'Lethal Medication'? AP Prefers Culture-of-Death Euphemisms for Assisted Suicide

Photo of Tim Graham.
  • Bookmark and Share

Count Associated Press as one American news outlet that prefers the terminology of the culture of death. On Sunday, the home page of Yahoo carried the headline "Washington to allow patients to seek life-ending prescriptions." It’s about the state of Washington, and one click gets the story headline: "Washington state to allow ‘dignity’ deaths." It did not use the term "assisted suicide." AP writer Rachel LaCorte began her story:

Terminally ill patients with less than six months to live will soon be able to ask their doctors to prescribe them lethal medication in Washington state.

But even though the "Death with Dignity" law takes effect Thursday, people who might seek the life-ending prescriptions could find their doctors conflicted or not willing to write them.

Many doctors are hesitant to talk publicly about where they stand on the issue, said Dr. Tom Preston, a retired cardiologist and board member of Compassion & Choices, the group that campaigned for and supports the law.

The culture-of-death lobby chooses titles like "Compassion & Choices," and vows to create a "cultural shift" toward eliminating the terminally ill. The staunchest opponent in the story told AP he couldn’t write a lethal prescription, but he’s willing to refer the patient to the "compassion" forces:

Dr. Stu Farber, director of the palliative care consult service at the University of Washington Medical Center, voted against the measure and doesn't plan to prescribe lethal medication to his patients for now.

"I am not here to tell people how they should either live their life or the end of their life," Farber said. "There's possibly a story out there, in the future, that's so compelling that maybe I would write a prescription."

Farber said he would refer patients to Compassion & Choices of Washington, the state's largest aid-in-dying advocacy group, after talking about how they came to their decision.

Another doctor is quoted offering a mild critique:

Two doctors must certify that the patient has a terminal condition and six months or less to live.

Some doctors who opposed the measure have argued that a six-month terminal diagnosis is never a sure thing.

"There is no question in my mind that, if this is too easy of a task, people will die prematurely," said Dr. Linda Wrede-Seaman, a family physician and palliative care specialist in Yakima.

But AP and LaCorte never quoted the actual political opponents of Initiative 1000 in the story, and make almost no reference to religious groups campaigning against assisted suicide. That S-word only appeared once in the story.

[Image from Wesley Smith]

—Tim Graham is Director of Media Analysis at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Elizabeth Scalia, aka the

Elizabeth Scalia, aka the Anchoress, wrote this piece back in 2005, after the Indonesian tsunami.  It has since been reprinted in a couple of places.  I would like to offer it for all to read:

A Tsunami Cannot Be Drawn in Pastels: On Dignity and Suffering

It is a  description of the lingering death of her brother, and to my mind is the most beautiful, heart-rending and moving description of life and love at the end of life that I have ever read.

My favorite part is her response to people who claim that her brother should be helped to a quick death:

Do you think that giving
my lionhearted brother a "compassionate" needle would truly lessen our
suffering, or his? By cutting short the process, do we step off the Via Dolorosa
and avoid it all, or do we merely thwart a plan for our own lives?
Should we steal from our brother the opportunity for him to reach out a
hand and have it immediately grasped, to have everything about his
existence affirmed, over and over?

 

Should we steal from ourselves the opportunity to love?

 

Read the whole thing; but have a tissue handy.

 I didn't think it was physically possible, but this both sucks and blows. -Bart Simpson

mb...I have this saved,

mb...

I have this saved, read the first page and will read the rest later...for personal reasons I can't handle all of it at the moment.

Just wanted to say ....Thank you.

bt...I didn't mean to upset

bt...I didn't mean to upset you; I'm sorry if I did.

I really had hoped to spark a discussion about the end of life, but the thread quickly got derailed to abortion.

I wonder if if it's because it's harder for people to deal with the facts of death, and easier to discuss abortion because it's not a human being that one has known and lived with for 40 years, but people seem more comfortable arguing for saving at the beginning of life and more willing to end it prematurely at the end.

I didn't think it was physically possible, but this both sucks and blows. -Bart Simpson

  Here's a 'hero' to the

  Here's a 'hero' to the die now crowd and a perfect person for government run healthcare.  It's also a good example of the idiocy of some so-called news programs.  (it's really funny)

and Obama wants gov't to decide effectiveness of treatment

 so obama wants to create a committee that decides what treatments are "cost effective" in the Universal Mandatory Health System. the same government that can't understand scientific methodology in regards to climate, thinks it can understand and properly determine medical procedures. Any bets on this "assisted suicide" being a perfectly acceptable and even recommended "procedure' by the new regime? And just like Obama's income threshold that determines "wealthy" constantly descending, any bets the "six month" moves to a year, then two or more? 

This is why government, health care and assisted suicides are bad ideas that get worse together. When government "assists" your death because it's "better for society" (and cheaper) than taking care of you, after making sure that you couldn't afford health care on your own. people love to believe that the military sacrifices lives for oil money, but they think for some reason their liberal friends won't sacrifice people for more money and control especially when they can do it "for the good of...'the children/the economy/the People"?

 

"to call an illegal immigrant an "undocumented alien" is like calling a streetcorner drug dealer an "unlicensed pharmacist".

"You spend your money anyway you want and respect other's rights to do the same&quo

This biased and unbalanced AP article is consistent with the

liberal principles of the Associated Press.

Here is another example of the AP's biased and liberal agenda. A few weeks after the presidential election, Associated Press writer Ravi Nessman wrote an article about the militants who had killed almost 200 people in Mumbai, India. The article appeared in my local newspaper. I couldn't find a copy on my newspapers online website, but a search found it at the Huffington Post.  

Ravi Nessman's article provides a detailed description of the terror attack, including the official responses to the attack from India's foreign minister, Israeli's Defense Minister and the Pakistani Defense Minister.

To be complete and fair and balanced, the AP article also mentions the United States response to the attacks. What did President Bush have to say about this terror attack in India?  You won't find out it in this bias AP article, because there is no mention of President Bush in this article.

This is the way the Associated Press' Ravi Nessman provided the U.S. response: "President-elect Barack Obama said he was closely monitoring the
situation. "These terrorists who targeted innocent civilians will not defeat India's great democracy, nor shake the will of a global coalition to defeat them," he said in a statement."

-------------------------------------------------------------

“They have plunged to such depths of incompetence and unprofessionalism and ignorance, it's actually hard for me to come up with accurate words to describe what has happened to them,….” ~ Rush Limbaugh on the media

This is one of three

This is one of three hot-topics which I am not conservative.  I think people should be able to smoke marijuana, I think people should be able to commit suicide if it is their opinion and their opinion only. Schiavo, for example, was not the decision maker and should not have been put to death.  I guess I am what you call a "fiscal conservative".  Everything else: immigration, spending, military, Iraq, capitalism, etc. I am as conservative as they get. But some people are in horrible misery. We have to make exceptions.

~A woman has a right to abortion

The only reason you are alive to form that opinion is because YOUR mother chose NOT to exercise that 'right'. Funny how that works.

Hope and Change=
Despair and Socialism

I understand that.  I will

I understand that.  I will never be 100% sure of how I feel about the abortion issue.  I go back and forth on that one.

~Back and Forth

Simple solution. Look at it from the baby's perspective.
Your mother is paying someone to kill you.

Hope and Change=
Despair and Socialism

I understand that.  That's

I understand that.  That's why the ultimate question is "when does life start"?  Is it at conception?  Is it at the first, second, or third trimester?  Personally, I am not certain.  I have a hard time believing a woman is killing her baby if she takes an after morning pill, for instance.  I will be first to admit that the topic bothers me to no end.

But back on topic: lets say you are right, that a mother should not have the right to abort her fetus.  If I agree with that, how does that relate to the assisted suicide issue?  What is the argument for not allowing someone to kill themselves?

 

~Christian perspective

Our lives are not our own to dispose of at will. We do not give ourselves life, and we have no right to take it. And personally, suicide is for cowards.

If life did not begin at conception, then there would be no baby. 'If it's not a baby, you're not pregnant' so to speak.
If a woman does not wish to become pregnant, she should either abstain, or use proper birth control. it is so easy to avoid pregnancy, I can see no excuse for 'unwanted' pregnancies.

Hope and Change=
Despair and Socialism

Thank you for the response.

Thank you for the response.  Thank god I don't ever have to make the decision.  

Mostly moderate.. if you go

Mostly moderate.. if you go back forth on the subject of abortion, I hope you eventually settle on the "don't do it" side. That newly conceived living being with uniquely human DNA deserves a chance to be born alive.

Mickey Mouse is one
of "Satan's soldiers" and must die, says Saudi Arabian cleric Sheikh
Muhammad Munajid.  - Daily Telegraph (UK), 9/15/08

Should we not afford everyone rights?

 I think a woman has a right to abortion

 Why does the woman have more rights then the child? What gives the mother the right to kill what she alone is responsible for bearing? What culture kills the only innocents among them? 

"Television is a freak show" Bernie Goldberg

It's a difficult topic for

It's a difficult topic for me.  You read my response before I edited it.  Sorry about that.

~You can probably guess

From my sn that this is a big issue for me. I won't pester :) you any further, I just can't not be passionate about it when I'm holding my little baby in my lap. Hormones.

Hope and Change=
Despair and Socialism

I can totally understand.

I can totally understand.  And personally, I would never want a girlfriend or my wife to have an abortion.  Just the name is sickening.  My essential concern is when a life is viable to the point the government can tell a woman what to do.

This is where I wish I was more religious.  It would make things much easier. 

I got it the other way

 government can tell a woman what to do.

 Gov taking the rights from the baby. The woman had a choice, the baby doesnt.

Anyway, I have never known anyone who sufferd with this question, to have the baby and then regret it, including family. 

"Television is a freak show" Bernie Goldberg

~Religious

My personal moral code is what guides my actions. For instance, I was a virgin until I married. Not because I thought that God would punish me (or whatever) but because my self-respect demanded it. I would not allow a man that kind of access unless he had committed himself to me (and our potential offspring) in return.

As far as 'sins' go, I refrain from lying, stealing, etc. because I don't want to be a liar, thief, etc. I just don't do anything I'd be ashamed to admit to.

My rule of thumb is, if I make a decision based on what is 'easiest' for ME, it's the wrong decision.

If you chicken out and try to avoid personal suffering (suicide, abortion, drug use) then you are usually just passing the buck to someone else. (grieving family members, unborn baby)

Hope and Change=
Despair and Socialism

cl3x

you're making way too much practical sense here

The way to stop discrimination on the basis of race is to stop discriminating on the basis of race.” -- Chief Justice John Roberts

~Sorry Bruce

Too much chocolate cake, I'm drunk.

Hope and Change=
Despair and Socialism

cl

you need to balance with the ice cream

The way to stop discrimination on the basis of race is to stop discriminating on the basis of race.” -- Chief Justice John Roberts

~Thanks for reminding me

I knew I was forgetting something. *Urp* 'Scuse me.

Hope and Change=
Despair and Socialism

Hey

Remember the "lie" birthday cake? It was Blazer's NB birthday.  I remember the cake.  It was chocolate.  (His tagline was "The cake is a lie".)  I think mine should be "The cake is a YUMMY lie"

~The Cake is a Lie

Apparently that's a quote from a video game. I prefer the kind I can eat! :)

My littlest daughter was 2 yesterday and my husband's B-day is Feb. 29 (poor fella)
My folks came over for coffee, cake and ice cream today. Now hubby and I are sitting here bloated with cake watching the snow fall. We've got about 4 inches now and it's the most snow I've seen in a few years. I can't wait for the girls to wake up in the morning, they'll be so excited!

Hope and Change=
Despair and Socialism

Oh he is so lucky

I would love to have a b-day every 4 yrs, they come around so fast now a days I cant enjoy them cause of the dispare. 

 

"Television is a freak show" Bernie Goldberg

~He had one last year!

He came home from work in a really good mood so I told him I was pregnant. *grin*
I know how to make a birthday memorable!

Hope and Change=
Despair and Socialism

Cl3x

  Man, you sure know how to give a birthday present! Last year my husband got new socks. (And they weren't even wrapped)

 

~Well, the previous year

I gave birth on his (sort of) birthday. :)
I don't think I can ever top that.

Hope and Change=
Despair and Socialism

i just want to say i really

Chooselife3x-i just want to say i really enjoy your post. it is nice to know that there are others like me out there. i waited until i was married too. sometimes my friends look at me like i am so naive because i choose to wait. 

it is sad that today the media has chosen not to cherish Marriage and purity anymore, there would be a lot less hurt in the world.

I waited too

  And so did my kids.  (The two who are now married.  The other two also plan to wait.)  They are 10 and 14 now, but both of them know the goal is to bring the gift of purity to your marriage.

my boys are only 3 and 6,

my boys are only 3 and 6, and i pray daily that they will grow up to be Godly young men who will respect women and wait until marriage. i know it will be hard for them, especially with the way our country is headed. 

i also think that being open with your children is important. it worked for me and my mom. she got pregnant at 18 and married my dad. i remember the many walks and talks and knowing that she would support me no matter what and i chose to wait till my wedding night. it was the best gift i could give my husband.

JAJT

Having had two grow up and get married and move out has made the time now with the two younger ones all the more precious.  I realize that we only have a few more years of influence over our son and soon he will be making his own decisions whether we like it or not.  Every conversation we have is precious as I realize how fast time with them flies by.  He still likes and respects us and listens to us now.  I hope that stays on as he gets older.  He told me the other day, "I just want you to know that I could have a girlfriend.  But I don't because you are right.  It is better to wait on that and just be friends with girls at this age (he is 14)."  I cried after he left the room. It turns out there are several girls who think he is quite the prize.  (Well, I think so too)  Anyway, just helping them set up the perameters that they can operate within is a lot of parenting.

~You're not kidding

Every person I talked to on this subject regretted many of their past choices.
Whenever someone tried to debate the issue of pre-marital sex as a valid 'trial' method I said that I, for one, wasn't interested in being taken for a 'test drive'. It's sad that so many people would take something so precious and treat it so cavalierly.
Three 'so's in one sentence..I think I need to go to bed. :)

Hope and Change=
Despair and Socialism

MM

What is implied in your post is the crux of the matter. 

I think that those who are serious about their belief in God view the process of death differently than those lacking in belief or those who have no belief.  We will never understand suffering in this world.  As a Catholic, I accept that.  I also have a Faith that knows there is a reason God allows individuals to suffer - even those who are 'good'.

"I am not here to tell

"I am not here to tell people how they should either live their life or the end of their life,"

This scares me as compassion killings become more common state by state.  Now it does preserve Constitutional rights as being state but I can see with universal healthcare teh feds making laws to allow this and even in some case having it as an alternative to treatment.

Yes Mr. Dan, we cant operate on you and stop teh cancer because the government wont allow the resources, but we can prescribe drugs to kill urself with.  And confidentailly I know of this "off teh books" clinic taht could help u if ya got the scratch.

Nuke em til they glow then shoot em in the dark.