Tom Brokaw's Nostalgia for '70s Liberalism in Earth Day Lecture

Photo of Tim Graham.
  • Bookmark and Share

On Tuesday’s Today, NBC brought out old anchorman Tom Brokaw to fondly remember the first Earth Day in 1970, when ultraliberals first declared the need for dramatic government intervention into the planet-despoiling capitalist system. He hailed how green protests saved rivers, eagles, and America itself from ruin: "The air turned brown, rivers died. Eagles almost disappeared. America the beautiful was America the endangered." Then the first Earth Day was a "massive success." He talked like a bumpersticker: "Mother Earth – love your mother. She’s the only one we have." He sounded a lot like the environmental lobbyist that the Clinton administration unsuccessfully invited to run the National Park Service back in 1993.

At 8:51 a.m Eastern time, the lecture began (as transcribed by MRC’s Geoff Dickens):

MEREDITH VIEIRA: We are celebrating "Green Week," here on "Today." And on this Earth Day we asked Tom Brokaw to give us his take on this nation's environmental history.

BROKAW: There was so much of America and it was so beautiful, so wild. And it was settled so late. It seemed we would never run out of open space, clean water, clear skies, wild game and birds on the wing. But in the 20th century, America became a different place, a great machine at full throttle, creating a colossus of factories, freeways and dams. Sprawling cities, farming by chemistry. The air turned brown, rivers died. Eagles almost disappeared. America the beautiful was America the endangered. But something else was going on. A new generation was taking its place in American life. A generation with lots to say and the power of protest.

Senator Gaylord Nelson of Wisconsin, a child of the North Woods, recognized the possibilities. He called for an Earth Day in the spring of 1970. It was a massive success. An estimated 20 million people participated, young and old, Democrat and Republican. The Clean Air Act, the Clean Water Act, the Endangered Species Act quickly followed. President Nixon created the Environmental Protection Agency.

RICHARD NIXON: I have sent to the Congress today a sweeping set of proposals to clean up our nation's air and water.

BROKAW: By the tens of thousands, Americans left the city streets to be restored in the wild. The journey is not yet complete. But the air is better. Water is cleaner. The eagle is back. And always there is this reminder. "Mother Earth, love your mother, she's the only one we have."

Brokaw obscured the real anti-capitalist, anti-technology bent of the Earth Day organizers of 1970. Back then, organizer Denis Hayes explained the whole agenda: "I suspect the politicians and businessmen who are jumping on the environment bandwagon don't have the slightest idea what they are getting into. They are talking about emission control devices on automobiles, while we are talking about bans on automobiles." 

In 1993, Bill Clinton’s Interior Secretary Bruce Babbitt offered NBC anchor Tom Brokaw a government job as director of the National Park Service. At the time, Brokaw told The Washington Post he considered the offer "very seriously," but decided to reject it because of turmoil at NBC (and the pay cut would have been dramatic). He professed "We need more park land" and "I have a lot of friends in the environmental movement." But he might have told the Clinton folks "I can do more for you here at the studio."

—Tim Graham is Director of Media Analysis at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Bringing Out The Retirees

The networks have the same penchant as professional sports to trot out the oldsters who've retired on those "special" occasions. Sad, really. No other businesses seem to feel the urge to pull their retirees out to active duty like that. It's especially sad when the retirees are so obviously past their prime. Wally Cronkite was the one that was the hardest to watch. He went from the most trusted man in America to garrulous old geezer mighty fast didn't he?


"All that is necessary for the trimuph of evil is that good men do nothing."

- Edmund Burke (1729 - 1797)

www.conservativeboot...

Well, we started out with

Well, we started out with "Earth Day." Now we have "Green Week." How long before the entire month of April is "Environmental Awareness Month"?

I did see a pretty good thing last night on the news about the woman who invented that "reusable" bill envelope...the one that has a window and the top tears off to reveal a new sticky strip, so you send your statement and check back in the same envelope it came in (I've received a couple of those in the mail).

They really are kind of cool. But I think a better way to save paper would be to encourage people to only get their statements online, and pay their bills online. I do a lot of that...not because I'm a big Greenie, but for convenience.

 

Hi motherbelt, We do the

Hi motherbelt,

We do the same thing, paying your bills online is a snap!

But mother... EVERY day is

But mother... EVERY day is Earth Day!

My daughter had a bunch of Earth Day-themed assignments from her first grade class yesterday. My wife got annoyed by the one that had to come up with ways to reuse things that would otherwise be thrown away. Like a butter dish to hold crayons or a soup can as a remote control caddie.

She said she felt like "Sanford and Son."

Still, it wasn't the hippie hootenanny that I guess it could have been. Nothing came home regarding global warming alarmism. Just a bunch of papers about being responsible (which, I must admit, seems kind of contrary. Shouldn't it have been printed on recycled grocery bags?) Still, I can live with that.

My idea to use six-pack holders as fishing traps didn't go over well. But with so much concern about how they harm the fish, they apparently work very well.

*****

"People only insist that a debate stop when they are afraid of what might be learned if it continues." - George Will 

Too late! I believe April

Too late! I believe April is already "earth month."

Going Green!

I do my part each day by making sure I drink a Beer out of a Green Bottle each night for the entire week. It not only feels good but it tastes good also.

Those were the days, my friend

Ahhh, I have fond memories of 70's environmentalism. That was when the “environmentally conscious” idiots drove VW Microbuses with "Save the Earth" bumper stickers plastered all over them. Those Microbuses were one of the most polluting vehicles on the road in those days. 25 percent of the gas used by them was not burned and was sprayed out the exhaust pipe. They also burned almost as much oil as gas. I can still see the clouds of oily smoke those damn things used to spit out as the hippies sang cumbiya, thinking they were saving Mother Earth and spending enough in gas money to buy several “lids” of pot every day.

I just love how these

I just love how these folks worship the creation rather than the Creator....oh I forgot they don't believe in a Creator. God's creation is wonderful and awesome, but He is so much greater.

Yeah, I'll bet Tom misses

Yeah, I'll bet Tom misses the gas lines and wage and price controls too!

Yeah, Tom, those were the days!

 

Take a number

I wonder how long it will be until Americans starts to see "No Ethanol Today" signs popping up at local "gas" stations all across America?

Soon I hope. Most gas today

Soon I hope. Most gas today is 10% ethanol. Mileage and power goes down the tubes with this stuff. The sooner its gone the better!!  

Save a SeAL, club a liberal!!

It is evident that Tom was

It is evident that Tom was so sheltered by the media and his job, he has not a clear vision of the past. This is nothing more than than an old fool remembering how he wished it had been. No relation to the facts. Besides, while they were here wishing for clean air in LA, (HA!), we were droping napalm and burning jungle...I know, I know. All that CO2, right? Just trying to do my part:-)  

Save a SeAL, club a liberal!!

Feelings

Have you noticed how those like Brokaw "feel" deeply about things like the environment, but it took Nixon, whom they look at as insensitive, to actually do anything about it. He created the EPA etc.

Brokaw et al are all talk and no game.

Tricky created it, all right...

Along with wage and price controls and various other artifacts of big government. None of it worked, either.
JMR

The tax & spend drug war looks racist in the real world.

Sarc... I'm actually worried

Sarc... I'm actually worried about you. No matter the subject you always seem to be in the "glass half empty" club. Cheer up, life is good! "Abstain from McCain"

I see very little good

Coming from big government Republicans or Democrats. If that's "glass half empty," it's also realistic. I lived through that foolishness. What's good about the EPA? Not much, except their PR arm.
JMR

The tax & spend drug war looks racist in the real world.

See what I

See what I mean? 

"Abstain from McCain"

Would Brokaw consider Gaylord Nelson's entire view?

Tom Brokaw is quick to rattle off this about the father of Earth Day:

Senator Gaylord Nelson of Wisconsin, a child of the North Woods, recognized the possibilities.

However, could Brokaw find the will within his liberal biases, to cross the line the MSM has drawn in the sand over supporting serious immigration reform?

Senator Gaylord Nelson also went on to say:

"We are preparing to celebrate the 32nd Earth Day just after the Census Bureau has announced that far from winding down in the 1990s, U.S. population growth boomed at its highest level in the nation's history! Not even the peak of the Baby Boom in the 1950s added as many people! This new population boom represents a profound failure in our nation's pursuit of environmental quality. Since 1970, another 80 million people have been added to the country. Every environmental goal has been delayed because of this failure."

In other words, is Brokaw really interested in achieving his goal, or just in sounding pretty to the libs?

Why would Brokaw want to celebrate Communism?

It seems odd Brokaw would be excited about celebrating the 100th anniversary of the birth (April 22, 1870) of the great communist mass murderer Vladimir Lenin?

This Earth Day Celebrate Vladimir Lenin's Birthday! (Capitalism Magazine)

The Anti 'Man-Made' Global Warming Resource

Those were the days

I fondly remember attending the 1st Earth Day in Central Park. Of the 100,000 there, 98,000 were either tripping or stoned or both. I think the earth felt much better afterwards.

I don't remember seeing Brokaw. 

sickof...

Well, the question for you might be: "perhaps that's because all you could see were rainbows?" (;~> gary

Earth day 1970. Didn't this

Earth day 1970. Didn't this guy host, or otherwise help put this shindig on?  

Save a SeAL, club a liberal!!