On Friday, The Hollywood Reporter published a talk it recently held with female TV news stars, and Fox News Channel’s Megyn Kelly and CNN’s Soledad O’Brien mixed it up over Sarah Palin.
Kelly argued that there was definitely a sexist media bias against Palin, especially the strange liberal argument that she couldn’t balance work and family life. Sticking up for the liberal media’s anti-Palin bias, O’Brien got personal with Kelly, asking her how many children she had. Kelly said none. O’Brien said she has four, so "I don’t dismiss it." I’d dare anyone to say on CNN that O’Brien shouldn’t be trying to do both. CNN, in fact, was the quickest to assume Palin could not do both. NBC’s Hoda Kotb got the discussion started:
HODA KOTB: I was talking to some people in the makeup room one day at work, and one person said, "Gosh, everyone's been so hard on Sarah Palin." And I said, "No one knows her. We don't know anything about her, so you have to start from the bottom up." Did you guys think it was sexist?
MEGYN KELLY: There was definite sexist coverage of Sarah Palin. In particular, the questions that were raised about how could she be both vice president and a mother. That was absolutely ridiculous. People saw this as an opportunity to rip on conservatives and the conservative movement, because this is red meat for people who don't like conservative women. The conservatives have, in the past, criticized some liberal women who wanted to both work and have children, so here's a conservative woman -- arguably far right -- who comes out and says she can do it all and she wants to do it all, and some of her detractors saw that as red meat and potential hypocrisy.
SOLEDAD O’BRIEN: How many kids do you have?
KELLY: I don't have any children.
O'BRIEN: OK, so I have four. It's really hard, and any mother would say it is really hard to do it all. So I think sometimes, don't dismiss it, because a lot of times the women who were raising that question were women with children who actually were on both sides of the political aisle.
This question came next:
HOLLYWOOD REPORTER: Do you think your subjects treat you differently when you cover them because of your gender?
O'BRIEN: Does being hit on count?
Is that a Bill Clinton question? Kelly said she drew a lot of hurtful negative e-mail when she began anchoring with Bill Hemmer on FNC about being blond, but then she talked about her "ninja" skills when guests underestimate her:
One of the greatest advantages you can have is somebody underestimating you. Having a guest come on, and they're looking for an argument and they want to make it contentious and they see my blonde hair, and they think (snorts in disdain). And then I bust out my ninja litigating skills.
The women also discussed whether there’s too much soft news and infotainment, and that spurred O’Brien to hammer critics of Katie Couric:
When Katie [Couric] went to [anchor the CBS Evening News], it was, "Well, she did the Peter Pan costume [on NBC's Today]." The woman had a reputation for grilling people that I think was unparalleled in morning television! And to have her career distilled down to a Peter Pan moment was not only unfair but absurd.
Where on Earth does O’Brien get the idea Couric was unparalleled as a tough interviewer? Did she ever watch Couric spoon-feed Hillary Clinton?
—Tim Graham is Director of Media Analysis at the Media Research Center.





















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
I love Megyn Kelly! She
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 16:10 ET by Gary P JacksonI love Megyn Kelly! She knows how to put people in their place!
www.teamsarah.org
Megyn ploitics?
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 20:38 ET by Wilbur747Any idea of her politics? Sometimes, just when I think I she's a conservative, she slips out with liberalism!
I think Ms Kelly is a
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 21:34 ET by Chris NormanI think Ms Kelly is a conservative but, first of all, she's an attorney who believes in the law and the constitution, even when it conflicts with things the conservatives would like to see happen - like having the noxious atheists in the Washington state capitol building thrown out.
I thought so too but...
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 21:41 ET by Wilbur747I also thought Kimberly Guilfoyle was conservative when I heard her speak but then again she was married to Gavin Newsome, the mayor of San Fran!
Megyn Kelly rocks. Dudes
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 16:21 ET by Mean Gene Dr. LoveMegyn Kelly rocks. Dudes dig chicks that have great skills. You know, like: cooking skills, computer hacking skills, ninja litiagating skills...
And if Ms. O'Brien believes that women may not be able to balance a career with children, then isn't it a little ridiculous for her to continue on with her career? Wouldn't that be a tad hypocritical?
The fact is that her argument seems to be based on the assumption that Palin singlehandedly does both. When we all know that is not true. Todd gives quite a bit of help as I'm sure that their teenage kids do too. Anything else is probably supplemented by hired help. So it really never was a question of Palin being able to balance family and career it was just hyperbolic bunk to convince the sheeple that she can't be a good leader.
"An armed society is a polite society. Manners are good when one may have to back up his acts with his life." --Robert A. Heinlein, "Beyond This Horizon", 1942
Soledad logic?
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 16:24 ET by Mica the MagnificentAccording to O'Brien, because she and other women had kids and decided to work, they have the right to question the judgement of Palin to have kids and work.
Ouch! Logic like that can rob brain cells from people in the next room.
OK, so I have four. It's
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 16:31 ET by fitzfongOK, so I have four. It's really hard, and any mother would say it is really hard to do it all.
Well, if it's so damn hard, why the hell is she still working at CNN? Isn't Soledad O'Brien being a little selfish? I thought "feminism" was about "having it all"...not having to make a choice between a family and a career. It's funny how a complete nonentity like Soledad O'Brien can enjoy the benefits of both (though God help us all if she's only as good a parent as she is a journalist) yet see no hypocrisy in denying another the same opportunity.
"Government's view of the economy could be summed up in a few short phrases: If it moves, tax it. If it keeps moving, regulate it. And if it stops moving, subsidize it." -Ronald Reagan
fitzfong.blogspot.com
first rule of economics
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 17:06 ET by katainkentthere is no free lunch. She can be a great mom or a great journalist but there aren't enough hours in the day to be both.
She must be one hell of a
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 17:48 ET by fitzfongShe must be one hell of a good mother, then. 'Cause she's a crappy journalist.
"Government's view of the economy could be summed up in a few short phrases: If it moves, tax it. If it keeps moving, regulate it. And if it stops moving, subsidize it." -Ronald Reagan
fitzfong.blogspot.com
Get real, Soledad
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 16:31 ET by nkviking75O'BRIEN: OK, so I have four [kids]. It's really hard, and any mother would say it is really hard to do it all. So I think sometimes, don't dismiss it, because a lot of times the women who were raising that question were women with children who actually were on both sides of the political aisle.
Get real, Soledad. Yes, it is a tough balancing act. But if Palin were a Democrat and Megyn and her female colleagues at Fox had raised these questions, you'd be ripping them into tiny little pieces.
Welcome to the era of unity, you racist!
U R
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 16:33 ET by Mica the Magnificentabsolutely effing correct, nk
Sarah Made it Look Easy
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 16:54 ET by allanfSarah made it all look easy. Here are these neurotic New York elitist women accesorized with their metrosexual husbands and nannified children and along comes Palin with a loving studly husband and family. Sarah did it all without being neurotic. It made these Barnard and Radcliffe gals crazier.
Know what, allanf?
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 23:16 ET by Scout FinchFor a guy, you sure do "get it". All these university-educated whiners are green-eyed jealous of Sarah and her handsome husband who's willing to share the load, and a large, close-knit family of children who are ready and willing to pitch in and help.
As a woman, I admire the heck out of Sarah. She can, and has, done it all. How snarky of Soledad to think that just because she thinks her life is difficult, Sarah couldn't do it any better. Sarah surpasses Soledad by a mile.
I wonder...
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 20:34 ET by Wilbur747how hard it is when you know she most likely has a live-in nanny to help with the kids, a housekeeper to handle the house and probably a sweet contract with day care in the studio just in case she has to work more than 4 hours!
Let's hope the O'Brien nanny/maid positions
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 21:23 ET by Cape Conservativeare not filled by illegals - have you checked out the HOMELAND SECURITY top exec in Boston who employed an illegal ?!? Paid cash for maid services and bragged about it to one of her employees...who blew the whistle on her!
A PROUD member of the Oogedy Boogedy branch of the GOP!
Didn't hear about that one!
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 21:38 ET by Wilbur747First thing...she should've shut up! That alone disqualifies her for the job! Give the job to the whistle blower!
I assume the exec was a Dem? If she is I'm sure it won't be posted all over the news like Linda Chavez's story.
BTW, I thought it's OK to hire them...at least Napoli-Reno seems to think so! Oh wait, only if your a lib!
believe it or not, the exec was a
Sun, 12/07/2008 - 22:11 ET by Cape ConservativeBush appointee! And she recommended her maid to one of her employees...cheap, cleans good etc ;-)
A PROUD member of the Oogedy Boogedy branch of the GOP!
Guys, gonna let you in on something
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 23:16 ET by BobAnthonyI work for an Au Pair agency in Stamford, CT. My job, scan things into the system, filing, mail sent out. Not my job in broadcasting, but well it helps financially.
Get ready for a shocker. Kiran Chetry, who used to work at FNC, now works for CNN, is one of our customers. Her husband by the way is Chris Knowles, a weekend weatherman at WPIX Channel 11 in NYC.
And also, Laura Ingraham is a client of ours to help with her adopted daughter.
If you want me to do some more namedropping, I'll do so.
For the record, I am NOT RECOGNIZING BARRACK HUSSEIN OBAMA ODINGA AS
PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES! I would like to become part of a
secession front!
Better be careful,,,
Sun, 12/07/2008 - 01:03 ET by Wilbur747This is how people get fired!
How many of these are au pairs are illegal aliens? If there are any, then your agency should be reported to INS and ICE.
Don't care about Chetry. She's an unabashed liberal and noting but fluff, and I don't believe Miss Laura would hire anyone who's an illegal given her convictions.
Soledad O'Brien makes much ado about how hard it is to raise 4 kids, when we all know in reality she has a nanny and a housekeeper to help raise the kids.
Heck, I would too if I had the $$.
Name-dropping
Mon, 12/08/2008 - 14:17 ET by HarmlessI wonder how your agency's clients would feel if they knew you were disclosing names and details about them on a blog. Not the classiest move you ever made, Bob, especially as it has nothing to do with the topic.
The Sarah Palin bashing
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 16:58 ET by Clear thinkerThe Sarah Palin bashing seems to know no bounds. Yesterday I posted this link The Left Still Hating Gov. Sarah Palin which is a piece about a guy that posted an online petition to "Tell Sarah to shut up". Well I did some research on the guy that started it and it seems as if he is a minor D.C. Republican insider. Go back to the same link and check out the UPDATE.
Making Fun of AGW http://giovanniworld.wordpress.com/
Effectively, Gov. Palin and
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 17:24 ET by iiiireaderEffectively, Gov. Palin and her husband have three kids at home. The eldest son is an adult in the Army; the eldest daughter is a soon-to-be mom and an adult, too. That leaves a 16 year old daughter, a young daughter, and a baby boy. Asking if Gov. Palin can do her job and take care of two young children with the help of her husband and teenage daughter is ridiculous. I had three children under age five and no one asked me if I could hold down my high-pressure job and take care of the kids at the same time.) What was more - I was a single mom for a good portion of the time.
They were just trying to get the "moms" to question Ms. Palin's loyalties. It was an effective tactic - a lot of women who have high pressure jobs use the job as an excuse not to have children; a lot of women who have families use that as an excuse not to have a career. The truth is - they don't need excuses - they are allowed to chose which lifestyle they prefer. Palin became a bit of a flashpoint in this equation as she was doing both. It was easier to drag her down than to explain their own choices.
So - in four years - Gov. Palin will have two kids at home - what will be the battle cry of liberals at that point?
BTW, if not knowing someone means you can start at the bottom - what was the deal with Obama? No one knows much about him but MSM tells us he walks on water. Oh, wait, he's not a conservative woman, so the rules are different for him.
Great insight into the "mommy wars" issue, iiiii's
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 23:25 ET by Scout Finch"Women's Lib" was supposed to be all about making our own choices. Make your choice, and live by it. Don't assume others have the same baggage as you. Someday you may want to run for President of the United States of America and you wouldn't want anyone to assume you couldn't handle the job if you could prove otherwise!
Tim.. and Couric spoon feeding Obama?
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 17:32 ET by Gary HallTim.. and Couric spoon feeding Obama? Remember this clip as posted by Mark Finkelstein on Nov, 3rd? Seemed pretty obvious to me that Couric had already cleared the question with Obama.
Couric has no follow up in this staged question to Obama
Note Couric's big ear to ear grin at the conclusion of his spin; no interest in grilling him, or in pushing for why he hadn't been able to find his aunt, on the government take, when the media could find her. In fact, she is so not wanting to see him challenged on the issue, that she almost seems impatient waiting for him to get done with his answer so that she can jump into her speciality - making the Republicans look negative. gary
Does anyone have the odds
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 21:20 ET by Cape Conservativeon whether 'auntie' will be sent home or not? Once again, proof that laws only apply to legal citizens, not illegals!
A PROUD member of the Oogedy Boogedy branch of the GOP!
Obrien: "....So I think
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 20:19 ET by winston smithObrien: "....So I think sometimes, don't dismiss it..."
I think I understand the Soledad logic --- Democrat women can have careers outside of marriage and family but Republican women are prohibitied. Very poor, juvenile attack on Palin. Soledad's failing miserably to mount a meagre defense of the legions of hypocrites in the news media who forever champion the cause of the working professional mom --- and then do a glaring, hypocritical about face when a Republican woman and mother succeeds beyond their wildest expectations. Soledad is the poster child for liberal media hypocrisy.
Just as in Congress, if a Democrat is
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 21:25 ET by Cape Conservativeat fault, you know $90k in the freezer, no problem...if a conservative is at fault - OFF WITH HIS/HER HEAD!
A PROUD member of the Oogedy Boogedy branch of the GOP!
And this is why we've come
Sun, 12/07/2008 - 00:43 ET by winston smithAnd this is why we've come to a very dangerous juncture in American culture. One party can say virtutally anything, no matter how flagrant no matter how inaccurate or dishonest and the media will go out of their way to agree with that party, protect that party or ax any story that could be detrimental to that party. Which means that members of that party now have carte blanche to lie to the electorate without recourse. That's why we have "man-made global warming", "47 million" without health insurance, the "homeless", the heterosexual AIDS "epidemic", Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac finances are just fine, a "quagmire" in Iraq, "torture" at Abu Ghriab and foreign terrorists being given their day in American courts. The media essentially prohibits and censors any criticisms or opposition to their favored politicians or chosen political beliefs. As long as our media continue to be Democrat partisans, that party can run wild with the Constitution, remove many of our cherished freedoms, and wage economic oppression on the middle classes.
I don't think the MSM was
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 21:46 ET by Chris NormanI don't think the MSM was being sexist against Gov. Palin as they were being blatantly politically biased against her and for Obama - even if it meant engaging in tactical unfair criticism to marginalize and minimize her - that was sexist in tone. With the MSM, all was fair in the battle to get Obama elected. Besides with them, it's okay to use sexist and even racist tactics against conservative women and minorities, because their conservatism nulls any right to politically correct passes.
Ms O'brien name?
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 23:00 ET by zachlindWhat kind of name is Soledad?
Just think...
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 23:03 ET by Wilbur747it could be worse. Her father could've been an electrician and named her Solenoid!
LOL
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 23:09 ET by zachlindLOL - I was serious :). I really wanted to know :).
Me too Z!
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 23:15 ET by Wilbur747I always wanted to know if her name is ethnic or one of those names people make up because they sound good.
I orginally thought she was of Indian (subcontinent) descent until she made a program about being black in America.
Maybe that has to do with her name. I'll grant you, it is an intriguing name.
I don't know what O'Brien's
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 23:36 ET by motherbeltI don't know what O'Brien's ethnicity is, but Soledad is a Spanish name. The word translates to "solitude" or "loneliness."
Another piece of information I don't know what to do with
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 23:34 ET by zachlindDidn’t occur to me to do some homework. According to Wikipedia one of the meanings for Soledad is solitude in Spanish. Her mother was Afro-Cuban and her father is Australian. At this time that’s probably more than any of us want to know.
Interesting...
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 23:51 ET by Wilbur747Now we know! Thanks MB and Z!
I do however find it interesting that she keeps talking about being black. Funny that those of mixed race descent will disregard every other part of their ethnicity and will always focus on being African-American.
An old co-worker of mine is about 25% A-American but he always checks the "A-American" box on any paperwork. Nevermind that he's 50% Apache!
Childish!
Mon, 12/08/2008 - 14:21 ET by HarmlessMaking fun of someone's name is a tactic of grade-school bullies, not mature adults. We need a lot more than childish behavior to move our agenda forward. Bullies just get a smack-down, which is what I suspect would happen if you ever entered a battle of wits with her.
Soledad is one of the
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 23:23 ET by bigtimerSoledad is one of the shallowest gals I have ever watched on the air since I saw her start on msnbc...
She was rude, crude, vicious and empty, doing here leftist work back then, just toned it down some now for CNN....
I could give a flying fig what she thinks about anything, anytime, anywhere.
"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh
We elected a president to
Sat, 12/06/2008 - 23:24 ET by SmartypantsWe elected a president to be that most people know little or nothing about, even his place of birth seems to be somewhat unclear. Yet, the media questioned little about him. And still, many of them with a straight face tell us that we didn't know anything about Sarah Palin, a sitting governor, and they act as if that disqualified her from being vice president.
Hi All!
Sun, 12/07/2008 - 00:46 ET by thebutlerdiditI am new here, have posted a few comments, anyway, be gentle!LOL. Just a few thoughts, I know how hard it is to work and raise kids, as a few people have stated. It does depend on how much help you have and how demanding the job. I had just gotten through w/ posting that my daughter got pregnant at 17. She did get married right away, but I don't understand why everyone keeps saying that Sarah needs to be home taking care of her pregnant teen daughter. I don't mean to say that she won't need some support, but, I'm sorry, if she is old enough to decide to have a baby at 17-18, she is old enough to take the responsibility to care for it herself. It hasn't been that long ago in time when girls married at 14, and some had 3 babies by 18. No one had their mommies raising their children, their mommies sometimes were still having them, also. I think it is ridiculous how people coddle their kids at this age. How do you expect them to parent, if they are treated like 10 yr. olds?
I was wondering if anyone had sent the petition to shut Sarah up to any of the radio guys? I am so slow as a poster, but if someone is industrious, I think they should send it to Rush, Sean, Mark, Laura, etc. with a short note explaining this guy is a Republican, that he worked for McCain, and make sure the surly comments are added. I think one of them might just read it on air, then it might get a lot of attention.What a sleezeball! I really believe there were lots of insiders who set out to damage Sarah, hard to believe the Republicans think they need any help, the Libs were working over time!
Howdy tbdi... I got here
Sun, 12/07/2008 - 01:06 ET by bigtimerHowdy tbdi...
I got here late tonight for me, leaving soon too, just wanted you to know I have read a couple of your posts already and enjoyed them immensely...glad you're here...looking forward to reading more.
Warning: As you may know...NBs can be an addiction!
"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh
Irrelevancies
Mon, 12/08/2008 - 14:39 ET by HarmlessI agree 100%. I wasn't one of those people saying that SP needed to stay home and take care of her kids--this is 2008 and that precedent was set hundreds of years ago. Those folks need to enter the modern age. It wasn't an issue with anyone but a few soreheads.
My issue with SP was/is her lack of experience on the national/world stage. No one cares that she ran for public office, and she isn't a single mother without resources in any event. But her lack of knowledge about what the real world outside AK is like had me worried sick. You can't live isloated and sheltered all her life, as she did, and then expect to be ready to be Leader of the Free World in a few months no matter how smart you are. If Mac had drafted Kay Bailey Hutchinson or Liz Dole or Olympia Snow, he probably would have won hands-down. At the very least, we wouldn't be having this conversation, and liberals would have had to dig a lot deeper to find liabilities.