Despite Stumbles, WaPo's Tom Shales Still Calls Obama 'Smartest Kid in Class'

Photo of Tim Graham.
  • Bookmark and Share

Even though President Obama clearly stammered and struggled in some answers last night, especially the odd New York Times four-parter, Washington Post TV critic Tom Shales loved "Obama's Enchanting Quizfest" (as the headline announced), and stressed how much better he was than Bush:

Barack Obama is a truly flabbergasting president. And in a good way -- not the way some of his predecessors were. He's not flabberghastly....

His verbiage is a melting pot that's always bubbling. A few times, he did stumble over words, and once or twice appeared semantically stranded, unable to find the precise language he wanted to use. But compare him with his predecessor and such moments seem trifling.

He didn't call him "President Wonderful" as he did after the last prime-time presser, but Shales said Obama was not only smarter than Bush, but obviously smarter than every reporter in the room:  

When Obama answers a question, you don't slap your forehead and moan, "Oh, brother!" He is, as guest expert David Gergen noted on CNN after the news conference, not only "up to speed" on the pressing issues of our time but also articulate about addressing them in a friendly, accessible way. He's not the student who wears a button that says, "Smartest kid in class," but clearly he is, at least when surrounded by the White House press corps.

He loved Obama so much so he even accused the networks of trying to distract from his skills:

The TV networks always get a little jealous when a president, or any news figure, turns out to be a great communicator. They start looking for ways to distract viewers. During the early minutes of the news conference, ABC ran little poll questions and news squibs at the bottom of the screen. That was just video gingerbread, and wildly unnecessary at that.

Meanwhile, CNN, in what looked an awful lot like desperation, embedded the news conference in a day-long (or is it week-long) gimmicky "National Report Card" routine, as hired experts and members of Congress rated the president on this and that. Graphically speaking, it was a mess, and one sympathized with Anderson Cooper and Wolf Blitzer and other CNN talents caught up in one of those Producers' Brainstorms that didn't work....

MSNBC showed its strengths -- at least two of them, anyway -- by going to ravaging Keith Olbermann and ravishing Rachel Maddow. Two smart people are a lot better than an arsenal of computerly contraptions.

Shales took the Royal Flatterer routine to its natural breaking point, as he proclaimed that Obama took steps to address the ridiculous notion that he's interested in growing the government, but those who say that are so predictably strident, so far from the Obama spirit of cooperation:

Obama doesn't want to run car companies or banks, he said late in the session: "I've got enough to do." He was deflecting criticism from those who contend he wants to grow the government. The disbelievers will still be unconvinced, but there appear to be relatively few of them, and many are just the predictable strident voices of the kind of partisan pedantry that Obama has said he abhors.

Shales should really look at the top of page 1 today of his own newspaper, where they report Team Obama's finalizing a plan to oust the chief executive of Chrysler and take the auto maker through the bankruptcy process.

—Tim Graham is Director of Media Analysis at the Media Research Center.

Read commentsFree email alertsTake action

Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

although I was sorely disappointed

with the second term  and especially the last 2 years of the Bush Presidencies, I say the same analogy can be made between he and both Clinton and Obama:

 Better a tongue tied straight shooter than a silver tongued liar.

Doesn't want to run car companies?

Lower taxes? well maybe income but not 100 other hidden taxes.

No lobbyists?

Transparency?

 

PS Didja hear we have another EMERGENCY? Don't think!!! Just do exactly as we say!!!  aaaaaahhhhhhh emmmmmergency!!!

 

PSS TOM SHALES???  A mediocre TV critic who has a voice because he pukes the liberal line. Tell me about American Idol. I care as much about that as your opinion of a Presidential news conference, er softball game.

Unsophisticated Urban Liberals Rate Style

Unsophisticated Urban Liberals prefer style of substance. Who is more style oriented than a TV critic?

 

The smartest kid in the class

What they didn't tell you was it was the "Special" class......

He doesn't need to wear a

He doesn't need to wear a "Smartest Kid in the Class" button, since the media are constantly pointing at him and calling him that.

His button has a  Big, Black, One on it.

I don't think he enjoys being in front of the press as much as he enjoys being on TV.

BTW does anyone else see shades of a Jesse Jackson cadence (complete with hand motions) slipping into his speech pattern?

 

They might say "Wow, that sucks!"  But at least they'll say "Wow!"  -Duff Goldman, the Ace of Cakes

more of the same...

Well, I guess we can expect this type of critique, again and again. But I'd much rather have a president with principled convictions than one that always works on the part of sounding and looking good. 

MB...

I don't know about you, but I couldn't stomach watching more than the first 2 or so minutes of him reading his press conference. I have NO confidence in or sympathy for anyone who already knows the questions that he's going to be asked ahead of time.  The MSM does EVERYTHING possible to make this incompetent "President" look good.

 I didn't watch a minute

 I didn't watch a minute of it.  I caught a couple of clips today while hubby had the news on and I was in the kitchen.

They might say "Wow, that sucks!"  But at least they'll say "Wow!"  -Duff Goldman, the Ace of Cakes

MB, can you actually say

MB, can you actually say Black One without someone from the admistration demanding that Newsbusters scrub you from their list? That takes courage.

___________________________________ 

The challenge is to follow a consistent plan despite inconsistent prices - Sarah Palin, State of the State of Alaska speech

I guess I should have said

I guess I should have said a big black NUMBER 1 on it. I was thinking of the First Division's patch and their nickname....The Big Red 1

They might say "Wow, that sucks!"  But at least they'll say "Wow!"  -Duff Goldman, the Ace of Cakes

Good one MB

The good old 1st ID.  I still have my Big Red One Christmas ornament from our time there....one of my fav's.

Thanks for the smile.

 

I hope he fails, too.

 

 

That's because...

...the teleprompter was functioning adequately last night. 

How much more of this odius

How much more of this odius crap do we have to endure from the obama worshippers? And why aren't these worshippers being laughed out of their jobs? I can't even imagine what makes these types of people think and write like they do. Are they really the freaks they appear to be, or are they under forced marching orders by their masters to make up syrupy stuff and print/say it -- for fear of their jobs?

Get ready for the next 100 days of worship and false reporting. I can't stand it -- I really can't. MB, where the hell's the duct tape, anyway?

___________________________________ 

The challenge is to follow a consistent plan despite inconsistent prices - Sarah Palin, State of the State of Alaska speech

Genius is in the eye of the beholder

Alas, I only see an amiable dunce, for many of the reasons listed in the forementioned "fact-check" post.
And he was stammering away yesterday am introducing Arlen.

The funniest topic is still his healthcare, which can only truly be controlled thru major tort reform based upon USPTF recommendations (ie limit all the fluff testing).

Tort reform from a Dem?  Never will happen :o)
Will the media ask?  Of course not.........
Healthcare for the most obese and sedentary society in world history will make TARP look cheap.
Yes, the lawyer will solve our healthcare issues--HAHAHAHAHA

Well the beauty

Of the Dems plan is, when the ration health care, there will be less lawsuits, so you end up with defacto Tort reform. Clever eh?

 

My Gov. thinks I am dangerous, so be careful

"Television is a freak show" Bernie Goldberg

ZERO

We have ZERO evidence of Dear Leader's intelligence. His transcripts from three schools, his SAT or LSAT scores, his bar exam performance, even his high school grades, have been buried deep.

If only he was as secretive with our country's strategic intelligence.

ZERO

nice!

"If only he was as secretive with our country's strategic intelligence. "

 How very true!  i may steal that for my tag line!

Neil

The end of the piece is

The end of the piece is always when the guns come out (there might be a pun in there somewhere). Here, Tom states:

"Obama doesn't want to run car companies or banks, he said late in the
session: "I've got enough to do." He was deflecting criticism from
those who contend he wants to grow the government. The disbelievers
will still be unconvinced, but there appear to be relatively few of
them, and many are just the predictable strident voices of the kind of
partisan pedantry that Obama has said he abhors."

How dare we criticize BeelzObama! He said he didn't want to grow the government, so it must be true..... how dare we! Look at what he says.... then look at what he does.... it's that simple.

And for Tommy Boy to exclaim that there are "relatively few" disbelievers .... "predictable strident voices"...REALLY?  He sounds like a hard core fan of "Spinal Tap" writing his "concert" review for the paper while the concert is still in progress and he's itchin' from his"contact" high. Just step outside the concert hall and travel a bit away from the parking lot and you will find MILLIONS of us who can't stomach "Spinal Tap"

"...this kind of partisan pedantry that Obama has said he abhors."   Yeah, he abhors it alright. He plants it, he cultivates it, he grows it, he harvests it, he "spikes" it.... hell, he even drives it in a truck to the market and advertises for it!

@$$ MUNCH!!

;~)

 

"We retort..... you decide."

Oh yeah..... and that

Oh yeah..... and that little charachiture of Tom in the corner looks like Sally Jessy Raphael!

 

"We retort..... you decide."

One thing for certain,

One thing for certain, Obama is smarter than Shales. But then that is really not saying much. 

"DumbAssity of Dope"

Hammer, Nail

Announced on Fox News that the Doofus will be speaking again today at noon. When reading a teleprompter is your one and only talent, it's the answer to everything.

It sort of brings to mind

It sort of brings to mind that one KFC commercial years ago when they used a young female tennis pro to pimp their chicken and her tag line was something like "I do one thing.... and I do it right!"

 

"We retort..... you decide."

I wish someone with the recources would put Bush and The O's

press conferences side by side. Show the tough questions and animosity given to Bush and the softball questions and the adoration given to O. I think the contrast would be stunning.

 

"Failure has been achieved!"

So true...

That would be fascinating to see. Journalists have just totally copped out on their job of getting at the truth for the American public~very sad.

It's time

We take Glenn Beck's emergency blinker out for a boat ride.

Never want a crisis to go to waste -- Is getting really tired.

If Barack Obama is the

If Barack Obama is the smartest kid in class, that tells you more about the class than it tells you about Obama.

By the way, I don't know where you got that Tom Shales caricature from, but it's ridiculously poor.  In real life, Tom Shales is sweaty and obese.

"Socialism is a philosophy of failure, the creed of ignorance, and the gospel of envy, its inherent virtue is the equal sharing of misery." -Winston Churchill

How do we know Obama is smart

 How do we know Obama is smart?  We still have not seen his transcripts, his thesis etc...  Despite how he stands on the soapbox of transarency it doesnt apply to him. WHY?  He may "seem" smart to the left but there is evidence that with out a teleprompter and someone elses words in front of him that maybe he isnt quite the genius that they would have us believe.

_______ Him and the Unicorn he rode in on

Because it's smart to be a

Because it's smart to be a socialist! 

The Rocky Mountain Collegian: Illustrating Idiocy

liberals associate

liberals associate intelligence with opinion and political ideology.  Liberalism is full of logical fallacies.  That's why the youth flocks to it.

Nothing like feeling smart without the effort.  Just believe it and you're smart. 

Obama doesn't think.  He

Obama doesn't think.  He let's his 12 year old, highly naive, incredibly fanatical liberal advisors make every decision for him.

Nothing he does seems to be practical.  He doesn't care about the economy.  He knows and his people know that he is a 1 term deal.

He is going to try and shove as much liberal bull on us as he can in the next 4 years to make the far left happy.  He's gonna slash and burn and try to make the government more liberal in the next 4 years.  It's gonna accelerate soon.  They have a year to shove as much as they can on us.  

Remember the "change" bit.  He isn't in "repair" mode.  He is in change mode.

Gays in the military. national socialized healthcare (at least some form, lay the egg), affirmative action hiring, gun control, destroying the coal industry, weakening the military, popularing "peace corps" type foreign policy, submitting to the muslim world,  etc, etc, etc.  If they get implemented they'll be impossible to revert.  

If Obama was actually trying to fix the economy he wouldn't be off promising to raise taxes, pitching green technology, etc, etc.  All he does is pitch the same liberal bull his party has been trying sell the last few decades.  His people give a rats ass about the economy.  The more people on government programs, the more people they think will vote their way.  They keep repeating it, too.   They blame capitalism, etc.   They aren't gonna fix an economy which they think is wrong.  They want to break it even further or just ignore it.

Anyhow, the whole deal with the auto industry is just to preserve the unions.  These unions provide the democrat party with a lot of capital.  They provide it in cold hard cash to campaigns.  

Look at what democrats and their buddies have done to Michigan and now watch Obama turn it national. 

 

Being the smartest liberal

Being the smartest liberal is like being the most honest grifter.

Smartest kid in the class?

 
Well, in this administration being the smartest kid ain't that much of a reach. Hell, even Tele Jr. is probably up there near the top. Top idiot is more likely.  Juz sayin'.  : )

 

Gary

All the oil is in Texas and the dipsticks are in D.C.!