Flashback 2007: Bloody-Handed Condi Rice Protester Never Painted as 'Ugly' or Even Liberal

Photo of Tim Graham.
  • Bookmark and Share

Brent Baker revealed how the network news on Thursday night described Rep. Joe Wilson’s "you lie" comment at President Obama as almost an international incident, a "shout heard ‘round the world" that symbolized the "ugly" tone of anti-Obama sentiment and a sign of disrespect on Capitol Hill.

It’s probably not shocking to remember that on Wednesday, October 24, 2007, when Code Pink protester Desiree al-Fairooz screamed at Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice that she was a "war criminal" at a hearing of the House Foreign Affairs Committee, none of the networks described it as "ugly," and NBC painted it as another sign of disarray for Team Bush.

On the Nightly News, reporter Andrea Mitchell weaved the Code Pink protest into a story on how the State Department was struggling with contractors in maintaining security in Iraq:

ANDREA MITCHELL:Before she even confronted lawmakers today, the secretary of state came face to face with a protester --

UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN: War criminal!

MITCHELL: – on top of scathing criticism, even from her own investigators, of the huge State Department security operation in Iraq.

CONDOLEEZZA RICE (Secretary of State): The department is being asked to do things in numbers and in size that are well beyond the bounds of we had been asked to do before.

MITCHELL: An acknowledgement of the disarray, today her top deputy for security, Richard Griffin, resigned abruptly.

Mitchell ended the story: "Under fire, Secretary Rice today promised more oversight, cameras to track contractors and better coordination with the military. Andrea Mitchell, NBC News."

The tone was aptly captured by the headline in Nexis: "State Department unable to handle war in Iraq."

CBS anchor Katie Couric was anchoring from San Diego, and only noted the protest stunt in passing:

On Capitol Hill, Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice was confronted by an anti-war protester at a hearing of the House Foreign Affairs Committee. The woman shouted "war criminal" before she and several other protesters were dragged away by the police. The secretary was unfazed by the outburst, and testified she expects there will be a Mideast peace conference between Israel and the Palestinians in November or December.

ABC mentioned the incident the next morning, as Good Morning America news anchor Chris Cuomo briefly noted: "A close confrontation for Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice on Capitol Hill. A protester with painted hands to symbolize blood managed to get in the secretary's face, calling her a war criminal. Rice, though, was unfazed and went on to testify about Mideast policy."

None of the networks made any attempt to identify the protester as Code Pink or describe her as liberal or leftist or radical. She was merely "anti-war."

On Friday morning’s Today, NBC anchor Matt Lauer asked Rice about the incident, but he never described it as "ugly," but simply as something that may have "frazzled" the Secretary:

LAUER: Let me end on just a different subject. On Wednesday you were set to appear before the House Foreign Relations Committee and a protester walked right up to your face, Madam Secretary, and said--with red paint on her hands and said, quote, "The blood of millions of Iraqis is on your hands." She was taken out of the room. Not on a policy level, on a personal level, what was your response to that moment? Were you angered? Were you upset? Were you frazzled? How did you respond to it?

RICE: No. In fact, she was there, she was taken away. Look, I know what I'm doing and I know what this administration has done to liberate millions of people from the tyranny and the grip of Saddam Hussein and to give them a chance for a better, more democratic future.

More on that here.

—Tim Graham is Director of Media Analysis at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

let me guess

This is different for litany of reasons and conservies should stop playing the equivalence game.

That about sum it up, lefties?

 

Bingo, Candance

We have a winner!

 

"I support the President but not his policies" - Blonde

It's a decent comparison,

It's a decent comparison, except that Desiree al-Fairooz isn't a senator. 

No, but for a period of

No, but for a period of times certain leftist Senators provided seating to the liberal nut-jobs to assure such commotion. 

 I recall the press was asked why they did not querry who provided the tickets to a closed session testimony to Code Pink ladies.  Those tickets were not available to the public and were distributed by the committee members.

So, PROXY war anyone?

Desiree al-Fairooz isn't a senator

Niether is Wilson... he's a congressman.

"What a revoltin' development this is!"

Chester Riley

LOL, I was going to comment exactly. Bal doesn't seem to know

the distinction.

Even so, I believe what happened to Condy was much much more dangerous and over the top.

Yes, representative,

Yes, representative, hardy-har-har. The point remains the same.

Bal: But you would have

Bal:

But you would have been fine with WIlson providing his ticket to a guy wearing an Uncle Sam Costume in the gallery who called the president a liar?

It is the inverse of what ht e left did for eight years.

 BD: No. And again, it's

 BD: No. And again, it's not quite the inverse when it's a congressman doing it in an address to Congress, and a Code Pink nutball doing it at a hearing.

So Bal

When Reid called President Bush a liar and a loser that was ok because it wasnt at congress.Oh I loved the boos by the Dems at Bushes speeches.Showed their class.Just a note:Reid was Minority Leader at the time.

well99, who said anything

well99, who said anything about Reid's comment being OK? 

balboa

Seems like everyone has forgotten about that and Reid was top dog in the senate for Dems.Want to bet if you can find more links on Joe Wilson or Rieds comments.

well99, no I don't want to

well99, no I don't want to be, since I wasn't talking about it.

It is EXACTLY. Except the

It is EXACTLY.

Except the congressman had the guts to say it himself rather than use a proxy.

candance

Balboa has a very good point a few post above. You can hardly compare a protester to a sitting Senator. Unless the msm is hiding something, I don't ever recall a Dem House or Senate calling Bush a liar during one of his speeches 

"I swear sometimes the self-appointed moral police are as obnoxious and demanding of big government interference as "environmentalist" gun control advocates, labor unions and trial lawyers"~fitzfong

technically speaking

Wilson isn't a Senator either (he's a house critter) but I cede your point.

Still, though, you have to admit. The media's acting like Wilson's outburst is armageddon. The collective assault from people like Miss Desiree here was much more vicious and encouraged by the media, which I would argue was more damaging than Wilson's little outburst.

 

Shawn

Lets take a look at Harry Reid

"Reid originally called Bush a "liar" in 2002 after a speech that Bush gave about storing nuclear waste at Yucca Mountain in Nevada, saying, " President Bush is a liar. He betrayed Nevada and the betrayed the country."

Did he get censured for that?

That might be true well99

.....but he did not say it during Bush's speech, in fact I don't ever recall it happening 

"I swear sometimes the self-appointed moral police are as obnoxious and demanding of big government interference as "environmentalist" gun control advocates, labor unions and trial lawyers"~fitzfong

Shawn

I not surprised.Does location matter?So if a congressman said a President was a coke dealer it would be ok as long as it wasnt during a speech?Oh by the way Harry was minority leader at the time.You can google it easy enough.The year 2002.

It does not make it right well

I agree, I am just saying I don't ever recall a member of congress calling a President a liar. Obviously if Joe Wilson was not ashamed by his actions or covering his @ss, he would not have apologized 

"I swear sometimes the self-appointed moral police are as obnoxious and demanding of big government interference as "environmentalist" gun control advocates, labor unions and trial lawyers"~fitzfong

Shawn

It wasnt right for Obama to call Sara Palin a liar either.Obama stirred the pot so I dont find Wilson outburst offensive.Whats good for the goose is good for the gander.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/05/06/AR2005050601814.html

Senate Democratic leader Harry Reid called President Bush "a loser" during a civics discussion with a group of teenagers at a high school on Friday.

"The man's father is a wonderful human being," Reid, D-Nev., told students at Del Sol High School when asked about the president's policies. "I think this guy is a loser."

Senate Leader Calls Bush 'A Loser'
LAS VEGAS, May 7, 2005
http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2005/05/07/politics/main693713.shtml

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/6646457/

 

tired of liberal

tired of liberal lies

.....but he did not say it during Bush's speech, in fact I don't ever recall it happening 

Exactly no MSM outrage, no outrage when the code pinkers were given passes by Democrats to attack Rice.   Hee Hee Hee can you imagine the media and Democrats reaction if a Republican gave a pass to a code pinker to pull this stunt on Clinton, their collective heads would explode. LOL

Our garden variety liberals do not care what happens to

conservatives...  ever.  That much is quite obvious when you read their comments from day to day.   What is apparent is their ability to reason away such dangerous situations like code pinkers being able to get that close to GWB's people and make such hay over a representative speaking truth to power during one of O's many lying sessions to congress.

eh....  nuttin' we can do about 'em 'cept watch them swirl the toilet bowl as they go down..... weeeeeee

I recall the zombie, Harry

I recall the zombie, Harry Reid, referring to then-president Bush as a "loser" while speaking at a high school sometime during Bush's second term.

And I distinctly recall hearing boos, obviously from the lefties, during a State of the Union address by president Bush in 2005 or 2006; remember those?

The scum and perverts in the MSM had no problem with that at all.  In fact, they like it.

I guess that maybe I shouldn't try to draw a comparison because, after all, it was against Bush and he deserved it, right? 

Was Wilson a genius?

I wish Wilson hadn't apologized.  At the least, I wish he had
cunningly phrased it so it sounded exactly like one of Obama's
'non-apologies'.

It would have been SOOO rich to have him standing in front of a
breathless liberal press corp, with their tongues hanging out, waiting
with slobbering mouths to hear him grovel.  

Only to have him say, 'I promised to apologize - and here it is. 
I'm sorry I called Obama a liar during his speech. I should have waited
till AFTER his speech to call him a liar.'  and agian, 'I am indeed
sorry.  I'm so very, very sorry that Obama lied to the american
people.  My heart is filled with the deepest remorse that Obama is such
a liar...'

But even so, what he did was brilliant.  Even with his apology.  He
may have planned the outburst because he knew it would throw every lib
in the room and across the media back on their heels.

Yesterday's speech was supposed to be Obama putting the protesters
in the doghouse.  It was supposed to be Obama's godly voice from Mt.
Olympus, squashing the protestors beneath his mighty heel while
everyone grabbed their ankles and waited for the reaming with hushed
voices.

And what happened instead?  Wilson exposed Obama as a short tempered
brat, on national TV, in front of the entire nation.  Him, and Biden,
Pelosi, et. al stood there flabbergasted and stunned as what was
supposed to be a protest-free gathering was drowned out by the loudest
protest of all - a simple two-word shout to our two-faced president.

Now they're scrambling around doing damage control for yet another
of his disastrous speeches.  Instead of talking about how brilliant Obama's speech was, they're talking about how Wilson called him 'liar' and they're repeating the 'liar' clip over and over again - giving it MORE air time.

Wilson may have apologized, but he
accomplished his mission.  All the world heard Obama being called a liar -
right in the middle of a speech where he was ordering his critics to
shut up and go away...

"Facts are stubborn things"

"Facts are stubborn things" John Adams, circa unknown

It wasn't what he said, but where he said it

Although I agree he had no need to apologize, at all, Wilson didn't apologize for what he said, only for where he said it.  I think he showed great restraint waiting as long as he did. He could have yelled 'liar' approx. 45 times during the "speech" and been spot on,  up to the point he did break, he' and America had already been subjected to about 15 lies.

"Life's tough.....It's even tougher if you're stupid"-John Wayne

Rush Limbaugh played the audio of George W. Bush's

State of the Union in his second term where he was booed by the Democrats.

Rush Limbaugh radio transcript:

RUSH:....Let's go back to 2005. It's unprecedented, Charlie Gibson never heard anything like this; Brian Williams never heard anything like this. State of the Union address, first one of his second term, February 2, 2005.

BUSH: By the year 2042 the entire system would be exhausted and bankrupt. (crowd rumbling) If steps are not taken to avert that outcome, the only solutions would be dramatically higher taxes, massive new borrowing, or sudden and severe cuts in Social Security benefits or other government programs. (booing)

RUSH: Got booed in 2005, what about the decorum there, what about the precious protocol? And, of course, Bush was telling the truth here about Social Security where it was headed and his attempt to reform it. Same night, same speech, Ted Koppel reported after the speech, said this.

KOPPEL: When the president talked about the bankruptcy of Social Security there were clearly some Democrats on the floor who thought that that was taking it too far, and they did something that -- they booed.

RUSH: Well, Ted Koppel describing it, it happened numerous times, and they did something that was taking it too far. Bush wasn't lying about anything. Barack Obama was lying through his teeth last night. That's taking it too far. That demeaned the entire chamber. If you want to talk about demeaning the chamber, the president of the United States demeaned the chamber last night. He showed up and lied through his teeth. He was petulant, he was mean-spirited, he was angry, he was arrogant, conceited, condescending, but more than anything else he lied through his teeth and everybody knows it. Everybody knows it. Here's John Roberts, cookie-cutter anchor at the time working for CBS. He was the White House correspondent talking about the boos that Bush got in 2005.

ROBERTS: At a couple of points in this address it looked more like the British parliament than the United States Congress. I've never heard the minority party shout at the president during the State of the Union address.

-----------------------------------------------------

Purchase a YOU LIE magnetic bumper sticker at
World Net Daily Superstore.

Cong.Joe Wilson

I also think Mr. Wilson should not have apologized.  It was just instinct and he couldn't help himself.   He's listening to lie after lie and just couldn't stop himself.

Go Cong.Wilson, Go Rush Limbaugh.   You both have hit the nail on the head about Pres.Obama.  Sen.McCain is a disgrace and doesn't even know what we Americans want.  No wonder he lost the election.

I saw him on his Town Halls, and he never even made any sense, and is a RINO.

if he did not apologize

.....it would have put other GOP politicians in a bad postion, they would either have to agree with him or denounce him. 

"I swear sometimes the self-appointed moral police are as obnoxious and demanding of big government interference as "environmentalist" gun control advocates, labor unions and trial lawyers"~fitzfong

agree or denounce

Other than Obama himself, how many Democrats have been asked to denounce Van Jones?

 

We could ask JasonC, he is here in this thread today.

  Of course, he may not want to pipe in. He forte is squishy issues, quotes from Hollywood loons, fallacious arguments, Obamby gushylove, and Ann Coulter.

  Something hard like the racist, hatin', trutherin', ecoloony communist Van Jones. Nah, he will give it a country mile.

  Even Binky won't stick up for him.

tired of liberal lies Oh

tired of liberal lies

Oh please...only Republicans are required to apologize for other Republicans-Democrats aren't even required as to their opinion on the statements of other Democrats by the media.  Didn't you get the memo one standard for those with a R after their name and another for those with a D after their name.

Fortunately for the dems they did not have to make that decision

 
Fortunately for the dems they did not have to make that decision candance, If Van Jones did not resign, they would have had to. Also Van Jones disgusting statements were made over 5 years ago, Joe Wilson said this two days ago and he is still has his job.

Obviously he is scared of losing his job, that is the only reason he apologized but it was still the right thing to do.

"I swear sometimes the self-appointed moral police are as obnoxious and demanding of big government interference as "environmentalist" gun control advocates, labor unions and trial lawyers"~fitzfong

merlin61....I really loved it today when Rush Limbaugh was

discussing John McCain, and said THIS:

RUSH: So he [McCain] partially throws Sarah Palin under the bus there which was... You know, he's just a useful idiot. They bring him in to do exactly what he did, and that has undercut everything that the Republican opponents, conservative opponents of Obama and health care are saying. He just falls right in line with it. But this is why Senator McCain lost.

==================================


"Powell's not a Republican.  McCain's not a Republican.  These guys are not even mavericks.  They are Washingtonians. Washingtonians have their own culture and their own desires, and it is to matter.  They don't care who's in power, they just want to be closely associated with whoever is.  That's the name of the game and they want press adulation.  They want to be loved and adored by the media, they want fawning treatment, they want to be thought of as something special, unique, dignified and so forth, and that's the Washington establishment." ~ Rush Limbaugh

Rush is right on the money when he makes those comments.

McCain beat himself.  He was hoplessly drifting left of the spectrum w/o a rudder, plan, idea.... and yet, he barely lost the key states by popular vote.

His only wise choice was that of choosing Sarah Palin as his VP.

Period.

McCain/Palin

His only wise choice was that of choosing Sarah Palin as his VP.

I have to wonder if that was really his idea! 

"I ask, Sir, what is the militia? It is the whole people. To disarm the people is the best and most effectual way to enslave them."
George Mason

"I have to wonder if that was really his idea! "

Damn Sarge! That's a very good point! I'll bet he had very little input on the choice, at least to begin with. He most likely wanted Lieberman.

Gary

Levi Johnstoned: The One Trick Phoney!

There is one word in the link to the old Newsbusters article.

  Elevating Publicity Stunts...

  Elevating - instead of leftist publicity stunts, we have normal Americans that are not being heard by the people they elected. And the MSM is helping to block their voices with the belittling, condescension, and insults.

  Rep. Joe Wilson is another line in the escalation. We need to be heard or the escalation will continue. I am wondering what is next, where the anger will pop up again.

Sincerely,

a Veteran of a 1000 psychic wars.

You lie!

Joe Wilson should have apologised, here is what he should have said:

"I am deeply sorry for any who might have thought my remark was in some way offensive. I let my emotions take over and I acted like a Democrat and that has shamed me. I will do my best to never let that happen again."

Get yourself a Joe Wilson bumper sticker.

D

Write your Congress and Senate and tell them what YOU think!

Keep the ILLEGALS out, join NumbersUSA to send free faxes to your reps.

I guess those codepink

I guess those codepink idiots got tired of being upstaged over the last few months.  At least they're not packing heat and misrepresenting Jefferson's aphorism about the tree of liberty...but this is still pretty embarassing.  I like how Condi barely even looks rattled by this protester.  And how has the latter not been tackled by a bodyguard at this point in the picture?

Is this where Binky slunk off to.

   Codepink has been visiting the Palestinians. Still busy.

   Who was packing heat? You referring to the black man that was at a protest separate from any town halls the President was to planning to appear? The only guy packing heat in the news the last few months? The guy that MSNBC tried to paint as a white right winger?

   Now why oh why do I know about the above, but you seem to know so little? Also, the woman was never tackled. She was escorted, not even roughly away from Miss Rice. She was escorted by SECURITY, not bodyguards. Very few people in government are protected by bodyguards.

  Now, why do I know that too, and Binky seems so clueless again.

  Kudos, you finally reserved one of your put downs for someone on the left, too bad it was a kook. Not like the average everyday Americans you normally put down. 

Sincerely,

a Veteran of a 1000 psychic wars.

Ps: How is ignoring me workin' out for ya, Binky?

Various problems with

Various problems with Sporty's post:

I never said the person packing heat was white.  Or a right-winger.  There were white people conspicuously carrying guns as well, though the person you refer to was noteworthy for carrying an assault rifle rather than a simple sidearm.

That's nice that she was escorted rather than tackled.  If I were in Condi's shoes, I'd have preferred tackling before the lunatic got anywhere near me.  Security, not bodyguards.  Fine, Mr. Hair-Splitter.  For all intents and purposes in my original post, I'm comfortable with using them interchangeably.

I reject your premise that I put down everyday regular Americans on a regular basis.  I put down those on the right who make an embarassing spectacle of themselves in order to advance their usually-wrong viewpoint.  And to say they are the average ones is pretty funny since they are obviously of the coterie that did NOT vote for Obama, and are thus not in the majority.

I'm going out for awhile now sporty, so if you reply to this and I don't get right back to you, no need to send a PM to alert me to that fact, mmkay?

Cue the deluge of posts

Cue the deluge of posts apprising me that "There's no such thing as an assault rifle!!  That's something the anti-gun left invented!!1!!!."

Tough, I'll call it what I like. 

Oh, cool... can I make up names too?

I feel that liberals are total deuche bags and basically feel the DB label is quite more fitting.

JasonC: "Tough, I'll call it what I like." ~ comments on rifles.

Binky Braveheart is back to the majority talk again.

   Binky thinks we are all stuped and stuk in Irak.

JasonC - bum.bum.bum ---- MATHMASTER!

July 9, 2009 - 07:15 ET by JWF

 But he was elected, by an overwhelming majority of U.S. citizens...

 He got 69 Million votes. 53% of the vote*.

 JasonC new math everybody! 53% is now OVER-FRIGGIN-WHELMING! BOOM! TAKE THAT! BAM! He got 3% over FRIGGIN HALF/HALF! 50% + 3% OVER-FRIGGIN-WHELMING! SNAP!

 Now, come on guys, I know, I am not being fair. He did say CITIZENS, not voters. The population of the U.S is 305 million, and 69 million of that or 22% is INDEED considered OVER-FRIGGIN-WHELMING according to JasonC's new math people!

 OK. OK. OK. Maybe he mispoke. Maybe he meant to say this...

But he was elected, by an overwhelming majority of U.S. citizens that were ill-informed, stupid, or card carrying socialists...

 Now that statement is factually true. 65 million of the 69 million democrat voters are ill-informed, stupid, or card carrying socialists. The other 4 million are dead, homeless multiple voters, or completely fictitious. THANKS ACORN!

 JasonC - opposer of war (boy scout honor badge - war opposer (13 Dec 2003***)) & now mathmaster!

Sincerely,

a Veteran of a 1000 psychic wars.  

Sincerely,

a Veteran of a 1000 psychic wars.

No. Binky does not put down everyday Americans. Nah.

 Binky: I reject your premise that I put down everyday regular Americans on a regular basis.  I put down those on the right

Binky:  new paranoiac fringe right... mouth-frothing hysterics.... sect of uneducated people...  shrieking inane, demented opinions... ...taking their marching orders from Beck and Limbaugh. same morass of self-righteous idiocy... 

Nah, Binky is right. He does not put down his fellow citizens at every opportunity. Nah. Not at all. Move along people.

K. Binky. Tell us all now how illegal aliens won't get government health care. Then tell us how Obama is gonna fight all teh fraud, waste and abuse just as soon as the Health Care Bill is signed

But wait Binky, iffin there is so much fraud wasted and abuse, why are we waiting until a bill is signed. For gawd sake Binky, you and Uncle Obama go fight that NOW! Why wait?

Sincerely,

a Veteran of a 1000 psychic wars.

Binky Braveheart's new math boys and girls!

69 million (overwhelming majority of U.S. citizens that voted for Obama)

 +  

15 million (number of illegal aliens elegible for ObamaCare)

________________________________ 

= Whole lotta new buddies for Binky Braveheart the War Opposer at Newsbusters.

JWF

I hope all is well my friend. Since we are friends I hope you don't mind if I ask you a question.  I understand your feelings toward Bink....ummm Jason, but do you feel if you want to taunt your opponent,  wouldn't one post  do just as well as 3 or more in a row?

"I swear sometimes the self-appointed moral police are as obnoxious and demanding of big government interference as "environmentalist" gun control advocates, labor unions and trial lawyers"~fitzfong

Stockin' the pantry buddy.

  I know you are gonna miss me when I hit the sack.

Guess who interrupted Bush's speech?

Guess who interrupted Bush's State of the Union speech to Congress in 2006? That's right, Senator Obama!  And Hilary Clinton, and several other liberal members of Congress. Where is the MSM outrage over that?  You won't find any.  Liberal's, you are all a bunch of hypocrites!

The Citizens of each State shall be entitled to all Privileges and Immunities of Citizens in the several States.
The US Constitution

Unless you're a fetus.
The US Supreme Court

cobra -- that's great.

cobra -- that's great. thanks for the link.

Gosh -- Obama and his gang of media apologists are so tech savvy -- funny how they never seem to remember that everything he ever did is on digital somewhere.

Conservatives believe in the laws of Supply and Demand. Leftists operate with the Big Lie and Command.

Here's another one.

Here's another example of Democrats interrupting Bush during a SOTU speech in 2005.  Listen for the "boos" coming from the Democrats 7 seconds into the clip. Joe, the democrats hardly know ya, at least they won't admit it.

The Citizens of each State shall be entitled to all Privileges and Immunities of Citizens in the several States.
The US Constitution

Unless you're a fetus.
The US Supreme Court

what???

I am aghast and bamboozled that he actually showed up for anything remotely associated with the US Senate.
He must have thought it was a fundraiser or community event, rather that a State of the Union.
Sam: "I hurt somebody's feelings once"

Where is Code Pink now that

Where is Code Pink now that it's been 7.5 months now and "savior" Obama has yet to bring the troops home?