New Republic: Reporters Suspect Media Matters Is a Hillary Proxy

Photo of Tim Graham.
  • Bookmark and Share

Michael Crowley's takedown on Hillary and the media in The New Republic is fascinating -- and in some cases, overdoes the hostility between the two forces. But liberals should note that even The New Republic forwards the notion that David Brock's Media Matters collective is a transparent proxy for Team Hillary, and brings numbers to the table:

Many reporters also suspect the Clinton camp of employing outside proxies to attack troublemakers in the media....Many in Washington believe the campaign feeds material to Brock's site, as when Media Matters went after New York Times reporter Anne Kornblut last July after Kornblut misrendered a quote that led to an erroneous story claiming Hillary had criticized fellow Democrats. Not only did Clinton aides fume to the paper's editors, but Media Matters pummeled Kornblut and the Times for several days. (A count of Media Matters stories from October found 39 headlines defending Clinton, compared to 15 for Obama and just one for John Edwards. A Media Matters spokesman strongly denied favoritism.)

Crowley goes on to recount how Hillary likes to intimidate reporters on her beat like Kornblut, now with the WashPost:

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Sometimes, Hillary even gets in the act. According to Gerth and Van Natta, Kornblut was just back from a planned vacation she took after her story appeared when she ran into Hillary in a hotel. Referring to Kornblut's casual attire, Hillary cracked, "Anne, I thought you left Barbados"--revealing an ominous awareness of the reporter's movements. "That's their imprimatur," says the Democratic strategist with presidential experience. "When there's a story they don't like, they seize on it and turn it back on the reporter, and make it about the reporter." (As First Lady, Hillary called for a public "frontal assault" against The Washington Post's lead Whitewater reporter, Susan Schmidt, according to the Post's Howard Kurtz, though the plan was never enacted.)

Several sources report hearing that the Clinton campaign has bragged about forcing one reporter at a major news organization from the Hillary beat. The boast, which one source heard from a senior Hillary aide, is incorrect. But the claim has become a part of insider Washington lore. Like the tale of the killed GQ story, it has only enhanced the dark mythology of the Hillary machine -- a mythology the Clintonites don't dispel. "They brag about scalps that they take, " says a Democratic operative who has heard such tales.

This is strange treatment for a press corps that Hillary seems to have had at "Hello," and especially the female reporters. But I think she carries around great insecurity that her career is at the media's mercy every day, and so they need to be instructed on how who is really Boss.

Update 9:45 | Matthew Sheffield. Sister Toldjah is right on the money about this article:

Hillary Clinton started off her presidential campaign talking about how she wanted to have a “conversation” with America. Well sure she does, as long as the conversation revolves around 1) what “wonderful” things she’s done as both First Lady (all the while restricting access to the archives of the work she did as First Lady) and Senator of NY and how she’ll do even more “good things” as president, 2) as long as she knows what questions are going to be asked of her in advance, and 3) as long as the mean ol’ “boys club” doesn’t pick on her, cause if they do, her hubby will rush in to the rescue.

Rest assured that most of the same people who have relentlessly slammed the Bush admininstration’s “secrecy” with regards to the information that comes out of the WH will give La Clinton, the modern day master of controlling the message, a pass. The few who do attack her over this will do so only because they support one of her opponents.

—Tim Graham is Director of Media Analysis at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Hillary

Will somebody please pull back the curtain!

"That's their imprimatur,"

"That's their imprimatur," says the Democratic strategist with
presidential experience. "When there's a story they don't like, they
seize on it and turn it back on the reporter, and make it about the
reporter."

Proof of that is very recent: In the debate flap, the story quickly became about the "attack" on Her Royal Clintoness, deftly turned away from the fact that she waffled and fudged and dissembled on her answers.

Yeah right

Next you will say she has plants in the townhall meetings.

This is one of the most

This is one of the most bizarre stories I have ever read. It's eerily Putin-esque. How arrogant of this lady to think no one will find out. NewsBusters needs to follow this story like Jason on camp counselors.

MSNBC Prime Time

Rush Limbaugh is fond of saying that Media Matters produces the little watched MSNBC prime time lineup.

Any attack on Media Matters is an attack on NBC

Too Often Overlooked

NBC is an owned an operated by General Electric.  It is GE that is responsible for the management and the ultimate programming that appears on that feeble network.  Despite numerous instances where MSNBC hosts have gone off the deep end with their own comments, or that of their guests, the suits at GE have been able to avoid any criticism for what they permit.  In other words, regardless of the slimey content or the abnoxious commentary that airs from that channel, GE is behind the damn curtain and should be held accountable.

 This crop of intrepid

 This crop of intrepid reporters follow a new motto..."We will report the truth exactly as Hillary dictates it to us".  What a brave lot they are..Thomas Paine would be so proud of them.

ConRex - your reference

to Tom Paine is lost on these intripid reporters - they don't have a clue who he is, or more importantly, what he stood for.

There is no sense in being stupid, if you can't prove it! - my dad V

Tom Paine ... isn't he the

Tom Paine ... isn't he the main character in that shoot 'em up video game?  No, wait, that's Max Paine.  Ummm... I know, he's lead guitar in the band Flaming Maggots.  No?  Well, h*ll, Ed, if it happened before Januarly 2001, then it's ancient history and completely irrelevant. 

"A communist is someone who reads Marx.  An anti-communist is someone who understands Marx."  Ronald Reagan

Threats

The threatened issue the most threats.

I've maintained, for a long time, that since they spend so much time insulating her, it must be a sign of how fragile she is. Unfortunately, lately I've come to the conclusion that the Democrats have no other alternative. Obama is the only other viable candidate, and he's a lightweight. So she'll likely get the nomination, but she'll incinerate herself against a legitimate opponent.

The trick is to let her be herself. She'll do herself in. It's almost a waste of time to look for scandals; after all, the Hsu scandal showed that the media will cover those up. Instead, I hope they focus on her lack of management experience. That calls her competence into question, and she's so fragile that she'll feel compelled to react to it. That's when you'll see that Grinch-like snarl start to form. That's when America gets to see behind the carefully-crafted image, and they'll see her for what she really is -- a very threatened and threatening person.

The trick is to let her be

The trick is to let her be herself. She'll do herself in. KC Mulville

All you have to do is give her a microphone and let her go....sooner or later her voice starts to rise, she tries to make her voice forceful, but it just gets louder and more shrill. Before she is done, every guy in the audience is hearing his ex-wife. And everyone else is having flashbacks to their mother yelling "And when I tell you to do something, I expect you to DO it!!"

  So TNR is finally

 

So TNR is finally acknowledging what the rest of us have known all along ?

Hey anybody heard we just put a man on the moon ?

 

"You will never find a more wretched hive of scum and villainy. We must be cautious. "

                   - Ben Kenobi on  Liberals, and the MSM.