Obama vs. Father Coughlin, Joe McCarthy, and George Wallace?

Photo of Tim Graham.
By Tim Graham | May 1, 2008 - 09:19 ET

Newsweek’s May 5 cover story professes to address Barack Obama’s "Bubba Gap," the growing chasm between the would-be Democratic nominee and white "working class" voters. Evan Thomas, Holly Bailey, and Richard Wolffe don’t so much report on the gap as complain about hateful conservative rumor-mongering. The authors complain that Obama is not just running against Mrs. Clinton or Sen McCain, but against every historical hobgoblin who liberals can dig out of a musty closet. Obama's not only opposed by George W. Bush, who hates pointy-headed intellectuals, but in Newsweek's historical imagination by "demagogues like the anti-Semitic right-wing radio priest of the 1940s, Father Charles Coughlin; Red-baiter Sen. Joe McCarthy of Wisconsin, and race-baiter Gov. George Wallace of Alabama."

The Newsweek team explicitly tied these men to the people who posted damaging tidbits from Reverend Wright sermons on YouTube and the spreaders of Obama's leaked remarks on the Huffington Post about bitter people clinging to guns and religion. They began by lamenting the injustice that a black man, long so oppressed, could be accused of elitism:

What is just weird is this: how can it be that a black man running for president is accused of being too elitist? For the first century of the nation's existence, blacks were kept in chains. For the next century, they were sent to the back of the bus and kept away from whites-only lunch counters and restrooms throughout the South – much less allowed to join the white elite in their schools and clubs and prestigious institutions. Then, starting in the 1960s, American society began to make a concerted effort to open up those doors. Barack Obama is not so much the beneficiary of that effort as the proof that blacks can make it on their own, if given the chance. He was, despite a modest upbringing, elected editor of the Harvard Law Review, a position at the very tip of the meritocratic ziggurat.

Yet to pockets of America, he still seems to be the "other." He seems a little strange, exotic; those cracked e-mails whispering about his middle name (Hussein) and declaring, fictitiously, that he is a Muslim who insisted on being sworn into office on the Qur'an rather than the Bible, keep buzzing around the Internet. To some, his manner is haughty; he is a bit of an egghead, one of those pointy-headed intellectuals whom George W. Bush liked to ridicule as a Deke brother at Yale and even later as president of the United States (and, long before him, demagogues like the anti-Semitic right-wing radio priest of the 1940s, Father Charles Coughlin; Red-baiter Sen. Joe McCarthy of Wisconsin, and race-baiter Gov. George Wallace of Alabama).

It’s bad enough that liberal Newsweek reporters would peck at their keyboards filled with the arrogance that their politicians are the smartest ones, and that mocking them for "elitism" is the defense of dumber people who don’t like eggheads. But Obama’s opponents don’t just hate eggheads, but they seem to be comparable to people who hate Jews (Coughlin) hate blacks (Wallace), and hate commies (McCarthy). Conservatives would only accept hating the commies, as opposed to Newsweek. If if were up to them and their deep imbibing of detente, the Cold War would still be going, and they'd still be writing giddy tributes to Soviet dictators who secretly love jazz.

It’s also pathetic that Newsweek liberals would keep using the Internet as a boogeyman, as if the left doesn't have any McCain-smearing sites. The same narrative can be constructed for McCain, that it keeps "buzzing around the Internet" that he’s a "senile warmonger," a Muslim-hating racist, and his wife is "a thieving drug addict."

How can they profess loathing that Obama would be dragged down by "guilt by association" to Reverend Wright and then pull the same negative-ad gambit against conservatives in their "news" copy? Directly after the Coughlin-McCarthy-Wallace sentence came this passage:

Demagoguing, even in the subtle ways enabled by new media, can have an impact over time. In the NEWSWEEK Poll, 13 percent reported that Obama is Muslim. NEWSWEEK reporters on the campaign trail could hear the wariness, even fearfulness, of voters as they spoke about Obama. Secretly taped by a "citizen journalist," then reported online, Obama's remarks to San Francisco fund-raisers—that some voters in economically depressed towns "cling" to religion and guns out of "bitterness"—did not sit well, nor did the endlessly replayed YouTube videos of Obama's former pastor, the Rev. Jeremiah Wright Jr., ranting against America.

Note how they sneer at a "citizen journalist," as if real journalists don't expose Barack Obama's Harvard-snobbish moments. They sloppily mix Obama Internet whispers with things he actually said and ministers he actually lavished with donations. Then they lament how voters are growing wary of their hero:

Richard Vallejo, 65, of Bristol, Pa., a typical working-class town, has voted Democratic all his life. But of Obama, Vallejo says: "He's prejudiced against white people. I'm in a small town and if I own a gun, it's not because I'm bitter. It is because of the Second Amendment, the right to bear arms." In Indiana, the next stop on the primary trail on May 6, Brenda Spreitzer, 42, told a NEWSWEEK reporter at a Clinton rally: "I think Barack's viewpoints and his past is too flamboyant. It's more radical than I want to go … I'm just not comfortable," she said, adding that she is concerned about Obama's practice of generally not wearing an American flag pin. (None of the candidates wear flag pins.)

The whining reaches fever pitch as the Newsweek-lings imagine how Obama might be headed for the pantheon of Misunderstood Democratic Losers:

The Republican Party has had a field day over the past half-century making fun of Democrats who are "effete" -- first Adlai Stevenson, a cultivated brainiac who lost twice to Dwight Eisenhower in the 1950s; then Michael Dukakis, a former professor at Harvard's Kennedy School of Government who made the mistake of being ludicrously photographed in a tank helmet and allowed himself to be cornered as somehow soft on crime (read: black crime); then John Kerry, a Yale man who seemed to enjoy windsurfing in Nantucket a little too much (forget that he was decorated for valor in Vietnam). Now there is Obama, a man who seems to want to think before he speaks and lacks Hillary Clinton's enthusiasm for hoisting a beer glass or throwing back shots of Crown Royal Canadian whisky for the ever-present cameramen.

That last sentence really reveals their Obama-loving desperation. Their candidate is being punished because he "seems to want to think before he speaks." That's not only a desperate airball-shot against every Obama opponent from Limbaugh to McCain to Hillary. It's a funny line in the same article where it's lamented that some uncooperative so-called journalist exposed him for saying bitter people cling to guns and religion and immigrant-bashing.

—Tim Graham is Director of Media Analysis at the Media Research Center

Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

and that mocking them for

and that mocking them for "elitism" is the defense of dumber people who don’t like eggheads.

Very well put, Tim!

Isn't it amazing that, in order to say they're not "elitist" they belittle the little people who just don't "get it."

And the best part is, they don't even see the irony.

Were Father Coughlin and

Were Father Coughlin and George Wallace real conservatives anyway? Coughlin wasn't a fan of capitalism, while Wallace was a New Deal Democrat.

“There are no easy answers' but there are simple answers. We must have the courage to do what we know is morally right.” - Ronald Reagan (1964 Republican Convention)

Father Coughlin

Father Coughlin was a huge fan of FDR and FDR and his minions appreciated the work the good father did in convincing the country that the New Deal stuff was great. If you get a chance, read Jonah Goldberg's book 'Liberal Fascism' in which he discusses this in detail. And yes Wallace was a Democrat.

Thanks for supporting my

Thanks for supporting my post, sanegononlib.

As for McCarthy, despite his questionable methods and tactics, he was right about Communists in our government.

“There are no easy answers' but there are simple answers. We must have the courage to do what we know is morally right.” - Ronald Reagan (1964 Republican Convention)

Pre-Loss Complaining

They're already crying in their chablis, and they haven't even had the decency to lose yet.

It's another example of juvenile thinking -- i.e., that if someone disagrees with you, they must be insane, under some influence, or simply stupid. It's the ultimate ad hominem argument.

The deceit is especially clear when they use the ignorance of the 13% (who think Obama is muslim) to make broad insults against anyone who opposes Obama (at least 50%). That's why they point out that statistic. They're trying to say that the whole electorate is ignorant because they found a few people in the electorate who are ignorant. It's a clear logical fallacy to jump from the ignorance of a few to a broad conclusion about the whole. Of course, on reflection, their own wallowing in illogic proves their own ignorance.

I'm telling you -- buy stock in a chablis company. After November, sales will skyrocket.

Let's not forget Woodrow Wilson

Let's not forget President Woodrow Wilson who was an avowed segregationist.  Oh, wait, he was a progressive, pro-union, tax and spend Democrat, wasn't he?  In that case, never mind.

Talk about Racism!

"What is just weird is this: how can it be that a black man running for president is accused of being too elitist?"

Talk about racism! This man just said that a black man could not be rich, affluent, educated, and well connected with other, similar people in political and social power circles, which is the very definition of elitism! Dude, let the blacks off the plantation already, will ya?

Did anyone in Newsweek

Did anyone in Newsweek mention that George Wallace was a Democrat?

Vote 4 change. Vote 4 anything. See Jack & Mr Shy's first campaign ad for the ONLY viable 3rd party candidate.

Jack - They left out the Dem label with Cauglen also

Even after Caughlin eventually turned against Roosevelt's New Deal, he still remained vehemently anti-capitalist.

Yes, there are many ill-informed

people that the author seems to think exist only on the other side, the side that he looks down upon. If he quotes a percentage of respondants in a Newsweek poll (now THAT'S reliable) who believe Obama is a Mulsim, I'd like to see a poll of people of his political persuasion; liberal, who believe that Joseph McCarthy was THE demon on the Committee on UnAmerican Activities in the fifties.

That would be the "House Committee on UnAmerican Activities". As in the HOUSE of Representatives. McCarthy was a Senator and had nothing to do with that committee.

I'm amazed at the number of rabid anti-conservatives that I meet who don't know that. I love to bait them into a discussion on the matter and then hit them with it. They pause for a moment and then utter that wonderful phrase that always shuts a logical argument down; "Well...but still...!" As if that's a trump card.

Typical of Newsweek and

Typical of Newsweek and all their brethren...Obama is in trouble, his numbers aren't good, and it is all someone else's fault...not his own words and actions or his associates in the past he has had dealings with over years and years...why no...of course not, it is the big bad American peoples fault past and present, who just don't see things form their own elitist, glass house, rose colored glasses, leftist views....

Pathetic....just pathetic...they are really scratching here to save their messiah...personally I hope they keep scratching and a digging, the more they do, the deeper the dig... the further they sink.

Just my two cents. 

"Never murder your opponent when he is committing suicide." ~ W. Churchill

Intellectual?

I would like to point out how the MSM implies that Barry is a "pointy- headed intellectual". I've known many intellectuals and would never put him in that catagory. I don't find him to be at all an "intellectual". For example, he was asked the other day to quote his favorite verse from the Bible. He couldn't come up with one. Intellectuals have a "quote" for everything, whether they believe it or not. Barry is a modern "liberal"/socialist/communist--poorly educated with left-wing ideology, not an"intellectual". I'm sure he knows more about basketball than he does about philosopy, for example. He's a pseudo-intellectual, propped up as oh-so-smart by the ignoramuses in the media (as was Bill Clinton).

NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"

20 years of hearing Pastor

20 years of hearing Pastor Wright quote the Bible and the phrase he remembered for his book was Wright's own words!

interesting

It's been very interesting to watch the intellectual acrobatics around Mr. Wright this week.

When those first soundbites were released only weeks ago, libs all said he was taken out of context and didn't really mean that stuff - it was all a right wing conspiracy to make him look bad!

Then lo and behold, he gives a speech on live TV where he confirms himself to be exactly how he'd been portrayed. No misinterpretation, nothing taken out of context...those soundbites had truly been an accurate reflection of him.

Now libs are acting like those old soundbites don't exist and he just woke up last Friday and decided to be hateful.

So...he didn't mean it when he said it five years ago, but now when he says the exact same thing he does mean it?

As a card carrying member of the vast right wing conspiracy, I do believe we are owed an apology. We never twisted his words. 

I agree, candance, and

I agree, candance, and "taken out of context," my foot!

If they were, he's lucky; the context didn't mitigate it..it made it worse!

Candance

"A card carrying member of the vast right wing conspiracy". So am I. A charter member. I even have a mug from the group in my kitchen cabinet. (high five).

NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"

An Inconvenient Truth

"White Democrats who hold unfavorable views of Obama are much more
likely than those who have favorable opinions of him to express less
tolerant views on race. In addition, nearly a quarter of Democrats
(23%) who hold a negative view of Obama believe he is a Muslim.

-Politico
"

Link

I'm surprised that Newsweek left out this embarrassing little fact. Actually, I'm NOT surprised.

(on edit:)

Another interesting tidbit:

"Nearly a quarter of white Democrats with unfavorable views of Obama say he is Muslim though overall, blacks are about as likely as whites to hold the misconception."

Link

Only 1/4 of them? What

Only 23% of them? What about the other 77% of the Democrats who have a negative view of him; what's their reason?

And did the 23 % actually say they had a negative view because they think he is a Muslim? Or was that a side question?

I don’t know

I don’t know, I can't find an actual breakdown of the poll questions and the demographics of the responders (granted, I didn‘t look that hard). I think that Obama's religion was a side question and responders were not asked if that was a reason for their unfavorable rating.

It appears that the poll was taken late August, so I would bet that the infamous Mr. Wright cleared up the question of Obama’s religious affiliations in the last week.

Thank God I have never spent

Thank God I have never spent any money on that magazine. Newsweek must be clutching at straws to explain why some people feel as they do about Obama.

Newsweek

Newsweek shows up in doctors' offices all the time. It may be deliberate on their part because it makes you sick before you even see the physician. More money for them. The nation's health might improve if Newsweek died.

NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"

isia... Now that's

isia...

Now that's funny!

That is another good reasons why I never pick one of those rags up, let alone open one in the doc or dentists office.

"Never murder your opponent when he is committing suicide." ~ W. Churchill

LOL, I think that's it.

LOL, I think that's it.

Liberal Elitists (in their

Liberal Elitists (in their own minds) in the media and politics cling to their self-assumed superiority, in part, to assuage their bitterness of not being in power. You can just hear them thinking, "Ungrateful Peasants...".