Old Media Helps Obama Push False Rush Limbaugh Immigration Quotes


Yesterday, the Washington Post's Ed O'Keefe reported that the Obama campaign was releasing some new Spanish language campaign ads on TV in Florida and other markets that feature Rush Limbaugh making what appears to be anti-Mexican comments. The ads then link Limbaugh to McCain on immigration attempting to smear them both in the minds of voters. The Limbaugh quotes, however, are so out of context that their use constitutes a lie. Unfortunately, too many media outlets are allowing these lies to stand unchallenged.

As O'Keefe reported on September 17, the ads feature quotes from Rush that display a shocking anti-Mexican immigrant feel. Titled "dos caras" -- or "two faces" -- Rush is quoted as calling Mexicans names and telling them to "shut up and get out."

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

"They want us to forget the insults we've put up with, the intolerance," the television ad's announcer says in Spanish as a picture of Rush Limbaugh appears onscreen with quotes of him saying, "Mexicans are stupid and unqualified" and "Shut your mouth or get out."

"They made us feel marginalized in a country we love so much," the ad continues. "John McCain and his Republican friends have two faces. One that says lies just to get our vote and another, even worse, that continues the failed policies of George Bush that put special interests ahead of working families."

The companion radio ad uses the same script as above and then continues:

"Don't forget that John McCain abandoned us rather than confront the leaders of the Republican Party. Many of us were born here, and others came to work and achieve a better life for their families -- not to commit crimes or drain the system like many of John McCain's friends claim. Let's not be fooled by political tricks from John McCain and the Republicans. Vote so they respect us. Vote for a change."

It turns out that Rush did actually say the words that the ads use against him. But, it also turns out he did not say them about Mexicans! Rush was not telling Mexicans to "get out" nor did he say that Mexican immigrants are "stupid and unqualified."

O'Keefe, however, does not explain this in his Washington Post story. This lack of context was the same in other papers relating the story. The Chicago Tribune, for instance, didn't fully report the truth and neither did the Wall Street Journal.

However, both Jonathan Martin of Politico and our friend Jake Tapper of ABC did report the true context of the Limbaugh quotes. And Tapper goes the extra mile with his coverage, as he always does.

On his Wednesday radio program, Limbaugh successfully proved that his words were wildly taken out of context. As to the "shut up and get out" quote, when Limbaugh said this line he was saying it in context of the immigration laws that Mexico has in its own country for foreigners wishing to live in Mexico. Mexico's immigration laws are very strict and, as Limbaugh said, if you don't like Mexican laws you can "shut up and get out" as far as Mexican officials are concerned. Limbaugh did not say that Mexicans here in the U.S. should "shut up and get out" if they don't like our laws and that is the context in which Obama campaign was using this Limbaugh quote.

The second quote, "stupid and unskilled Mexicans," was also taken out of context by the Obama campaign.

Here I'll let Tapper explain:

Second, the quotes of Limbaugh’s are out of context.

Railing against NAFTA in 1993, Limbaugh said, "If you are unskilled and uneducated, your job is going south. Skilled workers, educated people are going to do fine 'cause those are the kinds of jobs NAFTA is going to create. If we are going to start rewarding no skills and stupid people, I'm serious, let the unskilled jobs that take absolutely no knowledge whatsoever to do -- let stupid and unskilled Mexicans do that work."

Not one of his most eloquent moments, to be sure, but his larger point was that NAFTA would mean that unskilled stupid Mexicans would be doing the jobs of unskilled stupid Americans.

I’m not going to defend how he said it, but to act as if this was just a moment of Limbaugh slurring Mexicans is not accurate. Though again, certainly if people were offended I could understand why.

On top of all these misuses of Limbaugh's words, to link Limbaugh with McCain on immigration is also a lie. Limbaugh was strongly against John McCain's soft immigration stance in the Senate. So, linking Limbaugh to McCain is simply absurd.

So, this Obama ad is filled with what amounts to lies. Will the rest of the Old Media follow Tapper's and Martin's example and expose this scurrilous Obama campaign tactic? It doesn't look like they will because this story was out all day on the 17th and no one followed up like Tapper and Martin did. Will the rest of the media remain mum allowing this Obama lie to hang out there unaddressed?


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Will the rest of the media

Will the rest of the media remain mum allowing this Obama lie to hang out there unaddressed?

Of course they will (but that was a rhetorical question, wasn't it?)

This is the same as the Limbaugh "phony soldiers" manufactured controversy. I will bet that to this day there are thousands, perhaps millions of people, who think that Rush said soldiers who disagree with the war in Iraq are phony soldiers.

That's how liberals do their dirty work:  Just get something out there, true or not.  Most of the people who hear it won't hear the correction later, or read that it turned out to be untrue.

Mission accomplished. 

 

Not unlike

the distortions and selective edits that the paragons of virtue' Limpbaugh and McSame' have perpetrated on the voter for months regarding Obama... Obama has let the lies roll out and rebutted them with the truth..

KEATING 5 Keating 5---The Gramm Bill of 1999. The Gramm Bill of 1999....

... and WHEN is Obamessiah

... and WHEN is Obamessiah going to start that "truth roll out" again? Could it be when truth comes up and bites him on the rear? If it did, he wouldn't notice.

Let's Quote Obama

Obama described the Muslim call to prayer as

   "one of the prettiest sounds on Earth at sunset"

according to the New York Times.

Wouldn't this make a great McCain ad?

Here's Obama's "truth"

"I need you to go out and talk to your friends and talk to your neighbors. I want you to talk to them whether they are independent or whether they are Republican. I want you to argue with them and get in their face," he said.

He ought to be a little careful about telling his supporters to "get in their face".  This election is ugly enough as it is.

The lies and innuendo are continous now in the One's campaign.  It's disgusting.

David Gregory, do you know which damn network you lie for? ~ Uncle Jimbo, @Blackfive

 

".. and WHEN is Obamessiah

".. and WHEN is Obamessiah going to start that "truth roll out" again?
Could it be when truth comes up and bites him on the rear? If it did,
he wouldn't notice."

And even worse, the media wouldn't notice either.

docb

docb, Obama's own parents saw no value in him and abandoned him, I would suggest America take that as an example and do the same.

D

Keep the ILLEGALS out, join NumbersUSA to send free faxes to your reps.

Uh-oh

Out of curiousity, how stupid would you feel, when you learn that the ad grossly distorts the issue at hand?

How would you feel, if the statements attributed to Limbaugh, were taken so severely out of context, as to completely change the meaning of what he was saying?

In the interest of time, and the lack of ability for you to obviously know what the hell you are talking about, I'll explain it to you.

In 1996, when NAFTA was the big discussion on the political scene, Rush Limbaugh made the statement in defense of his not caring about NAFTA coming to pass, as it were, to a caller. He said, in essence, so what if jobs leave stupid and unqualified Americans, and move to stupid and unqualified Mexicans? This was noted above.

As noted above also, the second quote, taken completely out of context, is the issue of Mexico's own immigration laws. That if it's good enough for them, they should learn to take their own medicine, in other words.

How totally pitiful you are to defend a ridiculous excuse for an advertisement by "Obysmal" (yes, I know that abysmal is spelled as I just made it, but it seems to be exactly what Obama is -- Obysmal...). I would suggest that you actually read the entire article posted by WTH above, rather then what you were programmed and told to say by DailyKOS and MoveOn.org. It might show a little bit of intelligence to actually do so...

__________________________________________________________
If homosexuality is genetic, then it must be a birth defect. If it is a birth defect, then stem cell research might provide a cure.

They really want to expose the lie but . . .

In one ad the Obama campaign slaps around McCain/Palin and Limbaugh with lies in an attempt to fool people.

I'm sure the MSM would want to expose the lies, but other more important news took the air/print time/space.

BTW - Hey, Jack Cafferty! Lynn Forester de Rothchild, the most aggressive fundraiser for Hillary and member of the DNC, announced she is supporting McCain. Does that make her a racist? Jack? Hello? 

Rebuttal is not

lying.... to begin!! But selective edits and out of context quotes are the limpbaugh/Mcsame stock in trade.

As to Ms Rothchild...She is new to the elite circuit...She married her Baron in 2000...as to racist--I doubt it --she is just a rabid quasi-feminist...who lost her appointment to an ambassitorship when hillery crashed...but she will be disappointed--McSame has already sold ALL his appointments...

Silly docb

Silly docb, tricks are for libs.

According to Cafferty, she's a racist. Deal with it.

 

Um, what flavor of kool-aid

Um, what flavor of kool-aid do you drink, again, dooceb?

Dooceb, May I recommend Sears Die Hard refill fluid?

It is wonderfull if you've never tried it. Oh wait, by your posts it appears you have.

"I need more cowbell!" SNL

docb... You come across

docb...

You come across as someone who writes themselves alot of prescriptions for halucinagens.

Hate Rush Limbaugh Week - Again 

 

 

Making Fun of AGW http://giovanniworld.wordpress.com/  

For those paying attention

For those paying attention for these past few months, it's been clear Obama and company are running a low-rent campaign. Now, as more Americans begin to pay attention, it's obvious to any reasonable person. The attack on Limbaugh and stealing Gov. Palin's email are just the two most recent examples. There will be more. Nothing is sacred, nothing is off limits.

This is the tone Obama has set among his followers. No principles, no morality, anyone and anything is fair game. First Amendment rights? Out the window, Taking the high road? Ridiculous. Respect for the opinions of others? Don't be stupid. Change key policy positions? Whenever you have too, baby.

And this is what he will bring to the White House. This will be his contribution to the national dialogue as President. He will drive through the Constitution like a tank plowing through enemy lines, which, of course, is exactly what the US Consitution represents to Obama. And the MSM will applaud him all the way.

As everyone has said here many times: Obama is a very very dangerous person.

The major media report only half the news. Why are they surprised they have only half the potential audience?

Here is the April 6, 2006

Here is the April 6, 2006 Rush Morning Update in question:

 

 

http://www.youtube.c...

sean robins
blog.seanrobins.com

Thanks, sean, I hadn't

Thanks, sean, I hadn't seen/heard that.

It is obvious that the Obama campaign listened up until Rush said "Shut up or get out!" and then ran off in glee to create their ad, failing to hear him explain that those were Mexico's laws! Either that or they don't care.

This is an absolute replay of the "phony soldiers" controversy.  All we need is Dingy Harry on the floor of the Senate denouncing him again!

Rush didn't say it, but I

Rush didn't say it, but I will:

Barry, shut up AND get out!  You're not only "unskilled and stupid", but inexperienced, treasonous, and left of "Uncle" Joe Stalin to boot. You want change? Change your address to Kenya.  Problem solved. Punish your father's country with your unfortunate birth, not ours.

How do you fight such

How do you fight such mean-spirited, hate-filled beings who have no shred of decency nor any compunction to try to tell the truth without stooping to their depths?

This campaign is not about

This campaign is not about race, it's about the USE of race.

Kathryn Jean Lopez at NRO

Kathryn Jean Lopez at NRO has a great column about this ad and Obama Lies  and strongarm tactics, and how they just might backfire on him.

Looking for a Stupid Job?

Look no further, the DNC is now hiring community organizers. Positions available: Tire slashers, RNC window breakers, and voter registration filler outers. 

What about how the MSM and those on left who use the argument, "Immigrant's (Illegal) are doing jobs that American's won't or refuse to do."?

That is insulting on all fronts. 

I can't wait to hear Rush

I can't wait to hear Rush school this little twerp! 

Hey, Obama, I dare you to go on Rush's show and debate him one on one!  You wouldn't last 3 minutes!

Heck, I'll debate you, for that matter....

What an ignorant dwonk!

I can't wait to hear Rush

so good I posted it twice...

"Unfortunately, too many

"Unfortunately, too many media outlets are allowing these lies to stand unchallenged."

I really don't believe the perveyors, or repeaters/reporters of these lies really care a whit about truth and genuinely (as much as they are about anything) don't know what the excitement is about. If a message furthers their aims, it must be a good thing.  Truth is irrelevent.  As Rush said of Bill Clinton (if memory serves me correctly) by being unconcerned with truth, he freed himself to dispense any information he wanted.  He could move and function and act or react totally unconstrained by the confines of fact of truth, thus liberating and freeing himself to be as creative and deceitful as he wanted and to feign surprise when challenged. 

I firmly believe the same can be said of Obama and his shills, whichever rock they slithered out from under.  Truth to them is whatever they say or want it to be as long as it promotes or advances their singleminded goal - the destruction of the USA. 

And I will say that last Friday when I heard about the ad that ridiculed John McCain for not using e-mail, I was more disgusted than I have ever been by the ghastly slug that is Obama.  Anyone, whether they are a conservative or an American-loving democrat (assuming there is such an animal) who watched the video about John McCain's experience in Hanoi and is not moved to admiration, respect, or grief is an absolute pig and doesn't deserve to shovel excrement from honest grass eating bovine, never mind run for President of the United States.  I will not vote for this disgusting and vile vermin and I will probably stop speaking to anyone I know who does (fortunately that is a small number of annoying acquaintances anyway).

"Let every soul be subject unto the higher powers. For there is no power but of God: the powers that be are ordained of God."  - Paul (Rom. 13:1) 

The liberal media drools

The liberal media drools all over itself whenever there is anything negative said about Rush. I say... "give em hell Rush"!

Hate Rush Limbaugh Week - Again

  

 

Making Fun of AGW http://giovanniworld.wordpress.com/  

El Rushbo will be fightig

El Rushbo will be fightig back...they made a big mistake taking him on.

La-La-Land leftists are such fools.

 "America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh

why make the comment in the

why make the comment in the first place???...there is an old political saying...never give your opponents the stick to hit you with...and that guy is always handing out louisville sluggers!!!!!

»→ My Muslim Faith

Let's be fair!  When Barack Obama said:

"You’re absolutely right that John McCain has not talked about my Muslim
faith
."

Obama was really proclaiming his Muslim Faith.  It wasn't a gaffe or a joke, he was serious, and it wasn't until Stephanopolis reminded him of his surroundings that Obama adapted his statement to his audience.

We've observed this before with his statement about "bitter , clinging to guns and religion"

This is the kind of politics Obama is using against Limbaugh and McCain.

Somebody needs to educate John McCain in the "Chicago Way".  Perhaps a private showing of "The Untouchables"

"Us white folk will take care of you" - Barbara Walters