NBC anchor Brian Williams appeared on the Tavis Smiley show on PBS on Monday night and trashed Joe the Plumber's anti-tax cause as a silly issue, not a serious question about the redistribution of wealth: "Look at how our attention was able to get pulled into pigs and lipstick and plumbers. We got a plumber who's the third member of the GOP ticket, in effect, and that's - it's all of our fault, yes, and there will be time to bloody our own backs with chains, but it's also the sorry state of our discourse as if, Tavis, we don't have enough serious issues to concentrate on." Williams added: "I think we may find out it was a movement year, we may find out we all had to step aside and just let it happen, and we may decide we went down too many rat holes of distractions on our way there."
Williams also complained once again about the delay in his Sarah Palin interview, given his network’s leading stature. "I went more than third -- I went fifth or sixth," even as he added: "I think she's a professional at her job, I try to be at mine, and we kind of quickly got over it." Sounds like he hasn’t.
The interview began with the plumber-bashing:
SMILEY: Has this campaign, honestly and frankly, gone on just too long?
WILLIAMS: Oh, yeah. I don't even have to be honest or frank about it. It's just flatly gone on too long, and what's sad about it is I remember saying, naively, innocently, "Well, at least we'll have a thorough and serious and sober airing of the issues."
And instead, look at what we did. Look at how our attention was able to get pulled into pigs and lipstick and plumbers. We got a plumber who's the third member of the GOP ticket, in effect, and that's -- it's all of our fault, yes, and there will be time to bloody our own backs with chains, but it's also the sorry state of our discourse as if, Tavis, we don't have enough serious issues to concentrate on.
He returned to the theme just a few sentences later when asked if the networks did too much horse-race coverage:
A funny thing happened on the way to the nomination for President Giuliani and President Hillary Clinton, and that is it appears that if these polls hold and we've got it at 51-43 as of tonight, and our pollsters are very good, it looks like everybody else in this race ran smack into an American history movement. Ran smack into a changing of those iconic symbols at the front of all the classrooms we grew up sitting in, all those oval pictures, depictions of our presidents. It's about to change, after 43 of them, if these polls hold, and people need to get out to vote.
The American voter has a funny way of deciding for themselves what happens in our elections. So I think we may find out it was a movement year, we may find out we all had to step aside and just let it happen, and we may decide we went down too many rat holes of distractions on our way there.
Then came the Palin exchange:
SMILEY: You mentioned one woman a moment ago, Brian, of course, Hillary Clinton. There's another woman in this race, still in it as of this moment, Sarah Palin. Let me just ask you in a very forthright way. When you're sitting for a conversation, as you did days ago, with one Sarah Palin, and your own network, in fact, "Saturday Night Live," has made such a wonderful run of jokes about Sarah Palin, and they're not the only ones. But clearly, she has been ridiculed -- my words, not yours here -- ridiculed for being, shall we say, an intellectual lightweight. When you're going into an interview and you know that that's the rub, that's what's out there, how do you prepare for that conversation so that you don't get chastised for being too soft or too hard?
WILLIAMS: Well, by then, remember the context, Tavis. By the time I got to sit down with Sarah Palin, I was (A) allowed eight minutes with her in private; (B) allowed an extended period of time only if the top of the ticket, John McCain, was sitting with her. I went more than third -- I went fifth or sixth, if you count some of the interviews she granted. Charlie went first, then Katie. Here we are, to be gross about it, we're the largest evening news audience, and it was clear -- I joked about it on David Letterman's show - we were paying for some of the perceived sins of our cable network, and these days, everyone knows that in prime time cable programming, there's attitude.
You know what you're getting. There's truth in labeling. Nobody's being fooled. So was there a little tension? Absolutely. Can I develop a relationship, one on one, with someone? John McCain I've known for a long time, but the governor was new to me. Absolutely. And you -- I think she's a professional at her job, I try to be at mine, and we kind of quickly got over it. But a lot of -- to be frank about it, a lot of the good questions had been taken, so I chose to go down different roads.
Finally, Williams rather ridiculously claimed that no one, absolutely no one would have any idea of which presidential candidate he favors. Does he think no one noticed the difference between the pounding he gave McCain and Palin and the repeated hand-holding in interviews with Obama? But he implausibly claimed that he was a hard-core political agnostic:
SMILEY: Let me shift gears dramatically here. Obama, as you certainly know and have covered on the "NBC Nightly News," for whatever reason or reasons, has generated a certain level of enthusiasm and energy in the younger generation. You have two kids - I think 17 and 20. If my research is as good as yours, I think my facts are right. Seventeen and 20; and so they're in that age group that Obama has played so well to. Without betraying the confidence of your children, are you one news anchor who's had your children in your ear when you're not on the anchor desk about this campaign?
WILLIAMS: Oh, you've just landed on the recurring theme in my house. My family knows that I am such a political agnostic, I've never told my wife of 22 years or either child who I voted for for president. I've only said publicly that I think my politics might surprise some folks, that I've voted for members of both parties for president. But it drives them crazy, and it's been driving me crazy that I have to put ear plugs and blinders on when I come in the house. I can't hear it. I can't hear it, I don't want to hear it, I don't have a dog in this. I go up to my easy chair on the second floor of the house. My dog comes with me. She sits with me and keeps me company. She has expressed no view in this election, and so far she's the only member of my household to express no view in this election.
—Tim Graham is Director of Media Analysis at the Media Research Center.





WILLIAMS: Well, by then, remember the context, Tavis. By the time I got to sit down with Sarah Palin, I was (A) allowed eight minutes with her in private; (B) allowed an extended period of time only if the top of the ticket, John McCain, was sitting with her. I went more than third -- I went fifth or sixth, if you count some of the interviews she granted. Charlie went first, then Katie. Here we are, to be gross about it, we're the largest evening news audience, and it was clear -- I joked about it on David Letterman's show - we were paying for some of the perceived sins of our cable network, and these days, everyone knows that in prime time cable programming, there's attitude.














Editor at Large
Comments Policy
what a cry baby
November 4, 2008 - 22:04 ET by Maytaghow do people like him keep their job Thank god for FOX
anyone else notice
November 5, 2008 - 05:53 ET by ferv888Was Williams pandering when he talked about the chains to bloody his back????Hmmm
Dad was right, "Only the super poor and the super rich can afford to be liberal." Williams proved the wisdom of a guy who said it back in the 60's, he is too rich to worry about a tax increase.
ferv888
THE HAIRCUT SPEAKS
November 5, 2008 - 06:23 ET by SgthulkaBrian Williams - A Ted Baxter for our generation.
This from the jerk who officially declared Iraq a "civil war"
November 4, 2008 - 22:11 ET by krendlerAnd then refuesed to even mention the war once it had been won.
So he's bitching about the "level of discourse"? Don't remember him complaining about the idiotic, shallow hope/change/blah/blah/blah "discourse" that the Obama camp has been engaged in for the last 10 months.
According Williams and other Obama surrogates in the media, anything said that isn't favorable towards The Almighty One is either petty, below the belt (mean-spirited), or racist. In their view, THERE SIMPLY IS NO legitimate criticism of Obama, whether it be his broken promise on campaign finance reform or getting it completely wrong on the surge (how many times over the past 10 months did Couric, Williams and co confront Obama about those two issues? Ever?)
Typical condescending
November 4, 2008 - 22:18 ET by mattmTypical condescending arrogance from the leftist media elite. This is how they win: they dismiss common sense arguments against the liberal agenda as "silly" or fanatical, and enough people buy into it to elect an unqualified leftist radical to the highest office in the land.
And when it all comes crumbling down around them, they'll blame Bush and all the "Joe the Plumbers" and NASCAR rednecks who refused to get on the bandwagon; and enough people will buy into it to re-elect the punk.
"For the 3rd or 4th time in my adult life, I'm ashamed of my country." - Publius
Sorry state of our discourse?
November 4, 2008 - 22:38 ET by JPR1Sorry state of our media Brian, when a major "journalist" such as yourself shows such a flagrant disregard for the opinion of an ordinary American like Joe.
You suck Brian. No other way to put it.
Williams would do well to stay off the NASCAR circut.
November 4, 2008 - 23:07 ET by CTBrian Williams seems intent on becoming the 'A'hole of distraction. What fine reporting and commentary, I'm sure his contract at NBC will be renewed.
What the HELL?
November 4, 2008 - 23:27 ET by TexndocSince when does a jerk who sits in front of a teleprompter and reads what someone else wrote an expert on politics or plumbers? I SO want someone to go into Williams' private past: medical records, tax records, etc etc and publicize it like they did to Joe. Have Katie Couric broadcast it. From what I've heard, if they publicized Shep Smith's private affairs ( and divorce records), it'd be quite an Oprah Show. Or should I say Ellen.
Williams is exactly right
November 4, 2008 - 23:45 ET by goldwaterfanJoe the "plumber" is not a real plumber. He's a liar and a fraud. I'm glad his 15 minutes are up. Hopefully, we'll never hear from him again.
He's not a licensed plumber
November 5, 2008 - 00:56 ET by winston smithHe's not a licensed plumber but he does plumbing for a living. Because he is not licensed, that doesn't make him a liar or a fraud. Now if you want to talk liar and fraud look at how Obama talks about helping poor Americans and turns his back on the impovershed members of his own family. Now THATS a liar, phony and a fraud. Joe the Plumber works for a living --- Obama voted present 150 times in the Senate and never held a real job. Nice try "goldwaterfan"! LOL!
95% or more of the
November 5, 2008 - 00:57 ET by NL20795% or more of the plumbing work done in this country is performed by journeyman plumbers under the supervision of a licensed master plumber. That supervision in general consists of no more than an inspection after the work is complete.
Now who is the liar? And are you a fool?
Not a real plumber
November 5, 2008 - 02:04 ET by ChattychitoSamuel doesn't need a license if he works for a plumbing company under the rules an regulations promoted by the United Plumbers Union in Ohio. When we call them to come to our house to fix the pipes, they are called plumbers. the kids yell, "dad the plumber is here". but he is just a laborer working for the company.
Just because the guy asked a hypothetical question. you all spit fire at him. I dreamed of buying a company and I know it would make more than $250K a year. Now I am afraid to even think of buying it. I found great potential in Veitnam for starting companies to supply Intl. buyers with products. Go Overseas guys American Economics is dead.
If Obama puts the Dem's full forced go green policies into effect. we wont have any jobs except cyber jobs left. all else will fall
Joe the plumber nor you will have a job either.
One of these days Williams'
November 5, 2008 - 01:33 ET by CoolShadesOne of these days Williams' house is going to spring a leak, and the Plumber will have the last laugh.
What a phony.
November 5, 2008 - 01:46 ET by Jack HermanMr. Williams is the intellectual lightweight if he can't see his own bias.
Once upon a dream
November 5, 2008 - 01:52 ET by ChattychitoHow much money does Brian Williams and the restof the Lib Pac Media Muffs make per year?
Well if it is over $250,000 (Oprah included) they will have to pay higher taxes so their anti-messiah can spread their wealth around so we can all have the same chance at success.
This wasn't a race of Hope or Change this was a race of race to get a black man in the Oval Office. Well they got their One for the record books.
Now will they be man enough to stop him from taking their money and giving it to some lazy butt with 8 children living in govt housing, receiving a govt check, who doesn't have a job, and who will now get some of Oprah and Brian's wealth so they can go get some more Jack and Crack, and have the freedom to say, "God d*** America for not giving them even more." becaue they are poor oppressed slaves to the American white man's system.
Brian and the rest better wake up a dream is a dream. But after waking reality sets in.
Williams the Objective
November 5, 2008 - 07:49 ET by easygoerNow we have to listen to this crap?
Williams and MSM silliness
November 5, 2008 - 09:12 ET by nkviking75"Look at how our attention was able to get pulled into pigs and lipstick and plumbers."
Hey Williams, a lot of the silliness in this campaign was drummed up by media types like you dwelling on pseudo-controversies on the Republican side and sweeping real concerns about Democrats under the rug.
I wish we could sue the MSM for malpractice. You bozos really failed the country by being so blatantly partisan.
When you put the clowns in charge, don't be surprised when a circus breaks out.