Keith Olbermann’s Fox News-hating frenzy on Monday night might have obscured the nasty accusations against pro-lifers Olbermann drew out of Richard Wolffe, who recently left his job as a political reporter at Newsweek to be a full-time MSNBC pundit.
Wolffe said Tiller’s killing had a "direct link" to people yelling "Kill him" at McCain-Palin rallies and insisted pro-lifers need to look themselves hard in the mirror and ask themselves "Have I played a part" in Tiller’s death by charging that Tiller "committed horrendous acts"?
Wolffe also insisted Republicans were hypocrites for objecting to "Muslim terrorism" while encouraging terrorism against abortion doctors, since that's a natural "result" of abortion protests:
OLBERMANN: The homeland security secretary, Ms. Napolitano, bowed to Republican outrage in April, apologizing for that DHS assessment that warned of violent acts by right-wing extremists - are the Republicans in Congress still of the belief that the threat of right-wing extremist violence is some sort of fantasy out of the Obama administration?
WOLFFE: Well, Republicans in Congress want to have it both ways. They want to endorse the goals and aims of that movement and not be seen to endorse the results of that movement. And it strikes me as very curious that people who claim to have a zero tolerance for those who incite Muslim terrorism, who incite that kind of hatred towards America, find it very easy to turn a blind eye to people who incite hatred and violence towards Americans who are going about their legal work in America today.
And there is a direct link. And just to cite someone who maybe has some experience of violence in America, John Lewis -- remember, when he said in the campaign, when those people at the McCain rallies who are saying "kill him" about the now-president of the United States, John Lewis said there is a direct link here between those who fan this kind of mob sentiment and the violence this country has seen.
You know, they need to look closely in the mirror today and say, "Have I played a part -- no matter how smart -- have I played a part in what has ended up as a very sad event for one man and his family?"
Olbermann then wanted to insist that the Tiller killing means Sotomayor should get a free pass on abortion in the upcoming confirmation hearings:
OLBERMANN: We saw -- Dr. Tiller, obviously, come up in the nomination process for [HHS Secretary Kathleen] Sebelius. The GOP`s not going to bring this up in connection with abortion and Roe v. Wade and Sotomayor. Is it -- I mean, this is now third rail stuff, is it not?
WOLFFE: Well, the name is, but I don`t think the fortunes of the Republican Party are nearly strong enough to say to this hardcore piece of the base -- and I`m not talking about those who would embrace violence, but those who embrace the goals of that movement -- it`s not strong enough to say, "You know what, we condemn this." And that`s why our ears are ringing with the violence of the condemnation here.
Yes, people lament the violence and the death, but they actually try and justify these acts by saying that the man was evil or committing horrendous acts. Again, he was within the law. And if you want to change the law, then you should debate the law, not go out and incite hatred. And if you incite hatred, it leads to violence.
Is Wolffe such a die-hard liberal, or such an Obama lapdog, that he hasn’t considered that the Democrats also have a "hardcore base" on this issue – a base that thinks Tiller was a saint for performing abortions late in pregnancy when the vast majority of Americans oppose them in the polls, when asked?
Wolffe was followed on Countdown by "conservative" gay blogger Andrew Sullivan, who insisted, "speaking as a believing Christian," that "this murderer attacked Christianity" by shooting Tiller in a church. He insisted strangely that Tiller was a "private person" and shouldn’t have been publicly opposed:
This murderer attacked Christianity. These people and the way they demonize private people -- these aren`t public officials who can take a little bit of rough-tough out there in the dialogue, these are private people acting within the law, being basically -- I mean, not just this murder. He was targeted for months, for years. He was hit before. And if our society can’t protect these people doing what is legal -- even if we disagree with it -- then we’re lost. We’re finished.
It's bad enough that Sullivan would equate a late-term abortionist with the essence of Christianity. Like many liberals, Sullivan can't seem to distinguish between peaceful protesters and violent criminals. There's a huge difference between being "targeted" for silent protests by rosary-clutchers and being shot. If not, is every Code Pink protest at a military recruiting center at attack on "private persons" doing something legal, which might encourage shooting our soldiers?
Sullivan also displayed his unfamiliarity with the current pro-life movement in assuming that Operation Rescue is still represented by its founder, Randall Terry. He assaulted Operation Rescue for failing to condemn the murder, when its current leader, Troy Newman, did exactly that.
—Tim Graham is Director of Media Analysis at the Media Research Center.





This murderer attacked Christianity. These people and the way they demonize private people -- these aren`t public officials who can take a little bit of rough-tough out there in the dialogue, these are private people acting within the law, being basically -- I mean, not just this murder. He was targeted for months, for years. He was hit before. And if our society can’t protect these people doing what is legal -- even if we disagree with it -- then we’re lost. We’re finished.














Editor at Large
Comments Policy
You mean a direct link to the MSM.
June 3, 2009 - 06:28 ET by P. AaronThat "kill him" comment started with the press, not any McCain-Palin supporter.
That must be the link they're talking about.
Spot on P. Aaron. Repeat a
June 3, 2009 - 06:36 ET by USA4freedomSpot on P. Aaron.
Repeat a lie long enough..
Ronald Reagan, 1962: I did not leave the Democratic party, the party left me.
Insert: your name, 2008, and the Republican party.
Liberal logic: Man that
June 3, 2009 - 06:51 ET by USA4freedomLiberal logic:
Man that kills 6..0..0..0..0 babies = hero!
Woman that decides not to abort a down’s syndrome baby = enemy.
Ronald Reagan, 1962: I did not leave the Democratic party, the party left me.
Insert: your name, 2008, and the Republican party.
Kill Him smear started and repeated by Olby sidekicks
June 3, 2009 - 09:41 ET by pearlThe Kill Him smear was started by Olbermann sidekick Dana Milbank and the Secret Service exposed him.
http://fightthepalin...
Hey, Hitler started the
June 3, 2009 - 06:54 ET by nadadhimmiHey, Hitler started the Reichstag Fire as well, just like the msm started the "kill him" remark. They were BOTH done to silence political opposition, and BOTH may be successful. The usurper is just getting started in his dismantleing of the US constitution he hates and fears so much. Imprison the usurper now.
Correct. And MSNBC spun it
June 3, 2009 - 07:20 ET by kgCorrect. And MSNBC spun it as being all about Obama. Now they are re-spinning it. This reporter created statement is getting a lot of mileage. And they will use it again as well.
"DumbAssity of Dope"
Wolffe
June 3, 2009 - 10:27 ET by KC MulvilleThe supposed linkage is as real as the supposed quote.
Secret Service investigated "kill him" claim
June 3, 2009 - 11:03 ET by ArminiusAnd found no evidence to support it. So Wolffe is not only guilty of an incredibly bogus argument, he based that argument on a lie.
http://www.timesleader.com/news/breakingnews/Secret_Service_says_Kill_him_allegation_unfounded_.html
Outrageous
June 3, 2009 - 06:49 ET by HoosierEmHow dare Richard Wolffe lecture pro-lifers that they need to look in the mirror and ask themselves whether they have played a part in the murder of Dr. George Tiller.
The arrogance of these liberals is astounding.
Michelle Malkin in her
June 3, 2009 - 07:46 ET by motherbeltMichelle Malkin in her Townhall column today, has the money quote:
When a right-wing Christian vigilante kills, millions of fingers pull
the trigger. When a left-wing Muslim vigilante kills, he kills alone.
These are the instantly ossifying narratives in the Sunday shooting
death of late-term abortion provider George Tiller of Kansas versus the
Monday shootings of two Arkansas military recruiters.
(emphasis added)
I didn't think it was physically possible, but this both sucks and blows. -Bart Simpson
"left-wing Muslim vigilante
June 3, 2009 - 08:20 ET by criticalthinking"left-wing Muslim vigilante kills" My Conservative friends, you have absolutly launched yourselves off the deep end if you think that strict adherence to Islam or Jihad is some how a part of the left wing! READ BOOKS, THEY MAKE YOU SMARTER
Way to miss the point.
June 3, 2009 - 08:53 ET by optimistWay to miss the point. Learn basic logic, it makes you smarter.
you missed the piont...there
June 3, 2009 - 08:57 ET by criticalthinkingyou missed the piont...there is no such thing as a left wing muslim radical, so you can't compare one killing that actually happened to another that never will happen
Nonsense
June 3, 2009 - 11:05 ET by ArminiusHow many of the anti-Bush protests were made up of left-wing AND radical Muslim groups? They have clearly aligned themselves with one another.
hahahahahaha...you are a
June 3, 2009 - 14:14 ET by criticalthinkinghahahahahaha...you are a simplton!!!!!
How about this then?
June 3, 2009 - 11:40 ET by Jack Herman"Left wing apologists and supporters of radical muslims."
Which side of the political
June 3, 2009 - 13:03 ET by MrSnugglesWhich side of the political spectrum is always protesting agianst recruiting centers, forcing recruiters off of school campuses, vandalizing recruiting centers, etc? Ill give you a hint, its not the "right wing".
now this i agree with, but
June 3, 2009 - 14:15 ET by criticalthinkingnow this i agree with, but protesting war has nothing to do with islam, or radical muslims, my friend
criticalthinking ~ the name does not fit you at all.
June 3, 2009 - 13:40 ET by pahuberPerhaps you can change it to knee jerk, seminar poster boy, the cranky troll...
Off the deep end
June 3, 2009 - 09:09 ET by KC MulvilleIt's an easy-enough distinction to blur. Yes, Islamic fanaticism isn't left-wing. However, the left wing in this country is willing to overlook Islamic vigilantism but is happy to highlight anything that seems to cast aspersions on Christianity (even though the shooter had no apparent ties to religion). The point, which was missed here, was simply that there is a double standard.
Notice, however, the rhetoric here. Instead of simply saying, "oops, Islam is right wing," you offered that conservatives have "launched" ourselves off a deep end, simply because of this harmless distinction. Who, indeed, is guilty of overreaction here?
By the way, the deep end refers to a swimming pool. You don't launch yourself "off" a deep end. You launch yourself off a cliff. Or you go swimming in the deep end. Launching yourself off the deep end is a mangled metaphor.
good point on the deep end
June 3, 2009 - 11:26 ET by criticalthinkinggood point on the deep end metaphor. I agree, one doesnt launch himself off the deep end. However, I really do think it is an unjust charactoization of the left to somehow consider them in cohoots or evan at all sympathetic of radical islam...its part of partisan politics that i think is really ugly...i lean to the left, and am throuroly disgusted by jihad, and of my many lefty friends, or even my lefty university, I cant really think of anyone who roots for the taliban, or al queda. thats why i think Malkin's point doesnt work...so, in my conslusion, if a radical islamist pops off, no, you can't, no should you, hold the left responsible (ps, i also dont think the right is responsible for this guy getting shot. you have every right to protest something/someone you don't like)
Fair enough
June 3, 2009 - 12:04 ET by KC MulvilleI think the larger idea, to which we both agree, is that you can't hold a whole group responsible for the actions (or even the beliefs) of one or a subset of the members. That's just logic anyway.
No one thinks that
June 3, 2009 - 10:13 ET by danebramageAlthough that was admittedly a poor way of putting it on Malkin's part. What she means is, "When a left-wing approved Muslim vigilante kills..."
It's true that the left has no natural connection or affinity with Islam. But they have openly chosen the Muslim terrorists' side in the war between America and said terrorists, so it's perfectly accurate to describe them as supporting or approving Muslim crimes against America(ns).
As for reading books to make you smarter, you might start with "United in Hate: The Left's Romance With Tyranny and Terror" by Jamie Glazov (Glazov is the son of Russian dissident parents who fled Communism for freedom in the West). It details the long, sickening history of the American left's support for, first, Communism, and then--after the fall of the USSR--militant, anti-American Islam.
In fact, I'll even get you started. As it happens, Frontpage has a column up today by Jamie about his book. Being such an educated, critical thinker, I'm sure you'll want to rush right over there and read it: http://www.frontpage...
Critical Thinking
June 3, 2009 - 14:28 ET by Lord ErondYour typical bottom feeding garbage troll from KOS
"Let him who would move the world, first move himself." -Socrates
"We sit together, the mountain and I, until only the mountain remains." -Li Po
other venues
June 3, 2009 - 07:16 ET by xyzzypoofsIf you want to stop hearing/seeing statements like that in public, you can start by outlawing RAP "music" and then "digg.com (you should've seen some of the things THOSE goons were saying about Sarah Palin et al.)"
Irony, irony, all is irony.
June 3, 2009 - 07:16 ET by misterbee241It's funny how liberals are ok with the violence of a partial birth abortion. I dont condone Tiller's murder - while he was alive he still had a chance at seeing the error of his ways and repenting like other abortionists did. Now who knows. Maybe he called on the name of Jesus with his last breath.
But his church for pete's sake - what is that pastor teaching and preaching? I'll bet sin and repentance and forgiveness are not in the line up.
One thing I know for sure - If I were a pastor and somebody like Tiller was a member, I'd invoke Matthew 18.
"I dont need to read a newspaper to know the world's been shaved by a drunken barber."
Walter Brennan, The Colonel, Meet John Doe, 1941
Richard Wolffe
June 3, 2009 - 07:32 ET by Texndoc"who recently left his job as a political reporter at Newsweek to be a full-time MSNBC pundit"
Leaving the Hindenberg to take a seat on the Titanic.
very funny and astute
June 3, 2009 - 07:56 ET by nadadhimmivery funny and astute observation.
Connecting the dots
June 3, 2009 - 07:42 ET by Pilgrim1949Ah, a sheep in wolffe's clothing.....another bleating heart liberal?
So this twit wants to boldly connect the dots?..... regardless of the nonexistence of the dots, let alone the ethereal, fantasy connection.
Like the two mental patients who escaped their rooms one night and huddled in the dark on the roof of the building.
Patient 1 says, "Now what?"
Patient 2 -- We make our escape to the roof of that building over there, then down the stairs to freedom.
P1 -- We're 10 stories high. How do we get from here over to there?
P2 -- Simple, you dope! See this flashlight? I shine it on that building and then you just walk across the beam to safety. Then I through it over to you and you do the same for me.
P1 -- No way! Nothing doing!
P2 -- Why not?
P1 -- I know you and your practical jokes. You'll wait until I'm halfway across and then you'll turn off the flashlight!
This newsjerk is just the type to go boldly running across his flashlight beam, from one unfounded "dot" to the next....
Red Skelton
June 3, 2009 - 08:42 ET by general companyShould be credited for the joke. : ]
My Gov. thinks I am dangerous, so be careful
"Television is a freak show" Bernie Goldberg
socialist heaven
June 3, 2009 - 08:00 ET by nadadhimmiI say, let these liberals like Couric, Williams, Gibson experience the Obama style Socialism they espouse. Tax them at a 80% rate, NO EXEMPTIONS OR SHELTERS. SEE HOW THEY LIKE AND SUPPORT IT THEN. You see, liberals don't pay taxes, just look at the Obama Cabinet, taxcheats all. Seems as if taxes are for the "Little People". Flyover people.
Useless Idiots
June 3, 2009 - 08:03 ET by rightwingidiotGawd! Is there really so little news to report that these two useless idiots have to invent something out of nothing? I just don't get it.
Okay, Tiller wasn't liked a much by a whole slew of people. But, he was killed by one guy that went bonkers. End of story. Period. It's not some vast movement, it's not related to something yelled at a Palin rally, it's just not that damn important. One guy decided he'd had enough of what Tiller does and he offed him. Happens every day.
Tiller was just recently acquitted of charges that he did something illegal in performing late-term abortions. Were the original charges trumped up? Maybe. But he went through the court system and he won. The guy that shot Tiller probably had just had enough. Yeah, he might have been a part of a larger organization that hated what Tiller did but it was one guy, one guy, that decided he had to take the law into his own hands.
You cannot dictate tolerance or understanding to others. You may try, but, in the end, some people are going to believe what they believe. That's not news and it's not a movement, and it's not preaching hate, it's why a person, fed up, decides, on his own, to do what most of us think is unthinkable.
Get over it Olby and Wolffe. Your useless banter of a bigger picture is just two idiots dreaming stuff up that didn't, won't happen.
And to think, these dumbasses get paid to spew this crap.
Charges not trumped up.
June 3, 2009 - 08:23 ET by sevenSee note below. He was served by the State board of Healing Arts.
"Okay, Tiller wasn't liked
June 3, 2009 - 08:28 ET by criticalthinking"Okay, Tiller wasn't liked a much by a whole slew of people. But, he was killed by one guy that went bonkers. End of story"
Okay, The United States wasn't liked a much by a whole slew of people. But, 9/11 was just eleven guys that went bonkers. End of story.
Great logic, homeboy.
Not Relative
June 3, 2009 - 09:02 ET by rightwingidiotYou seem to be implying that there's some commonality between one guy, acting on his own, fed up with the system, and an entire network of anti-americans that planned, for years, to inflict as much harm as possible on the USA.
The vast network of anti-americans that attacked the towers didn't do it just once on a whim, they did it twice. And they made attacks on numerous other American targets. The network spent years training the 11 that did the deed. Bankrolled the operation. They learned how to fly planes and got their ultimate direction from a very misguided view of a religion.
So, are we to conclude, based on your comments, that the guy that shot Tiller spent years in training, was bankrolled by a pro-life, organization (maybe they bought his powder-blue getaway car, gun and bullets), and had a vast network of supporters that prepared him to do the deed and promised him some quantity of virgins when he entered heaven?
Or maybe the guy just woke up that morning and decided the law didn't get Tiller out of the business so he was gonna do it himself. I guess that's just too out there to believe.
Stop pestering
June 3, 2009 - 09:05 ET by contraryStop pestering the know-it-all with critical thinking skills.
"No I have the facts"
--The resident Joe Friday
Not only that
June 3, 2009 - 09:11 ET by general companyBut if all of us wanted to kill Tiller, as Wolfe and Oberdude suggest, I doubt he would had ever made it though his second abortion let alone 60,000.
My Gov. thinks I am dangerous, so be careful
"Television is a freak show" Bernie Goldberg
This is Relative
June 3, 2009 - 09:52 ET by rightwingidiotA sad story that was reported about the same day that Tiller was shot.
A local man, 31, a guy that played baseball with our son years ago when they were both in middle school, shot his soon-to-be ex-wife, her boyfriend, and then himself.
The guy was recently diagnosed as bipolar. I dunno if he was in treatment but I do know that he had been to a mental health center, on his own, about a month ago. The wife had a restraining order against him.
He shows up at the wife's house, the boyfriend and two children are there (one is his). He shoots the wife, then the boyfriend, in front of the kids. Leaves the house and then shoots himself.
This is a classic case of "I'm fed up and I ain't gonna take it anymore". The guy wasn't thinking when he did it. He was just acting on pure emotion or he was fogged by his bipolar condition or something. It wasn't planned, it just happened when he all of a sudden went bonkers.
I see the Tiller case as exactly the same thing. The guy finally had enough and he wasn't going to take the murdering of innocent children anymore so he acted irrationally and did something that even the most ardent pro-life supporter couldn't even imagine doing.
Tiller was close to getting shut down
June 3, 2009 - 08:21 ET by sevenNo motive to mess with tiller because Pro life, (anti murder) people knew the end was near.
KSBHA is charging Tiller "has committed acts likely to deceive, defraud or harm the public."
If KSBHA finds Tiller guilty, it can revoke, suspend, or limit his license as well as impose fines.
Why doesn't the media report Tillers legal problems?
State board of healing arts was just about done with him Tliller smears himself again.
Where to start? Geez
June 3, 2009 - 09:05 ET by general companyMcCain-Palin rallies and insisted pro-lifers need to look themselves
hard in the mirror and ask themselves "Have I played a part" in
Tiller’s death by charging that Tiller
So we are all responsible? What a putz. And who was charging Tiller with "committed horrendous acts" he did commit horrendous acts, inhuman in-fact. And just because you repeat the lies still doesnt make them true.
WOLFFE: Well, Republicans in Congress want to have it both ways.
They want to endorse the goals and aims of that movement and not be
seen to endorse the results of that movement.
So we all knew this was the gist of the liberals problem, you see in this jerks eyes you cant be against abortion without being responsible for inciting violence against others. Who do these creep think they are, by their own definition they are now inciting violence against the Right. God help them if they should get their wish.
The pure bias and reaching for the sky here is far worst then what any pundit on Fox has said about anyone, let alone Tiller
My Gov. thinks I am dangerous, so be careful
"Television is a freak show" Bernie Goldberg
Trying to make everyone guilty
June 3, 2009 - 09:59 ET by Blogger Guy00001This is just the left's attempt to call every anti-abortion person and every conservative guilty of this murder.
Rash of Murder-Suicides
June 3, 2009 - 10:54 ET by HoosierEmNow who is responsible for the multitude of murder/suicides in this country over the last several months? The state run media outlets speculated that the most likely cause was financial in nature. I can see where some people who might be a little whacko would be pushed over the edge by severe financial difficulties. Fine.
Hey! Let's blame Barney Frank, Chris Dodd, and the rest of the loser democrats who caused this financial meltdown. Yeah, that's the ticket!
→ Maybe
June 3, 2009 - 10:57 ET by Cool ArrowOr we can blame all those who devalue human life for the sake of lust.
"The only reason Clarence Thomas is on the court is because he's black". - Joe Biden
Re Dana Milbank
June 3, 2009 - 11:53 ET by slickwillie2001FTA: "Wolffe: And just to cite someone who maybe has some experience of violence in America, John Lewis -- remember, when he said in the campaign, when those people at the McCain rallies who are saying "kill him" about the now-president of the United States, John Lewis said there is a direct link here between those who fan this kind of mob sentiment and the violence this country has seen."
A textbook case of how a lie travels around the world. Note how even the lie that 'someone said' has now become 'those people'. Next it will be an entire crowd chanting it.
The excellent link above from another poster thoroughly debunks this: http://fightthepalinsmears.com
Remember it was Dana Milbank that started these lies. These lies must follow him the rest of his 'career'.
To the Left: 40,000,000
June 3, 2009 - 13:08 ET by Ten7sTo the Left: 40,000,000 babies killed by abortionists = right; 1 Left-winger killed = wrong. Liberals advocating killing of 40,000,000 babies = right; Pro-lifers condenming killing of one Leftie = wrong.
Lucifer is beaming with pride.
ONE SMALL PROBLEM
June 3, 2009 - 13:36 ET by Lord ErondNOBODY EVER SHOUTED "KILL HIM" AT SARAH PALIN OR JOHN MCCAIN RALLIES YOU FILTHY LYING DISTORTIONIST!!!!!!!! JUST ASK THE SECRET SERVICE
"Let him who would move the world, first move himself." -Socrates
"We sit together, the mountain and I, until only the mountain remains." -Li Po
Emanuel Goldstein going to
June 3, 2009 - 22:39 ET by RR GOPEmanuel Goldstein going to be vilified by these loons next?
Anything to deflect blame away from their failed ideology and policies that never have, don't and never will work...anywhere.
One of the 34% who thinks George W. Bush was a great President. One of the 61% who wants to bring back the stock and pillory (yep...approval for Congress now at 39%...do you believe that!?).