The battle between New London, Connecticut and the residents of its Fort Trumbull neighborhood began in 1998 when the City decided that it would redevelop the area for ultimate ownership by others and, if necessary, take the residents' properties for that "public purpose" -- not for "public use" (i.e., roads, bridges, schools, etc.), as the Fifth Amendment clearly intended.
Susette Kelo and other Fort Trumbull residents pushed back and sued to try to stop the city's plans. Ultimately, the Supreme Court rendered its 5-4 decision in Kelo v. New London in June 2005, erroneously (as the Founders would almost certainly have seen it) siding with the city.
In July 2006, after intervention by Connecticut Governor Jodi Rell prevented the City from carrying out its declared intent to forcibly remove final holdouts Kelo and the Cristofaros if necessary, the city and the holdouts settled.
More than 2-1/2 years after the settlement, 3-1/2 years after the Supremes' decision, and 11 years after the city's initial plans, oh boy -- a new tenant has finally moved into the Fort Trumbull Neighborhood. It's a government tenant (link at New London Day will be available for about a week), and the move is into an existing building:
Three Coast Guard units moved into a renovated office building in Fort Trumbull Friday, becoming the first tenants since the peninsula was cleared for economic development.
The move is "going to bring some life" to the peninsula and hopefully attract other tenants, said John Brooks, executive director of the New London Development Corp.
"There already has been some interest by other entities that would like to be at Fort Trumbull or be close to the Research & Development Center," he said.
..... The development plan for the Fort Trumbull area, drafted in 1998, calls for a mixed-use village that would include a hotel and housing. But the original master developer, Corcoran Jennison, couldn't obtain financing and the NLDC is now looking for another developer.
It's pretty bad when a public official tries to treat as spin a non-taxpaying entity's move into an existing office building in an otherwise abandoned area that used to contain perfectly functional taxpayers' homes as a significant, positive development.
Here is roughly how the area looks today, as you can see here from a Google Earth image:

The Coast Guard has moved into the building at the top (1 Chelsea Street).
The building that is just southwest of 1 Chelsea Street is that of the high-powered, politically-connected Italian Dramatic Club, which was disgracefully spared from the wrecking ball while whole city blocks of homes were obliterated.
As usual, the Day's coverage avoids mentioning what has apparently become a four-letter word in New London: Kelo.
As usual, the national press continues to ignore the ongoing non-developments in the wake of what some have called the worst Supreme Court decision since Roe v. Wade.
One of the commenters at the story had this to say in reaction:
The public should never forget what was permitted to happen there and any reference now to a positive outcome is a foolish mistake. New London will never be the same since officials allowed the push forward of such outrageous destruction of peoples homes and businesses. Furthermore, the glaring fact that our high court did not hold to the already existing determination that eminent domain was to only be used for the benefit of the public regarding large public projects (i.e. new major rail or road expansions, building of public schools, etc.) was horrible.
I don't think the commenter has to worry about a "positive outcome" for some time, except perhaps in one sense: The longer Fort Trumbull goes undeveloped, the more obvious the foolishness of the city's government and its officials becomes, and the more likely it is that someone in the national press will notice the travesty representing the real-world result of the Supreme Court's odious decision.
Author and investigative reporter Jeff Benedict has written a book, Little Pink House (HT Selfish Reasons), about the Kelo saga. The portion of his web site related to the book is here. Don't miss the must-see video promoting the book (also at YouTube) in the left frame. Part of the video includes a drive-through of what's left of the neighborhood. Warning: It might make you ill.
Cross-posted at BizzyBlog.com.
—Tom Blumer is president of a training and development company in Mason, Ohio, and is a contributing editor to NewsBusters




















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
You are kidding yourself if you think this is going to make news
February 15, 2009 - 10:52 ET by ironchefofmunchies"The longer Fort Trumbull goes undeveloped, the more obvious the foolishness of the city's government and its officials becomes, and the more likely it is that someone in the national press will notice the travesty representing the real-world result of the Supreme Court's odious decision."
NO, they won't. Because the press SUPPORTS the idea of the government taking private property away from people for the "public good" and will therefore spike any negative story about New London.
They can't have the peasants out there starting to question the aristocracy (er, "elected representatives"), now can they?
If you think otherwise, please link me any negative stories about Obama you've seen in the mainstream news.
Oh, if it happens ....
February 15, 2009 - 11:03 ET by Tom Blumer.... it will take years, maybe until the 10th anniversary of the decision. But each passing year increases the likelihood a bit. But you are right that the press is in general determined to ignore it. I see piece by a John Stossel-like person, maybe Stossel himself, at some point.
A mildly encouraging sign .... the uber-lib Hartford Courant published an op-ed by Benedict.
Eminent Domain-what a total
February 15, 2009 - 13:19 ET by RR GOPEminent Domain-what a total abuse of the Constitution these politicos have been carrying out forever and a day now.
Again I say unless it's a blonde bombshell suing over her sugar daddy's money, abortion, gun control or Larry Flynt, they don't want to hear it. They only want cases that are easy to decide, bring publicity to themselves, or ones that have few real repercussions.
The ostriches of Jurisprudence.
Meanwhile, there are scads of Communist judges throughout the federal and state systems legislating from the bench.
The scary thing about this is that beyond using eminent domain for purely political crookedness, they can buy you out and bulldoze your house if they feel like it because you opposed them publicly or said something they don't like,
One of the 24% who thinks George W. Bush was a great President. One of the 89% who wants to bring back the stock and pillory.
One minor point: Kelo was
February 15, 2009 - 14:18 ET by fenngibbonOne minor point: Kelo was a 5-4 decision, not 6-3.
When local governments fail to follow through...
February 15, 2009 - 14:34 ET by ThalpyWhen local governments fail to follow through, what are the legal consequences? What a pathetic joke they are! Someone should have to pay dearly for this travesty.
blame Bush? “The way to
February 15, 2009 - 14:42 ET by botgblame Bush?
“The way to stop discrimination on the basis of race is to stop discriminating on the basis of race.” -- Chief Justice John Roberts
The worst SC decision since
February 15, 2009 - 15:29 ET by bigtimerThe worst SC decision since Roe v Wade....people who own private property had better be prepared for more to come on down the line...the people O has named to the EPA, the Justice Dept. etc are all in line to taking more personal property in various ways, avenues...this fight has been going on for years and years now in the NW too.
They have the power, this has been in the works for years with the leftists to take over more and more of our freedoms...just chipping away...they are succeeding to-boot.
Be afraid...very afraid.
Fort Trumbull Update
March 7, 2009 - 17:23 ET by jeanwilThe Google Earth image is sadly out-of-date. I visited the site two weeks ago, and there are no buildings left except for the office building at the top of the image and the IDC to the top left. (The buildings shown in the lower right corner are part of the Fort Trumbull State Park complex.) All of the homes on the IDC block have been demolished. The homes to the south of Walbach Street have also been demolished. The Kelo house has been moved from the Fort Trumbull peninsula to a different location in New London.
When walking around the "neighborhood," all one sees is bleakness and abandonment. It is difficult to see what Pfizer was expecting in terms of development, since their building is set back away from this area. The peninsula is cut off from the rest of the city by the Amtrak tracks. And, as you approach the peninsula, you drive by other abandoned blocks that I believe had buildings that were taken for other grandiose development plans the City of New London had.
A total waste.