Here’s more proof that NPR’s most devoted listeners consider it their own liberal playground. NPR ombudsman Alicia Shepard reported "NPR has more than 400 reporters, editors, producers and analysts on its news team, and none is more of a lightning rod than Juan Williams. But it's usually not for anything he says on NPR." It’s about his appearances on Fox News, where he had a contract before joining NPR in 2000. Shepard wrote:
Last year, 378 listeners emailed me complaints and frustrations about things Williams said on Fox. The listener themes are similar: Williams "dishonors NPR." He's an "embarrassment to NPR." "NPR should severe their relationship with him."
It’s gotten so serious that NPR's Vice President of News, Ellen Weiss, "has asked Williams to ask that Fox remove his NPR identification whenever he is on O'Reilly."
Shepard didn’t ask which network is more willing to air viewpoints their audiences would dislike, since other than Williams, there are no Fox News analysts who regularly appear on NPR. (An NPR host was famously rude to Bill O'Reilly in 2003, and then-NPR ombud Jeffrey Dvorkin agreed the host, Terry Gross, came across as a "pro-[Al] Franken partisan.")
The current NPR ombud said of Williams: "Some think he is a conservative because he's on Fox. Others think Fox uses him as a liberal voice because, whether true or not, a perception exists that NPR is liberal."
But Shepard noted that letter-writers also object to other NPR people on Fox:
I question whether listeners, overall, object to what Williams says outside of NPR or the fact that he says it on Fox. NPR legal affairs correspondent Nina Totenberg appears on the Washington, D.C., ABC affiliate, WJLA-TV. Rarely do I get email criticizing her TV appearances. But in 2008, there were a healthy number of emails attacking political correspondent Mara Liasson for her regular appearances on Fox News.
The latest Juan Williams outrage, according to angry liberal NPR listeners, was a January 26 appearance on The O’Reilly Factor when he proclaimed Michelle Obama could become a political liability for her husband:
"Michelle Obama, you know, she's got this Stokely Carmichael in a designer dress thing going. If she starts talking, as Mary Katharine [Ham, a conservative blogger] is suggesting, her instinct is to start with this blame America, you know, I'm the victim. If that stuff starts coming out, people will go bananas and she'll go from being the new Jackie O to being something of an albatross."
Shepard passed along text of one letter:
"I am concerned about the objectivity Juan Williams brings to his news analysis," wrote Alison Fowler. "He has made statements on Fox News regarding Michelle Obama that appear to paint her as an angry Black Nationalist without any basis in fact. Despite the fact that these statements were not made on NPR, they undermine his credibility as an impartial news analyst on your network."
Shepard interviewed Williams and he called it a "faux controversy" at first:
But then he reviewed the tape and realized that "the tone and tenor of my comments may have spurred a strong reaction to what I considered to be pure political analysis of the First Lady's use of her White House pulpit," said Williams via email. "I regret that in the fast-paced, argumentative format my tone and tenor seems to have led people to see me as attacking instead of explaining my informed point of view."
His remarks apparently caused him to be taken into the woodshed for a stern lecture at NPR:
His "Stokely Carmichael" comment got the attention of NPR's top managers. They are in a bind because Williams is no longer a staff employee but an independent contractor. As a contract news analyst, NPR doesn't exercise control over what Williams says outside of NPR.
"Juan Williams is a contributor to NPR programs as a news analyst," said Ron Elving, NPR's Washington editor. "What he says on NPR is the product of a journalistic process that includes editors. What he says when he is not on our air is not within our control. But we recognize that what he says elsewhere reflects on NPR, and we have discussed that fact with him specifically in regard to his remarks on Fox News regarding Michelle Obama."
Williams told Shepherd he was referring to articles in The Politico and The Atlantic Monthly. But he certainly could have cited Michelle Obama’s Princeton research paper, which discussed Stokely Carmichael’s "Black Power" book and theories of separationism and how they "guided" her in designing her thesis, asking Princeton alumni whether they were more in line with a "separationist and/or pluralist" viewpoint or an "integrationist and/or assimilationist" ideology. She was disappointed to find more "integrationists."
Her thesis began with the notion that she would always be disdained by whites at Princeton: "Regardless of the circumstances underwhich I interact with whites at Princeton, to them, I will always be a black first and a student second."
—Tim Graham is Director of Media Analysis at the Media Research Center.




















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Why should Williams be
February 12, 2009 - 13:16 ET by P. AaronWhy should Williams be required to conform to PBS? Why not remove PBS from the public dole and see who supports it?
If comunism is such a great idea, why didn't they put up a picture window instead of an Iron Curtain?
Although he drops an occasional bomb...
February 12, 2009 - 13:18 ET by Prester John....Juan Williams is rapidly turning into one of my favorite commentators, simply for the fact he is showing more and more often that he can weigh two sides of an issue and make up his own mind rather than spouting the usual party line.
It seems that the grayer he is getting the more rational he becomes.
He still has anger control
February 12, 2009 - 13:20 ET by Chris NormanHe still has anger control issues. I can't wait to see his reaction to this. :)
The "Mainstream" Media: By liberals. For liberals.
→ Right Prester
February 12, 2009 - 13:21 ET by Cool ArrowWilliams doesn't feel the need to defend the indefensible.
He's got his liberal bent, but he recognizes the downside to the Nanny State.
Some of his discussions with Brit Hume were truly entertaining.
Cool Arrow
February 13, 2009 - 15:26 ET by NorthCoasterJuan Williams is my favorite Liberal commentator. If Sean Hannitty ever decides to partner again with a Liberal, Juan would be my choice for the partner. Juan's opinions are obviously his own well constructed arguments and as such, the Left has little or no use for him because they can't control him and cause him to spout the part line.
Juan Williams gets another
February 12, 2009 - 13:19 ET by Chris NormanJuan Williams gets another lesson in how tolerant and open to other views his liberal bretheren really are. Congratulations, Mr. Williams, you are on your way to being a conservative...
The "Mainstream" Media: By liberals. For liberals.
and...
February 12, 2009 - 13:20 ET by mizflame98...we'll be more than happy to welcome you with open arms.
"Not to be a republican at twenty is proof of want of heart; to be one at thirty is proof of want of head." - Francois Guisot
We're at the end of the
February 12, 2009 - 13:32 ET by Chris NormanWe're at the end of the path that Bernie Goldberg previously took. :) He was still describing himself as a liberal up to a couple of years ago. I think the viciousness in the reactions of the left to his book forced him into taking a long hard look at where he had been and he quickly finished the journey...
The "Mainstream" Media: By liberals. For liberals.
Goldberg
February 12, 2009 - 13:32 ET by iveseenitallSo right, Chris. Goldberg had an epiphany. Williams is next. This kind of treatment from the left will help him to see that you can...
NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"
Apparently NPR listeners are uncomfortable with ballance
February 12, 2009 - 13:23 ET by c5thenNPR listeners are so biased and uncomfortable with hearing other viewpoints that they would prefer correspondents be fired for appearing on other networks than to have to live with the idea that their are different sides and different opinons. They should change their name to National Partisan Radio.
Hey, I got the wrong "CHANGE"!
Alan Keyes / Sarah Palin - 2012
Alan Keyes? Pullleeeeeze
February 12, 2009 - 13:31 ET by theduck6why is it liberals can only survive when they are subsidized?
I thnk they are so dismal in the talk radio format because you have to occasionally debate with callers on the radio and can't just puke the pablum like they do on TV and NPR.
I think the EIB network
February 12, 2009 - 13:42 ET by kgI think the EIB network should receive tax dollars just as NPR does.
"Forget change, I want improvement!"
If they ever try to bring back the 'fairness doctrine'
February 13, 2009 - 20:33 ET by Cape Conservativewe should all focus on bringing attention to the fact that our TAXES are paying for more one-sided broadcasting than any commercial station!
It is no dishonor to be in a minority in the cause of liberty and virtue. ~ Sam Adams
Will they also share with us
February 12, 2009 - 13:26 ET by JTPhow many letters they get critical of their own content?
"I need more cowbell!" SNL
Juan could move to Fox full
February 12, 2009 - 13:26 ET by danboJuan could move to Fox full time. Juan would get a lot more listeners than Alan Colmes. I hope he has the will to tell NPR where to go.
Limited Disclosure: I used to belong to the Sierra Club untill they went crazier. Worse of all, I was bribed by Exxon with free New Orleans Saints glasses with fill ups in the 70's.
Will the "Fairness
February 12, 2009 - 13:28 ET by DingbatWill the "Fairness Doctrine" apply to NPR? Just wondering
It would, in theory
February 12, 2009 - 13:34 ET by Tim GrahamTheir affiliated stations are broadcast stations. But liberals should be forced to accept real fairness and balance on NPR and PBS before they try to foist it anywhere else.
But - but - Tim, Haven't
February 12, 2009 - 13:38 ET by Chris NormanBut - but - Tim, Haven't the liberals already pre-approved the broadcast networks as being the standard for "fairness" and "neutrality" - so no balance there is needed?
The "Mainstream" Media: By liberals. For liberals.
Fairness Doctrine
February 12, 2009 - 14:58 ET by patriotmomI have been questioning this myself alot recently. Who decides what is fair and balanced after the Fairness Doctrine is in place. The MSM feel that they are non-biased (even though we all know differently). Does anyone know who will monitor and enforce the Doctrine if it comes to fruition? I know that whoever it is - they will be all over Rush - but what about NPR? I am pretty ignorant about all this (except for knowing in my heart that it is a bad thing) - can someone enlighten me?
Rope-a-dope
February 12, 2009 - 15:06 ET by Chris NormanI think the FCC. Which, I'm sure, will be packed with Obama suppoting appointees. The commission deciding these things is supposed to be "balanced" too, but we know from our experience with the news networks, an all-liberal panel is considered "balanced".
The "Mainstream" Media: By liberals. For liberals.
Thanks - Chris
February 12, 2009 - 15:24 ET by patriotmomThanks - I thought it would probably be the FCC but just cannot imagine the subjective reasoning that would go into actually charging someone with violating such a doctrine. The managment of it alone would seem to be a nightmare....I need to study up on it.
Well known fact about NPR
February 12, 2009 - 13:29 ET by Kirk HallAnyone who listens to it is a douchebag. It is just that simple.
Well. That was succinct.
February 12, 2009 - 13:35 ET by Chris NormanWell. That was succinct. :)
The "Mainstream" Media: By liberals. For liberals.
What about "Car Talk" on
February 12, 2009 - 16:24 ET by De_Oppresso_LiberWhat about "Car Talk" on NPR? Now that's some fun & useful radio
I'm not
February 13, 2009 - 11:40 ET by dkazI listen to NPR sometimes and I am not a 'douchebag'. Its good to listen to what the other side is saying sometimes and get different opinions. I think Juan Williams is a very good example of what a good journalist can be in the otherwise dismal offerings nowdays, and I enjoy listening to him on NPR and Fox.
Juan is Alan Combs with
February 12, 2009 - 13:46 ET by ApacheJuan is Alan Combs with brain cells. Let NPR listen to their few but loud and obnoxious fans and let Fox have Juan.
The left doesn't like anyone
February 12, 2009 - 13:52 ET by QueenMumThe left doesn't like anyone affiliated with Fox News. They don't understand the concept of real fairness. If you're not a flaming liberal and card-carrying Kool-Aid drinker, then you're not taken seriously by the far left. I'd posit that if Nancy Pelousey had a place on Fox News, they'd throw her under the bus.
Is There a Pill That Cures Bassackwards Thinking? NPR Needs It
February 12, 2009 - 14:35 ET by L.N. SmitheeNPR (Never-ending Pi[ck]ing on Republicans) ombudsmanperson Alicia Shepard:
Oh, to be a fly on the wall when that conversation occurred. "It makes us look bad when you say something that isn't worshipful of Michelle! It doesn't matter if your skin's black, Juan -- you're not really black unless you sound black!" (I have personal experience with that point-of-view). I gotta wonder what that contract says that even gives them the right to discuss what he says on other media outlets since they admit they can't control his statements outside their studios!
More evidence the synapses of liberal journalists are twisted like rotini: If they were normal, logical people, the NPR people would take the opportunity of Juan Williams' high-profile centrism to blunt the image of the net as a bastion of effete government-funded Eurocentric anti-corporate Birkenstock-wearing left-wingers who play acoustic music where commercials should be. Instead, they embrace that image in suggesting Williams -- an independent contractor -- should be chastened for associating himself with NPR while on FNC air because of the content of his commentary when he isn't working there.
But the Nippers can't even admit the truth about its bias! "Some [NPR listeners] think Fox uses him as a liberal voice because, whether true or not, a perception exists that NPR is liberal." "Whether true or not"? Oh, OK then, let's review: "NPR has more than 400 reporters, editors, producers and analysts on its news team, and none is more of a lightning rod than Juan Williams ... there were [also] a healthy number of emails attacking political correspondent Mara Liasson for her regular appearances on Fox News." If NPR isn't liberal, why do the ones that on occasion stray from the leftist playground get pilloried? If the NPR crowd weren't such ideologues, they would not be complaining that Williams and Liasson lent balance to the network's liberal "perception." Instead, the VP of News wants to, somehow, protect NPR by asking Williams to disassociate himself from it!
Is there a pill that cures bassackwards thinking? NPR needs it!
"Well, I've got nothing against the press...they wouldn't print it if it wasn't true..." -- Joe Jackson, "Sunday Papers"
L.N.Smithee
February 13, 2009 - 15:42 ET by NorthCoasterYears ago I listened to NPR almost exclusively for news. My favorite journalists/commentators have been Mara Liasson, Nina Tottenberg and Juan Williams. My favorite segments have been "By The Numbers", a daily recap of business data and information and "Car Talk" with Click and Clack, The Tappett Brothers. I no longer listen to NPR regularly because I couldn't get past the bias presented over the past few years. Occasionally I tune in and catch one of my favorites and It's like going home. Now days mt favorite channels are the Fox Stationjs for various reasons. Looking at the latest cable viewership numbers, it appears that most of the country with cable tunes in to Fox for News and Commentary. This last fact is why the Left is intent on silencing news and commentary through the "Fairness Doctrine".
All Things Considered...
February 12, 2009 - 15:40 ET by CapeCodScottJuan Should wear it as a badge of Honor...The Intolerance of the supposed tolerant libs... Ouch, was that the hypocrisy bug biting them in the bottom!
www.ScottOnCapeCod.com
"Most men lead lives of quiet desperation"... until they get fed-up enough to finally say something about it!
Diversity? We don't need no diversity.
February 12, 2009 - 16:35 ET by pbthinkerLiberals really need to learn what tolerance means. They know how to say the word, they just don't have a clue what it means.
Election 2008-God's way of showing us that elections count.
You have to be a real nutcase...
February 12, 2009 - 17:03 ET by OxyCon...to have a problem with Juan Williams, who I think is one of the most decent, wise and down to Earth pundits in America.
Since the Democrats are now out of control, trying to bring back the "Fairness Doctrine", then I say now is the time for the Repubs to stand up and demand that the left wing, partisan NPR and PBS propaganda outlets lose all of their taxpayer dollars. American taxpayers should not be forced to pay for far left propaganda.
Dems want this war, it's time to take it to them. As soon as one of those loons bring up the "Fairness Doctrine" on the House floor, then the Repubs must try to attach amendments to every single bill which would strip taxpayer funding for left wing propaganda. It's time to start itemizing every instance of left wing propaganda broadcast on NPR and PBS.
I agree with your
February 12, 2009 - 17:08 ET by bigtimerI agree with your sentiments here, but trying to attach an amendment by the repubs is just about an impossibility the way things are now.
IMHO.
Could part of that be. That
February 12, 2009 - 19:50 ET by danboCould part of that be. That too many republicans are spineless. Either too worried about what the press will call them. Or interested in the crumbs the democRATS toss them.
Limited Disclosure: I used to belong to the Sierra Club untill they went crazier. Worse of all, I was bribed by Exxon with free New Orleans Saints glasses with fill ups in the 70's.
Sometimes I agree with Mr.
February 12, 2009 - 17:15 ET by RR GOPSometimes I agree with Mr. Williams, sometimes I don't. That's how I can tell that, though he definitely leans to the left, he's not a biased person.
One of the 24% who thinks George W. Bush was a great President. One of the 89% who wants to bring back the stock and pillory.
Smithee, you are right on!
February 12, 2009 - 17:38 ET by wyogatorYou are right on target! They obviously have no interest in even promoting the perception that NPR isn't monolithic in it's partisanship.
"The only viewpoint that can't be tolerated is the viewpoint that everything shouldn't be tolerated!" ---me
Learn about my daughter's Ugandan home for orphans with AIDS at
www.africaourownhome.org
Who cares what the people at National Proletariat Radio think?
February 12, 2009 - 18:00 ET by R D HelmThe only reason those NPR and PBS partisan hacks even draw a paycheck is because the federal government takes money that I earned away from me by force, at the point of a gun, and gives it to them.
FNC has never taken a dime from me, other than through my Comcast subscription, which I gladly pay voluntarily. Should I fail to pay them, they just cut me off. Should I fail to pay the IRS, they will send people with guns to my home. If those people with guns decide I am resisting unduly, they will shoot me DRT.
I hope Juan Williams, who I am beginning to build some respect for, tells them all to go pound sand.
-Dave
Our clueless political leaders are about to drive us all over a cliff. The time to HITM is now-before we go over.
Juan Williams is alright
February 12, 2009 - 18:22 ET by GalvanicI may disagree with Juan Williams on some policy issues, but at least I can respect him for his decency and integrity. When things are wrong, he'll call them wrong.
Williams is now getting from NPR a dose of what former Maryland LtGov Michael Steele got in his Senate campaign. For the Left, any black American who doesn't talk the liberal talk, or questions the behavior or motives of Leftists, gets labeled as an Uncle Tom, or in the case of Steele, gets the Oreo-treatment.
To the Left, skin pigmentation determines what you can say and not say. Period.
what a crack up
February 12, 2009 - 19:31 ET by baseballmavenBaseballmaven
So Alison Fowler says that to disagree with the Obamas makes her "concerned about the objectivity Juan Williams brings to his news
analysis." Let me get this straight--if you don't agree with the leftists, then you cannot possibly be an "impartial news anayst." Hahaha--so impartial = left. What a crack up.
He's 'Juan' cool dood!
February 12, 2009 - 19:38 ET by AmericanEnergistI like Juan Williams. He may lean left, but he does not abdicate common sense on issues. I feel the same way about Camille Paglia. I do not agree with all their positions but they present their side without hate and arrogance.
www.ArmchairEnergist...
Model talking head.
February 12, 2009 - 20:43 ET by brerolDon't care much for the brand of politics Williams expouses. But Williams does have a good handle on the issues of the day. And when he presents his point of view it comes across to me as a thoughtful one. And I don't recall Williams ever expressing a low cheap shot at someone who he disagrees with. A feisty but civil discussion is the order of the day for Williams. Why then would NPR want to distant themselves from Williams. If you have a guy like Williams on your team then take advantage of the positive pr that comes with it.
Absent again...
February 13, 2009 - 09:42 ET by Sergeant ROCK"A liberal is a man too broad-minded to take his own side in a quarrel."
- Robert Frost
"I ask, Sir, what is the militia? It is the whole people. To disarm the people is the best and most effectual way to enslave them."
George Mason
Bolton/KEYES 2012
Really?
February 13, 2009 - 10:00 ET by general companyLast year, 378 listeners emailed me complaints and frustrations about things Williams said on Fox.
All this to satisfy 378 listeners? What about the million that didn't complain, apparently they dont count? Quit using my hard earned money to fund this nonsense!!
"Television is a freak show" Bernie Goldberg
378? That's nothing
February 13, 2009 - 10:06 ET by Sergeant ROCKI remember years ago, that we had less than a dozen militant homosexuals show up at a local TV station to protest Jerry Falwell's Sunday Morning program. That's all it took to get it yanked off the air. The TV station said that it was just too much pressure.
"I ask, Sir, what is the militia? It is the whole people. To disarm the people is the best and most effectual way to enslave them."
George Mason
Bolton/KEYES 2012
fair and balanced
February 13, 2009 - 10:38 ET by anormThe attacks from NPR listeners are typical of my friends who are liberal. They simply cannot listen to anything that doesn't line up just right with their thinking. I don't always agree with Juan Williams but I appreciate hearing his point of view and I actually consider what he is saying. NPR is a Saturday Night Live skit to me, generally.
FCC and Fairness doctrine
February 13, 2009 - 12:47 ET by bbeemanBut dealing with the FCC is a bureaucratic nightmare. I was in broadcast management during the previous iteration of the "Fairness Doctrine."
Any opinion had to be balanced by the same number of seconds of opinion from the "other" side, and the liberals were constantly filing complaints alleging that the response time was not really equivalent on some pretext or other. The costs of defending against the constant allegations was immense.
It was so bad that the effect was simply to remove any shred of non-liberal content from the air. The small broadcaster simply lacks the resources to engage in a years long proceeding before FCC bureaucrats to defend their license.
To stay in business essentially all overt opinion was removed from the air...which is what the liberals want, since they control PBS and NPR and dominate almost all newsrooms.
NPR needs to come off public dole
February 13, 2009 - 13:14 ET by kevinm13NPR should be defunded from public money. They are way too far left in their so-called "news" reporting. Juan Williams is more left in his opinions than just about anybody on Fox News Channel (now that Alan Colmes is gone), yet the loons who pay attention to NPR want him to be in full socialits left-wing lunacy to comport with the rest of the full socialist left-wing lunatics on NPR. Get a life folks.
NPR is a joke
February 14, 2009 - 12:32 ET by Sergeant ROCKThe government shouldn't be involved in anything as subjective as this and art.
"I ask, Sir, what is the militia? It is the whole people. To disarm the people is the best and most effectual way to enslave them."
George Mason
Bolton/KEYES 2012