Chris Matthews Runs Rush's 'Liberal Lion' Kennedy Clip, Shrum Denounces His 'Appeals to Haters'

Photo of Tim Graham.
  • Bookmark and Share

On Friday night's Hardball, Chris Matthews showed how willing he was to carry Democrat water on their manufactured outrage at Rush Limbaugh for mentioning "that great liberal lion" Ted Kennedy. Matthews played the Democrat clip and came out with a sour face -- an odd pose, given Matthews tastelessly mocked Ronald Reagan in 1995 after his Alzheimer's letter on ABC for forgetting he left the country with a big national debt. He let Democrat strategist Bob Shrum roll out the talking point:  

MATTHEWS: What do you make of it?

SHRUM: It’s outrageous, it’s typical of him. He’s a tasteless guy. He’ll say anything. He appeals to haters.

MATTHEWS: Yeah.

SHRUM: And he is the face of the Republican Party right now, because no one else is doing a very good job and because he went to CPAC. This is not like the 1990s: Gingrich at his worst was massively popular compared to Rush Limbaugh. And stuff like this is just going to make it more difficult.

Matthews not only ran the audio clip and standard Rush picture of Media Matters for America -- MSNBC also added the Media Matters logo on screen for 10 or 11 seconds. Video is here (logo at 3:55).

Matthews claimed the president's health care plan was wanted by a lot of people, including business people, which meant it wasn't a left-right issue any more. This is exactly what liberals said about Hillary Clinton's fiasco in 1993 and 1994, that since some liberal businessmen supported it, it wasn't ideological any more. That only means that some businessmen aren't conservatives, not that nationalizing health care isn't a matter of capitalism versus socialism.

(Hat tip: Christopher)

—Tim Graham is Director of Media Analysis at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

   This kind of stuff is

   This kind of stuff is one of the main reason that some people came out to vote for obama.  He convinced them that he was going to bring us together and stop this constant bickering between the parties and he would change the tone in Washington.  Instead it has gotten worse and the Whitehouse is instigating it.  They won't destroy Rush but they are turning off the people who for the first time got involved in politics because they thought they were in a crusade to change the government back to being a voice of the people and not just a venue for self-serving politicians and their special interest friends. 

Silly Chris

As the markets crash and pension plans evaporate, Tingles chides "Republicans and their self-interest".

are your ratings gone? is

are your ratings gone? is your show irrelivant? your empty-suit messiah makes prez carter look like an absolute economic genius?

well just attack Rush Limbaugh as a last-ditch effort...

who's worst ever now?

There's an old saying

Weak security is worse than no security. The idea is when you think you are protected, you let your guard down. Rush is treating this  battle like battles he's had in the past, to his detriment. He doesn't see the Katrina on his horizon. The storm hasn't even started, and he's thinking "this aint so bad." Oh my.

Beware of a crazy woman throwing a hash pipe.

nwahs

wow for once i almost agree with you, -----> except it is the entrenched lib media that ia acting so secure while their market share and financial status continues to erode and they can not figure out why...............

Take the New York Times, , , , , , please"

Weak security is worse

Weak security is worse than no security. The idea is when you think you are protected, you let your guard down.

Another asinine statement from the master of odd. Any more gems? Little food is worse than NO food. Some water is worse than NO water.

Please continue to amuse us with your "logic."

Obama Amends The Constitution
Check out the poster @ Hollycrud checker-outers

Uhuh

Techs love people like you.

"My virus software sucks! I just updated the definitions 2 months ago and I still got a virus!"

 And as you walk blithely through life, the tech says...

Tech: "thats ok sir, we'll take care of it. Sir.. that door is out onl...

eww...thats gonna leave mark ."

Beware of a crazy woman throwing a hash pipe.

→ I get it.

You're waiting for one of the salesmen to bring back a brain needing a reformat and business is slow, so you're blogging.

Hey nwahs!  Circuit City went Tango Uniform.  You really need to go home and tell your mom.

Obama - Change you can bereave in

Your virus is obvious nwahs.

For the constipation of your brain get professional help.

For the diarrhea of your mouth, just shut up.

Jesus Loves You

I missed it. What are they outraged about in this instance?

Are they "outraged" that he mentioned Kennedy by name?  That the bill might be named after Kennedy?  The term "liberal lion"?

Liberals are constantly on the lookout for opportunities to be slighted and aggrieved, whether it's Jesse Jackson screaming about George Bush paying tribute to Corretta Scott King at her funeral, or the black community freaking out over Bill Clinton calling Obama a "kid", or Hillary mentioning Johnson and MLK in the same sentence.

F' em.  They're just a bunch of hyper-partisan, overly emotional, incoherent idiots.

Americans have the right to

Americans have the right to be offended - matthews should know this - but then he should also know journalism and broadcasting i guess

who's worst ever now?

Hate

I'd hate Chris Matthews if he was worth the effort.

 

Bob Schrum?

What a joke, 'tingles' matthews and eight times presidential loser Schrum talking about anything.  The markets crashing and job loss is up, so mslsd puts these two idiots together and this is all they got?  How out of touch can you get.  Oh yeah, Obambi sees the stock market 'as a poll, wavering up and down' when in reality it's nosediving fast.

My change is gone

Rush unpopular? Oh really?

".....and because he (Rush) went to CPAC....Gingrich at his worst was massively popular compared to Rush Limbaugh."

There is a channel on Direct TV that a subscriber can select that shows, among other things, the 5 most popular channels currently being watched.

Out of curiousity, about an hour into Rush's speech, I surfed over to that particular channel.  FOX News which was carrying Rush's entire speech was holding steady at the number two slot (The PGA Tournament was number 1).   With no apparent change to the rankings, I shortly returned to Rush's speech.

After Rush concluded his speech FOX News was carrying, I returned to this Direct TV channel displaying the top 5 channels currently viewed.  FOX News which had been covering Rush's speech had dropped to the number 5 slot.

So much for the absurd demedia claim that Rush is unpopular.

If someone called me a

"conservative lion", I would be complemented and honored.

What is so awful about being called the lion of your position?

It means that you are the king of your point of view, that you dominate the  landscape.

One has to wonder why the Dems are so dumb as to attack Rush, then attack him for using a complement of Kennedy, and then to go after him for wanting the other side to fail.

Are they really so dense that they don't know what fools they are making of themselves?

I loved it when Ari got them with response to MSNBC of "then why aren't the Democrats distancing themselves from Keith Olberman?"

When reason is used to consider what they say, they look like fools!

Chris the picture of you in

Chris the picture of you in this thread like you're sitting on a swollen hemorrhoid is priceless.

It's kind of how I feel if I watch a seond or two of your show.

Hey Tim, thanks for the link

I checked out Tim's link to what Matthew's said about Reagan ... it turns out that it is a really good line to use on Obama right now to go after Matthews! Here, read the original and what we can do with it ...

"The trouble is that Ronald Reagan left us with the check. He may not remember all this, but he left us with a $3 trillion debt."
-- San Francisco Examiner Washington Bureau Chief and America's Talking host Chris Matthews on Good Morning America, January 4.

I could easily update it to ...

"The trouble with Barrack Obama is that he is leaving us with a check. We will remember that all of this debt we have today was created when he left us a $3 trillion debt in his Stimulus Package to pay off."

 

It's easy to understand why

It's easy to understand why Bob Shrum would be offended by the term "liberal lion".  After all, when your record heading up Presidential campaigns best resembles that of the 2008 Detroit Lions, you're certain to be sensitive about the reference to that animal. 

"Socialism is a philosophy of failure, the creed of ignorance, and the gospel of envy, its inherent virtue is the equal sharing of misery." -Winston Churchill

That was a good one

 when your record heading up Presidential campaigns best resembles that of the 2008 Detroit Lions

Freedom is never more than one generation away from extinction. We didn't pass it to our children in the bloodstream. It must be fought for, protected, and handed on for them to do the same. RWR

remember the funny news busters line?

that shoe-thrower guy got a tryout at qb for detroit.

swing hard in case you hit it.

I'd be more apt to have him

I'd be more apt to have him go to the Pirates. At least the guy can throw over the plate.

Freedom is never more than one generation away from extinction. We didn't pass it to our children in the bloodstream. It must be fought for, protected, and handed on for them to do the same. RWR

Face of the Democrat Party?

This could be it if things don't work out in Minn.

Or how about this one?

Freedom is never more than one generation away from extinction. We didn't pass it to our children in the bloodstream. It must be fought for, protected, and handed on for them to do the same. RWR

Would this name fit?

To make up for the "liberal lion of the senate" not being much of a swimmer, could we call the bill "The Mary Jo Kopechne Memorial Health Bill"?

Mary Jo Kopechne (July 26, 1940 – July 18, 1969)

Chrissy

You know Chrissy some turds float and some turds sink but in the end they all get flushed. Which one are you-a floater or a sinker?

Freedom is never more than one generation away from extinction. We didn't pass it to our children in the bloodstream. It must be fought for, protected, and handed on for them to do the same. RWR

Cowardly Chris, the leg man himself,has a short memory

(or no memory - libs have such small brains) that he forgets what all the demolibs said about President Bush - lier, killer, he needs to go, etc - the president today is being propped up by the propagandists of the media, and they will continue to find someone to hate, using the very tatctics they abhore - to the cowardly spin artists of the greater proaganda machine, we, the people, are not as stupid as you guys look!

Have some courage, you spinners, and report on how socially ignorant the prez and his wife are (gifts to Brown), how financially ignorant he is (profit to earnings statement?), how structually ignorant he is (open a window, thinking it was a door), sloppy geographically, and the US of A (57 states).

Will any of you, in the spin propaganda machine, ever actually report, instead of being rip-and-reader of the admins fax machine? DOUBT IT!  If any on you actually think you can "report", instead of passing along the sorry thoughts of this socialist leaning prez, then you may actually be recognized as a journalist, instead of sniviling tool/fool of a character who cares not a wit about you, or the rest of us Americans.

There is no sense in being stupid, if you can't prove it! - my dad V

Liberal Lion used before (as COMPLIMENT)

CHRISSY MATTHEWS REALLY IS A JOURNALISTIC SLUT...

This moniker has been used before to describe Teddy Kennedy before:

National Journal's annual ratings are out, and the most liberal member of the Senate is Edward M. Kennedy. That may come as no surprise, since the venerable Massachusetts Democrat is often called the chamber's ''liberal lion."

http://www.boston.com/news/nation/washington/articles/2006/03/05/the_liberals_liberal/?page=2

Or how about this:

On this night a tumor could not tumble the Liberal Lion and chemotherapy and radiation had to take a back seat because the Lion had decided to leave his lair. After a nice video introduction set up by his niece, Caroline Kennedy, Senator Teddy M. Kennedy emerged from behind the stage and stood at the podium refusing a stool that had been offered to him to sit on. Stunted stamina, shorter steps and eclipsed endurance had to give way to the Lion's Roar! Yes, Teddy still has his roar!

http://faithfuldemocrats.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=789&Itemid=108 

A search on Yahoo gives the following result:

2,020,000 for Liberal lion Kennedy 

Chrissy Matthews is a Political Whore, and a debaucher of any useful Journalism...

__________________________ 

Long Live...THE REPUBLIC !

Shrum is just a RINO

This is absolutely typical of Mathews. He is just a party hack. What is worse is the Leftist media are parading out these Republicans, like Shrum, who is a complete idiot, and NOT a Conservative, and presenting them as spokesmen for the GOP. Sorry, but Brooks, Shrum, and others have nothing in common with the base. They despise the base and talk down to them. Well...genius without us you lose elections and look at the past to election cycles for proof. So, by throwing Rush under the bus, these RINOs just turn off the base, not the other way around, These RINOs are the problem for the GOP not Rush, Levin, Hannity, Newt, Pence, Boehner, and the like. Get a clue and go be a Democrat, because you talk like one.

 http://franklinslocke.blogspot.com/

I think you're confusing

I think you're confusing Bob Shrum with David Frum.  Shrum is the Democrat "Political Strategist" whose record in Presidential Elections flatters the records of Anthony Young, the 1976 Tampa Bay Buccaneeers and the 1962 Mets.  David Frum is the Canadian "neocon" who thinks that McCain losing in November indicates that we should be pushing Charlie Crist, Christine Todd Whitman or Arnold Schwarzenegger as our next Presidential nominee.  Apparently the Republican Party doesn't do enough pandering to "moderates".

"Socialism is a philosophy of failure, the creed of ignorance, and the gospel of envy, its inherent virtue is the equal sharing of misery." -Winston Churchill

Rush on a Roll

"By one measure, Rush Limbaugh is a clear winner this week: His ratings have nearly doubled since his feud with the White House burst into the media limelight."

http://www.washingto...

When I heard his comment about Kennedy, I didn't take it as a hint that Kennedy was about to die. Look how many Robert Byrd memorial buildings and other things are there in West Virginia, and he's still up and around.

Still, the real story here should be that government resources and people on government salaries are using our White House to attack a private citizen. That was one of the charges Congress made against Nixon in their effort to impeach him. Perhaps this will be the first charge eventually against President Asshat.

→ That's funny slick

White House press secretary Robert Gibbs said he would "plead guilty" to being "counterproductive." 

Quite an admission from an Obama lackey whose leader has just presided over a 20% drop in American wealth.

Nice of Gibbs to admit he's happy with having created a diversion.

Obama - Change you can bereave in

Rush parroted every comment

Rush parroted every comment made by a dem senator since Ed Kennedy got ill.  He did not add anything, he parroted exactly what was said.  And they get mad at Rush.  The idiots.

→ ConRex

If you watched Hannity last night you saw a Democrat strategist ready to spit nails when Hannity brought that to her attention.

She jumped out there with "deplorable" before Hannity had a chance to stuff it back down her throat.

Brilliant! 

Obama - Change you can bereave in

Double Standards

Liberals always have double standards. Blacks can use the fearsome 'n word' with abandon, but God forbid a white-appearing person use it. Liberal David Ehrenstein can write a column about Obammy being 'the magic negro', but God forbid Rush Limbaugh parody it back. Democratics use their double standards every day and the compliant old media lets them.

"Matthews played the

"Matthews played the Democrat clip and came out with a sour face"

He just realized he's lost 20% of his investments since Inauguration Day.  

Blame Limbaugh...who else?

Wonder if people are going to start showing up at hospitals today and being outraged if they're billed.  "Wait a second here.  Obama says our health care is free now!  What gives?!"

Oh, and wait until folks start buying cigarettes next week.  

Ah, the clueless masses.

One of the 24% who thinks George W. Bush was a great President. One of the 89% who wants to bring back the stock and pillory.

Chris Matthews is a Journalist, and Therefore a Supporter of

the First Amendment, that in part states that no one should infringe on Free Speech. Therefore, I'm certain that Chris Matthews believes Rush Limbaugh has a right to speak his mind.

In fact, Chris Matthews is such a respected journalist and a strong supporter of the First Amendment that he has been selected as emcee for the Association of Electronic Journalist (RTNDA) 19th annual First Amendment Awards Dinner on March 12 in Washington. 

Moreover, at that awards dinner two other well-respected journalists, Charles Gibson and Sam Donaldson, will present the Leonard Zeidenberg First Amendment Award to a third well-respected journalist and strong supporter of the First Amendment, Cokie Roberts.

In fact, journalist Cokie Roberts is such a strong supporter of the First Amendment that as the Media Research Center reported:

ABC's Cokie Roberts denounced as "irresponsible"conservative opposition to the "stimulus" bill and suggested those who voted against it should be punished, declaring on Sunday's This Week: "I just think that when you're in a situation like this, to do nothing is so irresponsible that you can't, you can't get away with it."

Isn't it comforting to know that the well-respected journalist in this country are looking out for our Free Speech, and are honored with an award for this dedication.

----------------------------------------------------


“They have plunged to such depths of incompetence and unprofessionalism and ignorance, it's actually hard for me to come up with accurate words to describe what has happened to them,…” ~ Rush Limbaugh on the media 

Winner

Rush -- for saying for others what they wish they would say for themselves.

It is what it is

Rush is correct of coarse.

I don't think socialized healthcare should be named sought after because of Kennedy.

After all, he doesn't suffer under the HMO's, or wait in line, or have trouble paying his medical bills.

The Dems will use his illness and impending death so as to rush through nationalized health care. I mean he couldn't be the "lion", the champion of this crap, and claim credit after his death!

They need to get on with it now while he is sober and breathing.

 

I don't "hate" anything.

I don't "hate" anything.  But I disfavor socialists, race-baiters, communists, elitists, welfare-states, unnecessary unionization, government "stimulus" plans that don't work and liars.

DIMocrats

When are the voters, who blindly follow the Democratic party line without ever considering why they vote for a particular individual, ever going to wake up and realize who it is that runs their train wreck of a party?  Chris Matthews' latest guest, Bob Shrum has been nothing more than a rehashed propetual loser for the past 15 years, and yet he's propped up there as some political scholar, who should be paid attention.  Begala, Carville, Emanuel are all political whores, or hoods, or both.  The only thing they care about is power and limelight, not the well being of our country. They are not the only hucksters, there are far too many to list.

Even after "buyers remorse" sets in from Obama and his henchmen, and they rid themselves of him in four years, they will still listen to flaks such as the afore mentioned, and vote for some other charlatan, with a big mouth and a mirophone, without so much of a thought, other than the fact that their candidate is a Democrat.  Hey, why not Sean Penn, he couldn't be any worse.

I started this rant with ...."when are the voters...yadda, yadda, yadda..."  I can answer my own question.....NEVER!  Democrats are DIMocrats and eat grass.  Baaaaa, Baaaa, Baaaa