Buried: NY Times Plunks GOP Protest In Middle of A-15 Story Titled 'House Democrats Seek Allies for Health Care Vote'

Photo of Tim Graham.
  • Bookmark and Share

While the Washington Post ran a full news story by Philip Rucker on the conservative Capitol Hill rally on page 4 on Friday, The New York Times buried it with just six paragraphs – smack dab in in the middle of a story on A-15 headlined "House Democrats Seek Allies for Health Care Vote."

The story by Times reporters Carl Hulse and David M. Herszenhorn focused mostly on how Democrats were organizing their own caucus and gaining endorsements from the AARP, the American Medical Association, and the American Cancer Society.

In paragraph eight, the Times duo finally devoted some 230 words to the conservative rally that drew thousands of Americans from across the country:

While Democrats sought to build support, Republicans engaged in an equally determined effort to block the measure, with House Republicans lining up to address thousands of conservatives gathered at the West Front of the Capitol. No House Republican is expected to vote for the measure, meaning its entire support has to come from within the 258-member Democrat caucus.

At the rally, initiated by Representative Michele Bachmann, a Minnesota Republican, those attending were encouraged to press their lawmakers to vote against the bill. Representative John A. Boehner of Ohio, the Republican leader, called it the "greatest threat to freedom that I have seen in the 19 years I’ve been in Washington."

"Let’s get to work," Representative Marsha Blackburn, Republican of Tennessee, exhorted the crowd. "We’ve got a lot of work to do between now and Saturday."

Arriving from around the country, the opponents were imbued with conservative principles and skepticism of the federal government’s ability to administer health care programs.

"The government couldn’t even get the shots out," said Karen Ambrose of Sunbury, Ohio, ridiculing the government’s efforts to vaccinate people for the H1N1 virus as an example of what government-run health care would look like. "Let’s just get the government out of all this."

After the rally, the Capitol police arrested a dozen protesters on charges of causing a disturbance at offices of Ms. Pelosi in the Cannon Building.

The reporters made no mention of the nine far-left Code Pink protesters arrested in Senator Joe Lieberman’s office. On the bright side, the Times didn’t find wacky signs and suggest they represented the entire crowd, as reporters sometimes do.

The rally was briefly mentioned in paragraph two, as Hulse and Herszenhorn anticipated Nancy Pelosi’s accelerated "landmark vote" for enhanced statism:

Democratic vote counters, working as thousands of conservative protesters chanted "kill the bill" outside the Capitol and later swarmed through Congressional office buildings, said they did not yet have the necessary 218 confirmed supporters. But they said they were confident they would exceed that total in time for a landmark vote set for Saturday on the $1.1 trillion, 10-year health plan that many Democrats have sought for years.

The rally was also mentioned on a front-page promo, which carried the classic Times bias of Democrats vs. conservatives:

Readying for Health Care Vote

As House Democratic leaders worked furiously to secure the final votes for weekend approval of a sweeping health care overhaul, conservatives turned out to protest the measure.

David Herszenhorn’s blog post on the rally yesterday, on the "Prescriptions" blog, interviewed more average Americans – and he suggested they were not very diverse:

It’s a generally older crowd, many in their 50s and 60s, predominantly, white, and many self-identified as Christians. They are fiercely conservative and deeply skeptical of the government, many of them adamantly opposed to abortion rights.

He also suggested they’re just repeating Fox News mantras:

Mr. Hershberger, like many of the demonstrators, repeated some of the most common conservative and Republican talking points heard repeatedly on Fox News. "It’s not bipartisan," he said, standing outside the Capitol wearing a Texas Longhorns baseball cap. "They are doing it behind closed doors." He added: "It’s going to drive us into a super-deficit."

UPDATE: Appearing with and debating MRC President Brent Bozell on Friday morning's Fox & Friends, New York Times columnist Charles Blow insisted conservative rallies are being over-covered. Did he see today's newspaper?

The implication that this doesn’t get covered is ridiculous. Yesterday in the afternoon, when it was happening, it was the lead story on Fox News. It was the display story on NYTimes.com. It was the display story on MSNBC.com. It’s everywhere. You do a basic search, tea party search – thousands of hits on the New York Times just in the last 30 minutes, last 30 days alone. It’s everywhere. I think it gets more coverage than it needs – especially when it was organized by Michelle Bachmann, when every time she opens her mouth she makes Sarah Palin sound like the president of Mensa. The idea that we’re not covering this enough is ridiculous to me.

Blow exaggerated just a little that you'd get "thousands of hits" from the New York Times on tea parties. A quick Nexis search of the last 30 days finds a modest seven news stories,  editorials and book reviews mentioning (often disparaging) tea-party protests.

—Tim Graham is Director of Media Analysis at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

"...with House Republicans

"...with House Republicans lining up to address thousands of conservatives gathered at the West Front of the Capitol. " 

...while House Democrats address the concerns of "caring Americans", huh? Again, the liberal media seek to marginalize and dismiss an anti-health ruin protest by labeling it "conservative" - implying that the crowd was just a bunch of activists. How does the NYT know that everyone who gathered in DC was a "conservative"? I'd bet that many were Independents who just don't want their health care destroyed.

The "Mainstream" Media: By liberals. For liberals.

Chris Norman Is Right

Yes, newspapers accurately describe these protesters as "conservatives." What's funny about this isn't that labeling -- it's the lack of labeling when the protesters are leftists.

Graham's Law of Labeling:

The epic political battles of time seem to be fought between the conservatives and the nonpartisans.

It's time that Congress was afraid of the people

All conservatives and independants who object to unconstitutional laws and programs being passed by Congress like the health care takeover, TARP, the Bailout, 12am deals that sell one private company to another (Lehman Bros), etc. Should let all their representatives know that in the next election we are going to...

Throw 'da bums out!!!

Before it's too late. 

www.loyaltoliberty.com

move along

nothing to see here.

 

nothing to see

Adjusting the famous NYT motto:  "All the news that's fit to print.*"

----------
* Except the stuff that makes our side look bad or our opposition look good.

It goes both ways

Yeah, the NYT isn't going to hype tea party protests. just like the republican media wouldn't cover the gay rights march a month ago when tens of thousands went to the capital to protest

Now it doesn't and shouldn't matter to the media whether you personally agree or disagree with gay marriage, if fox "news" covers news as they say they should at least do some reporting on it, but they didn't even send a camera. however they did send many cameras to the dozen or so people who protested the obama school kids song. i mean come on, really? 70 thousand people on capital hill, no cameras - a dozen in a school yard the entire fleet?

 "fair and balance, you decide" is complete BS and has been proven so. 

I just think that both sides of the media should be called out. if you're outraged by slanted, or unfair coverage by one side you should, if you have principles,  should be outraged by the same conduct on the other side as well.  

 

They do bother to cover the

They do bother to cover the NEWS WAY more balanced than 99% of the DEMonic MSM media.  The ratings tell the story.  And conservative shows are not their news coverage.  How dare a conservative voice be heard.  Off with their heads per the WH.

M-B

nice try

Talk radio shows either ignored the gay protest or criticized it.  That's the nature of partisan shows regardless of their ideology.  The 'republican news' (though to be fair, Fox is really more pro-business than pro-GOP) didn't lead with the story and didn't give it a whole lot of time, but they did cover it.  The number of search hits was way too large to find all or even the best, but here's the first link I found:

http://www.foxnews.c...

The media of all venues can

The media of all venues can bury, minimize, lie or ignore a major event all they want...they aren't the power anymore, whether they like it or not, this has been there own making, anything for their agenda...the internet is the main news, along with talk radio for real conservatives...

...so keep it up all you want...it no longer matters to me...I just want to see the day you all go belly-up...one way or the other.

'Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea'~Breitbart

NYT

Today the Gray Lady cut off comment on Krugman in 11 comments. Bad enough they never leave time for the West Coast--now the East Coast was apparently not going his way...something about indecisiveness and Anzio...I glazed.

Sit-in and Kill-the-Bill

Sit-in and Kill-the-Bill footage, featuring an elderly priest being carried away 3 cops.

 

"Steady."  -- Keith Olbermann to Chris Matthews

lotr... Hey thanks for

lotr...

Hey thanks for the link....because of what happened yesterday a lot wasn't covered that happened yesterday on the Hill...not that a lot of the msm was going to cover it anyway, but Fox was streaming live, then along came Gibbs and O at the WH Briefing....no, that wasn't intentional that O showed up there first supposedly out of the blue to thank the AARP first...what blatant BS they pulled...they have zilch for brains...or class.

'Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea'~Breitbart

Great stuff

I felt sorry for the Capitol cops, you could tell they weren't into arresting these people.

I hope Nanny Pelosi rots.

I hope he fails, too.

 

 

I was there and it was awesome :o)

My husband and I attended this rally and it was wonderful.  And the first thing Michelle Bachman said when she stood up to speak was, "You came!"  

That alone made it worth it :o) 

Me - "The libs/dems of today are the Quislings of former years - the cowards who would vote a fraud into office in exchange for handouts from the devil."

Hey Helen... Wished I

Hey Helen...

Wished I could have been there as well, had to catch all of it early hours this morning to hear all speakers etc.

I enjoyed reading others that were there live yesterday on Twitter and talking with them along the way.

So many people there on such short notice...can you imagine the numbers if there had been more time....of course the majority of the msm and the administration did their best to deflect..including O.

I'm still catching up with some things today that happened yesterday...thank goodness for the internet.

'Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea'~Breitbart

We were there too, Helen.

I wish i could have seen the speakers...too short, tall signs and tall people in front of me but thank goodness we could hear just fine.   We heard that Nancy had put herself in a bunker.  CAN YOU BELIEVE THAT!!  What a drama queen.   I was a little ticked at the blatant show of Assault Rifles by the guards on the steps.   It was insulting and an obvious attempt at intimidation. 

CJ... Drama Queen is

CJ...

Drama Queen is right and a dumb one at that.

As to the assualt rifles/guards...it had to be intimidating...sad what is happening to our country daily...hopefully we can take our country back...soon.

Too bad you couldn't see them, I understand that frustration, but well worth it all, like I said, sure wished I could have been with all of you great patriots...thank God for all of you.

'Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea'~Breitbart

In Spirit

I was with you in spirit and since I couldn't be there I took the time to call the offices of my rep and both senators.  Wanted to make sure they knew my opinion was to not support the health and cap 'n trade bills.

"Fighters are fun but bombers make policy"

thats so adorable and god

thats so adorable and god bless you that you speak up for the billion dollar corporations., the status quo. screw the poor and the "i can't afford that surgery" right? rock on!!!!

what flavor was the kool-aid?

Cherry?  Or grape, perhaps?  You learned your Marxist sound bite well.

The "screw the poor and the 'i can't afford that surgery' right?" part will change in only one way:  The poor will still be denied the surgery; but people who could afford to won't be allowed to get services beyond the limits of the gubm'nt-standard coverage, even if they're willing to pay out of their own pocket.

We're not inventing universal coverage, people.  We have at least half a dozen countries with mature systems in place already, and we can see what direction these systems evolve by looking at them.  Rationing of care is inevitable, and both doctors and patients will be punished if they go outside the system for 'extra' services.

Like good Marxist 'solutions', people are made equal not by lifting the living standard of the poor, but by lowering the living standard of all the rest.

And the NYT subscribers

And the NYT subscribers numbers are plunked lower and lower each month.

Ignore the NYT, its day has come and gone. 

Who the Lieberman 9 are

They are not Code Pink. The action was organized by Mobilization for Healthcare for All: http://www.healthcar...

 Four of the nine arrested were constituents of Lieberman.