The supposedly surprising rejection of the Lieberman-Warner climate bill last week had an element that Old Media in the US hasn't covered, but is very relevant.
While the press is ever eager to jump on politicians who fly in the face of supposed "world opinion" when it goes against US positions and traditions, it has been virtually silent over how "the rest of the world" has been rejecting the true linchpin of government climate policies: supposedly climate change-related higher taxes and fees. Surely some of the green-leaning Senators who were supposedly on board but voted against cloture were not blind to this.
Consider the following:
- Germany -- "German Car Tax Plan to Be Delayed: Government."
- In Canada, a sympathetic columnist cautions the Liberal Party, which seems to think that the road back into power is through green taxes, about "The Suicidal Allure of a Carbon Tax."
- Australia -- "The Sun Sets on Rudd’s Climate Change Credibility."
- New Zealand -- "Emissions Bill Hanging by Thread"
Each story is about how a government or party is finding that citizens/voters are not at all keen on reducing their living standards in the name of supposed environmental purity.
The biggest media blackout is over the political situation in Great Britain, where Tony Blair's successor Gordon Brown hangs by a thread, largely because of his radical environmental initiatives.
Brown continues to push his "Green Road Tax" on "environmentally unfriendly cars." Poorer Britons stand to be hit hardest, while his environmental minister plays the save-the-planet card:
Owners of the most polluting cars in band M will pay £440 (about $870) in tax. And from April 2010, people buying the most polluting cars would pay a one-off "showroom tax" of up to £950 (about $1,900).
(Environmental Minister Joan) Ruddock added: "What we can't do is lose sight of the environment agenda because this is everybody's future, the future of the planet."
She denied the retrospective aspect of the policy was unfair.
"Over a 10 year period...I think the direction we have been going in has been clear to people at the time," she said.
In other words, according to Ms. Ruddock, "Your crystal balls should have told you these taxes were coming."
Two weeks ago, a one-day strike by lorry drivers (truckers) over high fuel prices shut down London's roads in what was called the "capital's largest-ever fuel protest."
If most of all of this is news to you, it's because the US press is studiously ignoring it. New York Times stories about Brown's situation on May 14 and May 23 have not a word about the Green Road Tax, even though many Labour MPs have been calling it a "ticking time bomb" for several weeks. Wire-service stories have also been few and far between.
There are three lessons here:
- The tax plans environmentalists want invariably end up taking their pound of flesh from the people they supposedly care about the most.
- Once people see through it, they rebel.
- Politicians interested in self-preservation aren't about to commit political suicide in the name of greenness. Their best hope is that the news media keep details of the costs away from public view until after legislation passes -- a tough task indeed in the New Media Age.
Cross-posted at BizzyBlog.com.
—Tom Blumer is president of a training and development company in Mason, Ohio, and is a contributing editor to NewsBusters





















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Thanks; nice story!
June 10, 2008 - 14:46 ET by MaximusBraveheartThat was great. Encouraged that the truth is getting out there. I loved the story yesterday about how the world is getting greener w/more CO2! It only makes sense since it is fertilizer. So they have a problem w/making plants grow faster and helping all animals in the process? CO2 is not dirty but great just like O2. The word needs to go out further about what a scam & a lie this all is to get you to sign on to a very high tax system that will:
1) force you to pay more for all fuels
2) force higher prices on anything you buy
3) force you to sell your current car prior to your plans
4) force you into a smaller car
5) impact jobs due to economic hard times; people cut back, jobs lost.
Feel free to add more items!
Car wars
June 11, 2008 - 13:01 ET by Conservative BluesSo, if I have to sell my minivan that only gets 21 mpg but fits my wife, me and our 4 children, and replace it with 2 smaller cars (try getting 2 car seats and another kid into the back of one of those gas sippers) that each get 35 mpg, won't I be falling behind in the gas wars? Not to mention needing 2 drivers and twice the chance of having an accident.
O course the risk of getting ticketed for speeding is the same since my wife always drives the speed limit.
Ecclesiastes 10:2 - "The heart of the wise inclines to the right, but the heart of the fool to the left."
We're tired of being kicked in the teeth.
June 10, 2008 - 14:47 ET by CrashEven socialistic basket case politicians have to cave when it comes to pandering to what the super majority really want.
They only want to highlight
June 10, 2008 - 14:48 ET by suzycreamcheeseThey only want to highlight the rest of the world's opinion when it comes to picking our next president.
"Dirty US Media Secret"
June 10, 2008 - 14:48 ET by needleIsn’t this a redundancy?
Impunitas semper ad deteriora invitat.
"dirty US media secret"
June 10, 2008 - 15:34 ET by larry on LIthe reason for the lack of coverage is , imo, we have more 'fellow travelers' in the msm and congress then we have ever had in US history. the carbon cap and trade is repressive socialist sceme to bleed more taxes from the consumers. the people "on the dole" will be able to avoid the burden due to government support. it doesn't look like it will get any legs presently but if things don't work out in november ,it will be jammed down our throats.
Tom, As usual, great
June 10, 2008 - 14:57 ET by Roger the ShrubberTom, As usual, great work.
There has been a woeful amount of cverage on the mayhem caused by striking truckers all across Europe. When I say "woeful", I mean the US media, of course. (At least the NYT is finally noticing)
Truckers have been striking over the high fuel costs in France, Spain, Scotland, Portugal, Holland, Bulgaria, and England in the past few weeks. Even Hong Kong, Nepal, and South Korea are beginning to revolt. Italian drivers plan to strike in early July, but are always late, so who knows when it will actually happen.
Even fishermen are striking!
No hope and some hope
June 10, 2008 - 15:34 ET by UnsaneI would be hopeful, but similar things happened in France, Germany and Britain in 2000. Their governments didn't budge and the sheeple of Europe just fell in line.
However, what I find hilarious is that the Liberals in Canada, led by Stephane Dion, think imposing a carbon tax on Canadians is a GREAT idea. If PM Harper weren't having troubles of his own, I'd hope he called an election ASAP to see what Canadians think of the idea. My guess is that, with those in Vancouver (example) paying around C$1.40 a liter for gas, that idea won't be looked upon too kindly.
Res tantum valet quantum vendi potest.
So ... it looks like high
June 10, 2008 - 15:12 ET by CrashSo ... it looks like high fuel prices are a blessing rather than a curse.
I've been thinking the same
June 10, 2008 - 15:49 ET by ApacheI've been thinking the same thing. Whenever I find myself in a water cooler debate on Global Warming, my opponents will always resort to a line like "well how can it hurt to do something about it regardless of if it deserves the hype or not?". I try to explain that as well. But like any liberal, they must see the results for themselves before it sinks in. Once they find themselves paying a dollar more for their herbal tea and soy burger then the SHTF. They only hate money when other people have more. When it is their money then even they start asking questions. To this extent, higher gas prices may actually save the economy and, for that matter, the planet from liberal dilutions of grandeur and their reliance on how they feel rather than what is fact.
Tom
June 10, 2008 - 15:22 ET by Logic over emotionExcellent job, this is a very important story.
I've been trying to find the roll call vote by vote for the Lieberman–Warner bill but can't find it. Does anyone know?
Just the final vote against cloture ....
June 10, 2008 - 15:53 ET by Tom Blumer..... is here.
Question: If the number of
June 11, 2008 - 08:31 ET by SchnikeysQuestion: If the number of votes for cloture outnumbered the number against, then why was cloture rejected? Unless I'm reading something wrong...
------------------------------------------------------------
"It could be the answer to our age-old, philosophical question, 'Why are we here?' PLASTIC!"
I think most normal people
June 10, 2008 - 15:28 ET by taterI think most normal people (i.e. non-politicans) that live in the real world realize what these scoundrals are doing. Taking a tax on something that changes all the time (climate) so that they can always tax on it. If it's too hot then it's emissions, too cold well they'll come up with something else...when most people realize that the climate is largely driven by the sun and your position on the earth.
Great articles...it's showing that some people aren't sheep out there.
www.theholyrosary.org
"There is no problem, I tell you, no matter how difficult it is, that we can not resolve by the prayer of the Holy Rosary." -Sister Lucia
Hey Tom...excellent story
June 10, 2008 - 16:25 ET by bigtimerHey Tom...excellent story and information from what is going on elsewhere world-wide...of course the msm here is ignoring all of this...they have the same green agenda, congress doesn't get it, they should by now, but just like illegal immigration, they want to shove this down our throats when we aren't looking which they count on...
Power to the People...World-Wide...let's see if we all speak out here...NOW!
..."Never murder your opponent when he is committing suicide." ~ W. Wilson
Good work Tom!
June 10, 2008 - 16:35 ET by Parker1227I think it was Hannity on Fox who reported that the House cap and trade bill took 10 hours to read on the floor.
This is really NOT what we need. Yet another overly complex tax scheme which will result in countless "hidden" taxes being passed on to consumers - hurting the middle and low income earners the hardest.
Gasoline, and heating oil, and electric bills will all spike as the direct result of cap and trade.
And who will gain the most? Cap and trade accountants and lawyers of course.
If the congress really wanted to provide some immediate relief for truckers, commuters and consumers, it would pass some "all out" oil exploration/production bills Even with real increased production years away, it would probably be enough of a psychological hit to pop the current crude oil price bubble.
Send the speculators running!
And the lies go on...
June 10, 2008 - 16:40 ET by jonesey65244Then I heard some idiot blame the failure on Bush. Duh...the Dummycrats couldn't even get all their own people to climb on this gut wagon.
I'm REALLY tired of liars. On all sides...Dums & Pubs both... If you have an idea, promote it honestly.
jonesey65244
Been waiting for the GW Media/Congressional Push,it's started...
June 10, 2008 - 21:02 ET by JayTeeI've been wondering all winter/spring why it was so Quiet on the Global Warming Front. Not a lot of stuff was going on. Of course the "Threatened" Polar bear thing recently was a BIG start...especailly for Oil Price Run UPS.
If I was a Saudi Prince, I would be Supremely Confident that Congress wasn't going to give me any Competition in Oil for the next few years....Congress is sending a Message to the Russians, Saudi's, Candians, Venuzuealans, etc..that Oil Drilling is a good investment...they got no competition from the Worlds most Powerful Economy.
Drive them prices up, and Suck the Money from the USA.
The Republican Revolution will not be Televised
JT... Not long in the
June 10, 2008 - 21:12 ET by bigtimerJT...
Not long in the distance future we are going to be giving out Congressional Medal of Honors for Global Warming.
I'm serious.
"Never murder your opponent when he is committing suicide." ~ W. Wilson
The Wages of Sin Will Always Get You
June 10, 2008 - 21:21 ET by geoff.galeI knew how much people around the world are upset by the tax loads that accompany the climate change scam because I read overseas online press extensively. But you're right, Tom, the MSM have turned a deaf ear to the subject.
Something that I've turned up in my reading is an interesting set of facts:
The lefty International Energy Agency over in Paris released a report this week that projects a total cost of $45 trillion to "fix" climate change. I have only one question to ask of George Bush, Barack Hussein Obama, John McCain, Harry Reid, Nancy Pelosi, Joe Lieberman, Al Gore, Gordon Brown, Nicolas Sarkozy, Hu Jintao, Dmitry Medvedev, Angela Merkel, Ehud Olmert, Hugo Chavez, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, Nuri al-Maliki, Bashar al-Assad, and every other leader whose name I can't recall at the moment, how are we going to afford $45 trillion while keeping our economies operating well enough to cover the basics like food and clothing?
I have to wonder how long the MSM will be able to ignore the coming world-wide wave of violence against the wealthy as more economies fall apart under the strain of climate change payments and food becomes increasingly scarce/unaffordable. In true fulfillment of the Santayanan observation about history, we are well on our way to turning the egalitarianism of democracy back into the tyranny of wealthy oligarchs and I'm afraid we will suffer the inevitable consequences of doing so.
The good news is that I'll probably be dead by the time the major problems start!
"All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing."
- Edmund Burke (1729 - 1797)
www.conservativeboot...
Liberals are just liars, that's all
June 11, 2008 - 01:40 ET by wdhorningLiberals lie about the junk science of Climate Warming and then lie about world opinion too.
What makes these people so "mentally ill?"