Eight-Year-Old Gang-Raped, Shunned by Family: CNN's First and Only Network On It

Photo of Tim Graham.
  • Bookmark and Share

An eight-year-old girl, gang-raped by four young boys in Phoenix, then blamed for the rape by her family and shunned: how quickly and heavily will the media respond? Where is President Obama, who can comment on local police matters in Cambridge, Massachusetts? So far, Nexis shows CNN is the first and only network on this story, which should captivate Nancy Grace and Greta van Susteren for weeks, not to mention network morning shows. Here’s a summary from AP:

Authorities said Thursday that four boys ages 9 to 14 took turns raping an 8-year-old girl behind a shed for more than 10 minutes in what Phoenix police are calling one of the most horrific cases they've ever seen.

The outrage over the allegations intensified after police said the girl's parents criticized her after the attack and blamed her for bringing shame on the family.

"The father told the caseworker and an officer in her presence that he didn't want her back. He said, 'Take her, I don't want her,' " police Sgt. Andy Hill said.

...Phoenix investigators said the boys lured the girl to an empty shed July 16 under the pretense of offering her gum. The boys held the girl down while they took turns assaulting her, police said.

"She was brutally sexually assaulted for a period of about 10 to 15 minutes," Hill said.

Officers responding to an emergency call reporting hysterical screams found the girl partially clothed and the boys running from the scene.

Here's a story from ABC-15 in Phoenix. Will the major media's racial and religious sensitivities affect their coverage of the story? Liberia is estimated by the Department of State to be about 40 percent Christian, 40 percent indigenous African belief, and 20 percent Muslim. CNN reported the story on Friday (and apparently on Thursday), but Nexis presented only one transcript Friday, in the 2 pm hour. Why wouldn't CNN be carrying this every hour?

CNN anchor Kyra Phillips interviewed the president of Liberia, Ellen Johnson Sirleaf, and the Liberian ambassador to America. Here's a transcript:

KYRA PHILLIPS, CNN ANCHOR: All right, we're moving ahead at the top of the hour right now. It's a shocking crime scene, all the more shocking because of the age of the alleged victim and the age of the suspects. We're pushing forward on a story we first brought you yesterday. A 14-year-old boy and three younger boys accused of gang -- gang raping, rather, an eight-year-old girl in an empty shed near a Phoenix apartment building. All five are Liberian refugees.

Police call it one of the most horrific crimes that they've seen. Perhaps even more disturbing, the fallout. Police took the girl away from her family, saying relatives blamed her for the rape.

Now, the three younger boys have been charged as juveniles, but the 14-year-old, he's being charged as an adult. But this story's far from over. Now, friends and relatives of the older boy say that prosecutors are going way too far. Here's Kristine Harrington from Phoenix affiliate KTVK.

FEMALE: I beg you, I want to see my son. I want to see my son. My son.

KRISTINE HARRINGTON, KTVK: A mother heartbroken. Her 14-year-old son Steven Tuopeh behind bars, charged with kidnapping and sexual assault, making his first appearance in court where prosecutors say he not only participated in, but initiated the sexual assault of an 8-year-old girl.

FEMALE: The defendant was the person who gathered people together, bribed the other individual who actually committed the majority of the assault, and held the victim down while she was sexually assaulted.

HARRINGTON: The other three boys, nine, 10, and 13 years old, are being charged as juveniles. This mom doesn't understand why her son is being tried as an adult, unwilling to believe the charges against him.

FEMALE: I want to see my son. For a day, I've never seen my son.

HARRINGTON: Tuopeh and his family are Liberian refugees. They've only been here in the United States since 2005, and his family worries...

MALE: Whether he did it or not, he does not understand the people that he's talking to.

HARRINGTON: In court, this teenage boy was a man of few words, opting not to speak when asked if he had anything to say regarding his being held on no bond.

MALE: He does not speak English very well, and he does not understand English very well. He did not go to school. He started going to school when he came to the United States. And so, we deduced that he cannot really understand what is going on right now. And so everything that is being said to him, he has no choice but just to accept it even though he did not understand.

PHILLIPS: All right. Just a follow-up to that. We did talk to sources close to the investigation, sources that actually spoke with this young boy. And we are being told that he does speak English, so we want to make that clear.

Meanwhile, this story is sending shock waves around the world, as you can imagine, especially to Liberia, where the alleged victim and attackers are originally from. The president of that African nation, Ellen Johnson Sirleaf, has always been a friend to our news program. And she is actually going to call in and join us on the phone in just a minute.

But also joining us from Washington, the Liberian ambassador to the U.S., Milton Barnes. Ambassador, let's go ahead and start with you while we wait for Madam President.

You know, do you believe that what we're seeing here originates from your country, a country where, you know, often the woman is blamed for rape, shamed for rape? And, as you and I well know, rape was used as a tool during the Civil War and still is on many levels.

MILTON BARNES, LIBERIAN AMBASSADOR TO U.S.: Well, there is quite a bit of trauma involved all around. You are right, rape was used as a weapon of war during our crisis, and so our hearts go out to the young victim, the 8-year-old child. And our primary concern is for her well-being and her welfare. We have been in touch with the authorities in Phoenix, Arizona, particularly the police department, and so far, we are confident that they will use every resource within their power to ensure that things are done in a very quick, expeditious, fair, and most importantly, sensitive manner, particularly given the age of this child.

PHILLIPS: It's heartbreaking, an 8-year-old child being blamed (sic) for rape.Ambassador Barnes, stay with me, please. I do understand we do have President Ellen Johnson Sirleaf, the president of Liberia, on the phone with us now.

Madam President, I know that you are well aware of the rape case that has happened here in the United States. What do you have to say about what you have heard with regard to these young Liberian boys allegedly gang-raping this 8-year-old Liberian girl?

ELLEN JOHNSON SIRLEAF, LIBERIAN PRESIDENT: Let me say that we are deeply distressed at this behavior on the part of our young Liberians and very saddened at this 8-year-old child who has been so victimized. We appeal to the parents to protect their children, protect their child, and make sure that those who have infringed upon her in this manner are made to abide by the laws of the United States in this regard.

Let me say very clearly that rape is a problem in Liberia also. This is why we have made rape a non-bailable (ph) offense. It is a criminal offense. There is a strong law regarding that. You cannot even get bail.

So, those parents should know that things have changed in Liberia. No longer do we tolerate this. And this is not a question of shame on the family, it's a question of an assault on a young child. And that cannot be tolerated.

PHILLIPS: And Madam President, that's what's so heart-wrenching about this case, is it's this battle with culture and with crime. And we don't know why these boys committed this crime.

And we want to ask that question -- did they learn this type of behavior in Liberia, where rape is used as a tool during wartime, and where the young women are blamed for rape in that country? We hope to answer that question.

But what would be your message to the family of this 8-year-old girl that has been interviewed on camera saying, we're shamed by this, it's her fault, we don't want her back? What would you say to that family?

SIRLEAF: I think that family is wrong. They should help that child who has been traumatized, and they should make sure that they work with the U.S. law authorities to see what can be done about the other young boys who have committed this offense.

Not only should they abide by the law, but they too need serious counseling, because clearly they are doing something that is no longer acceptable in our society here. It's a problem, but it is a crime, and people bear the brunt of the penalty for such crimes.

They should be working with the authorities on this. I will ask Ambassador Barnes to work with the family to let them know what needs to be done, and to work with the legal authorities in Phoenix to make sure that this matter is handled, recognizing that we do not condone this and we must ensure the protection of that 8-year-old.

PHILLIPS: Ambassador Barnes, while we have Madam President on the line, can you tell us here at CNN and to our viewers and to Madam President that you will personally get involved in making sure this 8- year-old girl, whether it's with her family or another family, is cared for, loved, and embraced, and that these young boys will be taught that this is not permissible here in the U.S. and that there has to be an understanding that if they're going to live here and if they are found guilty of this crime, that it's wrong?

BARNES: Absolutely. Absolutely. Our primary concern right now is this child. I personally am concerned about her well-being and her welfare. We have been in touch with the authorities in Phoenix, and we do intend to work with the authorities and the families to make sure that she's safe, she's protected, and there is certain sensitivity exercised towards her considering that she is a child and doesn't know any better.

She certainly should not be blamed. She is only an 8-year-old kid, a baby, and doesn't know any better. And we will work with the authorities. We will, of course, also try to be in touch with the families of the perpetrators, the young boys, and also sure that they do get the appropriate counseling, but they do understand that what they have done is wrong and they will have to pay the penalty for what they have done.

PHILLIPS: Madam President, Steven Tuopeh, the 14-year-old boy that is being charged with rape, he is being charged as an adult. Do you support that?

SIRLEAF: If that's what the laws of the states dictate, then we'll have to follow the law. I do hope, however, that there will be counseling introduced into whatever happens.

These are also young people who clearly have had their value systems wrong. It does come from the practices of war. Many of them also have trauma from the war and are carrying on some of the same malpractices that we practiced upon them during the war. They have to pay the penalty, but we also want to make sure that they are counseled so that whenever they have already done time, or whatever, it is in accordance with the law that they, too, will have an opportunity to change and become useful citizens, not only in the United States, but when they return home.

PHILLIPS: Madam President, before I let you go, your message, please, to the 8-year-old girl, the young rape victim, and also to her family. What do you say to them?

SIRLEAF: Just say to them that we are so saddened. We are so sorry about that. We just want to make sure that the parents take care of that child. And if they don't, reach out to others, facilitated by our ambassador, to make sure she is placed in a situation where she can be administered to, that she can be loved and cared, and call upon the parents to do right by that child. We cannot allow her life to be so interrupted by this incident and take away the future that is so bright for her. So, we will be working with her through our ambassador to make sure that not only is she attended to, but that she can then continue in her education, and we can make sure that this particular incident is removed from her.

So, thank you all for following this and bringing attention to it. We will continue to work with the families and make sure that child is safe and protected.

PHILLIPS: And Madam President, we thank you. You have truly been a trailblazer there in Liberia, standing up for the rights of women, and have been an incredible asset, obviously, to our news coverage on a number of times. Madam President, thank you so much.

And Ambassador Milton Nathaniel Barnes, we call on you, too, and look to you to get involved in this case and keep us updated. We would like to talk to you again as we find more resolution not only for this family, this little girl, but for all the Liberian refugees here in this country, in particular the focus of Phoenix, Arizona, right now. ay we do a follow-up with you?

BARNES: Thank you very much. You're most welcome. I'll be available.

PHILLIPS: OK. We'll be in contact.

—Tim Graham is Director of Media Analysis at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

I just checked the CIA

I just checked the CIA factbook..

Liberia Religion:

Christian 40%, Muslim 20%, indigenous beliefs 40%

Okay -- no mention of the child-rape victim's religion, so it's safe to say it's MUSLIM.  I could be wrong, but experience tells us that religious omission is usually by commission in these areas.

I hope to God, she hasn't already had her genitals mutilated by a broken bottle.

Oh I'm sorry. Am I not being "culturally sensitive" enough. All cultures being equal and all.

That's just what America need: more Liberians... I'm sorry, I mean Librarians!

And.. what exactly is the sort of "counseling" that's appropriate for a 14 year old "boy" who rapes an 8 year old.

I have no wish to be prurient, but does it involve anatomically correct dolls by any chance.

I'm no Nostradamus, but I'm forecasting this "boy" is gonna be raping well into middle-age, counseling or no counseling. Am I right or am I right?

Ever notice how people who believe complex conspiracy theories, usually think the intricate universe and humans are merely an accidental product of random events. 

A problem with culture? The

A problem with culture? The problem is that people come to our country with their dysfunctional cultures and want to keep them going. If I wanted to live in the stone age, I'd move to another part of the world. The fourteen-year-old scumbag has been in the country for four years and can't speak English. I know people from Russia that within two years have spoken better English than a lot of native-born Americans. I'm out of tolerance for this sort of crap.

Send everybody but the victim back to Liberia. 

(Gee it feels good to get all wound up in the morning!)

Yeah, dontcha love

Yeah, dontcha love it?

When we go to their countries, we have to respect their culture. (Our Christian soldiers can't even wear a cross in Saudi Arabia!)

When they come to our country......we have to respect their culture.

Prayers going out for this

Prayers going out for this poor girl. Her father needs a healthy dope slap..  just a little north of where the sun don't shine!  

A slap is not enough

I beg to differ about the dad. He needs to be deported. We can come up with low-life parents on our own and don't need the world's help. He obviously does not want to be an American, he just wants to live here and benefit economically.

Now, if he would enlist and go fight the Taliban, I might be open to second thoughts.

"Her father needs a healthy dope slap"

The father needs to be gang raped and cast out of his own family to understand what his little girl is dealing with. He should have protected her; he's a monster.

 (sorry, i'm angry)

------------------------------------- 

"Nothing in the world is more dangerous than sincere ignorance and conscientious stupidity." --Martin Luther King, Jr.

              

               I say nail the little bast**ds to the wall.

Lets hope that the 8 year

Lets hope that the 8 year old in now in state custody too. If she is Muslim she may be the victim of a "honor killing" that is even more "legal" too them than anything as she was showing to much skin or something.

RIP

Zainab Shafia, 19, Sahar Shafia, 17 and Geeti Shafia, 13 – died along with Rona Amir Mohammed, 50 Canada's latest victims of a so called "honor killing"

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Long live George W. Bush

The Father's comments can only come from the mouth of a ...

... HEARTLESS BARBARIAN.  Err, I mean DEVOUT MOHAMMEDAN.

"The father told the caseworker and an officer in her presence that he
didn't want her back. He said, 'Take her, I don't want her,' "

I agree with other posts that people who come hear with  stone age baggage from their backward country should not be welcomed.  The outrage is that they think they are coming here to "enlighten" us to the "supremacy" of their gory "god".

Adoption

The father told the caseworker and an officer in her presence that he
didn't want her back. He said, 'Take her, I don't want her,' " police
Sgt. Andy Hill said.

That's a big red flashing Drudge light. That child should never be alone with her parents again. Change her name, ship her to another city and let her be adopted.

What? me worry?

The 14 yr olds mother says she is worried. Why? They've only been here since "05 so she must still think laws apply to black muslims. Boy oh boy, is she mistaken. She will soon understand the power her skin color and religion confer upon her in the USA. Her son will skate on this, most likely with an apology for interferring in Liberian affairs. Unless of course, he made the mistake of doing this crime in Joe Arapio's county. If he did it in THAT jurisdiction, the little bastard is in deep doo doo.

We will take her.  She

We will take her.  She would be safe and well loved and properly cared for here.  I wonder how one goes about taking custody of a child.  The parents should never get her back, never.

Me thinks

A nice bullet to the head would take care of the little animal that perpetrated this attack on this poor child. Shamefully, he will skate and live to do the same again, next time probably taking a life. Ship these animals back to their own countries, and let them keep their "culture" there. Multiculturalism is the death of our way of life here. Liberalism in it's purest form.

I have to say this is almost

I have to say this is almost kind of offensive to me, Tim. As I was reading the opening paragraph of this post I'm thinking "ok 8 year old gang-raped, disgusting act, but why are we upset the national media is not covering this? Why is this such valuable news? Why are we asking for a comment from Obama? Why is this the media's reponsibility to inform Americans all across the country about this despicable act? Are they non-whites or something? ....Yup, Liberian refugees...*sigh" ...Regardless of the ethnicities of these kids, I think the nation is better off not knowing about this story. Personally, it's not something I want to read or hear about unless it somehow allows me a way to help that poor girl's tragic situation.

And as far as you thinking it is because of racial or religious sensitivities; racial-possibly, religious-highly unlikely. I don't think the race of the kids played a major role in the networks not covering it (yet). I think it's just a story of a random violent, horrific act that didn't get picked up by everybody, thats all. Religious sensitivity definitely didn't play a role in the media's lack of coverage. As far as I can tell, the act had nothing to do with religion and kids who do something like this probably don't have much religion in their lives anyway. And when has the media ever focused on that aspect before when they're reporting on something 12 year olds do? "The 12 year-old robbed the local gas station. His family is Roman Catholic." You wouldn't hear that if it's not relevant to the story.

And if some national media outlets did squash this gruesome story because it might conjure up negative stereotypes, what is the huge deal? As you can see based on the comments so far, it's doing just that. It appears most of the commenters are already convinced these are Muslims and correct me if I'm wrong, but I couldn't find anywhere throughout the story where this was said or where it said religion played a role. It is sparking talk of "dysfuntional cultures" invading America, multiculturism killing our way of life, Muslim "honor killings", etc. To me, this is just a disgusting act that can happen anywhere that kids are raised without proper teaching and values, no matter the race or religion.

I agree with the general idea that the media sometimes does not report stories that they should because they are overly sensitive, and that can get annoying... really annoying. But with this one it is just not necessary. I could understand if you wanted the media to report on this because it could help save the poor 8-year old girl from her circumstances, but thats not the case. You just want the media to report the story because the attackers were Liberians, and maybe not Christians... c'mon. What will become of this site if we become a media watchdog in making sure the media constantly reports on every random rape, assault, etc. that happens from non-whites, or possible non-Christians? I hope I'm not the only one that thinks this is a little bit worthless and that little things like this help add to the fact that the Republican party has so much trouble attracting non-Christian and non-white supporters. Some wonder why it's dominated by white men. Well, we've got media watchdogs that think it's a noble cause to be up in arms and suspect racial/religious "sensitivity" whenever the national media doesn't pick up on random acts of violence by minorities (racial or religious). That should be our first clue.

So in summary to this book I just wrote, I think in regards to this specific post, NB acted stupidly.... er, uh, I mean...I apologize, I could've calibrated my words differently. 

Huh?

RE: "...I think the nation is better off not knowing about this story..."

-------------------------------------------

(The above posted in case anyone missed it)

Hey Wisdom, this is more than a gang rape story, it's about a cultural belief that teaches boys that rape is the girl's fault. That story needs to be told.  

Please note signature below. 

------------------------------------- 

"Nothing in the world is more dangerous than sincere ignorance and conscientious stupidity." --Martin Luther King, Jr.

ignorant wisdom

What planet do you live on? If the perpertrators were white this would alreadfy have been on all the MSM by now..You wrote: "And as far as you thinking it is because of racial or religious sensitivities; racial-possibly, religious-highly unlikely. "........Obviously you are spectacularly ignorant of mohammedan culture....You also wrote that there's nothing mentioned about the religion.........You gotta be kidding!! I gaurantee this will be show to be a mohammedan affair, especially the 'father's' reaction. It's people like you that create a demand for sites like 'Newsbusters' in the first place...............As Mark Levine would say "get outta here you big dummy!".......Leftists like you aren't almost offensive to sane people, you are offensive. ICABOD

Wisdom, did you post an

Wisdom, did you post an objection to the stories about the falsified rape charges against the Lacrosse players at duke University. I might have missed your post, but the story got national attention.

Wisdom, did you post an

Duplicate post withdrawn. I hate to be redundant twice! 

~"Wisdom" here is no doubt good-looking as well *cough*

I'm just glad he doesn't feel compelled to over-compensate for a serious mental deficiency by calling himself something absurdly pretentious.....

You just want the media to report the story because the attackers were Liberians, and maybe not Christians... c'mon.

Maybe not? Maybe? Seriously? Please feel free to cite the chapter and verse that gives Christians license to abuse women. Please give us a link that shows professing Christians raping anyone.

Meanwhile, here's a story about some self-professed Muslims. Oh look, another story.

Oooh, look at this..

He
told me that Thais were not Muslims; so having fun with their girls
were all right. In fact, he told me that that had been the practice
in Islam for centuries. Whenever the Muslims defeated the
non-Muslims, they could do whatever they (the Muslims) wanted with
the non-Muslims. The Muslims can use the non-Muslim women as sex
slaves and please themselves as they wished. A Muslim even had the
right to kill the women if he wished. In simple language the
non-Muslims were not really human beings. They (the non-Muslims)
were inferior even to cattle and animals.

 

FROM
THE QURAN - 70:22-30

"Not
so the worshippers, who are steadfast in prayer, who set aside a due portion of
their wealth for the beggar and for the deprived, who truly believe in the Day
of Reckoning and dread the punishment of their Lord (for none is secure from
the punishment of their Lord);  who
restrain their carnal desire (save with their wives and their slave girls, for
these are lawful to them:
  he that lusts
after other than these is a transgressor..."

Oh crap, this is really starting to look bad for your case, Ignorance.

Rape of 80 women arranged

A woman suspected of recruiting more than 80 female suicide bombers has
confessed to organising their rapes so she could later convince them
that martyrdom was the only way to escape the shame.

 

That high-pitched scream you hear is the big, fat idiot under my heel. 

Self-named wisdom:

Where is NOW and the rest of the so-called protectors of women?  Is your reponse the politically correct one for when a girl has been raped?  I never received the newest update of the socialist playbook.

Your hypocricy is showing; or are some females more equal than others?  Shame on you and your ilk.  You are truly disgusting and someday you will have to account for your double standards.

What the frack is wrong

What the frack is wrong with you? Seriously, unless this is some sort of failed satire, you seem mentally ill, sir.

I urge you to seek help.

Ever notice how people who believe complex conspiracy theories, usually think the intricate universe and humans are merely an accidental product of random events. 

Wisdom I think this is a

Wisdom I think this is a very relevant story.  The fact is that many muslims believe whenever a crime like rape is committed against a woman she is at fault and has brought shame upon the family. This gives any male in her family the right to perform and honor killing of her.  We cannot allow this to happen in our country.

Your example of a Catholic stealing gas is wrong because the Catholic religion does not condone stealing.  However when a Catholic priest molests a child the religion of the priest is featured prominantly in the story because it is relevant. 

This story isn't just about a rape, it's about the reaction of the family to the assualt of an 8 year old girl and how those norms may creep into our society if we aren't careful. 

 

Nexis/Schmexis

In commenting on bias then, it becomes necessary, Tim, to call into question whether or not Nexis is biased, since I have been following this item on Fox News since about 8:30, July 24th. I don't know why Nexis is showing only CNN carrying the story, because that certainly isn't true. While CNN may be devoting more prominent coverage, they most emphatically are not the only ones doing so.

V/R
Clyde

"...the aspirants to tyranny are either the...men of the state, who in democracies are demagogues,... or those who hold great offices, and have a long tenure.." - Aristotle, Politics, c350BC

Re: FNC and Nexis

Clyde: thanks for the intelligence. I should note that Fox transcripts on Nexis are more limited than CNN's -- but that's why I said "from Nexis" instead of checking the recordings at the ofc.

The outrage over the

Maricopa County, eh?

Enter, Sheriff Joe!

I wonder how many more there are.

I'll bet this child isn't the first. If girls are blamed, I don't imagine many would tell, and those who have were probably silenced by mothers who feared their daughters would be stoned to death or set on fire.  Did crisis counselors descend upon this refugee community? Are sensitivity classes being scheduled? Will all adults be required to attend classes on American law and positive parenting techniques? No, of course not; because as one person said, we have to "respect" their culture by not imposing ours upon them.

*slaps forehead*

Wisdom:

You need to get some (wisdom)! You are writing so sincerely about a subject you either know nothing about or are covering up for ! If it's the former, please educate yourself by reading sites like "Jihad Watch" and "Creeping Sharia." If it's the latter, get outta here -- we're too smart for ya.