Barack Obama's $1.1 Million Botanical Garden -- Er, $100,000 Gazebo (Graphics Updated)

Photo of Tom Blumer.

obamazebosignThe media and the Obama campaign (but I repeat myself) are comparing the "experience" of'the Democrats' presidential nominee to that of the GOP's vice-presidential pick -- meaning, one must assume, that the debate over his experience vs. John McCain's is over, in McCain's resounding favor.

Let's look back a couple of months at a post I put up on July 14 (with minor revisions) that gives a, uh, concrete example of one of Barack Obama's management "experiences" -- one that the national media has (of course) totally ignored.

______________________________________________________

Barack Obama's $100,000 Gazebo

Here's an interesting story I found in the Chicago Tribune archives (obtained from ProQuest library database; for fair use and discussion purposes):

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

ENGLEWOOD IS EYED FOR BOTANICAL GARDEN
Chicago Tribune. Chicago, Ill.: Jan 15, 2000. pg. 5

A group of politicians, school administrators and community activists unveiled a plan Friday for a $1.1 million botanical garden in the city's Englewood neighborhood.

The proposal calls for a walk beneath the "L" tracks on Princeton Avenue, from 59th Place to 62nd Place. Backers said they hope it will help spur redevelopment in the impoverished area, boost neighborhood pride and soften the impact of traffic and pollution from the nearby Dan Ryan Expressway.

State Sen. Barack Obama (D-Chicago) said he planned to seek state funding for the effort and estimated that ground could be broken in early 2001.

The proposed garden also would include a gazebo, a parrot sanctuary and a walk of fame.

Gee, that sounds exciting. Let's go visit:

ObamaGarden0708

(Google Maps image is more than likely from before the Sun-Times visit described below occurred, and before the related report and video were posted.)

Imagine that. No garden. No parrot sanctuary. No walk of fame.

How can that be? What happened? The Chicago Sun-Times tells us the answer, while revealing that "at least" there's a gazebo -- but not much of one (video is at link; HT Jennifer Rubin via the TIB All-Stars July 12 collection at Weapons of Mass Discussion):

Obama's $100,000 garden grant wasted
He vowed to 'work tirelessly' to build an oasis for Englewood. It never happened.

July 11, 2008

As a state senator, Barack Obama gave $100,000 in state money to a campaign volunteer who failed to deliver on a plan to create a botanic garden in one of Chicago's most blighted neighborhoods.

..... what was supposed to be a six-block stretch of trees and paths is now a field of unfulfilled dreams, strewn with weeds, garbage and broken pavement.

Kenny B. Smith, whose nonprofit group got the money, said it was spent legitimately, mostly on underground site preparation. But he admitted Thursday that the garden is a lost cause because other government money never came through.

..... Smith -- an early Obama supporter who gave $550 to his state and congressional campaigns -- said he gave his paperwork documenting the work to a state agency and no longer has it.

..... a reporter walked the site last week with a landscape architect from the Illinois Green Industry Association who found no evidence of the work Smith cited. The only major changes since 2000: A gazebo was added, and some trees were cut down.

Obama, the presumptive Democratic presidential nominee, said through a spokesman he wasn't responsible for monitoring the work; the staffs of Gov. Blagojevich and former Gov. George Ryan were.

..... In 2001, at Obama's direction, a $100,000 Illinois FIRST grant went to Smith's group. The garden site was part of Rosewood Estates, an affordable-housing development being built by the group, whose unpaid board chairman was Brian Washington, a Sun-Times security guard.

Plans called for more than 50 homes, but only a dozen were built, Smith said.

The remaining $1 million for the botanic garden was never raised.

Those legendary $400 hammers for the military have nothing on this $100,000 gazebo.

A trifling matter? I don't think so. More like a revealing one:

  • Obama feels no sense of responsibility for the results of money directed to someone HE chose. This isn't "the buck stops here" of Harry Truman fame; this is "the buck went somewhere else."
  • Gubernatorial staffs aren't responsible for monitoring projects like this. State agencies are. If the agency involved didn't do their job (according to the article, it's the Department of Commerce and Economic Opportunity), that's one thing, but the blame-shifting to other pols is either hopelessly naive (a legitimate possibility, given the candidate's seemingly endless well of ignorance) or irresponsible.
  • If you look at the full text of the press release that announced the project, you'll see that Kenny Smith was on hand, and that he made representations about how he was "work(ing) with a variety of governmental agencies and not-for-profit groups to secure funding this project including the Chicago Transit Authority, the United States Department of Agriculture, and the American Society of Landscape Architecture. We have made some progress ...." My bet: Smith had, at most, met with these orgs once or twice, and was blowing smoke about the realistic chances of getting money. For a nominal $550 in campaign contributions, Smith got 100 grand, which "somehow" has mostly gone bye-bye. Bottom line: Obama got hustled. Did he even look into how the rest of the "fund-raising" was going before directing the release of the grant funds?
  • Perhaps that's why Obama seems oddly indifferent to what ultimately happened. The response from his spokesman (and not the candidate) is tired boilerplate about "provid(ing) residents with a livable neighborhood." Zzzzzz.

The larger point is this: The guy is hopelessly gullible, can't even get a $100,000 grant right, and now wants to have the final say in matters relating to a $3-plus trillion federal budget and a $14-trillion economy in a town chock full of con artists and tricksters.

Yikes.

It would be cool if some enterprising photo-opster could make up a "Barack Obama $100,000 Gazebo" sign (or something more clever -- use your imagination), take some pictures at the site, and post them. Until that happens, this well-done contribution from NewsBusters reader "tnculp" will do very nicely:

obamazebo

Cross-posted at BizzyBlog.com.

—Tom Blumer is president of a training and development company in Mason, Ohio, and is a contributing editor to NewsBusters


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Gazebo

You can bet this is one of the very few places that this info will be printed

 

 

VOTE REPUBLICAN 

Didn't Obama make the

Didn't Obama make the comment that Palin can't stand the scrutiny of the press over 5 or 6 days like he has for a year.  Ahem, what scrutiny?  by what press?  Your article being another example of the MSM's failure to even cover this guy in any meaningful way.  I think it would be fair to say, their coverage of Obama has been as revealing as their (non) coverage of Edwards infidelity to his cancer stricken wife.

Nancy Pelosi and Harry Reid, starving the poor one gallon of ethanol at a time. Fill your tank with E85 and cull a village.

Great Place To Get Mugged

$100,000 gazebo?

I'd like to be Obambi's contractor too.

One lightbulb replaced = $50.

One picture hung, relatively level = $1000.

One room painted in pukey color = $5000.

Idiot Preznint-wannabe throwing money away on fellow charlatans = PRICELESS.

RRAM Tough! 

I know it's not much of a

I know it's not much of a photo op but could we get a McCain or Palin campaign stop there?

"Fighters are fun but bombers make policy"

Obama's support

He supported The Gazebo in the Middle of Nowhere before he was against it.

Holding my breath for the MSM to investigate starting now....

While on the surface it

While on the surface it does seem like a scam by this Smith, however development is a tricky business.  Depending on any number of factors he might have spent a pile of money on public underground improvements.  I have seen some developments in older depressed areas spend 100K in underground improvements to serve the site and then another 100K for above ground infrastructure.  Now this is just the public part and does not include any of the developers improvements to his property.

Nuke em til they glow then shoot em in the dark.

well Dan

If you read all the details, a landscape architect apparently surveyed the lot and could not determine that the work explained by Smith had actually happened.

Aside from that, I agree with Tom - Obama seems to have passed off 100K with no assurance that the plan was legit, no intention of holding Smith accountable, and no remorse for seeing that much money wasted.

 

Maybe so, BUT... Kenny B.

Maybe so, BUT...

Kenny B. Smith, whose nonprofit group got the money, could not tell the interviewer where all those underground improvents went (as per the article's linked video).

And Kenny seemed like such a hands-on, take charge kind of guy to me too! (not)

My hypothesis is that the money did go down-low... into his back pocket.

RRAM Tough! 

Enough?

Could this be Obama's Garden Tomb?

Or maybe Obama can put some curtains up and let his brother George live in the Gazebo instead of a hut.

Seriously, Why hasn't Obama been thoroughly vetted yet? For example, with all the talk about  health and heartbeats, why hasn't Obama released his medical records, and why hasn't he been pressed to do so??

Because messiahs are above

Because messiahs are above petty things like sickness or disease!

Google has street view of this "park"

Google has street view photographs of this neighborhood. You can go to Google Maps and select the address 6102 S. Princeton Ave, Chicago, IL. Twirl around until you are facing east (shadows facing away from you), and you'll see it.

The day the picture was taken, the grass was cut, but there's nothing but the gazebo and a lone tree on the property. The Elevated tracks line the background.

I don't know when the streets were scanned for the street view. It's a pretty bleak place for a park, anyway. Sad. 

If you want the screen capture, email me and I'll send it to you.

Google Earth

Wow, you are correct.

That is one sad little hundred grand gazebo.

What a sorry little neighborhood to "redevelop".  No one in their right mind would want to live there...train tracks on one side, elevated train tracks and what looks to be a major highway (with more train tracks on the other.

Thanks for posting the address.

Poor people of Illinois, paying for another Obama boondoggle.

Don't let this happen to us! 

David Gregory, do you know which damn network you lie for? ~ Uncle Jimbo, @Blackfive

 

Sad indeed Blonde - but for $75,000

Sad indeed Blonde - but for $75,000 more, Obama could get it painted!

Before it rots.

(;~> gary

You mean it's not pressure

Be Careful

Be careful with this stuff. Government waste is rampant no matter where and no matter what level. If McCain's campaign were to make this an issue, I'm almost certain that the Obama campaign could find half-assed projects in Arizona in which McCain had a hand.

Instead, I look at it as the heavy, clumsy, and uncaring of government at work. I used to be a consultant for federally funded projects (walking private enterprise through the boondoggle of bureaucracy), and the waste was breathtaking. Government would plow hundreds of thousands of dollars into projects, and we'd still have empty fields, unbuilt roads, stalled projects.

I've lost count of the millions of dollars spent to build a couple of bridges across the Ohio River at Louisville, and contractors have yet to turn a spade of dirt or string one girder of steel. I finished my consulting work on it nearly a decade ago, and they are still throwing money at it. I spent hundreds of hours working on it. It's Kentucky version of the Big Dig. Republicans and Democrats are equally suspect on the bridge project.

No one ever stops and asks about the source of the project funding. No one! They don't care.

There's something that sticks out in my memory from working on those projects. When my firm would report on our progress, we'd talk about what we accomplished and how we advanced the project or projects. When government bureaucrats talked about projects, they'd talk about how much they spent and how much more they plan to spend. Politicians always promised more money.

It's awful, folks. Awful. That career made me intensely conservative. I feel very betrayed by the Republican party, which became money throwers on par with the Democrats.

Govt. a lot like unions.

I heard of a nuke plant being built where one shift would build something and the next would tear all that work out. Then the next would rebuild, etc. making very little progress but lots of work "being done." I think this was the 1970s in Ohio. That is corruption and lack of mgt. for you. You (we the people) get ripped off.

Sounds Like

Sounds like Marble Hill in Indiana. It was awful. The ruins of the plant, which was never completed, stand along the Ohio River. Liberals in Louisville and Cincinnati pounced on that place. They were funded by the coal industry in Kentucky. I seem to remember some issues at Marble Hill like you describe.

I know a guy who won't go near one of the nuclear power plants in Alabama but will spend an entire weekend fishing within sight of the Paradise Steam Generation Plant along the Green River in Kentucky.

Take a guess on his political leanings.

Yep! It's that Paradise. The one of John Prine fame. Only, Peabody's coal trains didn't haul Paradise away. The damned TVA hauled away Paradise.

My version of the sign

Tom,

My version of the sign is here:

The Obamazebo

Nice!

I hope you don't mind if I use it at both places (eventually, later tonight).

Well, I suppose so! :o)

Well, I suppose so! :o)

NB scoops the MSM

News Busters has scooped the MSM again. Too bad this article will be ignored, buryed or spun.

Actually, this accomplishment is part of Obama's "Shelters for Crack Dealers" program he started when he was a community organizer.

I would wonder if the

I would wonder if the liberal media would care to rate this project as either good or bad, so that we could assess Barack's executive skills?

I would also like to know if the liberal media thought that this project brought about either "hope or change"?

The only hope Obama and kind are interested in is that the media doesn't notice or even cares.

The only change that came out of this "project" was the money left over when the rest was squandered...

I think Obama has left out a key adjective when he discusses how he is going to bring about "change"... and it is CHUMP.

"A group of politicians,....

....school administrators and community activists unveiled a plan Friday for a $1.1 million..."

...stiff deal for the taxpayer?

That sentence has an offensive odor.

Hey, guys I know of a nice piece of property west of Frosbite Falls; perfect for a water park. Have your people contact my people.

Why is it, that anything in this guys past that other achievement oriented "folks" could point to as successful is essentially an abject failure?

Omabazebo

I guess a small-town mayor is sort of like a 'community organizer,' except that you have actual responsibilities.

-Sarah Palin

AND NOW, OSAMA BAMA'S "MUSLIM FAITH"!

This says it all about his lordship Obamessiah! Another case of hoof-in-mouth disease...

http://washingtontimes.com/news/2008/sep/07/obama-verbal-slip-fuels-his-critics/

Let's see how he gets out of this one -  and let's see how much the MSM says about it!

"The sun's not going down, the horizon's moving up!" - Firesign Theatre

That's one for the

That's one for the snickering at the moron pile, the other piles with the bigger issues are higher priority like razor thin legislative record or his non-chairmanship of a committe that doesn't meet. Now had it been a Repub, of course we would never hear the end of it.

Nancy Pelosi and Harry Reid, starving the poor one gallon of ethanol at a time. Fill your tank with E85 and cull a village.

SUre would be nice

If the drive by media had a fairness doctrine ... If they send 30 reporters to Alaska, they had to send 30 reporters to Chicago.