AP Claims Discrimination Against Mexicans in Illinois, Offers NO Proof

Photo of Warner Todd Huston.
By Warner Todd Huston | November 28, 2007 - 04:40 ET

According to the Associated Press, folks who are "foreign-born" are "newcomers" who "feel anything but welcome" in the Chicago suburb of Waukegan, Illinois. The AP piece leads the reader to imagine that several of the town's laws have been specifically written to chase out Mexicans and that the immigrant community (legal or otherwise) in Waukegan is feeling pressure to get out. Yet, upon close examination of this AP piece, one cannot help but realize that the AP does not offer any statistics to prove that Mexican residents are leaving in any numbers, they don't cite any rise in arrests of Spanish speakers there to indicate possible harassment, nor do they even quote anyone to "prove" their contention but one Yolanda Torrez, a lawyer who specializes in criminal, DUI traffic violations, Social Security and DWL traffic violations cases for Spanish-speaking clients. In the final analysis, the AP offers no proof whatsoever that "foreign-born" residents are afraid or truly being discriminated against at all. They just state it as a fact using a single, biased person's words to assert it.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

After a description of the "sailboats" that gently float in nearby Lake Michigan, and other panoramic language the AP piece goes on to describes how "Mexican groceries" and other ethnic businesses have grown in the suburban town. And then the AP begins the scare-mongering with a grave, "despite their numbers, the newcomers feel anything but welcome."

AP continues that grave tone with some claims that they make no real attempt to buttress with proof.

"Coexistence has been uneasy at best ever since Waukegan officials applied last summer for a program that would train two local police officers to enforce federal immigration law. The proposal prompted a massive downtown demonstration by immigrant rights' groups and a boycott of businesses that didn't post signs opposing the application."

And what is the basis of this claim of "uneasy" feelings?

"'You have thousands of people who are hardworking, who came and invested in this city. They're being chased away,' said Yolanda Torrez, an attorney born in Waukegan whose practice handles criminal, traffic and real estate cases.

She said Latino residents are understandably skeptical. A decade ago, the city settled a lawsuit with the Justice Department over a housing code that federal authorities alleged was aimed at Hispanic families. And, she said, Hispanic residents now feel targeted by a city ordinance that allows vehicles to be seized and a $500 penalty imposed if the driver lacks insurance or a license."

If that isn't "proof" enough, AP allows Torrez to assure us that, "she's heard of Latinos who have broken their leases and moved away, and of stores that cater to immigrants that have seen sales slip."

And that was the beginning and end of the "proof" in this AP piece. Well, gosh, AP, if our unbiased friend, Torrez, who makes her living off of lawbreakers from the lowest rung of society says that all Waukegan's Mexicans are feeling oppressed... well, it must be true!

For one thing, and not that the AP reports this, but Alderman Larry TenPas is reported as having told a community group, "We had some activists there that stirred people up. They went around to all the stores; put signs in the stores, 'Don't shop here.' And it backfired. The sales tax still went up. It was a bad move." So, the AP's claim that businesses have lost business seems untenable.

Then the AP report goes on to attack various laws and ordinances that are purportedly anti-immigrant in the eyes of people like Torrez.

She said Latino residents are understandably skeptical. A decade ago, the city settled a lawsuit with the Justice Department over a housing code that federal authorities alleged was aimed at Hispanic families. And, she said, Hispanic residents now feel targeted by a city ordinance that allows vehicles to be seized and a $500 penalty imposed if the driver lacks insurance or a license.

The federal immigration enforcement program was created in 1996, but the first agency didn't join until 2001. Now, about 28 municipal, county or state law enforcement agencies currently take part, and the Department of Homeland Security has applications pending from approximately 75 more.

And the article discusses the ICE immigration training claiming that it is a reason that Waukegan's residents are feeling persecuted. Not surprisingly, there is one other statistic that the AP doesn't seem to want to highlight. According to Doug Heaton of the Assoc. for Legal Americans, "Based on the foreign-born population in Waukegan and research by Pew Hispanic Center, one out of 10 people in Waukegan is an illegal alien. Doing nothing is not an option." So, Waukegan has a reason to want to assist Federal authorities in getting rid of criminals who also happen to be illegal aliens.

Buried at the tail end of the story is the words of Waukegan city officials who say they never intended to use the immigration training to make immigration raids.

"Waukegan Mayor Richard Hyde and Biang have pledged that the city's new authority won't be used for immigration raids, and that illegal immigrants stopped by police for minor infractions, such as not wearing a seat belt or a broken tail light, won't get caught up in the measure.

Instead, they say they want to ensure that immigrants convicted of felonies -- such as rape, murder, drug and gang crimes -- are on the deportation path as soon as possible.

'I don't think even people here illegally, just getting by, doing their jobs, are going to object to that,' Biang said. 'It's their kids who are going to be the victims of drug dealers and drive-by shootings, along with everybody else's children.'"

In any case, the AP makes a lot of serious claims of racism against the city of Waukegan and makes no attempt at all to prove it. They simply state it as if it is all true and this is biased "reporting" at its worst.

It is, however, par for the AP's course.

Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

I guess if your AP all you

I guess if your AP all you have to do is write a story.Facts arent relevant.

And, she said, Hispanic

And, she said, Hispanic residents now feel targeted by a city ordinance
that allows vehicles to be seized and a $500 penalty imposed if the
driver lacks insurance or a license.

How dare they target people who are breaking the law!

That's discrimination and harrassment!

PS What does that big banner say? I can't make out the first three words.

The banner says:

The banner says:

"For the dignity and rights of the immigrants we are... America"

Right, right... they just

Right, right... they just come to this country and their voice should instantly outweigh those of people who have been born and raised here. [/sarc] I can't help but notice that gigantic mexican flag in the background dwarfing the American flag... kinda sums up their feelings, dontcha think?

www.rhjunior.com Great comics with a hefty dose of Christian and anti-nutjob goodness.

"With your mind as high as Mt. Fuji you can see all things clearly. And you can see all the forces that shape events; not just the things near to you." -Miyamoto Musashi

not only that

but did you see the Che Gueverra flag nextto the mexican flag.

I am tired of these people, coming here and DEMANDED everything why ......because this is the United States of America....and if your a victim or just CLAIM to be a victim the world has to stop because the rich white men are holding you back

 

My wife was here illegaly 11 years ago, and we married 10 years later we have 3 kids ( my "step"-daughter was 2 when get got married and we have 2 boys together) 

 

so we know many people who are here illiegaly , and that didn't bother me much but my wife told me a family we know found a person to do ther taxes ( with fake SS#'s) and they did their back taxes for the last 3 years and got a refund of $18,000. 

 

needless to say that pissed me off.  I know the aurgument "they worked for the money it's their's" well they way I look at it is it's a small price you people pay to be here.   

 

what can I do about this, this can not go on, I am fed up with them wanting the world from the USA. 

What can you do?

Turn them and their tax preparere in to the IRS. Using a fake ssn is illegal, and cheating on your taxes will get the IRS on you.

They are more interested than the immegration people.

 

yeah, they ought to be ashamed.

I've said it before and I'lll say it again. I'm soooo suprised.

"We don't want to confuse you with facts. Here is what you should think."

AP

Its not just the AP its most of the msm, they have no integrity, just a agenda!

I think there is

I think there is discrimination, but it's not necessarily a bad thing. Liberals have spent decades pushing the notion that ALL discrimination is bad.

How about discrimination against those who violate our immigration laws, and especially those who commit crimes?

These idiot leftists are creating a powder keg, and it probably doesn't occur to their stupid, stupid minds (STUPID!).

What is going on in Paris as we speak? Millions of unassimilated, jobless immigrants are rioting in the streets.

What would happen if our economy takes a downturn and all the jobs dry up? Will all these illegal aliens pack up and go home? Or will they resort to rioting and crime? The national consciousness would become extremely angry. And then there would be a huge reactionary backlash against all immigrants, where even peaceful people will get hurt.

See my comment above: How

See my comment above:

How dare they target people who are breaking the law!

I would dearly love seeing

I would dearly love seeing a law pushed through making entering this country without using the proper channels a federal felony. Fat chance of that ever happening, though...

www.rhjunior.com Great comics with a hefty dose of Christian and anti-nutjob goodness.

"With your mind as high as Mt. Fuji you can see all things clearly. And you can see all the forces that shape events; not just the things near to you." -Miyomoto Musashi

Here is the real issue

Illegal aliens feel discriminated against because once they are able to sneak into this country and find work illegally, they are constatly forced to comply with other laws and regulations or be found out. They feel that they are special and should not be forced to get a driver's license or car insurance because they are not "legal" and shouldn't have to jump through all the hoops that legal residents and immigrants and citizens have to.

"...And, she said, Hispanic residents now feel targeted by a city ordinance
that allows vehicles to be seized and a $500 penalty imposed if the
driver lacks insurance or a license."

Explain to me how that ordinance "targets" Hispanics or Latinos or Mexican/Americans or whatever they are referring to themselves as this month?



The day that "politician" became a career choice is the day we started losing the Republic. Let's get it back! Fred08.com

That is the perfect

That is the perfect picture, “We are America” as the Mexican flag flies above it..

Hey all I can say is if you don’t like how you are being  treated here: go home.

It’s like some one stealing a TV from Wal-mart, then  demanding the extended warranty…

 

 

These are the boys of Pointe du Hoc. Ronald Reagan- 40th Anniversary of D-Day

AP = Always Preposterous.

Wah wah wah --- even if it's true, which I seriously doubt, so what?

My immigrant ancestors were labeled with ethnic slurs of various kinds, told not to bother applying for particular jobs, viewed with suspicion...etc.

Did they whine about it?  No they just went about their business and lived their lives and built a foundation for future generations.  They were proud to consider themselves Americans even though other Americans treated them like scum...

Today's "immigrants" are treated like needy children...and the ones the crAP is talking about are here ILLEGALLY!!!  Sheeesh!

I'm sure.

And, she said, Hispanic residents now feel targeted by a city ordinance
that allows vehicles to be seized and a $500 penalty imposed if the
driver lacks insurance or a license.

 

Thank the Lord I'm not Latino. They are the only ones who can be caught by this obviously unjust fake law.

 

Right!

I Love it when they wave

I Love it when they wave their giant foreign flags and Che pictures. These are exactly the images that will stir up what little bit of patriot is left in many American.