AP: Tiller Murder Part of a 'String'; Abort Group's Own History Shreds Claim

Photo of Tom Blumer.
  • Bookmark and Share

TillerAbortionist0509Last night at about 8 p.m., the Associated Press's Roxana Hegeman became an early purveyor of the myth that abortion clinic-related violence and violence against abortionists has been a frequent and consistent occurrence during the past two decades when she wrote the following about the murder of Kansas abortionist George Tiller (saved here at host for future reference; bold is mine):

There was no immediate word of the motive (of) Tiller's assailant. But the doctor's violent death was the latest in a string of shootings and bombings over two decades directed against abortion clinics, doctors and staff.

But a look at the actual history of such violence accumulated by a pro-abortion group demonstrates that Tiller's murder is correctly seen as a horrible, isolated incident following a long, sustained decline in violence.

Here is the "History of Violence" accumulated by the National Abortion Federation (NAF), broken down into four categories:

Story Continues Below Ad ↓
  • Murder and shootings -- There were none since 1998 until Tiller was murdered on Sunday. From 1993-1998, seven abortion doctors or abortion clinic employees were killed, and 12 others were injured, many very seriously. One cowardly killing after 11 murder-free and shooting-free years following a period of seven in six years does not signal a trend by any reasonable definition.
  • Arsons and bombings -- Starting in 1976, NAF lists 13 such crimes during the remainder of that decade, over 75 during the 1980s, over 100 during the 1990s, and 16 since the turn of the century. Only six arsons took place from 2004-2008. The last arson listed at NAF's site occurred in December 2007. It should also be noted that arsons set by business owners in general to collect insurance money are not all that infrequent.
  • Butyric acid attacks -- Butyric acid is a clear, colorless liquid with an unpleasant, rancid, vomit-like odor. According to NAF, this clinic attack method was used "about 100" times from 1991-1998, and has not been employed since.
  • NAF lists over 650 antrax attacks and fake anthrax attacks from 1998-2002, and none since then. Over 550 of these occurred in 2001.

Overall, an "Extreme Violence" page at NAF listing activity from 1997-2007 identifies the following number of incidents per year:

AbortionExtremeViolencePerNAF1997to2007

As you can see, Rebecca Hegeman's alleged "string" has been broken twice in the past three years.

Abortion clinic violence and violence against abortionists has generally been on such a steep decline during the past decade that MSNBC stopped updating a web page dedicated to the topic in the late 1990s.

Without recounting already-known details, the unique specifics of Tiller's situation also supports the idea that his murder, which should of course be and I'm sure will be prosecuted to the full extent of the law, will more than likely not be a part of a new "string" of similar ones throughout the country.

Not that the establishment media types like the AP's Hegemen, the ever-opportunistic Obama administration, or far-left blogs will particularly care about these facts.

There's one more thing Ms. Hegemen forgot to note: The pre-born babies that George Tiller murdered were not available for comment.

Cross-posted at BizzyBlog.com.

—Tom Blumer is president of a training and development company in Mason, Ohio, and is a contributing editor to NewsBusters


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

A.P. stands for Abortion

A.P. stands for Abortion Propaganda.  This story is just part of the continued attempt by the pro-aborts to discredit the pro-life movement, but it won't work on any except the most idiotic.

"If all the pro-aborts had been aborted, there wouldn't be any pro-aborts." - Publius

One wonders if the press

One wonders if the press will similarly brand the Code Pink Protestors as responsible for the murder at the Arkansas recruiting station.

After all, they have spent the last eight years protesting at recruiting stations....

The Army Times is reporting

The Army Times is reporting the following:

LITTLE ROCK, Ark. — A man with “political and religious motives” killed a soldier just out of basic training and wounded another Monday in an attack on a military recruiting center, police said...

...Police arrested Abdulhakim Mujahid Muhammad, 23, along a crosstown interstate moments after the shootings at the Army-Navy Career Center in a shopping center in west Little Rock.

Muhammad acted alone, the police chief said, and based on an interview with officers, the suspect “probably had political and religious motives for the attack.” He lived in an apartment just 1½ miles from the recruiting center. A search warrant had been obtained for the apartment.

Thomas said Muhammad, previously known as Carlos Bledsoe, would be charged with first-degree murder, plus 15 counts of committing a terroristic act. Thomas said those counts result from the gunfire occurring near other people.

Anybody wanna bet that the nature of the crime is NOT laid out as an Islamic Fascism attack, but will rather be laid out as a economic crime?

More propaganda designed to

More propaganda designed to make it look like a white, right wing conspiracy of murder (total number of Doctors dead since 1988 = 8) is out there. Pushed far enough, this lie can cause numerous law abiding citizens to be harassed and even jailed. Now, where are the stories about the fantastically large numbers of murder victims killed by the following groups:

MS13

Crips

Bloods

Hell's Angels

African Americans (one of the most violent groups in America)

Illegal aliens

Various drug gangs

Oops, not right wing, not important.

D

Keep the ILLEGALS out, join NumbersUSA to send free faxes to your reps.

Deaths from drug overdoses

I just heard a huge number on the Bill Bennet show this morning that I wish I had written down. They started first with a large number of Heroin overdoses in Ohio then went on to give the number of total drug overdoses for the US. The number was astoundingly large.

More attention should be paid to promoting life.

Its takes a Democratic President

To get the right-ring kooks out of their caves. Fools.

7 abortion-related murders while Bill Clinton was President.

0 abortion-related murders while Bush was President.

Not 200 days in and we have ourselves our first right-wing abortion extremeist Janet Napolitano and Department for Homeland Security were worried about. They were right. Not surprising. Janet is a patriot and her report was spot freakin on. 

 

SayAnything

So, these items are related? What about the 2 recruiters that were just killed killed?

I think these numbers are related to a perception that the liberal governments are easier on criminals. Why do you think all of the tin-horn dictators are rattling their swords just now? The perception is that Obama will just let them sliiiiiiide.

Really? When the Secretary of Def. hasn't changed?

Sec. Gates and General. Petraeus actually agree with Obama in being anti-torture and closing gitmo. So its not policy that is making the toothless lion whine. Kim Jong-il is not healthy, he had a stroke and this isn't anything other than showin-off to his sadly ignorant citizens. China has put Korea on a tight leash as it is. Without China (as they provide the north with so much aid, food and fuel) North Korea is doomed. 

Yep

Sliiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiide!

That's what the "Apology Tour" was all about. We now have a love fest going on with the enemies of the U.S..

You ducked the point

You ducked the point regarding the recruiters....

Let's see -- eight ANTI

Let's see -- eight ANTI abortion related murders in 35 years. That's 8 deaths supposedly incited by antiabortion rhetoric.

Let's look at abortion advocacy rhetoric. That abortion is a fundamental right of women. That abortion benefits women and their families. That abortion is a responsible act. That abortion doesn't kill, it liberates. That there is no rational reason to object to abortion.

Murder is the number one cause of death of pregnant women. How many of those murders were incited by prochoice rhetoric, because the woman refused to "exercise her rights", refused to do the "responsible" thing, refused to do something there was supposedly no rational reason to object to?

 Does anybody have the stats? How many women's murders have been incited by prochoice rhetoric? 

"Let's see" the number you asked for

Women killed by pro-abort rhetoric - something in excess of 20 million in this country alone.

Hmm, lets see, 40 mil murdered babies to 8 so-called "doctors."

According to my vintage, trusty HP 11C reverse Polish notation calcumatatin' device, that is a ratio of 5,000,000 : 1.

Maybe Roxana's calcumatator is busted, but that sure don't look like much of a string to me.  

-Dave 

Lol

What you call an "apology tour" most people call diplomacy.

You know... its that thing Presidents do. To, ah, meet your allies and your foes.

 Bush was a pro at it. Just look at how chummy he got on his "apology tour."

http://media.photobu...

http://thelonggoodby...

http://www.sensorymo...

 

THe difference is that

THe difference is that Obama goes and says he believes we are a fundamentally bad country, have performed such evil tasks as set people free, and self flagillates us to boot.

Why, easy... He believes it.

Sayanything . . . .but the truth

Did you notice, Obama elected Illinois Senator, soon Illinois crime rates zoom, unemployment numbers zoom, taxes zoom, cost of living zoom, dropout rates zoom.

Obama elected President of the US, soon US crime rates zoom, unemployment numbers zoom, taxes zoom, cost of living zoom, dropout rates zoom.

D

Keep the ILLEGALS out, join NumbersUSA to send free faxes to your reps.