Worldwide AIDs Progress: No Credit to Bush, No Matter What

Photo of Tom Blumer.

E-mailer and frequent NB commenter Gary Hall sent me a link to a July 30 LA Times article about how worldwide AIDS deaths are down 10%.

In discussing the improvement, it's hysterical in one sense, but very sad in another, to watch how reporter Thomas H. Maugh II studiously avoided using the word "abstinence" (the A-word), which does not appear even once in his entire piece.

Just to be sure no reader could possibly leave the article thinking that the current administration has contributed to an overall improvement, Maugh pointed to the increased prevalance of AIDS in the US African-American community, and gave antagonistic spokespersons free rein to criticize an alleged lack of urgency without a countervailing response.

First, here's a sample of Maugh's A-word avoidance (noted in bold):

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Condom use and prevention efforts increased in many countries and adolescent sexual intercourse declined in some of the most heavily affected regions, the report says.

"In a surprisingly short period of time, there has been a tripling of prevention efforts in some countries," said Dr. Paul De Lay, director of evaluation for UNAIDS.

..... Condom use among people with multiple sexual partners is increasing, and young people are waiting longer to have sexual intercourse, the report says. In seven of the countries most affected by the pandemic -- all in Africa -- the percentage of young people having sex before the age of 15 has dropped from 35% to 14%.

I wrote back in April that Bush Administration anti-AIDS efforts in Africa were achieving remarkable progress, that few were acknowledging it, and that even fewer were inclined to give the administration even a tiny amount of credit, let alone admit that relatively inexpensive abstinence education has been a major factor in improvements on that continent.

My take then on journalists' refusal to properly credit Bush certainly holds true with Maugh's reporting:

Now I get it: George Bush isn’t getting much praise because he has violated a central tenet of Old Media concerning sexually transmitted diseases: Condoms uber alles. Journalists’ seemingly innate hostility towards anything that might be labeled a faith-based initiative doesn’t help either.

Maugh didn't even bother to give out the name of the President's initiative, PEPFAR (the President’s Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief), even though it is almost certainly the single largest source of worldwide anti-AIDS funding.

The LA Times writer then falsely, and in my opinion cruelly, turned the worldwide improvement into a domestic indictment, even quoting a tax scofflaw who presumably still owes Uncle Sam millions:

But those gains abroad come at the expense of African Americans, according to another report issued Tuesday by the Black AIDS Institute in Los Angeles.

..... Only four countries outside sub-Saharan Africa have a higher prevalence of HIV infection than the estimated 2% among blacks in the U.S., he added. Blacks account for 1 of 8 Americans but 1 of 2 HIV infections in the country.

"U.S. policymakers seem to be much more interested in the epidemic in Botswana than the epidemic in Louisiana," said the Rev. Al Sharpton, chief executive of the National Action Network. "This is an unnecessary and deadly choice. Both need urgent attention."

C'mon, Mr. Maugh (and those quoted). Does anyone with a brain seriously believe that there's a shortage of education about AIDS in this country (unlike the others) -- in homes, in schools, in churches, on TV, or in the rest of the media? With all of that, whose fault is it if people won't do what's necessary to avoid contracting HIV and AIDS?

Maugh's work is of a piece with what appears to be a disgraceful Old Media determination that George W. Bush not receive any credit of any kind for any accomplishment during his administration. If it happens, don't report it. If someone else reports it, minimize its importance. If that's not enough, don't give any credit, and be sure to point to supposed "failures" elsewhere, even if you have to pull them out of your posterior.

I am beyond sick and tired of it. This is one of many areas where historians will have their work cut out for them setting the record straight. Contemporaneous Old Media reports certainly haven't.

Cross-posted at BizzyBlog.com.

—Tom Blumer is president of a training and development company in Mason, Ohio, and is a contributing editor to NewsBusters


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

There is nothing that can be done

When people ignore the facts and insist on playing "Russian Roulette" with their lives, there are going to be casualties.

Those who abstain from pre-marital sex will survive and those who don't will not. Even condoms are not 100% effective.

Hmmmm? The Black AIDES institute...Seems that if AIDES were irradicated and/or if blacks didn't have a higher infection rate because of stupid behavior, these guys would be out of a job. I wonder how much effort is really being put into education, as in giving people the actual facts?

 

The day that "politician" became a career choice is the day we started losing the Republic. Let's get it back! Alan Keyes '08.

The Media Will Never Report Anything That Bush Look Good

 

American Journalists
are Trampling the Sacrifice of Our Fathers, Mothers, Sisters and Brothers

(Unfortunately, the
Journalists taking part in this travesty far outnumber the headstones at Normandy)
from
zachjonesishome.wordpress.com
Specifically:

http://zachjonesisho...

 

zachjonesishome.wordpress.com

time for a little reality

Why is AIDs more prevalent among inner city minorities in America than in Africa? Maybe because the Africans have embraced the concept of abstinence while public schools in America treat abstinence like a stupid idea.

Bush can only push an issue so far until stuff like this throws up a brick wall.

So instead of blaming Bush for stds in America maybe they should blame the real problem.

This might sound racist

But since I'm Mexican-American maybe I can get away with it?

Anyway, the biggest problem with the inner city African-American is their obsession not only with rap music, but also the rap lifestyle.  I had a cousin that used to be a good student, had good behavior, was not sexually active, etc. 

Then he was introduced into the world of rap music.  At first he just listened to the music and didn't get that involved in the lifestyle.  But after some nice peer pressure from his "friends" he started skipping school, doing drugs, having sex with random girls, etc.

I've listened to some of his songs (he is an aspiring rapper now) and it is full of references to hoes, drugs, etc.  It was sad to watch someone who had such a bright future get sucked into this world.

So one way to reduce the spread of aids in the African-American community is to help spread a different message than the one they are getting from the music they are listening to.

Thomas Jefferson once said, 'We should never judge a president by his age, only by his works.' And ever since he told me that, I stopped worrying. 

- Ronald Reagan

Media never reports good news

It's articles like this that I love this site.  We hear about good things on here that the liberal media conveniently leave out in their segments, articles, blogs and stories.  They only report negative stories or controversial topics.  They don't report good things like this or the big welcoming crowd in South Korea that welcomed Pres Bush.  Our troops have actually found several WMD's in Iraq since the war started, but the liberal media never reports it.  They never report the successes we've had since Bush has been President.  There's been a LOT of success, more than failures, since Bush has been in office, but the liberal media refuses to report them.  That's why I love this site and DrudgeReport (www.drudgereport.com).  We get all sides of the story here.  I love it.

-------------------------------------------------------------
Take it easy!  We're not making a western here.
      ~ Uncle Junior
 
 (The Sopranos)

AIDS, like homelessness

Might just not be a Presidential responsibility, despite the proclivities & reflexive-biases first of the leftist media & now of ostensibly right wing media critics, too. I know, I have a "radical 1800s ideology!!" because I've actually looked at the Constitution and can't find either of those alleged Presidential responsibilities.
JMR

The tax & spend drug war looks racist in the real world.

I agree

Ideally, the effort should have been a bully-pulpit one. Instead, as critics feared, even though it has indisputably done good, it has become an open spigot. Already-generous funding was tripled and the agenda was expanded beyond AIDS this year.

Since I was one of those critics, and a loud one...

I get my "I told you so" at this point. It's one of the few bennies of being a libertarian.
JMR

The tax & spend drug war looks racist in the real world.