy is winning because Americans like him and want him...

Rudy keeps winning because American likes him and wants him. Go Rudy. Rudy has the poise and temperment of a Ronald Reagan (yes I know not quite the same politics) and this makes him extremely likeable.

If you claim to be a conservative, please don't disgrace yourself and conservatism by thinking and arguing like a liberal.

you know, Guys (guy and art and tom)

You know; Rudy Giuliani is a fascinating man. I like him too, as my Pal, and a role model. Because he's brave and manly.

But for my country's Chief Exec? President? NOPE.

He's not a real Republican. He's a fallen-away Catholic. (OK, on his deathbed Rudy can make his peace with God; I want him in heaven someday, SURE.) But running this country? A known four-flusher who cheated on his wife. A gay marriage supporter, and abortion supporter who turned into this for political gain? We know what he really is: dishonest; a panderer like the other liberals. Not even as a Vice President would he be good for this country, IMHO.

Chrissy poo has been quite testy lately. Has he lost his way?

Chrissy poo has been quite testy lately.  Has he lost his way?

Since the elections he seems to have nothing to hang his hat on.  His favorite Party, the Democrats are cat fighting among themselves over whether to raise taxes now or raise taxes later; whether to change an ethic rule to fit 1/3rd of their thievery or 2/3rds of it; whether to have a symbolic vote against whatever plan Bush lays out; whether to raise the minimum wage but avoid having to talk to the Senate; he sounds quite lost now.

Gee,

I feel real sorry for the maroon.

ACA

...

Acaiguana says:  "I love blind Monkeys and any inference that I am making fun of blind Monkeys would be wrong.

Really, they WON. Why the l

Really, they WON. Why the long face, and why be so angry? I do not get why they aren't more happy. Could it be that they are perpetually perplexed?

Why the long face, and why be

Why the long face, and why be so angry?

Simple. It's called (our still being a) democracy and the U.S. Constitution.  

Perhaps it is getting harder

Perhaps it is getting harder for them to keep up the lie--it has to wear on a person and show on his or her face--strange, difficult world the liberals concoct for themselves.  Being angry suits them.

Liberalism is a convenient lie.

Just like setting up the batt

Just like setting up the battlefield in President Bush's speech, talking for a full week before about how it's going to be a failure. We get to have two years of the MSM telling us that if we don't vote for Shrillery, we're sexist. And if we don't vote for Obama we're racist. And if we don't vote for a Democrat, we're just stupid Republicans with a whole bunch of other sterotypes attached to me.

I thought stereotypes were bad.

Well, Chris, of course Americ

Well, Chris, of course America is racist.  After all, Michael Steele lost in Maryland, right? Right?  Oh, that's a bad example, because he's a Republican and a conservative. After all, we all "know" that the ONLY reason a liberal democrat could possibly lose an election is because of their race or gender.

Matthews gets more disgusting by the day. 

"The right to be heard does not automatically include the right to be taken seriously." --Hubert Humphrey

That's right--and Allen Keyes

That's right--and Allen Keyes won the straw poll (I voted for him) in the 1998/1999 GOP straw poll convention in--Alabama.  We're not racist; we're genuine and don't see a color in a person, we see content and heart.  Liberals show more racism than any other group--particularly against Jewish people in Israel.   

Liberalism is a convenient lie.

Chrissy Sissy Has A Hissy

Is Chrissy on a first name basis with Hil? If I was laying a wager I'd say not. If he called her by her first name, she'd have him for breakfast. How does this man suddenly have a magic crystal ball to predict anyone's electability? I think it's more like a magic eight ball. He earns the big bucks for this claptrap? I think he pissed off another person on his continuing downward spiral of unimportance.

The difficult we do immediately; the impossible takes a little longer.  Air Force Motto

I've actually met quite a few Hillarys in my life too, chrissy

 Where does this man get off with this nonsense.  I have known quite a few Hillarys in my life and once had a Col. with the first name of Hillary (he liked to tell everyone his favorite song was "A Boy Named Sue". 

As for being called a bigot, well I'm called that at every opportunity by someone who is absolutely cluess and even last night said I was one step removed from the Klan.  However, regardless of what this troll on the board and chrissy say, I believe most Americans want a good person, man or woman, whatever race to be in Office.  Unfortunately, we don't have too many of those in Congress (I do think President Bush is a good man but I'm not fan of Cheney myself) who aren't doing the right thing (Babs Boxer, Jack Murtha, various RINOs).  This is beyond the pale that this fool can color the whole nation a racist because he doesn't believe Hil the Shill or Ears Obama would be elected.  It hasn't dawned on old Chrissy that not a lot of people outside of NY really like HIl and who knows what Old Ears thinks.  I will state again that I don't think he gives the American people credit.  He wants to believe we all sit in single wide trailers with shotguns on our laps and pigs running all over the house if we're outside the Beltway, NYC, Boston or LA.

It might depend on what shade of color you are...

Hi, 1st time commentor...

Colin Powell and Condelessa Rice were Republican red. I guess that's why they have never counted in the media (with Powell - at least not as long as he was in the Bush cabinet)....

I was going to register and post about this topic on the Sec. of State Rice item from yesterday, but it fits here as well. - This comment is a little drawn out, but I think worth the effort reading...

I am student-teaching in 8th grade here in GA, after having been out of the country for just under a decade, and today the teacher showed the MLK "I have a Dream" speech. Then, she had a discussion with these 8th graders about some of the items King mentioned as part of the dream and whether we had achieved that dream so far or not.

Over the course of the long discussion, a few students said, "Pres. Bush is a racist."

Now, these are kids, so they didn't offer much in the way of concrete reasons for believing this, but over time, some of them mentioned New Orleans and Hurricane Katrina - but again without any specific details.

It dawned on me as I listened to this discussion to put their thoughts with the media blitz we've been witnessing over Pelosi and Obama the last few weeks.

Even before I read it on this site, I was writing on my blog how I could remember Gingrich and the Reps. getting a very different type of media barrage when they took over the House. The amount of soft coverage and cheerleading for both Pelosi and Obama has been staggering, and the hypocrisy on the Dem victory last year to the 1994 Rep victory should make the media ashamed.

But, they should also be ashamed if they could listen to these 8th graders of mine.

What I mean is ----- look at Colin Powell and Condelessa Rice - two black people, one a woman, placed in two of the most powerful positions in the whole world. Placed there by Bush. And how much media play has he gotten for it? I should say positive media play, because quoting Harry Belfonte calling them vile names is not the kind of press coverage I am seeing Pelosi or Obama getting...

If Pelosi becoming the first female Speaker of the House is big news, and Albright becoming the first female Sec. of State was worth applauding by the media, shouldn't the media be able to give a kudo or two to Bush and Rice? Enough kudos that it might stick in somebody's head in our society?

These 8th graders saying Bush is a racists for no reason they can think of are learning it at home - but where do the people at those homes learn such stuff?

From the media....

Colin Powell was (correctly) given a good bit of favorable coverage somewhere within the realm of Obama over the years (though far from the kind of canonization we are witnessing with him), but once in the Bush government, the media went immediately to a message that he was out of place and ostricized by the neocons --- they kept trying to peel him away from the Republicans and Bush until eventually he was gone. (Not totally different in effect than how the media kept with a strategy of constantly bombarding Newt Gingrich until they could hoist his head on a stick).

With Rice, they have simply ignored her for the most part - only focusing on policy issues and such. I can't remember any cheerleading about her being a strong, intelligent woman and a minority and having held two of the most powerful positions in the world.

I don't think it is a stretch to say, perhaps, Rice has even held a more influencial post than Pelosi so far (and possibly even as Speaker of the House given the amount of policy pull a Sec. of State has and how little big effect a Speaker has on such major international issues). But, who gets made into a queen and who gets the hardball questions????

Maybe that is what Santa Claus should give the media next Christmas - a sense of shame.

usin,Thank you.You are and wi

usin,

Thank you.

You are and will continue to be a great teacher...we are lucky here in this country to have people like you teaching our children and grandchildren.

We overlook the fact sometimes in our haste that you are prime example of what has kept this country strong since it's founding.

Your post is a perfect example of what this country is all about...once again, thank you.

Night.

Btw...I am glad you are here.

"If we ever forget that we are a Nation Under God....then we will be a Nation Gone Under."  Ronald Reagan

If Obama was a conservative,

If Obama was a conservative, he could win the presidency.  He is well spoken and carries a sincere staure.  But being dedicated to things like preventing legislation of parental notification when a minor is seeking an abortion doesn't endear him to most Americans.    

Liberalism is a convenient lie.

Chris Matthews is your typi

Chris Matthews is your typical leftist American liberal, bred out of guilt and shame at America's success. The issues matter not. He will always vote for black over white, female over male, atheist over Christian, as long as it is a liberal. I also notice a touch of anti-semitism in his pronouncements.

DSG

Let's imagine this: Bill

Let's imagine this: Bill O'Reilly says Hillary's electability ratings are so low that an African-American has a better shot than she has.

Reaction from the MSM......anyone? anyone? Beuller?????

"Bigot" - let's go to the Dictionary

"Bigot" - let's go to the Dictionary

Bigot:

 - a person who is utterly intolerant of any differing creed, belief, or opinion.

- One who is strongly partial to one's own group, religion, race, or politics and is intolerant of those who differ. 

-A prejudiced person who is intolerant of any opinions differing from his own. 

(those were the definitions from 4 different dictionaries)

Synonyms - Well, let me suggest that it just might appear that one's typical leftist activist, journalist, TV cable and network news anchor, white house reporter, MS cable news show anchor, and of course your average actor, seems to be walking a fine line here.

Did it ever cross Matthews' m

Did it ever cross Matthews' mind that maybe Hillary or Obama (once its clear what he actually stands for and how he's voted, something NewsBusters has done a good job of reporting) don't stand a chance in a Presidential election because they are Left leaning Dems whose ideas are repugnant at their core to Heartland America?  NO, it has to be bigotry.  Many Republicans (myself included) would love to see a Condi Rice ticket in 08.  I'll admit I'm not sure about some of the positions she might take on Domestic issues (just haven't heard her address these in any capacity), but in foreign relations I think she'd be spectacular (from the Natan Sharansky school, so to speak).  Would Matthews be labeled a bigot if he didn't support Condi in 08?  No, that would be just Matthews expressing "legitimate concern".  Double standards never end with how the Useful Idiots report.