GM's Auditor Issues 'Going Concern' Warning; Press Ignores Post-Bailout Sales Deterioration

Photo of Tom Blumer.
  • Bookmark and Share

GMsilverLogo0309.jpgAn early review of press coverage relating to this morning's warning by General Motors that "there is substantial doubt about our ability to continue as a going concern" shows no coverage of the reason why, despite $13.4 billion in taxpayer money (NOT counting bailout money going to GMAC), things have gotten so much worse so quickly.

The reason is that sales in the two full months since the Bush-approved, Obama-cheered bailout took place have tanked (see graphic at this NB post yesterday):

  • December 2008 (last [mostly] pre-bailout month) — down 31.2%
  • January 2009 (first full bailout month) — down 48.9%
  • February 2009 (second full bailout month — down 53.1%

Press reports I have seen are saying nothing about this frightening decay in the past 60 days:

Story Continues Below Ad ↓
  • An 8:22 a.m. CNN report by Chris Isidore and Ben Rooney only said that "sales .... have plunged more than 40% in recent months, (and) must rebound by next year if it is to survive."
  • An AP report during the 10:00 a.m. hour by Tom Krisher merely noted that "U.S. auto sales in February dropped to the lowest level since December 1981." Krisher did not tell readers that GM's February falloff was the worst of the six largest car makers. He also "helpfully" informed us that "sales volume .... dropped rapidly last year," staying silent about the past two months.
  • AFP, during the 9:00 a.m. hour, reported that "Other substantial risks to GM's survival include an inability to restructure its debt by June 1, a further collapse in global auto sales amid the deepening recession, the potential failure of key suppliers amid a collapse in auto sales and the success of GM's restructuring plan." There was nothing about how potential buyers might continue to shun the company because of its bailed-out status, either because of warranty or parts concerns, or because of philosphical objections to the bailout.
  • The Detroit News, in a not time-stamped report, has nothing about the last two awful months, but it does have this howler from an "expert" -- "The public, suppliers and people tied to the auto industry should not overreact, though, because the federal loans, Obama's economic-stimulus package and the automakers' restructuring plans will help salvage the industry, said Kimberly Rodriguez of the restructuring firm Grant Thornton LLP." Grant Thornton is surely involved in corporate restructurings, but it is in fact an "audit, tax and advisory organization."

The likelihood that GM can downsize itself to half it original size fast enough is obviously a lot lower than it would be if only a 30% scaleback were necessary. Whether accidental or deliberate, that's a fundamental point that reporters are totally missing.

While I'm in the neighborhood, perhaps someone here understands something I don't. It's mentioned in a couple of the articles cited. Here's the Detroit News's version:

GM has assessed and rejected the option of filing Chapter 11 bankruptcy, saying it would further hurt sales. The automaker also said it would need as much as $100 billion in government aid to operate after filing bankruptcy.

After shedding most of its liabilities in bankruptcy, why would GM even need any more government money? And if it really needs that much to become viable after a bankruptcy, how much more than that (no way it would be less) will it need to stay alive if it doesn't file?

A related post is at BizzyBlog.com.

—Tom Blumer is president of a training and development company in Mason, Ohio, and is a contributing editor to NewsBusters


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Most Evaded

I had to use Reuters 

JDW

DAILY WAVE

The government works for me, not the other way around

Nazi/Hitler/Treason

The admin and the complicit msm is setting this up to arrest Rush and try him, and don't think they won't.

This is only the beginning of the shutting down of dissent and religious freedom, including and especially Christian's. Remember this is all predicted in the Bible. 

Let Them Declare Bankruptcy.

Of course GM can't continue, the whole bailout deal was a scam from the get go. The government simply agreed, in principle, to pay GM's employees for them.

It's about time that the union and it's membership sees their jobs for what they are. Factory work. Try to find another factory that's paying it's workers $35 an hour plus benefits for unskilled labor. It doesn't take a brain surgeon to bolt a seat to a floor.

In their hey-day, when GM was one of only a handful of automakers, worldwide, making cars, they could get away with it. Not in today's global economy. I'm neither an economist nor an auto maker and I've seen this coming for years.

The greed of the unions and their membership will wind up costing them dearly. Good-bye jobs, good-bye pensions, good-bye GM. Too bad they couldn't see the forest for the trees.

 

GOING...GOING...GONE...

I have a feeling that General Motors or Chrysler, OR BOTH, will be gone by the next general election. Maybe a few things from either GM or Chrysler will survive, if there are people willing & able to invest in what Detroit did right. But the end result will be very bad, especially in Michigan. Last 1 out, shut off the lights.

If this happens, & I think at least 1 of them will go down, will the MSM actually look into the real cause of the trouble? Probably not, but we all know that Michigan has been the place where everything liberals/progressives believe in has been done. Everything the unions wanted, they got. Taxes were never high enough, so they keep going up. Then they wonder why Michigan's economy is in the crapper.

The bottom line is this, the only thing that has been run properly in Michigan for the last 2 decades has been the Detroit Red Wings. The rest of whatever is in the state, not so much. Good night, Michigan, it was good while it lasted.

 

"The Fairness Doctrine = Jim Crow laws for Conservatives".  Jim Quinn from "Quinn & Rose"

Yay! Accounting lingo! I

Yay! Accounting lingo! I knew going to college is worth it!

OT: Let them liquidate, this is what happens when you let the unions stick it up your hole for years. I hope Nissan and Honda buy their factories and brings some of their better cars over.Going from making the Cobalt to something like a 370Z would make anyone happy.

"two wars, a planet in peril, the worst financial crisis in a century" - PreBO

→ Fat chance

Push through Card Check, and there's absolutely no reason to consider building cars here. (Of course, Obama will get real protectionist on us)

Obama - Change you can bereave in