I don't anticipate that those in the UK who are rushing to the defense of their precious National Health Service (NHS) will be bringing up the item that follows any time soon, nor do I expect the U.S. statist heath care cheerleaders to take note of it.
The UK Daily Mail tells us that NHS is importing general practitioners who commute from foreign countries. Wait until you see the reason why, and the effect it has had on patient care.
Here are key paragraphs from the report by Rebecca Cambers:
The huge extent to which the NHS needs foreign doctors to treat patients out of hours is revealed today.
A third of primary care trusts are flying in GPs from as far away as Lithuania, Poland, Germany, Hungary, Italy and Switzerland because of a shortage of doctors in Britain willing to work in the evenings and at weekends.
The stand-ins earn up to £100 an hour, and one trust paid Polish and German doctors a total of £267,000 (about $441,000 -- Ed.) in a year, a Daily Mail investigation has found.
It raises fresh concerns that British patients are being treated by exhausted doctors without a perfect command of English.
.... The figures come months after an investigation was launched into the conduct of a German doctor after two patients died on his first shift in Britain.
.... (A) Nigerian-born doctor (based in Germany) injected 70-year-old kidney patient David Gray with ten times the maximum recommended dose of morphine, and an 86-year-old woman died of a heart attack after Ubani failed to send her to hospital.
The NHS is having to rely on doctors from overseas because a lucrative new contract for British GPs has resulted in more than 90 per cent opting out of responsibility for their patients in the evenings and at weekends.
Despite doing less, their pay has soared by 50 per cent to an average of almost £108,000.
Responsibility for out-of-hours cover has now passed to primary care trusts.
A different Daily Mail piece from August 20 tells us the following:
.... the controversial contract .... saw the pay of practice-owning GPs increase by 50 per cent over four years, to an average of almost £108,000 (about $178,000), even though they are now working seven hours a week less.
Meanwhile the rise for salaried GPs, who work longer hours, has been just 10 per cent to £54,000 on average.
That second Daily Mail piece reports that the salaried GPs want to form a "breakaway union." So in case you didn't know that even doctors who own their own practices are unionized under the NHS, now you do.
Back on point: What in essence happened is that NHS cut a deal with its unionized in-country GPs that was so favorable to the GPS that they stopped doing what they had been doing. Rather than attempt to go back to the docs and try to solve the problem, NHS bureaucrats took the easy way out, spending lots of taxpayer money for expensive, imported temps. In some cases, not surprisingly, they haven't vetted their commuters very well.
Say what you will about our the imperfections of the current health care system in the U.S. -- and yes, there are many -- it's almost inconceivable that it could have produced a widespread bureaucratic screw-up in the provision of primary care such as this. But with a statist health care regime in place, even if run by the allegedly best, brightest, and most noble (which, sadly, would be far from the case under ObamaCare, based on the presence of the likes of Ezekiel Emanuel) botches like the one described here are likely to become a standard feature, as is the case with NHS -- which, as seen here, has a long, long history of wide-ranging problems.
Cross-posted at BizzyBlog.com.
—Tom Blumer is president of a training and development company in Mason, Ohio, and is a contributing editor to NewsBusters




















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
I'm not sure if this is
August 25, 2009 - 07:19 ET by dmntd1I'm not sure if this is more damning to the concept of Universal Health Care, or to the concept of unions. Either way, their both a bane of my existence!
WE THE PEOPLE of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare,
Imported Doctors
August 25, 2009 - 07:20 ET by nyyankee55Of course we're going to have imported doctors in America, we already have an imported President and co-president George Soros
I visited a website that was
August 25, 2009 - 07:34 ET by billbI visited a website that was dedicated to dental implants. On one UK site, the patient goes in for a consult locally, but must travel to Hungary for the procedure! The wesite is complete with travel arrangements and reservation help. Sort of Travelocity/Implants
bill ~ Medical tourism
August 25, 2009 - 07:56 ET by BlondeWe have an on-going Forum on socialized health care going over on the forums. A while back, I found a great article at American Thinker about socialized medicine and medical tourism:
I thought it was worth re-posting, here. Hope you enjoy it.
I hope he fails, too.
5 o'clock
August 25, 2009 - 08:04 ET by sevenThe doc can walk out at 5-o'clock and leave his patient in stirrups. What is the problem? Medicine can take on a union mindset.
Read this about the same issue in Canada...
August 25, 2009 - 08:47 ET by jazboCanada's Immigration Ministers and members of Canada's immigration industry like to tell Canadians that many highly qualified immigrants are doing a type of work far below their level of education. A favourite example they cite is the legendary "doctor" who is driving a taxi.
In the case of disputes over credentials, critics have pointed out that a tiny fraction of the immigrants who come here are involved in certification issues. Most immigrants who come to Canada have very low qualifications.
In the case of the legendary "doctor" driving a taxi, Canadians would be shocked to learn of some findings of Ontario medical schools entrusted with examining the qualifications of immigrants applying for M.D. certification in Ontario in 2004.
Although a small umber of applicants did well on both written and clinical exams, the results for most were not flattering. The findings point to the problem of undermining Canadian professional standards in order to pander to immigrant doctors and other immigrant voters.
For those who may not have seen the reports, here are some important observations by Ontario medical schools in 2005:
(1) About half of 1088 immigrants applying for MD certification in 2004 in Ontario did not pass the first (and basic) step in their bid to achieve MD status in Canada. This involved passing a written exam to determine their knowledge of medicine. A second step, involving clinical ability, resulted in even further failures. (Applicants also had to demonstrate proficiency in English and produce proof that they had a medical degree.)
(2) The quotas set by the Ontario government for about 200 International Medical Graduates per year were high and unrealistic and were placing pressure upon examiners to pass unqualified people. In 2004, only 165 out of the 1,088 original applicants (15%) got the spots, and only 14 were fast-tracked.
(3) Some examiners felt that they were being intimidated and that they could not object to the process. One examiner commented: "This is the underbelly of this politically correct movement. God forbid you express any clinical and scientific criteria to the process. These people will be passed through on the wave of political expediency. The government is playing a shell game with this and is likely to create a public health fiasco."
Below, Immigration Watch Canada provides a 2005 Windsor Star news article by reporter Doug Williamson. On the same issue, we also include a 2005 National Post Letter To The Editor from Dr. Henderson Lee, Assistant Professor, University of Toronto, Faculty of Medicine, Department of Anesthesia, Toronto East General Hospital on a similar article which appeared in The National Post.
Both the article and the letter question the concept of "fast-tracking" which is commonly promoted by Canada's immigration industry. They also question the assumption that immigrants' professional qualifications equal those of Canadian professionals.
http://www.immigrationwatchcanada.org/index.php?module=pagemaster&PAGE_user_op=view_page&PAGE_id=634
"Democrats; Breeding voters like farm animals since 1962"
So really Canada's problem is the reverse
August 25, 2009 - 09:00 ET by c5thenThe real problem is the "taxi driver working as a doctor".
Now I see why so many liberals are pushing for the US to adopt a similar system. This could solve the access to health care problem and the illegal immigrant problem all at the same time.
How do you say "Cough" in spanish?
Throw 'da bums out!
no incumbent re-elected, with very few exceptions!
www.loyaltoliberty.com
No, read on... the taxi driver was a govt ruse. The real..
August 25, 2009 - 09:11 ET by jazboissue is unqualified doctors being foisted on the public from places where the doctors shake rattles and wear leaves for shoes.
"Democrats; Breeding voters like farm animals since 1962"
So goes the USA
August 25, 2009 - 09:46 ET by slickwillie2001Of course we will go this way, it's inevitable. The Bamster will open the immigration process to anyone with a medical degree in order to force down doctors' salaries. Don't tell me that socialists don't believe in the laws of supply and demand, they just pick and choose where to believe it.
And re unions, maybe our doctors should form a trade union; the AMA certainly is not working for them, and the Bamster and his ilk seem to hold unions up as some kind of model organization, over private business.
Obamacare can only work if doctors and hospitals are forbidden from transactions outside of Obamacare. No cash business allowed. That's what leads to medical tourism. It already happens, to India, Thailand and other countries. Offshore medical clinics will be a booming business in a few years.
Obamacare also requires
August 25, 2009 - 11:40 ET by AlanaObamacare also requires affirmative action for would-be doctors, rather than relying on their smarts or ability as prerequisites for medical school.
Which would, of course, result in people avoiding dark-skinned doctors in away they never did before. This would be unfair to the good, qualified doctors who happen to be of a different race.
But Obama simply has no understanding of either doctors or medicine. It's rare to have someone so ignorant of basic medical knowledge spouting off about it in the public eye, let alone as president.
Dr. Mother-in-Law?
August 25, 2009 - 10:52 ET by slickwillie2001Maybe the Bamster's mother-in-law can hang out a GP shingle based on her qualifications as a Doctor of Santeria. Why not?