Name That Party: NBC Philly 'Forgets' Convicted Vincent Fumo and Associate Are Dems

Photo of Tom Blumer.
  • Bookmark and Share

VincentFumoPhillyPol0309Vincent Fumo's chronicle of corruption is extraordinary, even by the "standards" of Philadelphia, PA.

Thus, it's a journalistic fail that in a story about the convictions of former 30-year state senator Fumo and longtime associate Ruth Arnao, NBC Philadephia (HT Michelle Malkin) did not identify his or her Democratic Party party affiliation.

Here is a portion of NBC Philly's early-morning story:

Fumo Guilty on All Counts

Guilty is the verdict on all 137 counts for Vince Fumo in his federal corruption trail. His co-defendant Ruth Arnao is also guilty on all counts against her.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

It was standing room only as the verdicts were read, capping off a dramatic five-month trial and a dramatic morning.

Attorneys for both sides argued over whether Fumo was a flight risk. The government asked for Fumo's bail to be revoked saying he had a "strong incentive to flee." The judge decided not to revoke Fumo's bail and instead set a hearing for 2 p.m.

Fumo hugged his younger daughter, who was crying. He hugged his girlfriend, Carolyn Zinni, who was also in tears.

The man who once held arguably the most powerful political position in the state, now faces time in federal prison.

..... Fumo is guilty of defrauding the Senate, a charity and a museum of $3.5 million and with destroying evidence. He left the Senate last year after 30 years.

The trial, which started Oct. 22, featured more than 100 witnesses and 1,300 exhibits, made OPM a household acronym and gave us much more than a glimpse of Fumo's failed relationships as a friend and a father.

Taxpayers found out how their hard-earned money was being spent, at times, on dinners Fumo had with a former girlfriend. Her testimony revealed a power-hungry man with a sense of entitlement who often picked up the tab with "OPM," his acronym for "Other People's Money."

Fumo's and Arnao's party affiliations are also nowhere to be found in a Philadelphia Inquirer story ("Longtime Fumo associate Ruth Arnao guilty on all counts").

Most of the rest of the press seems to have done a better than average but far from perfect job identifying Fumo's party than has been seen in many other cases involving Democrats with criminal or ethical problems:

  • UPI.com mentioned Fumo's Dem affiliation in its second paragraph.
  • An initial four-paragraph report from the Associated Press mentions that Fumo is a Democrat in its final paragraph. A later report carried at a Nashville, Tennessee station's web site saves it for the final paragraph of five. Another AP item whose timing is undetermined has it in the third of five paragraphs. A fourth AP story carried at KDKA has a third paragraph with an odd post-conviction use of the present tense -- "The 65-year-old Philadelphia Democrat is charged with defrauding the senate, a nonprofit and a museum of more than $3.5 million, and destroying e-mail evidence."
  • Philly's Fox TV station ("Jurors Blast Fumo After Verdict") has it in Paragraph 2.
  • PennLive.com's story ("Fumo guilty charge brings ethics to the forefront") doesn't directly identify Fumo as a Democrat. Its 6th paragraph refers to a different Keystone State Democratc scandal, noting that "As news of the Fumo verdict broke, there were new developments in Bonusgate, too. In that scandal, Democratic house staffers are charged with spending working hours doing political work for the Democrats."
  • The Pittsburgh Tribune-Review waits until the seventh paragraph to describe Fumo as "once a powerful Democrat." Later in the story, the paper did a good "no comment" roundup ("Many lawmakers, particularly Senate Democrats, didn't want to talk about the verdict"), naming the names and flagging the party of Governor Ed Rendell and Senate Appropriations Chair Jay Costa.

The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette did the best job with the story of all those I reviewed.

Its headline ("Fumo, powerhouse of Pa. Dems, guilty") is the only one I saw with Fumo's affiliation, and it appears to have been the only publication to note that "Twice before, the former state senator and Democratic power had beaten criminal charges."

Though it goes a bit over the top at one point ("there was no escaping yesterday as jury forewoman Karen White delivered guilty verdict after guilty verdict, her words falling for 13 long minutes like dirt into a grave"), it importantly describes key elements of Fumo's claims and testimony, portraying an incredibly arrogant man who thought himself untouchable and made OPM (Other People's Money) a lifestyle -- something that in this case, considering how long his fellow party members tolerated his behavior, is properly associated with the Democrats.

Cross-posted at BizzyBlog.com.

—Tom Blumer is president of a training and development company in Mason, Ohio, and is a contributing editor to NewsBusters


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Other Peoples Money

If I were still a Republican [The GOP left me!], I would paint every Commiecrat in America with this OPM lable. I would morph every candidate into this guy's image! The slogan would be something in line with "They don't mind spending money as long as its other peoples money! Just ask convicted thirty year Democrat Senator Vincent Fumo! His girlfriend says he always picked up the tab because it was OPM[Other Peoples Money]." I'm only dreaming because just as Reach Across The Aisle McCain would not allow any of that negative campaigning, I'm sure the GOP [Gladly Out of Power] would think it to be "unstatesmanlike!"

Not to defend NBC-10, but,

Not to defend NBC-10, but, in Philadelphia, to say that someone is an elected official, is to say that they are a Democrat.

There are virtually no Republicans in elected office.

sean robins
blog.seanrobins.com

Only true reactionaries 

Only true reactionaries  would mention that the poor, unjustly convicted criminals were Democrats. They were probably framed by imperialist, capitalists dogs. Long live the Oligarchy comrades. Power to the (controllers that disburse our welfare checks so we can get high every night and sleep till noon and still get free money without working which is for suckers) people. The brave new world awaits.

Democrat Scandals

I will continue to say it.  The Democrat party is an organization of criminals posing as a political party.

I told my local paper when I cancelled it that the main

reason I was cancelling was because of incomplete stories  like this. They denied it. I sent them the clippings of all of the stories for one year..... No comment after that.

"I need more cowbell!" SNL

Republican Attack Machine's Fault.

But he had to keep all that money somewhere, so he must have had help from those "mean bankers." Yeah, that's it, those mean old, greedy bankers. And they probably invested it in big oil, and then they invaded Iraq to steal their oil, and then there's Haliburton, and Dick Chaney and then, and then, and.... It's Bush's fault!!!

 

Thanks for another great book Anne. I read these stories much differently now.

Of all...

The MSM's consistent and widespread refusal to label Democrats in trouble is absolute proof that liberal bias exists.  Likewise, the consistent and widespread practice of labeling any Republican in hot water, just further proves the point.

Let's face it, the end justifies the means when you have no ethics and it works.

 

MSM = PR firm for the Democrat Party

The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette is not a center-right newspaper.

It is a left-wing newspaper.  The Pittsburgh Tribune-Review is a center-right newspaper.

 

thx

..... removed the ref completely.

X

Tips for reading print media...if you must

If no political party is mentioned, then its Kommiecrat

If no race is mentioned, then the perp is black