New MSNBC Host Martin Bashir Lashes Out at 'Disingenuous' Move by Tea Party Congressman
On his first day at MSNBC, new host Martin Bashir immediately adopted the network's liberal line, attacking a conservative Congressman for advocating severe spending cuts, deriding it as "the most disingenuous play on the American people."
Previewing the interview with Representative Joe Walsh of Illinois, Bashir noted that he has refused congressional health care. The anchor solemnly wondered, "Is that his idea of health care for every American?"
Bashir, who previously co-anchored ABC's Nightline, offered this loaded question to the Republican: "You're a freshman in this Congress. Are you satisfied that your first significant act in Washington will help bring the government to a standstill?"
The cable host closed out this interview and then snidely segueing to his next guest: "And for more on the political ramifications of this budget battle, including, hopefully, a little truth serum, let's bring in NBC news analyst and senior political editor at the Huffington Post, Howard Fineman."
A transcript of the segment, which aired at 3:10pm EST, follows:
MARTIN BASHIR: And when we come back, a congressman who refuses health care, even with a wife who has a preexisting condition. Is that his idea of health care for every American?
3:13
BASHIR: Now to the possible government shutdown looming at end of the week. Both parties say they're considering a Republican plan to keep things up and running, but the clock is ticking. Speaker of the House John Boehner says continuing to do the people's work, well, it's a moral issue.
SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE JOHN BOEHNER: We have a moral responsibility to address the problems that we face and that means working together to cut spending and to rein in government, not shutting it down.
BASHIR: Congressman Joe Walsh is a Republican from Illinois and he joins me live from the capitol. Mr. Walsh, good afternoon.
REP. JOE WALSH: Good afternoon, Martin. Congrats on the show.
BASHIR: Thank you very much. You're a freshman in this Congress. Are you satisfied that your first significant act in Washington will help bring the government to a standstill?
WALSH: You know, absolutely. Republicans have been clear that we don't want a shut down government. And I think it's very impressive that we sent a two-week- a two-week budget over to the Democrats in the Senate to try to keep the dialogue going so that we can avoid shutting down government. But, Martin, make no mistake, they sent us here to cut spending, and that's what's in this two-week CR.
BASHIR: Let's just sit for a moment on the cutting and spending. Isn't this the most disingenuous play on the American people? Because from Planned Parenthood to collective bargaining in Wisconsin, spending cuts is the excuse. But the real target, well, that's your political opponents.
WALSH: No. You know what? Martin, spending cuts are the real truth. That's why 87 Republican freshmen were sent to Washington. The Speaker alluded to it as a moral issue. It is a moral issue. Our country's broke and that's because we're spending too much. We're on a path right now that's going to bankrupt our kids and grand kids and that's morally irresponsible. That's almost criminal to do to future generations. The Republicans are keeping their word, and we're systemically going to go at the spending problem.
BASHIR: You've said President Obama ought to be ashamed of himself for not dealing with- for not dealing with entitlements in his budget. You say it's time to raise the retirement age and means test Social Security. But, do you have support from Speaker John Boehner?
WALSH: Absolutely. Look at Paul Ryan. Look at Paul Ryan to the north of me in Wisconsin. He has been a leader on this. He stuck his neck out last year and proposed reforms of Medicare and Social Security. Martin, I stand by those words. The President put out a budget and he should be ashamed of himself because he punted on entitlement reform. And everybody in this town knows that you've got to have a serious dialogue about Social Security and Medicare because that's where the bulk of the spending is. The Republicans are not going to be afraid to take the lead on this. And I think the American people are ready for that discussion.
BASHIR: Is it true that your own wife has decided to reject any health care insurance at this time?
WALSH: I pledged a year ago that, if I were elected, I'd turn down all congressional health care and retirement benefits. I just don't believe, as a member of Congress, you should take those. I don't want to increase the federal footprint, no matter how much it costs. It means a lot to me. And my wife was with me every step of the way. She had a procedure last week, Martin. She did have a preexisting condition and like a lot of Americans we have to pay that out of our own pock.
BASHIR: And how did the procedure go, by the way?
WALSH: Thank you. It well and she's recouping. Thank you.
BASHIR: And how much did it cost you?
WALSH: Uh, you know, I don't want to get into that, but it's something I'm going to feel. It's going to take me a while to pay off.
BASHIR: Okay, Congressman Joe Walsh of Illinois. Thank you.
WALSH: Martin, thank you.
BASHIR: And for more on the political ramifications of this budget battle, including, hopefully, a little truth serum, let's bring in NBC news analyst and senior political editor at the Huffington Post, Howard Fineman.
— Scott Whitlock is a news analyst for the Media Research Center. Click here to follow him on Twitter.
- Scott Whitlock's blog
- Login to post comments
















Comments
How can he say "truth serum"
Submitted by bassndude on Mon, 02/28/2011 - 6:18pm.
How can he say "truth serum" and "Howard Fineman" in the same paragaph, let alone in the same sentence?
Save a SeAL, club a liberal/troll!!
Truth Serum?
Submitted by JayVee on Mon, 02/28/2011 - 6:19pm.
I thnk any real "truth serum" would be to HuffPo kind of like splashing holy water on a vampire.
"Why"
Submitted by mad53PA on Mon, 02/28/2011 - 6:20pm.
I continue to be amazed at Republican/Conservative reps who go on this network (I'm being kind) and expect anything other than attack style journalism.
They have no interest in facts, being fair and presenting the opposing side of an arguement.
MSNBC is dedicated to making those on the right look bad.
Bashir is a long time hack pretending to be a journalist and is right at home on the piece of S**T network.
I think Boehner should put the word out, stay off because there is nothing to be gained by talking to them.
Why feed the sharks. Without any one to go after, this network would fade away even more quickly.
Is that his idea of health care for every American?
Submitted by donabernathy on Mon, 02/28/2011 - 6:34pm.
Wow....... a man decide'n what is good for him and his Family...don't he know he isn't capable of decide'n for himself... Only an Acorn Obama Care Advisor is smart enough for that kind of decision..
Bwahahahahahaha
roflmao
Conservative politicians must
Submitted by Miss_Me_Yet on Mon, 02/28/2011 - 6:43pm.
Conservative politicians must completely boycott all Obama administration media outlets immediately, continuing through the 2012 election season.
I think the M in MSNBC now stands for muslim also. All they hire now is muslim, America hating ji hadists.
Liberals ... we can't live with them, they couldn't survive without us ...
Oh I dont know MMY
Submitted by Boudin on Mon, 02/28/2011 - 7:08pm.
I thought Walsh made a proper a$$ out of propagandist Bashir
The President put out a budget and he should be ashamed of himself because he punted on entitlement reform. And everybody in this town knows that you've got to have a serious dialogue about Social Security and Medicare because that's where the bulk of the spending is. The Republicans are not going to be afraid to take the lead on this. And I think the American people are ready for that discussion.
Bashir forgot he was talking to an Adult, not a fellow fantasylander. Fantasylander: Those who do not differentiate truth from fiction,I wondered where Hosni Mubarak---
Submitted by matthewdean on Mon, 02/28/2011 - 8:43pm.
ended up.Whoah...
Submitted by Spud on Mon, 02/28/2011 - 8:55pm.
I missed Bashir's debut because I was at the hospital dealing with Dad and forgot to DVR it. I'm trying to keep an open mind and I don't agree with everything NB chooses to cite as an issue (and how it occasionally front loads some of its headlines with dubious at best claims) but this doens't sound good...I hope we don't have another David Shuster in the making here...one was enough.
Whoah???
Submitted by Boudin on Mon, 02/28/2011 - 9:06pm.
dubious at best claims
Dont suppose you would like to elaborate?
Hey Tater---
Submitted by matthewdean on Mon, 02/28/2011 - 9:15pm.
One David Shuster was enough? Howza about Keith Olbermann, Rachel Maddow, Larry O'Donnell, Cenk Uygur, Bob Schieffer, David Gregory, Katy Couric, Brian Williams, Matt Lauer, Meredith Veira, Ann Curry, Harry Smith, Ed Schultz, and good old misplace Hawaii, volcanos in Iceland?, run down a pedestrian who later died, whatzisname?Must be
Submitted by UpNorth on Mon, 02/28/2011 - 10:59pm.
the ones you named are all upstanding, fine journolists, MD. Not a single one there with an agenda that coincidentally matches the agenda of the DNC. Not a single one who gets their talking points from the White House every morning.
And you left off Scarborough, Mika and the rest of that fun-loving gang.
UpNorth---
Submitted by matthewdean on Mon, 02/28/2011 - 11:13pm.
Yeah, you're right about ol' Joe Scab and his bunch; but I would have had to go to the mat again with Jer over his perception that Joe is in reality a staunch conservative.
Damn, that Scarborough hides that fact well, don't he?
MD
Very astute of you....I wondered if anybody else picked
Submitted by nonncom on Mon, 02/28/2011 - 11:17pm.
up on that.....did you notice how he worded that so as to say the congressman he just interviewed was lieing?.....it's like the guy who had the brain transplant, and was informed that the brain, from a democrat, would cost 5,000.00.....he said what about a Republican brain.....he was informed that that would be 200.00......when he asked what the difference was, he was told that an adjustment had to be made because Republican brains were used, as opposed to democrats brains, which were hardly used at all.....
I was replying to bassndude......don't know what
Submitted by nonncom on Mon, 02/28/2011 - 11:18pm.
happened....
Another idiot at MSNBC
Submitted by Hippopaulimus on Tue, 03/01/2011 - 12:36am.
I've had no use for this shmuck since his special on Michael Jackson years ago.. .... I can't even listen to his voice, or change the channel quick enough when I'm unfortunate enough to hear it! ... Figures these idiots would sign him.
White - does not mean racist
Heterosexual - does not mean homophobic
Male - does not mean sexist
"truth analyst" and Huffpo in
Submitted by eaglewingz08 on Tue, 03/01/2011 - 2:18am.
"truth analyst" and Huffpo in the same sentence. What a riot.
First they tried to target Joe by claiming he was going to break his promise about not taking health care and he's a hypocrite for doing so and he was living like a parasite off the taxpayers. Then when it was pointed out that he didn't sign up, he's a terrible person for keeping his promises, and he wants everyone to die! quickly! Gee, where have I heard that before?
It shows how insular his echo chamber is
Submitted by WingletDriver on Tue, 03/01/2011 - 10:31am.
Bashir takes it ab initio that everybody in the US wants socialized healthcare. There were no dissenting voices against Obamacare. There is no problem with Medicare. He must have a crack research staff mumbling in his earpiece.
crack smoking maybe.....
Submitted by Miss_Me_Yet on Tue, 03/01/2011 - 10:54am.
crack smoking maybe.....
Liberals ... we can't live with them, they couldn't survive without us ...