The Bush Plan: Networks Prepared Audiences With Week of Badmouthing 'Surge' Option

Photo of Rich Noyes.

By the time President Bush delivered his Iraq speech Wednesday night, the news media had spent several days engaged in what the military calls "preparing the battlefield." The media's air war against the plan to try to actually win the Iraq war assured that most of Bush's audience would have already heard journalists claiming the new mission is wrong-headed and doomed to failure. A few examples:

"Like a folly." Last Tuesday on NBC's Today, anchor emeritus Tom Brokaw argued that the way Saddam Hussein was executed revealed Iraq as "a deeply divided country along tribal lines," and that sending more troops would "seem to most people...like a folly." Brokaw added: "I think a lot of people who are raising their hands to join the armed services are wondering, ‘I'm giving my life for that?'"

"Wrong Way Corrigan." The next morning on Today, political analyst Chris Matthews declared the President's plan dead on arrival: "I expect it will be treated the way Richard Nixon's invasion of Cambodia was reacted to. The American people aren't gonna like it." Matthews insisted that the voters wanted to end, not mend, Bush's Iraq policies and "for the President to go Wrong Way Corrigan on this thing and to increase the number of troops, take us deeper into Iraq, would be to reject the opinion of the American people."

"Absolutely no difference." This week, as more details of the President's plan were revealed, the anti-surge drum-beat got louder. On CBS's Early Show, co-host Harry Smith asked Baghdad reporter Lara Logan if extra troops would make a difference. "The best thing we have is to look at what has happened already. When the U.S. brought in 12,000 more troops into Baghdad last summer, it made absolutely no difference," Logan replied. "In fact, security here in Baghdad got even worse."

"Lost Cause?" On Tuesday's Today, NBC's White House reporter David Gregory suggested even White House insiders have lost faith. "As the President prepares to start a new phase of the war in Iraq, the White House is fending off charges that key figures in the administration have concluded the war is lost." NBC's graphic headline read "Lost Cause? Can U.S. Win the War In Iraq?" Gregory also cited unnamed "critics" to suggest Bush's motives were psychological: "U.S. commanders who opposed adding troops to Iraq have been replaced, prompting critics to charge the President's resolve has become stubbornness."

Roll call of critics. On Wednesday's Good Morning America, Diane Sawyer confronted White House aide Dan Bartlett: "I just want to run through a partial roll call of the number of people who have either opposed what the President is going to do, or expressed serious reservations." As she read off names such as Colin Powell and Chuck Hagel, their names and faces scrolled over her right shoulder. "I could go on and on," Sawyer told Bartlett. "What don't they get? What don't they understand?" Bartlett objected, saying some of the generals she listed as critics "helped devise this plan."

"Breaking Point." On yesterday's Today, co-host Meredith Vieira doubted that the U.S. military could meet the challenge: "The cornerstone of his plan is sending around 20,000 additional U.S. troops into the war zone. But is the military stretched to the breaking point already?" Reporter Jim Miklaszewski suggested it was: "The pace of two wars has left two-thirds of the Army's combat brigades rated ‘Not Ready to Fight.'"

"The cost has been enormous." Uniquely last night, CBS's Katie Couric decided to introduce Bush's speech by repeating the war's terrible toll: "Four years into the war, the cost has been enormous. More than 3,000 American military killed, more than 22,000 wounded. The dollar cost, close to $400 billion." Emphasizing her point, CBS posted each demoralizing statistic as a full-screen graphic.

The new plan may succeed, or it may fail. But the media's mantra these past few days has been that failure seems inevitable, so we shouldn't even try.

—Rich Noyes is Research Director at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

...and the sky is falling the

...and the sky is falling the sky is falling!

Chicken Little's all of them....

I am sick to death of all of them, I say we start a war at home, get rid of all of the enemy within....here and now!

We will be able to accomplish any war we need to anytime if they are extinct.

"If we ever forget that we are a Nation Under God....then we will be a Nation Gone Under."  Ronald Reagan

Bush blew a big opportunity t

Bush blew a big opportunity to put them in their place.  He should have called the MSM on their prejudice and how their bias and negativity promotes the cause of the enemy.  To fight the enemy within, we need the president to recognize that they are the enemy, not just Americans of a different opinion.  (I'm not referring to all those who oppose the war, only those who voice their opposition and push their agenda through propaganda, slander and lies)

opposing voices

According to the libs the President doesn't want to hear opposing voices. Same goes for them but they are either too ignorant to see it or too arrogant to admit it. And isn't it amazing how many foreign policy wonks have appeared on the MSM recently. It boggles the mind. But I wonder why these geniuses are keeping the best stategies so secret. Between them and the Dems they should be able to end this thing , with no casualties, within a week. YUK!

NEVER,NEVER trust a liberal

A question for Brokaw

Brokaw added: "I think a lot of people who are raising their hands to join the armed services are wondering, ‘I'm giving my life for that?'"

Tom, I have a question.  If that's really what our military men and women are thinking as they are sworn in, then why are they going through with being sworn in?  They're not draftees; they're volunteers.  Are you suggesting they aren't smart enough to keep from volunteering for what you imply is a lost cause?  I can't imagine anyone would join the military at this point in history unless he or she believes in what we're doing.  And if such a person doesn't believe, please, stay home.

even worse, viking

To hear Tom Brokaw's flap, our men and women are only sent to the battlefront to die. Quote: "Giving my life for that?"

No American EVER, not one, is taken from his home and family to a front by his commanders to die. This is a common error always declared as if true; to gullible and effeminate Americans.

The soldier is always sent there to FIGHT. No one expects him to die. I would quote the words of Saint Joan of Arc as she rallied her army. "WE shall give battle. The King of heaven will give the VICTORY."

Where is the fool who can imagine her saying instead, "Prepare, for you are here to die for France." --? ? ?

Excellent point! "No basta

Excellent point!

"No bastard ever won a war by dying for his country. He won it by making the other poor dumb bastard die for his country."
- Attributed to General George Patton, Jr. (from "A Genius for War" by Carlo d'Este)

The cost has been enormousI

The cost has been enormous

It's been about 4 years? Somewhere around 3,000 deaths?

Why wasn't 3,000 deaths in about 2 hours during 9/11 'enormous'?

JDW

Kerry: "You know, education, if you make the most of it ... you can do well. If you don't, you get stuck in Iraq."

You think there are people th

You think there are people that will say they weren't?

Where are you seeing this i

Where are you seeing this in the news media or hearing it from the dems?

JDW

Kerry: "You know, education, if you make the most of it ... you can do well. If you don't, you get stuck in Iraq."

So, Democrats have to preface

So, Democrats have to preface everything they do by saying 9/11 was a horrible ordeal?

Bal-go read the posts on the NYT Reporter story

Go read the posts on the NYTReporter story.  They really get to the heart of what we're saying and why we feel the way we do about the MSM elites.

"He who has a thousand friends has not a friend to spare, and he who has one enemy will meet him everywhere"          -Ali ibn-Abi-Talib, 4th Islamic Caliph

Um... Once would suffice.

Um... Once would suffice.

How about for every ten times they trash the War on Terror which they are hell-bent-for-leather the US lose; they simply have a moment of silence for those folks who on 9/11/01 committed the terrible crime of going to work.

ACA

...

Acaiguana says:  "Which city is next?"

ACA,I am terribly surprised t

ACA,

I am terribly surprised that NO ONE HERE even remarked upon this part of GWB's speech last nite....

Succeeding in Iraq also requires defending its territorial integrity – and stabilizing the region in the face of the extremist challenge. This begins with addressing Iran and Syria. These two regimes are allowing terrorists and insurgents to use their territory to move in and out of Iraq. Iran is providing material support for attacks on American troops. We will disrupt the attacks on our forces. We will interrupt the flow of support from Iran and Syria. And we will seek out and destroy the networks providing advanced weaponry and training to our enemies in Iraq.

And for some reason....my att

And for some reason....my attempts at continuing that comment kept looking very strange....so...

Why is it that no one has commented on this part of GWB's speech?

As I posted earlier.....I suspect we are preparing to go BIGGER, LONGER, and MORE WHUPASS than the dems can stand.

So I say to all of the critics, who nit-picked GWB's look and demeanor last night....so sorry...you've been an idiot again....to pick on the "look" of the man, and not is what is in his heart.

It's going to really suck to be a liberal when we win this war.

What’s the dem plan to st

What’s the dem plan to stop Iran from obtaining nukes?

JDW

Kerry: "You know, education, if you make the most of it ... you can do well. If you don't, you get stuck in Iraq."

Let me ask you this: Why do y

Let me ask you this: Why do you think this will work? 20,000 more troops. I have no idea if it will or won't, no preconceptions. Why will this get the job done?

dear balboa

Bush said he's consulted with his people at the Defense Dept, and with the Dems input. If it was decided 20K troops are adequate to the task, we suppose it is.

The opposition goes on the false premise that all will just go there to die. Is this supposed to be true? Would you see it this way, just because it comes from the Bush side?

I have no presumptions just b

I have no presumptions just because it's Bush. I'd just like to know why exactly this will work. I want something to work.

good, our best wishes for Bush

You may wonder why 20,000 more troops won't help the situation.

But after all, Bal Our G.I.'s aren't there to fight 20,000 soldiers in the first place. They add to a force which apparently wasn't controlling enough territory or traffic. With the added strength (surge) a more efficient job may be done. It stands to reason. That's not a small number. A 20,000 force in this context is formidable strength added. Wouldn't you say?

Yuck, bal...The only one here

Yuck, bal...

The only one here who is willing to talk to you on a substantive basis is TUMBLER.

Perhaps it's time to come over to the right side of the debate?

Well, no one else was replyin

Well, no one else was replying. I'm just looking for an informed opinion.

she's drunk again

Bal, Blonde has periods of intoxication during which she loses control of her emotions. Then all hell can break loose. She becomes Medusa, whose face turned men to stone. Blonda fancies herself a conservative. But colleges are replete with this kind of indecent harpie. Spine-tingling feminists taking over every campus. They resort to indecent language, hate speech and drunkenness. All must go to their knees and tremble before them.

I'm not likeable to her. I won't kneel. I cannot offer my friendship to a bigot; you know? No way!

You are so amazingly boring a

You are so amazingly boring and ignorant.....

Just because I call you out as AN ILLEGAL ALIEN APPOLOGIST!

You shouldn't get all bent out of shape, again, and again.

P.S.  Although Bal would never admit it....he'd rather be associated with me...rather than associated with an a$$hat like you.

blonde's mantra

AN ILLEGAL ALIEN APPOLOGIST! ----OK, if the shoe fits, I can wear it.

There's no intention in any of my posts, to excuse the illegality of those poor people. I agree they ought to be deported.

But why should I give Bigot here the satisfaction of protesting against her label? Let her call Tumbler whatever pleases her. At nearly 70 yrs old, I've taken much worse punishment. I have no hard feelings toward Blonde. Her attitude is typical of intolerant and cruel people. Just like the kind who hated Jews on the streets of Berlin long ago. Nazis, the super race. It was no use reasoning with them. Jews were only insects in their world.

Today illegal aliens are insects to our kind-hearted Blonde. She would love to destroy them all, and their children too. And, for Blonde, nobody is allowed to speak up for them. That's called being their apologist. Haha!

There's no intention in any

There's no intention in any of my posts, to excuse the illegality of those poor people.

Uh, actually that seems to be the intent of every post you make on Illegal Aliens.

dear free stink,

Uh; could you produce ONE, single statement of Tumbler's in which I declare illegal immigrants should be given special priveleges or a free pass to break our immigration statutes? FIND IT; I won't deny it if you can produce it.

I stand for the DECENT American majority. We detest racism and bigotry.

Isn't it telling; over all this time arguing, Blonde-- Misterbill,-- the whole lot, have never denounced racial bigotry in our society? Never spoken out against hatred of illegal aliens or any other minority? It tells us volumes! They can't speak out against their own prejudices. A prostitute can't denounce money in defense of morality.

You've dug yourself another u

You've dug yourself another ugly hole, there, tumble.

Sheesh....you are so bloody predictable, it's not even very fun any more.

Silly old ILLEGAL ALIEN APPOLOGIST.

Nope, can't do it.Hasn't happ

Nope, can't do it.

Hasn't happened.

BTW...for all of you ignorant a$$hats out there...

Cite your own posts...morons... tumbler said it was a million, or a zillion, or whatever...

Well, that was KINDA cute. 

Well, that was KINDA cute.  tumble fumble.

You can make up anything....and everything about me.

Which is what you continue to do here.

Your fevered brain is in overdrive.

Poor old tumbler, fumbler.

ILLEGAL ALIEN APPOLOGIST!

Too bad, so sad....I don't hate you.

Silly old fool....you are beneath MY contempt.

Which means you don't even show up on my radar.

Dumbass!

blonde re: your post.

"Your fevered brain is in overdrive."

A medical impossibility. You are communicating with an Hispanic Charlie McCarthy. There is not even anyone behind the curtain. It is a pre-programmed DVD. It has a one theme argument

"SELF APPOINTED ILLEGAL ALIEN APOLOGIST"

and that is followed by insults which when countered is then followed by entreaties to God and how the other person has no soul. I have made a decision that I will never respond to him again. BT today suggested that he had a troubled childhood and was living a troubled life. BT is usually right.

I feel better now that I have decided to ignore him. However, I am even older than him and his insults to you, a nice lady, sorely trouble me.

misterbill..good evening  :-

misterbill..good evening  :-)    I wonder if our "friend " is as drunk as he was last weekend??     :-)  ww                           Being "Politcaly Correct"  with    ISLAM  will distroy America......WW             

mb & ww,matters not...one

mb & ww,

matters not...one iota.

Actually, gentlemen, I am a bit distressed that we are not more interested in what our President said last night.

blonde don't faint

blonde  don't faint-- I actually missed almost the whole dang thing. I was calming a crying granddaughter. Also, I fear my President is whipped. He has such a hangdog look. Please enlighten me with any news--esp. what was distressing.

Blonde...As I posted a couple

Blonde...As I posted a couple of weeks ago ;  we are past due in puting more troops in Iraq.    We need to go in there and "take names and kick ass" like I said.    We need to clean out Tickret, and a couple of other cities there that support the terriorist.     We should have taken care of Tehran Iran an very long time ago.  Demascus Syria  too!                            Being "Politcaly Correct"  with    ISLAM  will distroy America......WW             

Gentlemen...(mb, and ww)....P

Gentlemen...

(mb, and ww)....President Bush just  put a rather sharp point on things.

Those who think they know him well (MsM) badly misinterpreted the message.

We will be fine.

Support the troops!

Support the CIC.

Continue to crush the idiot trolls.

Regards, to you fine gentlemen.

/Blonde.

Blonde..Thanks for your kind

Blonde..Thanks for your kind words....on my car I have a yellow ribbon that says  "Pray for  our Troops!"   I sure do support and pray for our Troops.     I have had one of my many "dog tags" on my key ring on my belt for over  40years now ;   each time I feel them, I rub them and ask GOD to be with our Troops and bring them home safely.  And regards to you young  Lady...  :-)                           Being "Politcaly Correct"  with    ISLAM  will distroy America......WW             

blonde

I think that fighting a war with political correctness in mind is idiotic. Our boys and girls should have been allowed to go in there, shoot anything that threatened them, secured the area, kicked some Iraqi butt to step up to the plate and assume responsibility for policing the country. When the militias formed, we should have put a decisive end to that.(IMO, it would have only taken about another week if our troops were allowed to do their jobs without interference.) Another thing that is bothering me is all this puling and whining about the President reading our mail. I may be out of step, but if reading my mail is going to protect my family, well, hell, send it to the White House first.

don't speak to misterbill

Thumpa:

Not now, please. Looks like misterbill has a hemorrhoid flare-up. I'm sure he'll talk to you tomorrow.

Tumbler Shut Up

Tumbler, please stop sniping. No one agrees with you on illegal immigration so accept and try to understand. I've worked with illegal immigrant kids and the ones I saw in Colorado showed no appreciation that they were even getting a free public education (on the public's dime). No, they wanted to skip school last spring to protest people wanting to hold their parents acountable for breaking the law and of course that's actually easier than going to school and keeping your mouth shut. I'm fluent in Spanish and subbed this basic English class and I wish I hadn't. They called me a bitch and ignorant white woman who didn't understand the plight of others (but then I've been called all sorts of names as a teacher). These kids know nothing of sacrifice (I have some Native American blood and let me assure you that Native Americans gave up much more than illegal immigrants ever will; settlers took from Native Americans and now illegal are taking from America). I learned from parents, one who grew up during the Great Depression and the other who grew up poor, that you work for what you want, you don't take it and believe all of us when I say, ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS ARE TAKING ALL OF OUR RESOURCES. As to Pres. Bush, I'm a military spouse and I'm tired of MSM bastards continually defaming him and the military. If they had their way, Pres. Bush would be impeached and the military would be disbanded. There are Americans out there who want the military to disappear because the DOD takes away from their precious social security (which is a lie since the entitltement spending is twice as much as military spending). No, no one, except you guys, will listen to me, a military spouse, when I say that if the American people don't start thinking for themselves, the terrorists will eventually eliminate all their freedoms and not the other way around.

The difficult we do immediately; the impossible takes a little longer.  Air Force Motto

ww---shame on me

ww---shame on me--I hadn't even thought about alcohol. You are quite likely correct. He and I had quite a go around today. I don't think it is good for me to get involved (with him) in any more discussions. He is adamant in his position and cannot recognize his extreme prejudice. If I might, I do not have a lot of experience, but could you lend me your ghillie if I find an address. It's called "resolution".

In a serious vein, with all I have been reading lately about the US of North America and all that jazz-I don't want to ;ive in that environment and will get these decrepit senior bones up and fight to the last breath. I canot believe that we have elected politicians that will give away what so many people have spilled their blood to save. I am puzzled--I cannot imagine (other than a handful of liberals ) who would do this.

misterbill..."the US of

misterbill..."the US of North America"   :   For those who support that ----------   "Get a ROPE!!"      :-( 

As for "fighting against that"  ....   Like I have said before...." my head thinks I'm still 20 :   but my fat lil' bod's still  65....    :-)     tho I would anyway.   I still know how;   and most important ;  still have the will.                               Being "Politcaly Correct"  with    ISLAM  will distroy America......WW             

My head thinks I still wear a size 4

 Thumper, made my night with your head thinking your 20 but your body says 65. 

thump - a little bad humor

thump - a little bad humor--with me it's my (fat) ass that knows it is 73 years old. Believe it or not, I have started working out three times a week. My objective is to be strong enough to help my country in one way or another. I still have (cringing) 40 pounds to lose.

thump ps

thump ps--I know you have the will and because of who you are, you will find the way if you are needed.

Being pol correct with a lot of issues will destroy America. I fear that within the next 10 years there will be a great internal conflict. I honestly believe that the America WE love will change drastically.

I pray I am wrong.

emjem

Emjem  --Read yr profile. Be proud of your man. Be proud of yourself. You talk the talk and youand family walk the walk. I am just an old retired guy but I know what your husband is doing for America. I know we owe him. We have so many great folks at this site. I am happy you found us. I am happy I found NB. I often felt alone. Most of my friends are conservatives, but they don't have a single clue as to what is happening in and to our country. One friend in NY, a registered Republican and office seeker scoffed at the idea that there may be another attack on America. Thank God he is in tune on most other issues. Another close friend sees no harm from illegal immigrants. He has hired some aliens  but never checks to see if they are legal. His Dad came illegally so he sees no danger there. I see you have become familiar with our resident apologist. I decided today to give up on him. He isn't worth the bother.

Welcome!