For Zimbabweans, A Cow Dung Christmas; AP Still Partially Deflects Blame from Mugabe

Photo of Tom Blumer.
  • Bookmark and Share

MugabeHands1208I held this item for a couple of days after I found it because I didn't want to spoil Christmas. Readers can fairly criticize me for waiting.

It is truly astonishing how little attention this two week-old story has received (Warning: Very disturbing content; the underlying news at caritas.org is here; bolds are mine)

Out of food, Zimbabweans eating cow dung

Harare, Dec 10, 2008 / 08:01 pm -- Caritas Internationalis is warning that the crisis in Zimbabwe is so grave that people facing crushing food shortages are mixing cow dung with their food.

With pressure continuing to mount on President Mugabe to relinquish his hold on power, Zimbabweans are suffering the consequences of his government’s policies.

Besides the lack of food, people are also suffering a cholera epidemic and crippling hyperinflation.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Caritas Internationalis Secretary General Lesley-Anne Knight reports that "people in Zimbabwe are dropping dead on the streets from Cholera. They’ve witnessed people mixing cow dung with what’s left of their food to make it go further. This is poverty at its most dehumanizing."

..... A Caritas survey in October found 70 to 90 percent of households going hungry and the remainder on the brink of starvation. At least 5.1 million people are facing starvation out of a population of 13 million people. Additionally, nearly 14,000 cases of Cholera have been reported.

Knight also commented on the political crisis, saying, "Zimbabwe’s political impasse can continue no longer. An effective government that can rectify the policies that have put the country into this position must be established.

It's obvious that the Catholic News Agency, the source of this story, is closer to the awful facts on the ground than the Associated Press. Two AP stories, one on December 23 by Angus Shaw and the other unbylined report on December 25, won't even clearly state why this is happening. Though what the stories do tell us is still awful, it waters down the impact, especially when compared to what CNA has (bolds are mine; links are dynamic and/or short-lived):

December 23 ("Mugabe rejects US, British calls to step down"; saved here for future reference)

Zimbabwean President Robert Mugabe said Tuesday the U.S. and Britain are "stupid" to think he shouldn't be part of a unity government.

The top U.S. diplomat for Africa said over the weekend that Washington can no longer support a power-sharing proposal that leaves Mugabe president, and Britain's Africa minister backed the U.S. stance on Monday.

..... (Mugabe) has faced renewed criticism because of a humanitarian crisis that has pushed millions of Zimbabweans to the point of starvation and spawned a cholera epidemic that has killed more than 1,000 people since August. Food, medicine, fuel and cash are scarce.

Critics blame Mugabe's policies for the ruin of what had been the region's breadbasket. Mugabe blames Western sanctions, though the European Union and U.S. sanctions are targeted only at Mugabe and dozens of his clique with frozen bank accounts and travel bans.

++++++++++++++++++++++++

December 25 ("Lawyer: Zimbabwe activist's location unknown"; saved here for future reference)

A Zimbabwean peace activist held in an alleged plot to overthrow President Robert Mugabe has gone missing again, a leading human rights lawyer said Thursday. Human Rights Watch called for the immediate release of Jestina Mukoko saying the charges she faces "seem politically motivated."

..... Mugabe has faced growing pressure to step down. Charging Mukoko, the respected head of a group known as the Zimbabwe Peace Project, is a sign he is not prepared to yield after nearly three decades in power.

..... Mugabe, 84, has ruled the country since its 1980 independence from Britain and refused to leave office following disputed elections in March.

Food, medicine, fuel and cash are scarce in Zimbabwe, and critics blame Mugabe's policies for the ruin of what had been the region's breadbasket. Mugabe blames Western sanctions, though the European Union and U.S. sanctions are targeted only at Mugabe and dozens of his clique with frozen bank accounts and travel bans.

..... Millions of Zimbabweans are in need of food aid and a cholera epidemic has killed more than 1,100 people.

You see that CNA unequivocally pointed to "the consequences of (the Mugabe) government’s policies." But AP gave him undeserved wiggle room two separate times. CNA reported that cow dung has become part of many Zimbabweans' diets two weeks ago; though it should know of this situation, it appeared nowhere in either of AP's reports. CNA cited "at least 5.1 million" facing starvation two weeks ago; AP only told us of "millions ..... in need of food aid," which I believe most people tend to think of as "two or three."

To its credit, AP does have a month-old video on how many Zimbabweans have resorted to eating crickets, rodents, and termites to stay alive. But the video can only be found at AP's home site; readers at other sites carrying AP reports will have no idea of what Zimbabweans have to do to keep from starving.

Coverage of the true extent of the crisis in the rest of the press has been scant.

A late Thursday evening December 9 through December 25 Google News search on [Zimbabwe "cow dung'] (typed as indicated within brackets) returned only 22 items, with all duplicates included:

  • Seven of them go to a December 12 Bloomberg News story where Mugabe denied the existence of cholera.
  • Two go to WorldNetDaily on December 21, where commentator Barbara Simpson quotes a doctor-priest who says that "the situation has reached 'Auschwitz proportions.'"
  • There's a Fort Worth Star-Telegram editorial that is also introduced at at McClatchy's home site. That editorial ends with mind-number stats about the country's plight: Life expectancy - 44.3 years; Fertility rate - 3.72 children per woman; Adults with HIV/AIDS - 24.6 percent; Unemployment rate - 80 percent (2005 estimate)
  • All other search results are from foreign or relatively unknown sources.

The same search at the New York Times came up empty. The Washington Post? Nothing. LA Times? Nada.

Maybe the Catholic News Agency should become the real "Essential Global News Network" that the Associated Press only pretends to be. It's obvious if you compare CNA's two-week-old story from Zimbabwe with the two recent ones from AP that the wire service isn't up to the challenge of telling us what's really happening, and will, even as people die by the thousands, sanitize what it tells us based on what appear to be inexplicable sympathies.

(Image was found at Alamo City Pundit.)

Cross-posted at BizzyBlog.com.

—Tom Blumer is president of a training and development company in Mason, Ohio, and is a contributing editor to NewsBusters


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Mugabe or Obama, what's the difference?

Since the charismatic socialist Mugabe decided to "spread the wealth around", in less than a decade he has turned a country that was known as the breadbasket of Africa into a country that now cannot even feed its own people.

 Maybe someone can explain to me how the "charismatic" socialist Obama's "spread the wealth around" policies will turn out any different for this country?

"Don't blame me.....I voted for Palin"

→ What's in a name?

Rhodesia, by any other name would . . .?

Good thing the Brits pulled out.  A beautiful Marxist government arises within 30 years.

  • LYDSEXICS UNTIE!

Happy Kwanzaa! Now, eat

Happy Kwanzaa! Now, eat your dung!

→ Thanks, Rog

Mommy I hate my sister's guts.

  • LYDSEXICS UNTIE!

It's Bush's fault

The mainstream media won't even come close to condemning or saying anything negative about this black tyrant who threw out the white farmers so things would be FAIR.  Well now they have their fairness and if the US gives in to feeding another starving nation that will eventually throw it's leftovers at us then let their African and Asian and Arab neighbors help.  (I don't mean Obama).  A black racist is tolerable in the media--Wright, Farrakhan, The founder of Kwanza, Mugabe..etc., but God forbid your not totally comfortable with Diversity or Affirmative Action or Obama and your a racist that can't be saved.  That according to the MSM.

"Don't let the bastards grind you down."

Red

They’ve witnessed

They’ve witnessed people mixing cow dung with what’s left of their food to make it go further.

I call BS on this, pun intended.

If it is true, then it would be someone who was delusional.  It is also possible that a delusional person could convince someone else to partake in their delusion (Folie à deux).  It is doubtful this behaviour is generalized to a population.  If so, more than an aide worker would have noticed and been reported on already, with video on the six o'clock news across the country and world.

The accounts of famine/starvation in history that I have read about have never included stories of people eating cow dung, or any fecal matter, to bulk up portions like Westerners using Hamburger Helper to stretch a pound of hamburger.

This sort of activistic journalism will do little to alter the plight of the people in Africa or anywhere.

 

→ Strat

Wouldn't that be Folie à deux deux?

Bwahahaha!

  • LYDSEXICS UNTIE!

Potty Mouth

Cool:

Way to turn starving cow dung eating Africans into a joke.

No, really.  Funny stuff.

NewsBusted should use that and tie it to the Liberal mentality, as in who's more full of it.  :-)

(I make no claim upon any payment you receive.)

 

→ Thanks strat

I was hoping to see the billboard

Missionary - The Other White Meat

  • LYDSEXICS UNTIE!

How About...

Missionary Position - Roasting over coals on a spit

Three thoughts

First, I don't think Caritas, the source of the original info, would risk its credibility as a charity by making stuff up.

Second, I believe that starving animals have been known to eat fecal matter. This isn't proof, but it's in the neighborhood. Sufficiently desperate people might do so too.

Third, even if the cow dung reports are eventually disproven (which I doubt will happen), the AP itself has documented that Zimbabweans are eating crickets, rodents, and termites -- in an onsite video, but not for readers of its dispatches. Why not?

People from various

People from various cultures have eaten and still eat crickets, rodents and termites.  This is not done out of starvation necessarily.  Anthony Bourdain's show No Reservations has documented the ingestion of a number of "foods" that Westerners would not typically eat.  I've had a chocolate covered cricket and bee.  Of course during subsistence or less than subsistence dietary times, people will eat many things they normally would not given a choice.

Given the history of the world and the many times of natural and man-made famine, how many occurences have you read about coprophagia?  Why is the starvation in Zimbabwe different?  It isn't.  There may be deluded individuals that are eating feces, but they are not a norm of their peers, and I am referring to the norm of other starving people.  That some other(s) may be recruited into the delusion is also not the norm.  When did psychological illness become representative of the starving masses?

In fact, cannibalism is more likely of starving people than coprophagia.  Why would this be?  Is it just the bad taste of feces?  Or is it because people have learned over time that feces holds little to no nutritive value and can kill you if eaten?  Why not cook up brush or dirt then?  Same effect with better flavor.

As to Caritas publishing this story... even the best can be hoodwinked or allow a little nonsense in order to promote a greater good.  Maybe pictures of children afflicted with marasmus and kwashiorkor no longer engendered the desired reaction in our over-stimulated and cynical MTV culture to the extent that coprophagia by a couple of deluded people might shock Westerners into action.

As to animals eating feces... dogs will do this even if not starving.  I don't think there is much analogy between humans and animals in this issue concerning starving people.

The bottomline for me is that one can oftentimes find bizarre outliers such as someone eating feces.  Upon further inspection, I would posit that the alledged coprophagia if true is tied to a confined psychological abberation not explained just by hunger.

While it is well documented that people stranded afloat in the ocean without water will drink salty seawater knowing it will harm them, there have been no reports I am aware of of people eating feces during times of starvation.

****EDIT****

Just found on google - "Starving Aleuts and Inuits eat reindeer pellets."  The closest I got to a primary source was here.  Not exactly encouraging on the veracity front.

Biblical precedent

Stratman: try 2 Kings 6.25 (dove's dung being sold during famine, apparently for food). The Rabshekah's warning to Jerusalem during Hezekiah's day also suggested that the siege was going to lead people to eat their own dung.

http://www.changeint...

Tim:Excellent find! 

Tim:

Excellent find!  Anything's possible.

I did find some explanations concerning"dove's dung" which might give an alternate meaning to the words here, here, and here

I can not vouch for the accuracy of these sites nor their explanations, but, intuitively, their explanations seem more likely to me as people have given colorful names to things in nature for centuries and the universal historical cultural aversion to eating poop. 

Still, there is a coffee bean, Kopi Luwak, that is ingested and then pooped out before humans collect it for making coffee.  Of course this is considered a delicacy for which idiots, sorry, connesuiers will pay $100 per pound!  Even Oprah endorses it, so it must be worth it.  ;-)

I hope we are not getting closer to Soylent Green days. 

→ Birdnest Soup

There are caves in Borneo that are mined for the nests made of bird puke.  Supposed to be a delicacy.  Doesn't quite qualify as dung, but I'm in no hurry to try it.

  • LYDSEXICS UNTIE!

I suppose

...there are always alternatives on offer, especially when the natural readings seems extreme.

Of course, the Rabshekah's warning isn't open to that, as the eating one's own dung was placed in parallel with drinking one's own urine. Though, admittedly it is easy to say the Rabshekah was resorting to hyperbole.

http://www.changeint...

A little hyperbole is OK

A little hyperbole is OK with me if it keeps people from eating poop.

The world's gone a bit mad.  Who would have thought we'd be discussing this topic on NB's!

U.N. Anyone?

Where is the United Nations in all of this??  Of wait, America isn't footing the bill and sending in 90% of the troops so the U.N. isn't going to step into this pile of crap situation.

"If you love wealth more than liberty, the tranquillity of servitude better than the animating contest of freedom, depart from us in peace. We ask not your counsel nor your arms. Crouch down and lick the hand that feeds you."

U.N. Forces

If Khofi Anan was more concerned with skimming oil profits from Iraq than the genocide on his home turg, don't expect Ban Ki Moon to care either.

  • LYDSEXICS UNTIE!

Where's the U.N?

Ban Ki Moon and his fellow bass-ackward 3rd World cronies are too busy planning new and inventive ways to separate 1st World citizen's from their hard-earned money.

If what has been going on in that sad country for years hasn't demonstrated once and for all what a total waste of real estate the UN really is, I don't know what will.

-Dave

Zimbabwe starves

White Zimbabwean farmers Have been run out of Zimbabwe as part of Mugabe's land reallocation and share the wealth program. Their farms are now idle and unused. I don't suppose that has any bearing on the lack of food.

The evicted farmers are being invited by Nigeria, Angola, Zambia and Mozambique to relocate there and farm.

Political correctness and racism is more important to some than food. Of course the leaders, Robert Mugabe in particular are eating high on the hog. Maybe I shouldn't be so critical, he's just a community organizer so it's OK.

→ Right on coco!

And if the "king of kings", as Qadaffi is called by his fellow thugs, doesn't see that something is done, I can only wish Reagan's attack had been more precise.

  • LYDSEXICS UNTIE!

 Where is the hell is Bono?

 Where is the hell is Bono? There was plenty to eat and export when whitey was in charge. Sorry I'm not supposed to speak the truth.