N.Y. Times Styles Michelle Obama As 'U.S. Fashion's One-Woman Bailout'

Photo of Tim Graham.
  • Bookmark and Share

The pre-inaugural glee is showing. The "Thursday Styles" section of The New York Times splayed Michelle Obama pictures all over the top half of their front page this week, with the headline "U.S. Fashion’s One-Woman Bailout? In Michelle’s approach to dressing, a faltering industry sees hope." The Times sought out designers who connected Mrs. Obama to Jacqueline Kennedy in the historical halls of stylishness.

A caption describing six color pictures of Michelle’s wardrobe reads "SUITING HERSELF: On the campaign trail Michelle Obama signaled an interest in both looking stylish and advancing the cause of American fashion by mixing off-the-rack items from stories like J. Crew with high-end pieces from designers like Thakoon Panichgul."

There is no mention of the ka-ching prices of her "high-end pieces" even as Republican readers might recall the "high-end" hazing of Sarah Palin. Fashion writer Guy Trebay makes no mention of Palin. He quickly dismissed Cindy McCain’s campaign fashions as mildly improved, that she softened it to "seem more populist and less like a member of the rules committee of an exclusive country club." Trebay told the reader the story’s subject may seem trivial, but a whole industry is on the line:

Insignificant as this may seem in the larger scheme of things, it is less so when one considers the distressing state in which American fashion has found itself lately, with both chain and department stores shutting their doors, consumers confidence at its lowest level in decades and manufacturers struggling to remain afloat in what, as May Chen, the international vice president of the union group Unite Here, explained, "has always been a very credit-sensitive industry."

Hamish Bowles, the Vogue editor who was curator of "Jacqueline Kennedy: The White House Years," a 2001 show of Kennedy’s style at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, said of Mrs. Obama, "My perception is that she’s already had an extremely potent effect" on the business.

"Just looking at the designers she’s been drawn to, you can see she’s shown astute sartorial judgment," Mr. Bowles said. What she has also made clear in her choices, he added, is "that thoughtful and intelligent American designers are perfectly capable of creating clothes that have an impact on the world stage."

The key word in that statement is "American," a fact not lost on the retailers burdened in recent years by the weakened purchasing power of the dollar in Europe, where most designer fashion originates, and by the decision American consumers seem to have made to shop in their closets as they wait out the recession.

"There is something timely about celebrating American fashion and American designers," said Stephanie Solomon, the fashion director of Bloomingdale’s, although that "something" may be largely a function of the $5,000 price tag on a typical imported dress from Lanvin.

"Mrs. Obama is, first of all, very elegant and has wonderful taste," Ms. Solomon said. "But she also recognizes the value of beautiful dresses and not big prices. She dresses like taste doesn’t necessarily have to do with brand or status, but with what looks well on your body and makes you look glamorous, bottom line." And that, she added, is "very refreshing and appropriate for this period."

Readers are told all about how Mrs. Obama set off a fashion frenzy by wearing a $148 dress on ABC’s "The View." Then comes the second reference to Jackie Kennedy, more explicit than the first:

"She could potentially do what Jackie Kennedy did, bring about a new awareness and a fresh outlook, just by not being so intentionally ‘first lady,’ by mixing designer things with off the rack," Ms. [Anna] Sui said. "She can give a big boost to the American fashion industry — and we need all the help we can get."

If one thinks about it, said Thakoon Panichgul, a gifted industry favorite whose name entered the mainstream after Mrs. Obama wore one of his short-sleeved print dresses on the final night of the Democratic Convention, Mrs. Obama does not "dress so young, exactly, and yet it’s young because it feels fresh."

He continued: "She’ll wear a sheath with flats and not pumps. That’s not, quote unquote, appropriate, and people perceive that first ladies should be appropriate. She has the chutzpah to put it out there regardless of what anybody says."

If in Mr. Panichgul’s view it is Mrs. Obama’s casual yet savvy approach to fashion that makes her compelling to watch, for other observers there is something deeper in play.

A reader might suspect an actual critic of Michelle Obama might emerge, but there was only another encomium to unload:

"Actually, her taste is very conservative, kind of jock-preppy, a version of a safe American WASP way of dressing," said Andrew Bolton, curator of the Costume Institute at the Metropolitan Museum of Art. "But what is truly compelling about her is her body. She has this athletic, commanding and confident presence that is very American." She may look great in a shift dress, he said, "but her body is so strong that I end up forgetting what she’s wearing much of the time."

The potential effect Mrs. Obama’s physical and intellectual confidence can have on fashion, the designer Diane Von Furstenberg, president of the council of fashion designers, said in an e-mail message from London, is to promote "individuality" at a time when fashion is casting about for ways to replace the designer cultism it so recently enshrined. It does not seem insignificant, either, that Mrs. Obama expresses her pleasure in following fashion without worrying that to do so automatically compromises her seriousness.

But the Times ends by trying to make sure their spin is exactly right: she may be the black Jackie Kennedy, and she may thrill fashion designers, but that doesn’t mean she’s an elitist out of step with the average American female:

"The way Michelle Obama dresses is not her stimulus package to the fashion industry," said Mr. Kolb of the designers’ council. "It’s how she is. I think about my sister who lives in New Jersey and is a teacher, and about the women she works with, and how they can look at Michelle Obama and not have to pretend to be that woman, that working mother with kids who knows the big designer names but also shops at J. Crew and the Gap. She’s who they are."

People who just skimmed the piece for the picture still found the budget-fashionista spin, if they saw the text box highlighting the fashion director from Bloomingdale’s insisting "She dresses like taste doesn’t necessarily have to do with brand or status." All this story was missing was hand-drawn hearts and flowers.

—Tim Graham is Director of Media Analysis at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Looks like

If that is fashion, she should definitely stick with shyster payoff appointments to hospital board seats. Fugly fits.

Lipstick on a Pig

Now I know what Barack was referring to when he mentioned  putting lipstick on a pig.

Yuck, Oh Please

Oh, come one.  Remember those pictures of Michelle meeting Hillary?  She was wearing a big dirndl skirt and a cardigan sweater and flats.  All in a beigy-color.  It made her look as big as a house and as frumpy as a hausfrau. 

The fashion industry requires its models to weigh about 100 lbs., but they have no problem with Michelle's enormous behind. 

This, and the orgasmic writing about Obama's physique, are nothing more than wishful-writing. 

The black widdow dress didn't do much either.

"Forget change, I want improvement!"

Okay, I'm not very smart

Okay, I'm not very smart but what the hell does "you can see she’s shown astute sartorial judgment" mean?

I know Michelle's wardrobe is important to point out to the yahoos who voted for her, I mean him, but I believe there are more pressing matters at hand. And who would want to buy anything that woman has worn anyway? Anything she's worn, I'll make sure not to wear.

LOL...here goes. Astute

LOL...here goes. Astute means shrewd and sartorial is tailoring. So it means "Shrewd styling judgment".

 

"Forget change, I want improvement!"

What Mr. Bowles is really

What Mr. Bowles is really saying to us fashion numbskulls in the hinterland is something like this (took awhile to decode it)

" I'm a pasty faced metrosexual who has been fascinated with women's clothes since I was a child. I used to play with dolls until daddy stopped that. Now I fantasize how I would look in one of those expensive gowns. In fact I own quite a few. So there. I know more about womens' clothes than they do. And I look better than they do in them."

 

For liberal Democrats and the MSM, everything is crisis, chaos, calamity and catastrophe. And only the government has the solution.

Celator

 "until Daddy stopped that?" ROTFLMA That was great. I have to say though, I'll bet he secretely thinks MO's butt is huge, and that his would look way better in her clothes, but he knows better than to say that here. The other translation is, MO knows her butt is huge, that she is a big-boned woman, so she picks clothes that hide those things.Newsflash, stupid, most women already do this.

 

Bringing the government in to run Wall Street is like saying, "Dad burned the dinner, let's get the dog to cook." PJ O'Rourke

If that hideous thing she

If that hideous thing she wore on election night is any indication of her fashion sense then she is in trouble.  She looked like a black widow spider.

I just watched MST3K the

I just watched MST3K the other night, and Michelle's Election Night Outifit reminds me of the gown worn by the title villain in "Manos: The Hands of Fate".  Worst. Movie. Ever.

"Government's view of the economy could be summed up in a few short phrases: If it moves, tax it. If it keeps moving, regulate it. And if it stops moving, subsidize it." -Ronald Reagan

fitzfong.blogspot.com

I enjoy my Thakoon

I enjoy my Thakoon Panichgul with a bowl of Tom Yum Goong, don't you?

 

 

Can someone explain to me.......

Why Michelle Obama wearing $5,000 dresses is elegant but Sarah Palin's clothing budget provided her by the RNC is a scandal? 

Artillery lends dignity to what would otherwise be a vulgar brawl.

Vomit

Not only will we get more of this 'Michelle is Jackie' nonsense we will see the following (as News) sometime after the 20th:

Today, when people woke up, the air seemed a little fresher, hearts felt a little lighter, smiles looked a little brighter. Out of work? No matter. Can't pay the mortgage? Won't worry. Seriously ill? No problem. There's a new kid in town and his name is Obama. He's gonna fix it all. We know. After all, he said so. And we believe him.

And on and on ad nauseum.

D

Keep the ILLEGALS out, join NumbersUSA to send free faxes to your reps.

So the press is going to

So the press is going to use the fashion industry to makeover the image of one of Obama's greatest liabilities.  Brilliant.

They made fun of Laura Bush one year when two other women showed up to the White House Christmas Party wearing a similar gown to hers.  I can only imagine what the spin will be if others show up to future White House Christmas/Kwaanza/Festivus Parties wearing the same dress as Michelle...The First Lady has inspired women so much that some have taken to wearing the same outfit she's wearing as a mark of respect...for the first time in our lives, we can be proud of our First Lady (or some other nauseating non sequitur). 

"Government's view of the economy could be summed up in a few short phrases: If it moves, tax it. If it keeps moving, regulate it. And if it stops moving, subsidize it." -Ronald Reagan

fitzfong.blogspot.com

well obviously fitz

You're not a fashionista.

Here's the scoop (which I read somewhere, a while back, but my memory usually serves).

There is an official "gown registry" now for the innaugural balls....so that such an embarassing thing will never happen again.  Those Obamas think of everything.

Personally, I think Michelle O's astute sartorial preferences run more along Cruella DeVille lines....anyone who would willingly appear before a national audience dressed up for Halloween like a black widow spider has the fashion sense of a cartoon character.

 

→ Hot futures tip

I'm putting all my money in Burlap and Cotton sacks.

  • LYDSEXICS UNTIE!

Fine, I'll corner the

Fine, I'll corner the barrel and suspenders markets...apparently she's bringing "the bare arm" back into fashion.

"Government's view of the economy could be summed up in a few short phrases: If it moves, tax it. If it keeps moving, regulate it. And if it stops moving, subsidize it." -Ronald Reagan

fitzfong.blogspot.com

→ You beat me fitz

I was going after the Right to Bare Arms next.

  • LYDSEXICS UNTIE!

Funny CA

Do you remember our hater clone, burleysacknpumps?

LOL.

 

Just burley....  LOL

Just burley....  LOL

come on back lefties

To those who kept insisting yesterday that there is no double standard about women in America, please explain this.

Please explain how an humble woman with five children is out of touch and a Barbie doll when she wears designer clothes - and when a "community servant" who earns some 300 thousand salary wears designer clothes it's classy.

Please explain how Cindy McCain's diamonds were extravangant but Michelle's diamond ring was pretty.

Please explain why modern women are under intense pressure to have perfect skin and designer clothes, and then if their politics are wrong these things are used as a weapon to insult them.

Ah the enlightened liberal mind, judging a woman's appearance while claiming to be above superficial things.

 

I'm a typical white person.

Yeah, she's an up and

Yeah, she's an up and coming fashion icon...especially with that blood clot of a dress she wore the night her husband was elected. That looked like a used Maxi pad....but, it was a $3,000 Narcissco Rodriguez, so I guess, it was ok to the Liberals.  But, let Sarah Palin buy off the rack at Neiman's and all hell breaks loose.

What a bunch of mental cases...

Finally. A fashion critic I can understand.

Love your way with words, marpel.

Is this the dress you described so elequently?  :)

 

 

No representation, without taxation!

→ No Karma

It's this dress we're talking about.

  • LYDSEXICS UNTIE!

Photoshop, CA?

I like how you quickly altered the dress size to make it appear they are two different dresses. Have you no shame.

 

No representation, without taxation!

→ It's a test Karma

One is an original, and the other is a cheap knockoff.

  • LYDSEXICS UNTIE!

Cool Arrow, that's exactly

Cool Arrow, that's exactly what it looked like....I had one of these in my den the other night, and I said, "Michelle? Is that you??"  LOL

No, I think it's this

No, I think it's this dress.

"Government's view of the economy could be summed up in a few short phrases: If it moves, tax it. If it keeps moving, regulate it. And if it stops moving, subsidize it." -Ronald Reagan

fitzfong.blogspot.com

Funny

I think she is saving that dress for one of the balls she'll be attending on the day America dies.

I had actual hopes

on the morning after the election that the reports would be that Michelle consumed Barack after an especially satisfying post-election mating event.  Oh?  She only dresses like a black widow?  I don't think that's fair....

I am a great admirer of women,

I am a great admirer of women, but if you're all going to look like her I'm going to begin looking at men.

That's it.

I'm closing my blinds.

 

No representation, without taxation!

If you need any pointers on

If you need any pointers on that, just watch Harriet Smith, Matthews or Olberdouche.

THANK YOU! This whole

THANK YOU! This whole article just makes me sick. If that lady has fashion sense, then I don't ever want to be fashionable. Simply atrocious. There was maybe one outfit out of the 17 that was half decent. One in particular looked like a cakery blew up on her.

If these

people were dogs we would be smacking them on the nose with a rolled up newspaper (while they are still available) for what they are doing on the Obama's legs. The gushing and complete over the top insanity of the fawning crowds is embarrassing and nauseating at the same time. If she served up poop finger sandwiches they would swoon over it.

I always thought the

I always thought the election night dress was made that way so's all of us ignorant regular people wouldn't mistake her for a man. You know, the red was splattered over the boobs and uterus area, like shrieking, "I'm female, look, I have the parts to prove it!"

If this woman is the epitome of fashion I think I'll be content in my unfashionability.

 edit: I just looked at that slideshow. I can put up with her hideous taste in clothing as long as she never, EVER tries to do a close-lipped smile ever again. Every photo of her with a closemouth smile looks like she's struggling to cover up her huge horse teeth. She's much prettier just showing them off. Maybe she can stop tweezing her eyebrows into a perpetual frown too, now that her husband has actually gotten a job she can be proud of.

Her and Oprah have the exact

Her and Oprah have the exact same horrendous taste in clothes and the same big fat butts.  The clothes they choose sort of scream, "Look, I have a huge, fat butt!!"  I have never seen an outfit on Oprah that I thought was remotely attractive, and the same goes for Michelle.  Warning:  EYE ASSAULT!!!.

I can't really speak about

I can't really speak about Oprah, but you are right about Michelle.  Her clothes are not flattering.  I have no idea why these people think she is such a fashion icon.  I can not remember one thing that she has worn that is memorable (except for the hideous election night dress).  On the other hand, I distinctly remember the winter white outfit Laura Bush wore on (I think) Bush's 2nd inauguration day.  She looked stunning.

Seashell

I have no idea why these people think she is such a fashion icon.

they don't really, they are trying to manufacture a return to the Kennedy Camelot (which was fake the first time)

 

The way to stop discrimination on the basis of race is to stop discriminating on the basis of race.” -- Chief Justice John Roberts

Botg

Bingo!  That can be the only explanation.

Marpel

Could it be because Oprah's people have been dressing and making over Michelle for the last yr or so? Michelle said so in one of the chick magazines. That's why your astute eye picked up on that same dressing style. Are you sure you're not one of the those guys from Queer Eye??LOL

 

Bringing the government in to run Wall Street is like saying, "Dad burned the dinner, let's get the dog to cook." PJ O'Rourke

She may not do as bad

She may not do as bad as we think. All her fashion problems are behind her.

All her fashion problems

All her fashion problems are behind her.

Right, the fashion problems are at the bottom of her list.

stealing one from motherbelt

When she moves into the White House, I hope she doesn't forget to leave all the junk in the trunk.

 

Baby's got stink eye!!!!!

Isn't Michelle Obama swell.

Did anyone hear similar comments about Laura Bush, I don't recall? Is there a fund for Michelle's clothes habit that the MSM will even notice? Michelle sure is a certifiable "clothes horse". No, make that "clothes rhinoceros". She sure does have the approval of the election deciders, she sure is swell indeed.

I'm sure to bury my money in the back yard....