SF Chron Cuts Obama 'Pay Grade' Comment from Print Edition

Photo of Tom Blumer.
  • Bookmark and Share

It doesn't get much more obvious than this.

A San Francisco Chronicle article last Wednesday relating to growing concerns about Democratic presidential nominee Barack Obama's recent campaign performances "evolved" in a quite convenient way for the Illinois senator by the time it got to the paper's print edition and went through its final web revision. That article, among other things, addressed Obama's appearance at Rick Warren's Saddleback Values forum the previous weekend.

The current entry at Google News, obtained by searching "That's above my pay grade" (entered in quotes), reads as follows:

SFchronGoogNewsObama082008

Although it's framed in a very biased way ("thoughtful but fuzzier"?), at least a reference to Obama's infamous "That's above my pay grade" comment is present (the original transcript segment containing that remark is here).

Wait until you see what happened next.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

I copied a text string within that Google News result, and was able to gain access to an earlier cached version of the article (saved at my host in the event the cache goes away), written up by Chronicle Political Writer Carla Marinucci. It doesn't have a normal web page appearance, but it does appear to contain what would have been the article's full text, including the Google News result text cited above.

That text consists of 24 paragraphs. Paragraph 16 says:

And Obama's thoughtful but fuzzier answers to questions about when human rights begin ("that's above my pay grade") were a clear contrast - and not a good one - to McCain's head-on approach that it was "at the moment of conception," he says.

But if you click on the original Google News link itself, you get taken to a revised version of the article ("Bad news should wake up Obama, experts say").

At the bottom of that linked page, we are told that "This article appeared on page A-1 of the San Francisco Chronicle." So this is what print edition readers got to see.

But what they got to see contains only 23 paragraphs. The one removed was -- you guessed it -- the one that referred to Obama's "pay grade" comment.

The only other difference I found between the cached and print version was one spelling correction, changing "jiu-jitsuing" to "jujitsuing" in the tenth paragraph. Otherwise the two are the same, word for word.

So at some point, the full original 24-paragraph report was available on the web; otherwise, my original Google News search would not have picked it up. But the "offending paragraph was later deemed to be unworthy of the print edition, and was also removed from the web edition. Now you can't find that paragraph on the web any more without engaging in workaround tactics.

Don't even try to tell me that traditional media outlets aren't doing everything they can to cover for Barack Obama.

Cross-posted at BizzyBlog.com.

—Tom Blumer is president of a training and development company in Mason, Ohio, and is a contributing editor to NewsBusters


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Bottomless Media Memory Hole

Dumping Obama's toxic waste down the memory hole is not above the establishment media's pay grade. 

Hey Tom

You think that's bad?

Try finding Michelle's remark in Puerto Rico that Barack is going to require us to change our traditions, our history.

Try finding the UPI link to Michelle steering patients away from her emergency room.

These are getting thin.

I ♣ my seal

First quote

"And Barack knows that we are going to have to make sacrifices, we are
going to have to change our conversation, we’re going to have to change
our traditions, our history,
we’re going to have to move into a
different place as a nation to provide the kind of future that we all
want desperately for our children."

it's 2:48 into this at youtube, but not easy to find otherwise.

I ♣ my seal

This is what's scary about

This is what's scary about politics today. Not only Wikipedia, but people can go back and "scrub" their comments where they are recorded.

How long before Biden's foot-in-mouth comments disappear, along with his plan to partition Iraq, and they become "hearsay" and the "creations of a right-wing smear machine"?

It puts a burden on you staff here at NB to look for and compare cached pages, but I know you are up to the job, and we all appreciate your labors!

 

No one will know

Hey, why not edit the record?  It's not like it was on TV or anything. 

When you put the clowns in charge, don't be surprised when a circus breaks out.

Newspeak at the San Francisco Chronicle

Not only did the San Francisco Chronicle edit out parts of the print edition in the online version, they even changed the question asked in the Saddleback forum as presented in the print addition from when does LIFE being to when do HUMAN RIGHTS begin. Talk about Newspeak!

Obama: My job is above my pay grade

I originally thought that too about "life" v. "human rights"

But the Saddlebrook link has Warren asking about human rights:

AT WHAT POINT DOES A BABY GET HUMAN RIGHTS IN YOUR VIEW?

I just looked at a vid, and that IS what Warren asked (it fades in, but you can hear it):

HERE

 

("that's above my pay grade")

So's Commander In Chief, butt biscuit.