Conn. Paper: Tired of Attacking Palin, Attacks 'Angry' Town of Wasilla Instead


This one has got to take the cake for stupidity and lack of journalistic integrity. The Old Media has been gyrating in ever widening circles to find new and unheard of ways to destroy Governor Sarah Palin and now from the Hartford Courant (Connecticut) we find the most ridiculous one yet. With this Robert Thorson column we have now gone from slandering Gov. Palin herself, to attacking every last member of her family -- including her Down Syndrome child, Trig -- to this latest stop on the smear Palin express: attacking Palin's hometown Wasilla, Alaska. Thorson seriously tries to make us believe that Wasilla is an "angry" town! Why? Because of its "geography." And because of something that happened in 1976.

Yes, Wasilla is filled with "disappointed" and "angry" people and this is what "scares" Thorson about Governor Sarah Palin. And Thorson knows that everyone in Wasilla is foaming at the mouth mad because of his intimate knowledge of Wasilla and it's people, right? He knows this because of his extensive research into Wasilla's newspapers, or TV reports, or interviews with citizens all of whom are telling him about their mental perturbation, right? Uh, no. He "knows" this because of an Encyclopedia entry and little else.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Thorson gives us the sad tale of a Capitol move gone wrong and posits that this has made Wasilla a town of crazies, losers, and trouble makers, a dangerous place that he obviously thinks might give us a dangerous vice president. Thorson tells us that in 1974 Wasilla was chosen to be Alaska's new capital city because the original capitol, Juneau, is not easily accessible. But the big move ended up not happening because by 1976 the voters of Alaska decided not to foot the one billion dollar price tag to pay for it all.

Because of this failed 1974 initiative, Robert Thorson seems to imply that Governor Sarah Palin is mentally unfit to be vice president and all her fellow citizens in Wasilla are damaged goods.

Of course, we have reason to doubt Thorson's opinion right off the bat -- and I say opinion because there is little by way of fact to support his supposition in this story. We understand his seething hatred of Governor Palin with his very first sentence. (My bold)

The media attention on Alaska's governor has been torrential. Not wanting to give her any more attention, I'll focus on the geography that shaped her character.

Next, while describing the history of the attempted Capitol move, Thorson takes a swipe at the size of Alaska's voting population. He says of those who voted for the Capitol move that the number was a "whopping total of 46,659 souls." Need I remind you that this guy lives in the giant, heavily populated state of... Connecticut!? There are 3.5 million citizens in all of Connecticut. For a little perspective, in the City of Los Angeles there are 3.8 million people. Thorson has no place to talk about tiny populations.

Then, because the Capitol move died still born, Thorson somehow divines that should it have succeeded Palin would not have gotten where she is today. And he makes absolutely no attempt to prove his case or explain his claim, either.

Thorson scoffs at the 1976 decision not to move the Capitol because the costs would have been such a "small fraction" of what Alaska had in the bank.

But for a small fraction of the money Alaska has in the bank, the history of Wasilla would have turned out very differently, and the present governor would probably not have been the governor or the republican vice presidential candidate.

Why it is that Palin "would probably not" have been Governor and the VP pick, we are left to wonder because he makes no attempt to explain it. He just says it as if it is fact.

So, since the Capitol didn't get moved to Wasilla, Thorson thinks everyone in Wasilla is angry still to this day.

Expectations were crushed, leaving a sense of disappointment, even anger. High school sports would substitute for political excitement. Pentecostal and Bible-banging congregations would offer succor, becoming a dominant influence in an isolated town in an isolated state with libertarian leanings and an isolated state capital.

One can almost feel Thorson about to say that he thinks the people of Wasilla are bitter and cling to their religion and guns.

But, how does Thorson know any of this? Did he conduct interviews? Has he given us multiple examples from newspaper stories from Wasilla that tells us of this anger and disappointment? Is there proof of this claim? Who knows? We sure don't. At least, not from the complete lack of evidence that Thorson presents. All we really end up with is Thorson's say so.

So what is the upshot as far as Thorson is concerned?

This is the kind of geography that scares me, in spite of Wasilla's stunning natural beauty and vibrant, outgoing personality.

This "geography" is enough to "scare" him? If this isn't the most incoherent, uninformed, substance free attack on Sarah Palin, I have yet to see it.

Finally, what are Thorson's qualifications for all this wild speculation and partisan talking points? What makes him replace the hard work of actual investigation and old fashioned newspaper leg work with simple, unsupported supposition? Is he a clinical psychologist? Is he an historian? Has he been to Wasilla, met its citizens?

No, none of that.

He is a professor of geology at the University of Connecticut's College of Liberal Arts and Sciences.

How's THAT for qualifications?

And he has the gall to question Palin's? Worse, he questions her mental balance!

Some may wonder if Robert Thorson might want to engage the readers in a discussion about his complete lack of any journalistic integrity? If so, he can be reached at profthorson@yahoo.com. Let him know I said, "Hey."


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Oh: HE Lived there in 1974!!! So he's an expert!!!!

Thorson missed the point: it would have cost a <best Dr. Evil voice> BILLION dollars to move it!

Liberals wimper that there was money in the bank so lets spend it! But Liberterians (like he mentioned all Alaskans have a streak of) don't LIKE government spending money.

And then he breaks into people in Wasilla are clinging to religion and guns because of it.

I assume all his tests are multiple choice...

Right

Because he lived in Alaska back in the 70s when he was a youngster, he KNOWS all about Wasilla's bitterness!

He must be a very sensitive guy....

Cause I've lived in Alaska since 56...lived in Wasilla now for about 4 years and have missed the bitter side of folks around here altogether.

I think mebbe this twits thinkin' of some other Wasilla.  The one in his tiny overworked imagination perhaps.

Isolated town?  I dunno...we have roads and everything...even an airport or two or three or four.  And of course lots of landing strips all over the damn place for the numerous private planes.

Isolated state?  Uh...Anchorage...air crossroads of the world. Modern port facilities at the oceans edge.  Why we even have satellite TV and the internet!  Twit.  isolated my ass...

What's isolated is his tiny lonely brain cell.

Happy Trails...

this is just another attempt

this is just another attempt to get obama elected
and it's huge news believe me
i am quickly running out of pity for these lefties

PHILLY...

If this Robert Thorson is right about why the city of Wasilla is angry, because the plan to move the Alaska state capitol to Wasilla was snuffed out. Could I then assume that Philedelphia has become an angry & violent city because it was once the nations capitol, but it left in 1800. Could this a major reason that Philly is 1 of the toughest, meanest, & most murderous cities in the USA? If I was Robert Thorson, I might think so. I think it's because the city of Philedelphia is run by a corrupt Demacratic party machine with mob ties with more then a bit of group politics.

I see Wasilla & it's people as normal & happy people. Those who are angry since the city of Wasilla hit the news a couple of weeks ago are the libs who are frantic about the fact that John McCain picked Sarah Palin as his VP, & it's looking like that may sink Obama once & for all. Thorson, like the rest of the MSM, sees that the Obama campaign & the Dems don't have a clue how to fight McCain-Palin without looking bad. So Thorson, along with the MSM, feel THEY have to try to sink McCain-Palin, her in particular. They are doing more harm then good to Obama's cause, & I suggest they KEEP IT UP.

 

"...it's still We The People, Right?"  Megadeth 

an isolated town in an

an isolated town in an isolated state ....

An isolated town?  I thought he said they considered moving the Capital to Wasilla because Juneau was isolated!  Why would they move it from one isolated town to another?

That'st the beauty of leftists when they argue.  They cheerfully contradict themselves from one paragraph to another without batting an eyelash.

Grasping at straws.....no flimsy criticism left unspoken.

hilarious

That one escaped my eye! Of COURSE his silliness is overwhelming. Good one, Motherbelt.

What else

Does one expect from THE MOST left leaning "newspaper" in the People's Republic of CT-Stan which many critics have labeled The Hartford Koran't.

 

On the other side of the spectrum, there is The Waterbury Republican-American.  Take it from someone who has lived in the million-dollar milqtoast marxist enclave of Greenwich most of his 34 years...AND HATING IT.  My paper the Greenwich Time is just an extension on the Koran't especially on editorials. The Rep-Am features some incredible local editorials and comments from conservatives like Charles Krauthammer, Mona Charen and George Will

 

Growing up middle class in a town known for opulence and excess, our family may as well be considered poor!

 

Speaking of Krauthammer, who created the phrase Bush Derangement Syndrome, the corporate fascist media is suffering from what some will call, if not done so already Palin Derangement Syndrome.  Believe me, the media was the first in on this, thencome the silver spoon socialists in Hollywood!

Total poppycock!

The only thing scary about this article, is HIM!  

ROTFLMAO!!!!

This is it??!!! This is all the angry left can come up with?

Oh, they are DOOMED in November!

I know of a couple of moderate "swing voters" who are planning to vote for McCain/Palin simply becasue they are pissed at all the smears and cheap-shots that the media have taken against Palin since her nomination.

 

The day that "politician" became a career choice is the day we started losing the Republic. Let's get it back! Alan Keyes '08.

Wasillian madness

Those wascally wacky angwee Wasillians are going to be the death of us all.

"that was the trip of a lifetime to visit our troops in Kuwait and stop and visit our injured soldiers in Germany" - Sarah Palin

Robert Thorson's Being a Geologist...

is not the problem, here.  [OK, I am biased as a Geologist and as a Geology teacher, albeit at a junior college.]  BTW, to those outside of this field, Geology is the study of the Earth (and its processes and history), not just rocks.

Yes, despite their science backgrounds and supposed practice of logic, Geologists can be infected by liberalism.  It happens.  [I am dismayed by the number of blogging Geologists that buy into the Anthropogenic Global Warming hoax, when carbon dioxide constitutes just 0.038% of the atmosphere.]

I haven't yet read the Thorson piece nor have I looked at any sort of archives to see if he regularly writes for this particular "news outlet".

If he had done his fieldwork/homework and backed up his assertions with facts (or at least learned opinions), he wouldn't seem such a dunce.  Maybe he is just looking for a "new angle of attack" not yet tried by "professional" journalists.

Geology and Geography are closely related (I have an unofficial minor in Geography as part of my M.S. degree), but his "geography judgements" seem clouded by his seeming "liberal" distain/disgust for small town residents.  Does he honestly believe this or has he adopted northeast, blue-state, academic ivory-tower attitudes to keep his job (or to gain favor) at his particular institute?

In summary, I would blame Robert Thorson's liberalism for his attitudes and journalistic failings, not his being a Geologist.

And I...

In summary, I would blame Robert Thorson's liberalism for his attitudes and journalistic failings, not his being a Geologist.

And I would blame his editor for allowing this junk to pass as a real article!!

Now Having Read Thorson's Column...

I primarily see his liberal bias [I haven't read any of his other columns] in the first two and the last two paragraphs.  And in his assertion about the citizens of Alaska not wanting to cough up the billion dollars for the move from Juneau to Willow.  But most of it is in his assertion that he didn't want to give Gov. Palin any more publicity.  That pretty much says it all.

[We don't know if the editors removed any other pertinent info or thoughts.  Maybe in their own zeal to "have a different angle", they decided to "fly with this".]

To me, the realities of Juneau being what they are, moving the state capital makes sense, but it would be a monumental hassle and knowing government, the $1 billion needed would grow.  Though just a short distance "as the crow flies", moving everything associated with state government would be a logistical nightmare (as would be finding everything after the move).

As to the Alaska citizens "being to blame" for not wanting to pay the $1 billion, I am sure that there are plenty of Juneau businesses (including ferries and airlines) that would suffer if the state capital moved inland.  They could have played just as much a role in the decision.

As for Wasilla, for every speculator that got burned, I am sure that there is a resident that is glad that the hassles of the state capital did not come to town.

I know what Thorsen is saying

Hey! I know the town of Kingston hasn't been the same since they changed New York's capital from Kingston to Albany over 200 years ago.

Those people in Kingston can hardly get up in the morning without vomiting!

Poor...

Those poor, poor, angry Kingstonians!!

Small Town Anger

I enjoyed the article regarding small town anger since it has provided us down here in New Zealand with many amusing examples of journalistic frustration. Sarah Palin has values that obviously don't mesh with the author's but that doesn't require, nor does it deserve, the liberal political element to castigate her so. It is amusing because of the ridiculous overreaction and then watching the rather childish competition amongst the those on the left in trying neutralize her effect on the opposition. She seems to be a breath of fresh air and has inserted a verve in an otherwise dull and boring two years of your election process.

What a complete liberal twit!

I would be extremely upset if I were paying this idiot my good money to teach my child geology. He obviously has no clue about how to apply the scientific method to everyday life and therefor I must conclude that he is clueless about it's application in his chosen profession.

These are the types of 'scientists' that give the others a bad name. I have no doubt that he is an avid member of the Anthropogenic Global Warming club since using old bad data and jumping to illogical and unfounded percipitous conclusions seems to be where his expertise lies.

UCONN has just been crossed of the list of possible colleges that my children can choose from.

 

The day that "politician" became a career choice is the day we started losing the Republic. Let's get it back! Alan Keyes '08.

I Do Not Wish to Defend Robert Thorson...

but what does the Scientific Method have to do with his column?

If he had written it, in an unbiased way, from the perspective of a "what if" piece on what Wasilla might have been, without the snarky attacks on Gov. Palin and Alaska citizens, I wouldn't see any significant problems.  I do not know his background, he may have had some Geography courses in his background.  As I mentioned earlier, the two disciplines are related.

[And I do agree that his is probably a Global Warming alarmist.]

If I decide to read more of his columns, my opinions may change.

»→ OTR

Maybe he's building a consensus.  It's all the rage among "scientists" these days.  They take a vote. 

"that was the trip of a lifetime to visit our troops in Kuwait and stop and visit our injured soldiers in Germany" - Sarah Palin

As a Follow-up...

On the subject of liberal condescension and snarky comments, what is with that travel guide that Thorson quotes?

From his column:

"Frommer's Travel Guide to Alaska describes Wasilla as "the worst kind of suburban sprawl of highway-fronting shopping malls and gravel lots.""

Anyone with a grain of sense knows that you don't insult potential customers.  Do they assume that they have no customers or potential customers in Wasilla? 

There are more diplomatic ways of saying the same thing.  Try "Persons seeking a small-town Alaska experience may be disappointed with the strip malls and gravel lots".

Maybe that is why Thorson selected that travel guide, as maybe they "speak his language".

C5, I think you summed it up

C5, I think you summed it up perfectly.

"What a complete liberal twit!"

That is about all that really needs to be said. Although the last two words are kind of redundant.

I completely understand where Mr. Thorson is

coming from. In 1847 our state (the 26th) moved the capital from one city to a different city. Since that time the original city has been so pissed off about it that there have been union riots, mafia hits, race riots, outrageous murder numbers, corrupt lying mayors (whom will soon do jail time) and numerous other things that people will always do when the Capital label is taken away from them. So yes, I think he was spot on with his reasoning and we should avoid Palin at all cost.

"I need more cowbell!" SNL

Stick to rocks, please.

From his 6-19-08 Courant column:

"I have a dream — that one day our freeways will be free of traffic jams, and that our exit ramp culture will have given way to one based on real communities that live together, rather than park together. Only then will I believe the price of gasoline is high enough. "

Sounds to me like he's pining to live in Wasilla. Just another angry, insulated Edu-lib. Stick to rocks, Professor - let the MSM handle the heavy lifting.

Gratuitous factoids: when

Gratuitous factoids:

When Palin was born, Alaska had only been a State for six (6) years.

When the Messiah came down to earth, Hawaii had only been a state for only two (2) years.

It's Palin by four! 

Yeah, Thorson is Infected

SickofLibs;

Thanks for doing that bit of homework.  Does Thorson have a lib girlfriend in the Journalism Dept. he is trying to impress with his writings?  Just wondering.

I think he is pining to live in Wasilla as he imagines it should be, in his lib utopia.  Once there, he would hate it just as much, if not more than he does now.

Just looking

Just looking at him, I'd suggest boyfriend instead of girlfriend.
;)

Ewwww.

For all the times I have done fieldwork with other geologists, I am glad that situation hasn't happened. Hey dude, this ain't Brokebutt Mt., get back in your own tent!

That is why I always slept with a rockhammer beside me (just kidding).

I like words like...

I like words like "rockhammer."

Taken literally, it could mean one of a number things...

1) a hammer made for rocks
2) a hammer made of rocks
3) a hammer used in rock music
4) a hammer made by rocks

Thanks Norm Crosby
;)

The Answer Would be "1"

2 would be too brittle. 

3 would damage the drums or other instruments.  And unless you have some pieces of slate or some thinly-sliced rocks, rocks generally don't have much of a ring to them.  We try things like that when we are bored and/or drunk (after the day's work is done).  I believe "The Far Side" had a cartoon addressing primitive rock music made by cave men.

4 would be an interesting interpretion as rocks are to be beaten and broken with a rock hammer, how would a rock modify such a tool?  Would it make it out of aluminum or cover it with velvet to soften the blows against its fellow rocks?  Or would it make it out of wood to make it hurt even less?

Well, how 'bout

Alright, smart guy. How 'bout this one:

Baby Food

1). It's little food
2). It's food made for babies
3). It's food made of babies

Take THAT one!

capitol move

I was told when I was up there that the reason they kept Juneau  the capitol was the very fact it was hard to get in and out of.  The natives told me that they figured if could keep the politicians bottled up in one spot they would be easier to keep an eye on.

Good Point!

Libs would have a problem with that assertion, also.

The Left's Paranoia

The left's paranoia is about rural America. It cracks me up. I have some very liberal friends. I have spent the last decade traveling throughout my adopted home state of Kentucky.

My liberal friends ask me things like, "don't you get scared working with those people by yourself?"

I've offered to take them with me to some of the places I work, but they refuse. They are scared to death to get off the interstate highways and would never stop at a crossroads general store to get some RC colas and Moon Pies (I've had some of my most enlightening political discussions over that combination). They are convinced that I'm going to turn up dead as the result of gunshot wounds.

I have a co-worker who gets nervous when he sees a pickup with a NRA sticker in the window (he's unable to set foot on my property).

The irony is that they have no fear of another terrorist attack. They fear their fellow Americans, but they see no threat from Islamic terrorists.

They have the nerve to imply that I'm paranoid. I always quote Frank Burns to them: "I'm only paranoid because everyone is against me." They don't see my point. They are the ones who are paranoid.

This dope from Connecticut exposes the left's paranoia.

When Barry Hussein made his statement to the gathering in San Francisco about us "clingers" in the rural area, I wasn't surpised in the least. Those comments are completely consistent with people on his side of the political divide.

That presumption on the left is not lost on rural America, either. We know how we are perceived in the cities and on the coasts, and voters in these regions consider that when they cast their ballots. I've always used Kentucky as a bell-weather state when it comes to politics. If it is a bell-weather state this year, Barry is going to get creamed.

Excuse me. I've got to go cling to my guns and Bible for the rest of the day.

Years Ago,...

while attending UT El Paso geology grad school, I had a Jewish roommate from Brooklyn.  All he knew of my native Georgia were the movies "Macon County Line" and "Deliverance". 

When he and his relatives went to Florida, they only left I-95 for gas, being afraid they might take a wrong turn and wind up in the sequel to one of these movies.

I have a similar paranoia about entering big northern cities without a guide.

While we shared an apartment, after he tormented me with his Jazz Crusaders albums, I would torment him with Charlie Daniels.  Actually we got along pretty well.  We just kidded around a lot.

When I would absent-mindedly say - "Hey Steve, I'm going to Burger King, want a cheeseburger?", he would chuckle and say "It is not the ways of my people" and I would remember about the milk and meat thing.  I was glad that he wouldn't get offended over little things like that.

Wondering,

Does a thimble brained jester like this actually get paid when the editors botch their jobs.

What did he get for this tripe? $30? $50? $200?

Another example of cuckoo for cocoa puffs

Yes, Wasilla is filled with "disappointed" and "angry" people and this is what "scares" Thorson about Governor Sarah Palin

How could any sane person, comparing the day to day demeanor of the Dalibama and Sarah Palin, come to the conclusion that Palin is the one that is angry? Do you think Thorson has any idea who Odumba sleeps with or who he listens to at church?

Alaska the Beautiful

I spent two weeks in Anchorage Alaska sixteen years ago and I found the place to be very beautiful and breathtaking. I also discovered that Alaskans are very proud of their roots and their state. If anything, I found them similar to Texans in a sense that when you mess with one, you mess with all. There is unity there and divergence of cultures, adding to its flavor. This writer conveniently lumps all people in Wasilla in a mold that was cast by all the MSM and BO in his infamous angry "people clinging to their guns and bibles" [paraphrased quote]. A slippery slope of an argument if there was one.

Thanks Wasilla,

for standing up to this onslaught. Hope you're all " bitterly clinging to your guns and Bibles"

What is Thorson et al thinking? This article sounds like the spoutings of an elitist who knows nothing about the people he's writing about.

Really makes you want to support his side of the ticket doesn't it? These people have no clue what small town America is like